Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

To buy a mortiser or not?

Posts

To buy a mortiser or not?

#1

JL

To buy a mortiser or not?

JL

I have an "opportunity" to purchase a gently used Delta Mortiser (I believe a 14-651) with chisels.

The guy is asking $200. It has been used maybe a couple of times. I have a mortising attachment to my drill press that I have used off and on. Nowadays, I mostly do loose tenon joinery - so I use my router and then just square things up.

So - good deal or no? Is it worth making an offer? I can get a new one from Amazon for $290 - I already have the chisels.

Thoughts?

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#2

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

Barry Irby

I can't believe I am saying this, but a tool you don't need is not a bargain at any price. In my case I have a DP and the attachment but no mortise. I make mortises occasionally and the attachment of the DP does a perfectly acceptable job. I have a small shop so another tool would be in my way when it was not in use. And I don't have $200 to spare at the moment. So if your case is similar to mine, my answer would be no. If my shop were bigger and I had some spare cash it might be yes. If I cut a lot of mortises it might be yes anyway. But, If I cut a lot of mortise and couldn't resist a mortiser, I would want to be sure I bought the right one and I know nothing about the one you are considering.

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#3

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

George Colonel

Good Afternoon JL,

That Delta is one of those I test drove in comparison shopping for a mortiser. Its a nice tool, although it wasn't my final choice. I had been doing mortises on my drill press, and was not happy with set up time. I bought a Shop Fox #1191 and have used it in building my household furniture. I would agree that there are alternatives to a mortiser, and a dado head or router are very effective. I let the set up considerations rule when I choose which method to use. If I need to place a mortise EXACTLY on carefully drawn lay out lines, then I break out my mortiser, because I can visually see and correct any deviation immediately. A cross slide vise lets me proceed incrementally while maintaining my settings. Otherwise its a PITA to use a fence and clamp arrangement. To be honest, I'd offer $175 or less including the chisels, and be prepared to walk.

George

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#4

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

roger lance

only you can say if you should buy it or not....if you are going to be making a fair number of pieces and mortise/tenon is your style, why not go for it....if you don't like/use it, sell it...how much will you lose??...not that much...I will say that a bench top dedicated mortiser is a real step up from the dp add on...and a free standing floor mortiser is a big up grade from that (etc etc)...part of the fun of the hobby is to try new things ...stretch your wings a little...the earth will keep on turning either way.

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#5

Kneale Brownson

I bought the delta.  Then I bought a vise

Kneale Brownson

With four-way movements to make it easier to line up the chisel with my marks.

I should have gone a bit more (probably have $400 or so into the whole thing that would be $600 at today's dollar "value") and gotten one of the machines in the recent comparison HERE

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#6

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

Jesse Cloud

Personally, I sold my Powermatic mortiser a few years ago and never looked back.

If you buy a mortiser, get an XY vise as well. Also be prepared to spend some time sharpening the chisels if you want smooth walls. I never could (undoubtedly my own fault) get as good mortises with the hollow chisels as I do with the router. Mortisers also pretty much suck if you are working with curves. The higher end mortisers can kinda sorta do angles, but you can also make wedges...

I guess what I am saying is that Barry nailed it. ;)

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#7

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

If you ever plan to do Arts and Crafts furniture, a mortiser is an invaluable timesaver.

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#8

Amen !


Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#9

Amen #2.  Don't have one but I'm looking!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My last project involving mortises was a set of night tables for my son. All told there were 104 mortises. That's not THAT much fun.

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#10

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

Michael Wilkins

If you are using a router to make the mortises and using loose tenons, I say save the money for more lumber and later consider getting a decent-quality floor model mortiser. There are many pro furniture builders using loose tenons and getting acceptable results.

Re: To buy a mortiser or not?

#11

Free to a good home

Larry in NW Ohio

I have a HF that is free to anyone that comes to pick it up and donate something to WC. I live in NW Ohio just 25 miles north of Lime in Ottawa Ohio. Larry