Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

"Seen" versus "Saw"

Posts

"Seen" versus "Saw"

#1

Moses Yoder

"Seen" versus "Saw"

Moses Yoder

In school back in the '70s and '80s I was taught that the the word "seen" is a past participle of "see". "Saw", on the other hand, is a verb. It is the simple past tense of the word "see".

To use the word seen it would be prefaced with a verb, normally "have". A proper sentence would look like this; "I have seen a tool that looks like it". If you said "I have saw a tool that looks like it" you would be carted off to the mental facility.

The word saw being a simple past tense verb can be used without a preface. A proper sentence would look like this " I saw a tool that looks like it". This would mean you have seen a tool in the past, because saw is the past tense of see.

Today everybody uses the word "seen" as the simple past tense verb of "see". It makes me constantly question someone's sanity when I hear them say "I seen John a week ago". I was thinking maybe proper English is just too hard for everybody and we should throw out the whole dictionary and just use what we see fit. The other thought I had was that maybe the rules have changed since I went to school.

What say you?

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#2

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

Stuart Johnson

If the seen vs. saw use isn't specifically tested here in Texas on TAKS then it won't be taught on the "teach to the test" theory of education. It is two bad Texas teachers aren't allowed too teach.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#3

Amen Moses!

Stuart Hough

Here in South Carolina I hear that at least one hundred times a day, along with "I done that" and "me and (insert name) are going". It is a pervasive thing! I work for a former educator who sends emails with the word "allot" in place of "a lot". I can deal with, and even enjoy, hearing the local colloquialisms, such as "ya'll" and "over yonder" because that is part of the makeup of my area, but the others just show a lack of effort on the part of the speaker to use what they have been taught. It's sort of a commentary on the general decline we are living through.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#4

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

I totally agree, Moses.

I worked with a very smart fellow at TI that was always screwing up seen, and he had a masters degree.

I wonder how many people really know the proper use of the verb to be, and as you have pointed out, to see.

Now, I am not an expert by any means in the use of the English Language, and my wife often corrects me with ridicule like ' I done gone, or you goed where?. But I really did cringe and feel sorry for the chap a couple days ago that used 'keeped' several times in his post.

Remember to Eschew Obfuscation, and definitely don't engage in sesquipedalianism.

Now, I is done bloviating,

Ken

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#5

stuart, I done been in Texas for over 30 years

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

and I still dont have my fixin tos down right.

I surely wish that Jackie Gleason was still with us so that we could have another Smoky and the Bandit movie.

Ken

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#7

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

Gary Smyth

If you said "I have saw a tool that looks like it" you would be carted off to the mental facility.

Let's give the benefit of the doubt and give the guy a break. Perhaps a word was transposed, "I have a saw tool that looks like it."

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#8

proper English is dying

paul in AZ

At least that which we were taught as English.

Some of my peeves are the inability to differentiate possessives and pleurals [the 's added to pleurals] and homonyms or more accurately homophones [there/their etc.].

We haven't seen the worst yet. Wait until the text messaging generation takes full control of the language.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#9

Moses Yoder

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

Moses Yoder

You know I think you are right about that one. If the guy is not wearing his pants down around his knees I would be willing to cut him some slack.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#10

Invite versus Invitation

mdclor

This is the one that really gets my blood circulating. It seems that the verb has totally replaced the noun. >(

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#11

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

Howard Acheson

The two that get me are the misuse of "calvery" when referring to "cavalry" and the mispronunciation of "library" as "libery".

Just recently I was listening to three well educated historians discussing Custer's Last Stand and all three spoke of the calvery when they were referring to the cavalry. What topped it off was when one of them suggested that viewers may want to go to the libery to verify some facts.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#12

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

Fred Davis

Without looking it up Moses , explain the difference between "further and farther"

While I am at it, how many is "several"?

One of my favorites was Jack Nicholson being over heard at a party when a Lady approached him and asked, "wanna Dance" and he replied "wrong verb". ;-))

FredD

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#13

Re: proper English is dying

Ron Jones

Your point on the text message generation is very accurate.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#14

Not Moses, but

Henry Higginbotham

Further usually applies to extent, as in "I'll have to look into this further."

Farther should be reserved for application to something measurable, as in "The beer store is just a little farther down the road."

These are just a couple of rules of thumb; you could go a lot deeper into the subject and ruffle a lot (not alot) of feathers along the way.

Bonus Marginally Useful Information:

Further: The bus owned by Ken Kesey and The Merry Pranksters

Furthur: Band formed by ex-Grateful Dead members Bobby Weir and Phil Lesh

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#15

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

chispy

My favourite peeve is people on the phone that ask me to 'verify' my address. I always say yes and then there is this strange silence. Unfortunately the other person does not realise that I would have to see their version of my adress so that I can 'verify' that they have it right.

My second peeve is when the airline tells me that we wil be landing "momentarily', again not realising that momentarily means FOR a moment and not IN a moment.

My final peeve is the addition of the letter H to words with S's in them, eg sHtress, shtorm,etc.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#16

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

Stuart Johnson

I think there is a difference between the written word and the spoke word. Regional accents come into play. I seriously doubt if Norm spells saw with an r but it sure sounds like there is one in there someplace when he pronounces it.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#17

Clint Searl

As evidenced on this board

Clint Searl

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#18

or "nuk-you-lar"?

paul in AZ

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#19

Obviously, you don't party!

Bill Howatt

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#20

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

Fred Davis

Then then there are "non stop flights "................

FredD

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#21

Re: Not Moses, but

Fred Davis

Your trolling now Henry, suffice it to say , one is a adverb and one can be either a Adverb or Adjective,which is which? ;-))

FredD

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#22

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

John Veerkamp

Myself instead of "I" or "me" is my current get on the nerves misuse.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#23

further vs farther

Jim Pugh

It is my understanding that 'further' means in addition to and the correct usage would be a sentence containing the words 'further more'.

Farther simply means more far. The mountain is farther away that it appears.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#24

affect vs effect 

Dan Donaldson