Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

Posts

Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#1

Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Barry Irby

Just had a tire installed on my 99 model Mazda B3000. One of the lugs broke off. They wrung it off with an air wrench. Appears to have drum brakes. How much trouble is it to replace a lug? Who does it? Do I go get one form the dealer and do it myself? Can I drive it with four out of five lug nuts in place without a problem? Thanks for the help.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#2

The tire people should replace the wheel

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Leo Cuellar

Barry, 4 lugs are ok for a while if you don't do any Duke"s of Hazard driving. Studs should be available at any good auto parts store. But if the tire shop broke it I'd make them fix it. The lug can be pressed or hammered out from the outside of the drum after backing off the brakes & removing the drum from the car. To install one make sure the splines are lined up with the grooves in the hole and tap it in. Alternatively, it can be drawn into the hole by using a few washers under the nut and tightening it until it seats.

Good luck either way!

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question *LINK*

Dale Lenz

Think that most cars are the same when it comes to removing/replace wheel studs, seems I've done it as described in the link below years ago(??). Proceed with caution, me thinks it should work.


Replacing wheel studs

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#5

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Yonak

To avoid the problem of an over-aggressive kid with an air wrench wringing off a lug, years ago my mechanic advised me to ask the tire place to only hand-tighten lug nuts. I have done that since. Whether they actually do what I ask them to do, I don't know, but no one has ever refused to agree to it and I've never had a problem since.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#6

Replace it ASAP

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

I had a similar problem a number of years ago with the local Toyota dealer. I went to switch from snow tires to summer tires just a week after the car had been inspected. As part of the inspection they are supposed to pull a tire and inspect the brakes. I had to put my full weight on the 4 way wrench to get the nuts to move. The second one I tried the stud snapped off. The following morning I took the car to the dealer and they claimed the studs had rusted (in a week). I had borrowed a calibrated torque wrench from work and it took 250 foot pounds to back off the nut. Normal torque was supposed to be 65-85 ft-lbs. I insisted that they replace all the studs on the car, since it was new, with new studs. They refused. I wrote to Toyota and within a day of getting a telegram from Toyota, the dealer was one the phone asking me to bring my car in for stud replacement.

Don't fool around driving on 3 studs there are four or more there for a reason. Also, when you leave your car at a garage insist they hand torque your lug nuts when they put them back on. If they refuse, take your business elsewhere.

Lee

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#7

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

When one lug's broken, undue stress is transferred to the others. At minimum, you can bend the wheel. At worst, you can create a cascade of broken lugs, which can lead to the wheel coming off, something that only ever happens at high speeds during rush hour (a variant of Murphy's Law).

I agree: if they broke it, they should repair it, regardless of cost. And check the wheel right away. When some tire store idiot broke off a lug on my truck (didn't know about lefthand threads on the left side, something that was common in the early 50s), the wheels got bent just in the drive home from there.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#8

And another thing about lug nut torque...

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

whenever you rotate, replace or otherwise R&R a wheel (I believe this applies mostly to aluminum wheels), you need to hand torque when you mount the wheel and then recheck again after about 3-400 miles. Failure to do this will likely cause premature brake rotor warpage. I found this out the hard way. This does not apply to drum brakes, but most cars today have disc brakes anyway.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#9

Not sure

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Aluminum wheels tend to relax somewhat after torque leaving the nuts loose, so you should re-torque them after a100 +/- miles. I don't think it has anything to do with brake discs warping.

Lee

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#10

Re: The tire people should replace the wheel

Barry Irby

They covered they a$$es with a "Not Responsible for Broken lugs" sign, Which was about the only English in the place. I was there for cheap tires and I got them.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#11

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Larry in NW OHIO

Same as Yonak. Whenever I have tires rotated I tell them I do not want an air wrench on the wheel nuts and only torque the nuts, I think they are suppose to be around 100lbs. It`s in your manual. Larry

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#12

Dale Lenz

Re: The tire people should replace the wheel

Dale Lenz

That sign is probably not worth the paper it's written on. Kinda like trucks hauling rocks w/ sign not responsible for broken windshields. They are calling your bluff. Bluff back. As I tell my sons: Be Nice, but Firm. Roadhouse movie: Patrick S. , Don't need to ask them to take it outside, :").

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#13

Indeed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm not sure it's possible to absolve yourself from responsibility by posting a sign that says, "We don't guarantee that we're competent." There is a general standard in civil law that a company that sells a product or service has to be basically competent to sell it.

Granted, broken lugs are not exclusively the fault of the particular shop that breaks them - previous tire/brake shops could have stretched the lug almost to capacity. But if it wasn't broken going in, and was going out, it would be pretty hard to argue that they weren't the proximate cause of the break, bearing some responsibility. And it's so well known that air wrenches over-torque that, here on a woodworking board, you got multiple responses from people who were aware of that.

There's a reason that the manufacturers (car and wheel) state a torque for lug nuts. If that shop could prove that their air wrenches torqued accurately to a specific value, then maybe they'd have an argument; but I think there'll be pigs flying overhead before anyone can prove that with the kind of air wrenches available to the average tire/brake shop.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#14

I'd try out the shop too...

John in NM

Frankly, wheels studs are so easy to replace in many cases, that if a shop has such a sign I believe I might tell them they're idiots. Good customer service starts with doing all that trivially easy stuff as a courtesy, the customer doesn't know how easy it is, so you really shine when you do it for them. Mind boggling how many businesses miss some of these basics. This is likely the same sort of shop that swipes your core refunds and charges you 3X for brake parts, selling cheap tires to suck you in.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#15

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Joseph Mulherin

I agree with the idea of having the attendant NOT use the air wrenches on the lug nuts. And they should only be tightened to 55lbs. I had a blowout on the highway two weeks ago and had to stand on the lug wrench to loosen it enough to remove the lugs to replace the shredded tire with the donut replacement tire. And the donut replacement tire should only be driven on for about 50-70 miles and the tire pressure should be at 55lbs.... at least on my vehicle.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#16

Two different issues

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

I agree that the aluminum wheels relax and that's the reason for the re-tightening. However, alot of people just cinch them up with an air ratchet set for too much torque or crank on them too tight with a lug nut spanner, and not do the proper torque setting. When they do that, my brake guy swears it results in premature warped rotors. He's had to replace too many rotors warped by the owner's failure to tighten properly when rotating tires. He now tells every customer about this. Maybe it's baloney, but I used to do it the wrong way and have had rotors warp way earlier than I thought they should.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#17

It's baloney alright...

John in NM

Now if the lugs were out at the edge of the rotor, there might be something to that :D Driving habits are a much, much more likely cause of the problem. Habitual fast braking is going to warp rotors faster than gentile use (and granted, "gentile use" is not always practical in city driving :D ). I bet your brake guy would find a dearth of customers though, if he told them stuff like that :D

All this is not to criticize the tightening regime suggested, it's not an unreasonable thing to do. The justification for it just sounds unlikely. It does have the benefit for your mechanic of discouraging DIY work though :D

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#18

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Things like this is why I always go to Discount Tire. They use an impact wrench and then follow up with a torque wrench. I can't validate the torque settings, but I have never has a problem with a wheel over the 20 plus years I have used them.

Let us not forget that torque is measured in POUND FEET, not foot pounds, regardless of what nascar says. High on my pet peeve list....

Auto repair shops are like buying tools, buy quality and spend your money once,

Ken

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#19

"gentile use"  ?????

paul in AZ

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#20

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Steve Schoene

Since multiplication is communicative how is foot-pounds any different than pound-foot?

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#21

P-F and F-P

paul in AZ

AFIK the technical difference between P-F and F-P is that one is a measure of torque and the other is a measure of distance. Unless you give me plenty of time to try to remember which is which don't ask me which is the correct one to use when it comes up. In ordinary use they are interchangeable for me -but I don't teach physics.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#22

Re: P-F and F-P

Bill Howatt

I think the proper unit of torque is pound-force-foot but force gets left out usually. The unit of work is supposed to be foot-pound intended to reduce confusion with torque. They seem to be used interchangeably.

Bill

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#23

Re: P-F and F-P

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

Very good, Paul, Bill.

A pound-foot is applying the force of one pound to a lever at a distance of one foot from the pivot point.

A foot pound is, as stated, a unit of work. Lifting a one pound mass one foot is one foot pound of work.

Now you have the one pound at one foot off the ground. your buddy says he can shoot a hole in the mass before it hits the ground. Question, where does your buddy aim his gun?? Assume that the gun is fired at the exact time you drop the mass.

Happy saw dust,

Ken

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#24

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Mark Nowicki

Lots of trouble if you have never worked on drum brakes. (if you had you would know what brakes you have)

To change the lug you will have to take the drum off, which might involve backing off the star wheel adjuster.

Mechanics do it.

Lugs are easy to get at any auto parts store.

www.ericthecarguy.com is your friend. Guys on this forum mean well but boy, talk about thread drift.

Mark

Gotta run, changing the pads on my Honda.

Re: Car Guy? Replacing tire lug Question

#25

Re: Car Guy?  Replacing tire lug Question

Mark Nowicki

Finished the back, pads changed, hand brake cleaned, lubricated and adjusted.

Forgot to answer your last question re: safety.

Engineers don't design cars, accountant do. Four is cheaper than five, unless five are necessary.

BTW my torque wrench is marked in inch pounds and in M and KGS

Mark

On to the front pads