Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

Posts

Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#1

Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

Gary Smyth

Saw Stop technology is going to at least one committee on Capitol Hill today. Sorry, I don�t know what committee. It reflects consumer protection and all that entails. Keep your collective ears to the wall. The consumer case revolves around that Saw Stop is and has been a proven technology for nearly a decade, it is a relatively inexpensive addition to the initial cost given that accidents not using the technology are expensive to fix or not fixable, and that other table saw manufacturers are holding back only until the patent expires in order not to pay the inventor (Steve Gass) license fees. In addition, the ten (10) �serious� table saw accidents, per day, in the U.S. makes their case stronger. Similar to what was done with cigarettes, a very powerful lobby, the court awards for accidents not using saw stopping technology are massive. If this strikes a chord on the Hill, I�m betting that within five years, saws will not be sold in the U.S. without the technology, and that existing saws that aren�t adapted (or adaptable) will not be able to be sold (as a saw).

Remember this? "Sawstop was in the multimillion dollar suit that was won by an individual using a small tabletop saw with no fence or miter gage,or blade guard,with the blade raised to it's maximum height. Sawstop had apparently been dealing with the manufacturer to purchase the product for their saws,but the manufacturer backed out. With everything the individual did wrong, he won the case because Sawstop had this safety feature which the company could have incorporated in the saw, but failed to do so."

In my view it was a bad award, but as with cigarette legislation, personal choice/responsibility is taking second place to the "greater good".

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#2

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

It is my hope that many who hear of this will purchase a new Delta saw (made in the USA) before the idiots in Washington propose to make the addition of this technology a law. I have been woodworking for over 55 years and have never even nicked myself on a table or cabinet saw. I have been bruised a few times due to kickback (my own stupid fault) but highly respect the cutting ability of my tools.

Pretty soon they will try to outlaw sharp chisels and pointed drill bits and saber saw blades (both of which have "bit" me a few times in the past). They will also probably want to put radar on nail guns to prevent shooting into a finger etc. - (I have nicked myself with them). Guess they have to develop new lumber too, some that can't have splinters. Course it will have to have no more weight than Balsa so it won't break your toes when dropped or hurt your back when lifted.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

Moses Yoder

The government revealed their idiocy when they made it illegal to kill yourself. I don't think they have come up with anything to top that.

I know several shops that have SawStop saws. Due to the safety of the saw, the employees are so careless with it they set the brake off all the time. 5 or 6 times this year already the brake has been kicked off by 2 different employees. Without the technology those guys would probably be dead now and wouldn't be able to breed.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#4

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

If those Idiots get involved we are all in trouble. Back in the 80's I was Plant foreman in a display manufacturing company and we had an OSHA inspector come to the plant. I was assigned the pleasure of showing him around. From the Get Go he kept telling me how difficult it was for him to survive on his salary. We came to the oscillating spindle sander and he said he was violating us because it didn't have a guard on it. I told him it didn't need a guard. He replied " all routing machines are required to have guards". I proceded to show him it was a sanding machine and he quickly resumed his sad tale of woe about how under paid he was.

We got one violation for water on the floor in the Ladies room. I think he missed the toilet.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#5

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

steve mackay

I'm glad I up-graded to the big TS a couple years ago. This one should out-last me. By that time LOML should be able to sell off my "old fashioned", "simple-to-own" machine for a decent price. They'll be in demand.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#6

what about other products

McKay

If you have a wreck in a Kia that does not have the "accident detection technology" that the Mercedes has, does this law suit open the door to those people against Kia because their car does not have that technology? I really do not understand how this got this far. If I want the technology, I pay for it. Apparently this is not the case here anymore.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#7

Maybe No

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Larry,

Last time I look, Delta was being made in Asia like most of the others.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#8

mostly Yes??

Ron

copied from the Manufacturer:

Assembled and Machined in the U.S.A.

The new Unisaw is proudly made in the U.S.A. of foreign and domestic components in our Jackson, Tennessee facility. In this product, we use cast-iron milled and machined in the U.S.A. and include an American-made Marathon Motor.

By making products here in the U.S. we can adhere to higher standards of quality and accuracy than our competitors - many of whom use low cost imports. It also means jobs for American workers.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#9

Ah, So

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

It's Asian iron and steel, alloyed and cast/stamped like any of the others to save money, but with boring and the top milled/ground here. Well, at least the motor's American, unless, of course, it's made by the Marathon Electric plants in India . . .

If its all the same, when I choose to "Buy American" I want the whole deal done right here; anything less and we get to start asking questions like "How much machining is done where, etm. etm. I have a basic distrust of what amounts to "Ad copy."

We have a whole generation of skilled foundry workers flippin' burgers. That's not much in the way of retraining from my view.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#10

Re: Ah, So

Kurt

"We have a whole generation of skilled foundry workers flippin' burgers."

Foundries are not a green industry. They are not allowed here.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#11

Re: mostly Yes??

Larry in NW OHIO

They try to give you a bunch of CRAP about,"higher standards of quality and accuracy", thats the same Bull____ we get out of Washington. If they want that, I don`t understand then why don`t they do more here in the states. What about the rest of their products, they don`t care that it`s just garbage. Larry

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#12

Why knock partial USA-made, given the options?

Ron

The USA-made table saw didn't collect enough votes ($) to continue its long term in office. Now its not even a candidate. We can gripe about this fact of course, but that's not particularly productive unless it's just to reminisce. For the near future, we can vote for a candidate that is a bastard, by its own admission, but if we don't vote for it heartedly, guess what happens next.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#13

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - update *LINK*

Gary Smyth

The Power Tool Institute, a trade group representing table-saw manufacturers including Black & Decker and Bosch, said in a statement that the price of table saws would "increase dramatically" if companies had to use the SawStop technology. "The lower-priced consumer bench-top saws will disappear from the market," the group warned. NOTE: AND NOW FOR THE REAL REASON -- It also said SawStop would enjoy an unfair market advantage. Link is well down the list under Huffpro Reports.


http://www.huffingtonpost.com

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#14

Because

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

They hide or try to obscure the "partial" while catering to the "buy USA" population. That's a half truth with is the most pernicious of lies.

Don't get me wrong, I have a shop full of Asian iron, but JET was quite honest about it.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#15

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - update

Steve Schoene

Well yes--obviously SawStop would have a competitive advantage. When a government instituted rule mandates a technology which is has a patent held by one competitors, the others face a very difficult competitive situation, since they MUST negotiate for the licence to use that technology from a monopolist competitor.

Think about buying a used car when the salesman knows you absolutely must buy a car today. Clearly royalty demands would be really expensive--and saw sales would be reduced to the monopoly level. Reportedly in early round negotiations the fee demand was reported to be 8% of the wholesale price of the saw. In additiion, in the intitial negotiations, to the extent information became public, it appears that SawStop, in addition to collecting a healthy royalty and to be the sole manufacturer of the stop cartidges, which could be a major expense to licencing manufacturers. I can't swear that those are accurate figures.

That's why regulators tend not to pass regulations that would provide one competitor with a monopoly position. That's not very good for consumers.

Of course the rule would likely mean that the lowest priced tablesaw on the market would be somewhere around $500. Mr. Gass seems to think it would add only a little--say S100 the cost of the machines. But the experience of his own company tends to contradict that with the prices of his machines substantially more than $100 more than comparable saws without the Stop mechanism. The issue not mentioned in the cost comparison from Mr. Gass is that the added cost is not just the saw stop mechanisms, but is also the requirements to have a beefier saw in order to survive the stresses involved in stopping and moving below the table for a saw blade at 3500 rpm.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#16

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - update

FredD

I can imagine Mr. Gass didn't swell on the after Market expenses , like the cartridge and new saw blade, each and every time for whatever reason the gadget shut down the saw.

FredD

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#17

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - update

Gary Smyth

You get no argument from me one way or another. My table saw is not a Saw Stop. Still, the handwriting is on the wall. Think biscuit joiners, multimaster tools -- they were out there for years at high prices, protected by patent. When the patent lapsed all sorts of companies jumped in with similar tools. For even heavy users, most of the other, newer company�s tools work just fine. Just how much of the market did Lamello and Fein lose when the American market opened to everyone else? Whether you like a Saw Stop or not, the technology cannot be ignored, and every manufacturer out there that doesn�t offer that technology will be forced, if necessary, by legal incentives to do so. Pay me now or pay me later.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#18

The patent

Phil Joines

They could just void his patent in the public interest. It's been done before.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#19

Re: Ah, So

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Actually foundries can be incredibly green. The sand used for making molds is a natural non-processed product and is reused in the casting process. The shop I apprenticed at uses electric induction furnaces. A lot of the metal cast comes from recycled sources and all the in house created scrap is re-melted.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#20

More to it than meets the eye

Neal in San Jose

Somone mentioned smoking as being a user's choice. I would agree with that if ALL smokers took personal responsibility for the consequences of their actions. My understanding, and I'm open to be corrected, is that much of the added medical costs caused by smokers is passed on to the general public. that means, I, as a non-smoker, am subsidizing smoking. Thus, I'm in favor of, and vote for laws that restrict smoking.

My guess is that everyone, even non-woodworkers pay for table saw accidents thru higher medical insurance costs, taxes to pay for worker's comp and disability, and the loss of wood shop in public education.

Addy protocol: I own a Sawstop and I admit to making a mistake that it saved me from. I can still count to 10 because of my Sawstop.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#21

Re: what about other products

AZ in Colorado Springs

"I really do not understand how this got this far."

Always remember that legislation passed in Washington DC is less concerned with safety, value, etc. -- it's about power, manipulating markets, and $$.

That might sound overly cynical, but if the politicians were really interested in simply providing leadership, they'd stay for a term or two and go back to real jobs. But they stay in Washington forever and make their careers on building up their own political power & clout.

I'm not saying you can't trust anyone in Washington, but realize that they do not approach any issue from the same viewpoint that you do.

That's how it got this far ... in all areas of legislation/regulation, and not just concerning power tools.

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#22

Watch out for "hard water" as well,

mdclor

it is a killer!!!!! :D

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#23

Re: Right on Larry

Chuck Lenz

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

#24

Re: Capitol Hill hearings - Saw Stop

FrankG

There should be a law that restricts those people from breeding to start with.