Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Conversion factor for board feet??

Posts

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#26

Re: Rules....

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Re-read Jl's post, there is no price listed but rather a "conversion factor" for straight line riping.

I have had J.E. Higgins do the same and while I did not care much for the practice what I really objected to was that they rounded the tally up to the nearest bf and then applied their conversion factor and then rounded up again. I objected to the double rounding and was told it is industry standard and I informed them that Van Arsdale Harris who has been in business nearly as long does not double round on the tally and if they chose to do so with me they would only do it once, and that is exactly how many time I have done business with them.

I do object to posting one price and charging another it would be like seeing the price of chicken posted at the butchers counter as .99/lb and then being charged 2.99/lb for the skinless bonless breast meat at the checkout counter. The bucher counter has different prices for the different cuts rather than one price and a conversion factor applied at check out. And while we are making butcher shop comparisons my butcher charges acording to .01 of a lb no rounding up to the nearest Lb. I can understand if a yard is making a tally with a stick but most use a measuring tape and a calculator or a computer so there is no need to round up. And why round up, why not round down?

On the rare ocasion I buy wood I shop at lumber yards that post the true price. My sawyer will quote me a price for green and one for KD and then holds to that price.

Robin

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#27

Thanks for the post

Bill Tindall

Your "bravery" in posting the question has resulted in at least a few more people knowing that when they buy hardwood lumber that they need to ask how it will be tallied, especially if they see lumber leaving the place in hundred bdft quantities on trucks with company names on them.

I just delivered a 105 pound lamb at $1.48 per pound. The bill is 105 x $1.48. Well in fact I delivered 48 pounds of chilled meat and 57 pounds of stuff went in a hole in the ground. It never occurred to me that the customer could have thought that they would be getting the 48 pounds of meat for $1.48/lb. Fortunately, it never occurred to this customer that I would be selling chilled lamb meat for the astonishing price of $1.48/lb. But I will be more specific in the future.

The moral of the story is that there are marketing conventions for most markets. If you are new to the market, ask. If I see the customer is new to the market I need to ask.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#28

one minor correction

Bill Tindall

Anything over the 1/2 mark is rounded up. Anything under is rounded down. The person doing tally keeps track of the exact halves and alternates up and down. Some rules measure net, others apply the "shrink".

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#29

Re: You make an unfair and uninformed assessment

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Don't know about your outfit, but the company I buy from has been in the hardwood business for 102 years. Their prices are based on measurements after kiln drying. "No additions are made to cover shrinkage" (LLJohnson Lumber sales catalog). Their board-foot price varies based on quantity, usually around $1-2 less for 1000 board-foot quantities as compared to 1-99 feet. Price breaks occur at 100, 500 and 1000 feet. I may not like the price, but I know exactly where I stand with these folks, no matter if I'm a rank amateur buying one board or a boat builder buying 1,000's of board feet at a time.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#30

While I don't expect retail service at such a yard

John in NM

Neither do I feel the need to scrap and bow in gratitude for their deigning to take my unworthy pennies....

'come on Bill, get real :D

The price of $2.83 is in line with what you pay at most commercial yards that serve the cabinet industry, not what I'd call amazingly low. They sell single boards to pro's all the time if that's what they need, and a lot of them pay cash rather than running a credit account. Most of these places are perfectly happy to sell to anyone who comes in, knows what they want, and pays for it. I don't think I'd call these yards "wholesale" but whatever, not going to argue about that.

I have also come across a few commercial distributors who sell to commercial yards and never sell retail because they don't want every schmoe with a pickup showing up for two or three boards. These places do not break units, tend to want to sell truckload quantities, and never offer services like straightlining. I suspect you are blurring this distinction a bit.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#31

Re: Atittude . . .

FredD

Your post reinforces the proposition that a business like Dale Hardware in Fremont , Ca, for instance, that sells service first and product second will always do well is spot on.

FredD

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#32

Re: an explanation of what's going on

FredD

"When lumber is straight line ripped somebody is going to pay for the part that gets ripped off. Again, it is common to assume a standard loss from this operation and add it to the tally. Alternatively, the lumber could be priced according to what is left after KD and ripping, but that isn't how it is done at this level in the food chain"

That may be as it is where you live , but on the West Cost , specifically J.E. Higgins Hardwood lumber wholesaler that catered to Cabinet Shops and Contractors and the occasional walk in , if they were notified in advance , like a Adult Education student of one of my classes , this is how they treated Straight line rip.

The customer has already paid for the lumber, the straight line rip is a add on charge which at the time I dealt with them was seven cents a running foot , Not what was cut off.

This was a service they provided and you paid for, not a mysterious or arcane business practice.

FredD

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#33

Re: Check the price paid and then decide

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

To help me understand all of this:

If i were to walk into a local electronics store "A's wholesale",speak with an associate and agree to purchase a 42" Television set at a price of $399,when I get to the register I am told the TV is now $449.

I pay the $449 and go home with my new TV. When I get home,unpack and hook up my new TV I find that it is only a 37" TV. I am supposed to accept this as the "industry standard" because after all I could have paid $499 for the TV from "B's retail outlet" so I should consider myself to have saved $50 no matter how I look at it?

Is that analogy correct?

Thanks,

Andy

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#34

Re: Thanks for the post

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I understand where you are coming from Bill, but at least h+ere in Indiana the lumber yards are more forthright. And yes I do check on how the bf is tallied. Although I have never purchased wholesale, the mill I purchase from rounds up only the width and length of each board - IE: if the board is 11 5/8" wide it is considered as 12". 4/4 may vary from 7/8 to 1 1/8 rough sawn and is charged the same. I do pick out each board from the stacks and re-stack the rest. They have (posted) extra charge for extremely wide / long boards but discount shorts. They do not have any "roundup" after the tally PERIOD. They do sell in truckload quantities as well as one board lots. I have purchased (with my son) up to $1200.00 quantities as well as some $50 - 60 lots. Their pricing is well in line with everyone I have found - about a tenth of Rocklers - HD etc. I would unload my lumber back in front of their door (without paying) if anyone tried to add an "adjustment factor" after I purchase lumber at the posted or announced bf prices.