Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

"Seen" versus "Saw"

Posts

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#51

Going to be a contrarian...

John in NM

My efforts to use proper grammar and spelling are due in part to those who point out errors and in part due to those who don't bother to take pride in their writing, and due in large part to those who insist on using texting shorthand when they are not texting :D

If I were to be fanatical about it, I would attempt to do the same in my speech, but I'm afraid I have never spoken as well as I write.

If it's any help, think of language as a tool, just like your dovetail saw, chisels, plane, or what have you. If you wish to communicate about woodworking, isn't it prudent to keep your language as sharp (figuratively of course :D ) as your woodworking tools?

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#52

Me, too

Henry Higginbotham

Bill's "deal" isn't exactly apples to apples. Woodworking is a elective activity that any given person can do without if he chooses. For most of us, it occupies only a small percentage of our time.

Language, on the other hand, is used by practically everyone, every day. It's what moves ideas, opinions, and the like from your head into mine, where they're processed and remembered as useful or discarded as drivel.

Of course, I'm well aware that some people may naturally have better language skills than others, but I also know that some people simply put more effort into it. I don't consider myself "smug" about it (I know I could use some improvement, too), but I do think that anyone could take the time to hit the preview button and review before posting. If you write it once, 200 other people may have to spend extra time deciphering what could have been easy with just a bit more effort on the front end. It's just common courtesy to those trying to wade through the post.

I grew up in semi-rural Alabama, and my speech has always been in need of improvement. I've had my share of people correcting me. But I didn't get defensive; rather, I took note of the comments, looked things up if appropriate, and learned something.

And by the way, Bill: If everyone's posts were as lucid and useful as yours, this thread would probably not exist. You're a long way from number one on the list. :)

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#53

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Me, too

Joe Bradshaw

Words mean things. Say what you mean and mean what you say.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#54

Bottom line

Bill Tindall

This forum depends on contributors willing to expose themselves to the thoughts and comments of others. Anything that dissuades someone from posting interesting or useful information reduces this participation. We need to turn "lurkers" into contributors and attract more of each. Posts that begin "my pet peeve" aren't helpful for encouraging active participation.

If a post is not clear post a question requesting clarification. This action has a good chance of leading to a favorable result.

I think I understand the complaint. People can be chronically lazy or trendy in their communication and this attitude can be annoying, especially the trendy part. But I don't see much of this behavior on this Forum. In other cases consider that the poster has something useful to say but they may be tired, or short of time or whatever(a word I find useful but others take offense at) and not carefully craft a post. Be tolerant.

The above was crafted to the best of my ability in spite of the fact I need to plant tomatoes.

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#55

Re: Bottom line

Ken DeMarco

Thank you Bill! As someone who at least weekly reads this forum, but very infrequently posts (usually in the turners forum), I can tell you the intimidation factor here is very high., just based on the quality of everyones work and their knowledge. If i have to worry that my spelling, syntax amd puctuation are perfect I know i would never post, and would probably stop reading. Fortunatly the friendly factor here at woodcentral seems to keep most from atacking any new people for lack of knowledge, either woodworking or grammer. Just one of the reasons this is the BEST woodworking forum on the web. (and yes i have been scolded on other forums for my spelling and pucuation, and oposing viewpoints on popular equipment brands)

Thanks,

Ken DeMarco

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#56

Re: Bottom line

FredD

I agree with Henry about Language being a form of communication and like Woodworking , the more accurate it is , the better the understanding.

Barry was worried that he might be a "Redneck" awhile ago and poor spelling , syntax and so on are a hallmark of that part of the population.

I am a Abilene Cowboy and the English and Literature departments in high school took the view of"do it until you get it right" just like the Shop Teacher did.

I read a lot and poorly composed articles in the Newspaper are becoming the norm rather then the exception, not to mention Obits that have people dieing before they are born , married to Brothers or Sisters and like that.

The last two books I read had the Author losing track of his Characters in the middle of the page.

Lastly my Dad was a poor speller, but had beautiful handwriting that I have envied all of my life , since my penmanship requires you to read it when it is fresh , before the idea completely slips my mind, I have tried many times to improve it and failed every time.

FredD

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#57

If somebody tied my hands I'd be a mute!!!

Jay Lombardo

Re: "Seen" versus "Saw"

#58

Re: If somebody tied my hands I'd be a mute!!!

Joseph Mulherin

Sometimes Silence is Golden.......