Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Design question

Posts

Design question

#1

Design question

Bill Tindall


The question is feet for this chest of drawers. The front surfaces will be faced with a bull nosed molding which is not yet applied to the front edges you see in the picture. This molding will be seen taped to subsequent pictures.


This is my first thought on feet. Straight up from floor and then an arc transition .


In this iteration I made a reverse curve at the bottom of the foot. What is show seems just a bit too little of this return arc?

In any case.....foot comments and suggestions please.

Re: Design question

#2

Re: Design question

Galen Vetterick

Bill

Just my opinion but for the taller heavy piece the bottom is too open. I'd reduce it by at least a third of what it is now. A little wider leg for the same reason. The arc size you have now will make it even look heavier when the open height is reduced.

Its' going to be another nice piece when finished. You put a lot of thought and hard work into it.

Re: Design question

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Design question

Moses Yoder

Something to consider which you don't show would be cutouts on the sides as well, don't know if you were planning that or not. Attached is a drawing of our different styles of furniture skirts.


Re: Design question

#4

Re: Design question

Bill Tindall

thanks for drawings. Yes there will be cut outs on sides.

Re: Design question

#5

Re: Design question

TomD

The top one looks Chinese and the bottom one is lacking something. One really needs to know what the style is, and handles.

Re: Design question

#6

Re: Design question

Bill Tindall

I don't think of this piece as either "tall or heavy". It's about a 3/4 sized chest of drawers for a child. It is only 27" wide and about 4' tall and the lumber is thinner than standard, lightened even further by the bull nose edge. In person, it looks dainty and needs dainty "skirt" feet......of some sort. The tall narrow foot enhanced the dainty look. Though interestingly, an artist I consulted working from a picture also used the same word, "heavy" and wanted a robust foot to support this heaviness. Not at all the look I am striving for.

As far a what style it is, I have no idea. It is what it is. Having never seen Chinese furniture I may have unknowingly reinvented the style, though the re-curve on foot 2 is similar to French Feet on Federal pieces.

Knobs/pulls are undecided. I would like to make wooden ones, likely blackwood, if I can.

Re: Design question

#7

Re: Design question

Galen Vetterick

Bill

I should have thought about your ealier posting that this was not a full size piece. From the photo I guess my eye could not tell it was not. I see how another could be fooled with nothing in the picture to make a comparison. The scaled down version is well proportioned.

A full size of thicker stock would in my mind be a heavy piece by weight and to my eye then.

Re: Design question

#8

Re: Design question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Think your proposal is OK for the size of the chest, however, I'd suggest a slight arch across the "span" and a fair curve carrying straight to the floor. If you're married to the return at the bottom of the leg, I'd suggest you go a bit wider, more like Moses' examples. Given your bull nose trim, you might also consider beading the inside edge for an additional shadow line.

Re: Design question

#9

Ellis Walentine

Re: Design question

Ellis Walentine

Design is subjective, so go with whatever appeals to you. I personally don't care for the tight inside radii and the straight verticals at the ends your cutout, with or without the reverse curves at the bottom. Arches such as those shown by Moses have a couple advantages. Aesthetically, they are gentler and more graceful, without the austere geometry of the quarter-round inside radius. Also, the greater width creates a (to me) nicer balance with the negative space of the opening and results in less short-grain.

There are no correct answers here. The particular curvature you choose might want to be considered along with the overall form of the chest. Will the top overhang? If so, what molding detail or edge detail will it have? How will the shape and dimensions of the base complement this top edge? Does the finish piece want to hark to a historic style that people will read into it, consciously or sub-consciously? If so, what is that style? E.g., Greene & Greene style might have cloud-lift details on the base; Colonial American styles might have recognizable curvatures and/or detailing....

More questions than answers, I'm afraid.

Ellis

Re: Design question

#10

Re: Design question

Larry in nw ohio

Bill I`ll be a little different, how about doing a double opening in front, with a foot in the middle. Also when I do these, maybe you might do it also, I always brake the front edge with a 1/4" round over or so. I hate sharp edges. Larry

Re: Design question

#11

Tight radii

Bill Tindall

I have scale drawn numerous foot patterns. The tight radius and tall open space provides a "perky" look like the thing is on its tip toes. In drawing development I kept shrinking the foot width and radius to develop more perkiness. This look will be consistent with the perky high angle drawer dovetails and the overall dainty size of it.

I tried the larger radius and it gave this small piece a ponderous bottom heavy look like a colonial maple chest of drawers. Not after substantial colonial look.

To be sure of the design I have been making some actual foot patterns from some scrap wood. The translation from drawing board to the chest may well change the expected effect. But whatever, light and perky is the look I am after, like a French Foot, except flat. .

Re: Design question

#13

Arch

Bill Tindall

I had not considered the arch. It is common with French Feet and could well be the trick as I am trying to achieve a similar mood on this piece. So its back to the drawing board, literally.

Re: Design question

#14

Re: Tight radii

Barry Irby

Probably should not listen to me. I design things, build them and then wish I had done something else, but....

You have lots of options. How about turned legs or feet? Or is the slender tapered turned out Leg/Foot the French foot? I like those.

Re: Design question

#15

It's off to the books.....

Bill Tindall

You comments have sent me to my book collection to seek inspiration and test concepts. Indeed, to get a light, uplifted, perky effect the leg needs to be narrow and tall. I found a chest in a Shaker collection with a foot almost exactly like #2 and it lifted the chest that sat upon it. I had not considered the French Foot to be an inspiration for the flat "bracket type" foot I had in mind but I have come to see that what I am looking for is an informal French Foot effect in a bracket foot, with no sticky-outy part.

If anyone has a picture of perky bracket feet please post.

If you all have a favorite place (book) to look at furniture pictures for inspiration I would like this ideas too. I like the early Taunton Press Design books.

Re: Design question

#16

Re: It's off to the books.....

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I would recomend you take a look at some Louisiana Acadian furniture. Some of the informal acadian deigns have a simple eligance I think you will like.

Robin

Re: Design question

#18

Re: Design question

pdmay

You are a good artist moses :-0

Re: Design question

#19

Re: picture?

Larry in nw ohio

Bill I hope you can make this out, I`m not very good with camera and computer pictures. I hope it helps in someway with your project. Larry

Re: Design question

#20

Third dimension

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You've had plenty of good thoughts on the shape for the cutout. I'm wondering how you'll handle the third dimension. With the bullnose molding you're applying around the drawers, I wonder if the base should have a large-radius curve, either at the top, shading to flat as it reaches the "leg" portion, or over its entire height.

Re: Design question

#21

The decision

Bill Tindall

I had occasion to make a fall leaf hike with an artist yesterday. I took along numerous scale drawings, and model plywood feet for her to render an opinion about.

You guys must be good because she asked all the same questions and made similar comments. However, when considering the size of this piece and my desire to make it perky she immediately chose the leg with the straight beginning, tight curve at the top and no bow in the middle. Any variation from this simple form subdued the perky in exchange for another flavor- French Provincial, Colonial, Ponderous, etc. In the mean time I have found pictures of two similar chests, one Shaker and another "Modern" and each had these perky feet.

Actually now I am fretting over applying the face bull nose. The drawer divider facing will intersect the verticals with "darts", as I have done before, which leads to successfully making 14 of these joints, perfectly, for this part will show, and more than show it will be most obvious. I will illustrate the process with pictures when I get it done. I am not a advocate of flauntable drawer dovetails that don't show, but these joints will, or won't, make the piece.