Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Conversion factor for board feet??

Posts

Conversion factor for board feet??

#1

JL

Conversion factor for board feet??

JL

I went to the lumber yard today.

I picked up a bunch of lumber for shelving.

By my rough "calculation", I got ~150 board feet of nominal 1" lumber (13/16, S2S and straight line ripped). I was charged for ~176 board feet. I was told that there was a "conversion factor" for shrinkage, kilning and the like. It was 1.18.

What?? I'm missing something here. I thought the conversion factor was figured into the cost as I was getting 13/16" lumber.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#2

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

FredD

Lumber is sold by the Board foot , units and sq ft such as plywood.

Anything else is marketing BS.

If the grade is hand picked for clear, that is a expensive wood ,but it is still priced by the Board foot.

Some lumber yards and big box stores sell Hardwood by the length or running foot per board and each board is priced separately and that used to be illegal , but apparently anything goes now with the explanation that it is "business".

FredD

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#3

Never heard of it . . .

steve mackay

I buy off the "cheap skid" or the "good skid". They both have a price on the price list posted inside the bay door. The only "conversion" I know of is sales tax. I go in with a set amount of money in my pocket. I would never return to a place where I didn't know what the total was going to be BEFORE I went into the office. Sounds like jibber-jabber to me.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#4

Re: Never heard of it . . .

Larry in NW OHIO

The only conversion factor that was, was the extra money you had, was from your your pocket to theirs. If they would have told me that, I would have dumped their lumber on the ground and said there is another conversion factor, from my trailor to your ground and left. Larry

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#5

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

Jesse Cloud

I've been charged 4Q prices for 13/16 and I've been charged extra for a straight line rip, but I've never heard of this 'conversion factor' stuff.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#6

Green Tally

Bob Lang

Some dealers try to set their pricing based on a "green" tally, in other woods how much wood there was before it went into the kiln. The justification is that the wood shrank after they bought it, therefore they charge by what they say they bought, instead of what they delivered.

In reality it's a sleazy way to lure you in, then jack up the price, in this case by 18%. It isn't right, but some people do it.

Bob Lang

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#7

Re: Conversion factor for board feet?? *LINK*

Dick Coers

Here's a good discussion about gross vs net footage.


gross vs. net

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#8

Ellis Walentine

Yeah, I was about to say...

Ellis Walentine

... the same thing. It's not unusual for a lumber dealer to add milling charges for surfacing and straight-lining the material, but that should be included in the price, as should kiln drying. At the end of the day, you're willing to pay the price or you aren't.

Ellis

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#9

Re: Yeah, I was about to say...

FredD

The few times I ordered straight line rip or somebody else did and I was paying, this was lastly done in the middle eighties and J.E Higgins Hardwood had been charging seven cents a running foot which wouldn't break anybody .

FredD

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#10

an explanation of what's going on

Bill Tindall

This business likely sells hundreds if not thousands of bdft of lumber to mostly regular customers. The regular customers know how the business is pricing the lumber and what they are doing, while it may seem strange to a new customer, is not unusual at a place selling larger quantities of hardwood lumber to other businesses. The whole affair is strange only because you are new to the market.

Retail places that cater to individuals typically avoid confusion of this pricing convention by adding the losses to final price. Either way the customer is paying for shrinkage and cutting losses.

It is not uncommon to price hardwood lumber based on the measurement before kiln drying. It is commonly assumed that there will be about an 8% shrinkage during drying so this amount is added to the KD talley. We bought thousands of bdft of lumber by this convention.

When lumber is straight line ripped somebody is going to pay for the part that gets ripped off. Again, it is common to assume a standard loss from this operation and add it to the tally. Alternatively, the lumber could be priced according to what is left after KD and ripping, but that isn't how it is done at this level in the food chain.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#11

Dale Lenz

That only true when the customer...

Dale Lenz

is dealing with the sawmill or some wood business between the mill and the lumber yard. At the lumber yard if the price is a $1.50/bd.ft. that should be the price + sale tax the customer pays! This hidden cost reminds me of the air line industry, sucking the customer dry with baggage and peanut cost etc.

I'd for sure let the lumber yard know I was not pleased with this transaction and take my business somewhere else.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#12

You make an unfair and uninformed assessment

Bill Tindall

We were in the hardwood lumber business for nearly 30 years. What JL encountered is, or at least was, typical for hardwood lumber sold in larger quantities at wholesale. We bought all our KD lumber by this convention. We never stocked straight line ripped lumber but it too had the same convention.

While JL might have been "lured", as you say, by his unfamiliarity of the hardwood lumber business at this level in the food chain, the typical customers of this business are certainly not. I'll wager this company has been in business for some time. If its customers, that is those that know the business first hand, had the same assessment as you do, how do you suppose they stay in business. Rather, their typical customer knows the conventions of tally at the wholesale level and make their informed buying decisions accordingly.

If I recall correctly the price JL was quoted it amazed me how cheap it was. If you, or he, think he was over charged, trot on over to Woodcraft and buy at their retail price.

I dreaded the small retail customer because they didn't know the market or market conventions of tally and grade and the result was usually ill will in spite of the fact they were getting lumber priced like they were a wholesale customer of large quantities.

The bottom line in these affairs is if you want to get the price large customers pay then learn and accept the customs of the business.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#13

Re: That only true when the customer...

Bill Tindall

You can say what this business "should do" but if you aren't their typical customer you don't get to determine what they should do. Without knowing anything about this business I can make a good bet based on how this purchase was tallied and priced that their typical customer is buying large quantities of lumber and that this business does not cater to the small retail trade. Odds are when JL checks prices at the retail establishments that cater to individuals he will be back at this place, more knowledgeable, and thankful they will bother selling to him.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#14

question......

Bill Tindall

Didn't you run a shop at some time that would have been buying several hundred bd ft of lumber at a time? If your tallies weren't based on predried measurement I will be amazed. The practice was so ubiquitous that lumber sticks could be bought that had the shrinkage built into the calibration. There was even a Federal case that challenged the practice, I think in the 1980's. For a short time our suppliers changed tally and then went back to the old way of doing business.

Do you have similar angst over buying a 2 x 4 that isn't? No, because you understand the convention. The problem here is lack of understanding by the customer, not the business practice. Can you imagine this place staying in business if their major customers thought their business practices were as you describe them? I suspect that if they changed the way they tally their customers would see the higher price posted and go the competitor down the street.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#15

Re: That only true when the customer...

Chuck Kettler

I am always amazed at the number of times that price trumps value on this discussion board. If you don't perceive the value of the lumber you have selected to be worthy of the price that you are charged go somewhere else. I still have hand selected FAS cherry that I bought from Bill Tindall 18 years ago because the ratio of value/price was so very high from my point of view that I could not pass up such an opportunity. You want price at any cost then drive up to Union, IN and tour the Frank Miller Lumber mill when the WoodCentral gang sets up a tour. They will sell all you want at lowest price you will ever see for high quality lumber and you get a lot of free entertainment. If you find a reliable supplier who treats you right, whatever that means, then cultivate that relationship to keep your supply chain stable. If price trips your trigger, then search to your hearts content knowing that time is money and you are paying yourself in synapse food, not dollars.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#16

Re: You make an unfair and uninformed assessment

Bob Lang

Hey Bill,

You're entitled to your opinion, especially with your experience in the business. I don't think I'm uninformed however. As to fairness, if the foxes were in charge of henhouse security, and I called them on their methods, they probably would think I was unfair too.

I don't care much for any business model that seeks to take advantage of the uninitiated by disguising the true cost in the way described by the original poster. Even if you buy into the argument that shrinkage in the kiln is a recoverable cost, the price wasn't made clear at the beginning of the transaction, and the upcharge is considerably more than the 8% standard.

If lumber dealers don't want to deal with the retail customer as he is, they shouldn't deal with them. I've bought a lot of lumber over the years, and when I deal with someone I haven't dealt with before, I make sure to pin them down as to exactly what they are talking about when it comes to grading and quantities. It's an industry that has written it's own rules, and then doesn't follow the rules with any degree of regularity.

Bob Lang

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#17

Moses Yoder

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

Moses Yoder

When I buy lumber at my local Amish supplier, he uses a stick with a hook on the end, I think it is called a board rule but can't remember for sure. It hooks on one side of the board and has calculation for 8', 10', and 12' boards I think. It has lines every inch or so I think, and number for how many board feet are in the board. If I hooked it on one edge of a 5-1/2" wide board, that would be figured as a 6" wide board, if it was 94" long it would be figured as an 8' board, 13/16" thick would be a 4/4 board, and it would be calculated as 4 board feet based on the marks on the board rule. In reality it is 2.917 bd feet of lumber. That is about 27% less lumber than I am paying for, yet I keep going back there because I think they have great lumber for good prices.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#18

Check the price paid and then decide

Bill Tindall

In a previous post JL said he was quoted $2.40/bdft, presumably for FAS1F 12" and wider red oak, straight line ripped. The price was $2.83 per bdft for the surface measure received. This is an amazingly low price even at the wholesale level and the price ensures JL was buying at wholesale if my assumptions of grade are correct. The problem is that JL, as well as those that think JL was mistreated, didn't/don't understand the conventions at this level of the lumber food chain. In stead of heaping abuse on the business, the business should be commended for offering a retail customer lumber the opportunity to buy lumber at a price normally paid for wholesale packs of lumber.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#19

Re: Check the price paid and then decide

Stuart Johnson

I don't think it is a case of fair or unfair. A quote for x BDF, milled as requested, for the requested grade. If any one of the three items in the quote is changed the total quote should be changed. If the buyer doesn't like it they can go elsewhere. Nobody should expect to pay the same for 25 BDF retail as someone purchasing 1000 BDF wholesale no matter how it is quoted. I do feel any business has an obligation to state how they do business. I don't care if it is a lumber dealer adding a percentage or the local fast lube that has a $25 special then adds on labor, filter and disposal.

In this case my feeling is the dealer should know he is selling retail and probably to a non-professional. A 20 second comment to JL would have prevented the issue. FWIW, I purchase from Brazos Forest Products in 25 to 100 bf amounts at the retail side of their Grand Prairie, TX operation. My last purchase was totaled as 24 BDF Ash 4/4 FAS&1F KD RGH MILLING S2S1E TO 13/16" for $2.24 BDF. To be honest I don't know how many BDF I actually received but I selected the boards I wanted and was satisfied with the total price. If I was purchasing a lot I would check to see what I received and if it was off by very much I'd ask them what was going on.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#20

Re: Check the price paid and then decide

Yonak

The contention that, in the end, the price justifies the tactic doesn't fly, in my book. If the lumber yard is proud of their price then they should tell you what the price is up front instead of telling you one price then upping it by 18% when you've got your truck loaded up and it's time to pay. Simply, it's a deceiving business practice.

It reminds me of when my wife and I went to buy wallpaper. The sign said, "$2.99 / roll". When we got to the cash register the price was double. "Oh," they said, "they are all double rolls." Honesty, clarity and good service is what gets my business."

After 15 years I still don't have my blades sharpened by a local sharpening service that is the closest and has competitive pricing because he cheated me one time and, when I brought it to his attention, he refused to make it right.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#21

Rules....

Bill Tindall

Lumber is marketed at the wholesale level according to rules established by the National Hardwood Lumber Association. The rules are established in cooperation of the produces and major users (think furniture factories). Most, probably all, wholesale operations as well as large customers are members. Even those that aren't would typically abide by NHLA rules. Rule books are readily obtained from the organization. The NHLA has a dispute resolution process that works. The rules are enforced. (Export marketing is a whole different situation. Buy Export graded lumber when you can... but that is another story......)

See my post below that suggests that at the amazingly low price JL was paying he was at the wholesale position in the lumber food chain. It is presumptuous for a retail customer in this environment to be critical of marketing practices when they represent a tiny fraction of the customer base.

We agree on one point. The marketing practices in the hardwood lumber industry are arcane. To that end I wrote a series of articles for WoodCentral(to be found in the Articles section) that describe this industry. To wit, logs are typically measured by the Doyle Scale, a scale that hugely underestimates the yield on small logs and over estimates the yield on large ones. While most lumber is graded from the worst side of the board, the lumber we mostly buy is graded from the best side and it is typically not one grade but 3, or sometimes four grades, lumped together. KD lumber is measured and graded in the "green" state. Etc......

As an editor of a popular magazine your time would be better spent educating your readers about the conventions of the hardwood lumber industry rather than advocating changing its large-customer marketing practices. Might I suggest a future article....."Arcane practices in hardwood lumber marketing that you may encounter as a retail customer". Knowledgeable customers avoid this confusion, as you stated in your post. The slant of the article should be educating the customer, not railing against the retail customer's perception of whether the practices are fair or unreasonable. They are what they are because that is the way they have been for decades and competitive pressure will resist change. You don't want to be the first business to raise your posted price by 18% to reflect surface feet delivered, if your competitors don't follow. That was the situation when the government tried to enforce more logical practices and confusion reigned.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#23

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

Chuck Jurvelin

Wood Central is fortunate to have intelligent, level-headed participants like Bill Tyndall to set the records straight. The customer ultimately has the choice to buy or not and the bottom line is the price paid is competitive for good material. Buying a little and getting a lot is great when it happens, but everybody in business is entitled to a profit. It is getting more difficult all the time to find dealers that will work with the small quantities that the little shops want to buy.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#24

JL

Good points all.

JL

I've been quite happy with the quality of the lumber from NGH. They've been a reasonable dealer. I've just never really "back calculated". I usually just pick the boards and go.

The guy called me and explained the calculations - big plus. Now I know. So I'm reasonably content.

Their factors - 0.81 for 4/4, 5/4 and 0.91 for 6/4 and 8/4.

Re: Conversion factor for board feet??

#25

Atittude . . .

steve mackay

My long time, small time outfit always sold me my one, measly red oak board for one price. What was on the price list. And were more than happy to do it. They wanted my money. They NEEDED my money. Even if they had to get it twenty bucks at a time. To my horror they sold out to Blue Linx. While Blue Linx kept a bundle of oak off to the side for "one, measly board" customers it wasn't hard to tell that they would rather that I not darken their doorway. But I couldn't bring myself to pay "dimensioned" lumber prices at the Borg. So I groveled at Blue Linx. The guys from the independant outfit ( DAKOTA HARDWOODS, El Paso, TX) got fed up, left and re-opened again (thank the lumber gods). NOW they not only sell me my one, measly board but sell it to me at the "truckload" price, with a smile and conversation about what I'm building this week. My guys business is on the up-swing and doing pretty good and (you guessed it) Blue Linx is on the down. Loosing customers AND employees. With their formulas and alchemy the big yard doesn't need my twenty bucks. My little guys do. And it shows. Its not so much about the price its more about the attitude.