You make an unfair and uninformed assessment
Bill Tindall
We were in the hardwood lumber business for nearly 30 years. What JL encountered is, or at least was, typical for hardwood lumber sold in larger quantities at wholesale. We bought all our KD lumber by this convention. We never stocked straight line ripped lumber but it too had the same convention.
While JL might have been "lured", as you say, by his unfamiliarity of the hardwood lumber business at this level in the food chain, the typical customers of this business are certainly not. I'll wager this company has been in business for some time. If its customers, that is those that know the business first hand, had the same assessment as you do, how do you suppose they stay in business. Rather, their typical customer knows the conventions of tally at the wholesale level and make their informed buying decisions accordingly.
If I recall correctly the price JL was quoted it amazed me how cheap it was. If you, or he, think he was over charged, trot on over to Woodcraft and buy at their retail price.
I dreaded the small retail customer because they didn't know the market or market conventions of tally and grade and the result was usually ill will in spite of the fact they were getting lumber priced like they were a wholesale customer of large quantities.
The bottom line in these affairs is if you want to get the price large customers pay then learn and accept the customs of the business.