Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT Trespass Questions

Posts

OT Trespass Questions

#1

OT Trespass Questions

Barry Irby

I am mostly venting here, so if you don't care feel free to quit reading.

I bought a house at foreclosure. Fixed it up and my son is living in it. turns out there is an easement across the back f the property and there is a commercial property on the other side. The Property line runs right down the middle of the easement and the commercial property has a privacy fence on heir side of the easement.

There were feral cats living in the area when I bought the house. They had found their way into the house We made repairs and blocked them out. Later we discovered that someone was feeding them in the woods behind the neighbor's property. They had a trash can with dry cat food and several cat carriers wrapped up in plastic to serve as shelter. Then the woman who claimed to won the building behind us came around the end of the fence and accosted us working in the yard. She was shrieking about the cats and that we had cut trees and taken down our fence and on and on. We tried to settle her down and pointed out that we had nothing to do with the cats and wished they would go away. Our fence was rotten and beyond recovery so we had remove it along with fifteen truckloads of debris. And we had not cut down any trees in the easement. She left, throwing the cat paraphernalia over the fence and into her dumpster.

Later, tenants from the commercial building came over, upset at the loss of the cat paraphernalia. We explained that their land lord had thrown it away after accusing us of feeding the cats. They were surprised, saying that their land lord had known all along they were feeding them.

Later, she squeezed my son of damaging her fence. We pointed out that the fence had rotted because they had used landscape timbers for posts and that they just rot. We offered to give her any posts from our fence that were serviceable to use to make repairs.

Later, She had the property line surveyed. Then she had people drive posts in the easement on the line and put up posted signs. We removed the last of the old fencing, but left the posts. She has had the fence posts repaired by adding a few extra posts.

Now she has accused my son of trespassing and filed a warrant on him. How do we deal with this?

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#2

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

What is the easement? That must be set forth in a document filed in the property records where you can get a copy of it. Generally easements are for a particular use (driveway, utility access-way, fence, etc.) and do not give the holder (of the easement) rights to exclude the landowner, from "entering upon the land" in question. They often carry the obligation to properly maintain the area to keep it free of hazards, refuse, rotten fences, etc. Moreover, some easements are limited and personal (from A to B), some have limited duration (6 months, 20 years, "while A is the owner") and some "run with the land" and survive transfers.

You need to get a copy of the document and then speak to an attorney in your area. As a property inspector, I'm sure one of your real estate attorney clients would give you a bit of free advice on this.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Moses Yoder

My friend Al Capone taught me the 3 S's. (He lives in a swamp near where I live.) The 3 S's; shoot, shovel, and shut up. Sounds like your only line of defense against crazy. If you don't take this advice, I would consult a lawyer.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#4

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

You may have just gotten a clue as to why the property became available to you in the first place.

Since you had an attorney present at closing, I would suggest that you contact that attorney and set an appointment to discuss the easement and your options regarding it. Then I would file a complaint or obtain a restraining order against the neighbor if she is in fact exceeding her authority in regard to the easement. If she confronts you or your son again after the restraining order has been put in place, then I would simple call the police and let them deal with her.

Failing that, I would locate a for sale sign and sell the house at a profit now that it is fixed up and leave the neighbor hood.

Lee

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#5

Re: OT Trespass Questions

del schisler

First i would get my laywer that done all the checking out all the paper work. And have him find out what the easment is for power co. lines water co. ect. Than you know what you can do. If it work's out that the easment is for the above. Maybe you can put a fence back up and keep here on here side?? The easment doesn't mean that the property is not free and clear of all leen's . The title company should have all that info on the property. Some time they have lived their so long thet thay thank they own all of the ground all around. Time to change that. By law i mean . I have a easment on the back of my poperty for power line's but they are out frount figure this one?? I check and that is what it is? I don't need to worry about it i have a canal in the back. The only thing is stay back 20 feet.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#6

Me too . . .

s mackay

The phone company's lines are buried in back. An easment is a very specific thing with very specific stipulations for a very specific purpose. Thing is that it is all explained, in detail, in the real estate papers. So should your's. Sounds like she has been bullying for a long time and getting away with it. In the ARMY we would call the lady a "Latrine Lawyer". A professional is going to shut 'er down.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#7

I find this amazing.....

Barry Irby

My son and I bought a derelict property that had been sitting empty for a long time. Its in a residential neighborhood with this commercial office building behind it on the other side of the easement and privacy fence. We have spent about $50,000 cleaning up and fixing up the property. The residential neighbors are thrilled. Nothing but happy responses about our cleaning up the blight on the area.

We have not encroached on the easement except to give her about a dozen 4x4's she could use to fix her fence. I truly do not have a clue as to what has ticked her off.

It is a utility easement. Power and phone and Internet and whatever, but not a drainage easement. I stopped by the county and talked to the utilities dept. and they assure me I have done no harm and they don't care if I enter upon the part that is on my property to clean it up or do what ever as long as I don't erect any permanent structures that might block their access.

Before she filed the warrant on my son I talked to the attorney who closed the property for me. He explained about my rights. Interestingly, I have no complaint that she came on our property to photograph them working on her side, but she can now complain because she posted her side. I find it to be the height of hypocrisy that she trespasses on me while complaining about people trespassing on her. She also did not call Miss Utility to see if driving the property stakes would interfere with the utilities. Would have been a shame if she caused someone to be injured while driving the stakes.

Did I mention she painted our side of the fence lavender but her side is Red Wood color?

The attorney explained that she can paint her fence any color she wants. I wanted to write them a letter but he said such letters get twisted around and that I should let her alone in hopes she would calm down. Not so much.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#8

Wait now

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

What does this easement have to do with this adjoining landowner? Has she put her fence on the easement or some other structure there? Do I understand that she is complaining about what you do on your own property or on hers? A utility easement will usually have been granted to the power company, not her. Are you sure the fence is on her side of the line? Are you sure that the stakes she's placed are in the correct locations?

Something is not matching up here.

If, in fact, she has put a structure (fence) inside the easement, albeit on her side of the property line, let the power company know. They are likely to drop by and remove it, lavender paint and all, for interference with the easement.

Suggest you consider planting a line of arborvitae along the whole line of the easement on your side as a living fence. Then "post" it yourself.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#9

The fine line....

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...to walk in legal stuff is between knowing and defending your rights and letting the other side get to you in a way that causes you to do/say something stupid while doing so. Whenever you get emotional, you lose.

I'm with Mark: find out exactly where the property lines are, what the respective rights are (yours, hers, the utility company's), write it all down for yourself, and then defend your rights.

There's a general saying: anyone can sue anyone for anything. This doesn't speak to the merits of the suit, and a lot of suits get tossed in court because they so obviously have no basis whatsoever. This one sounds a little different: if she has actually had a warrant sworn out on your son, that's a criminal rather than civil matter (unless the word is meant differently in your state); but the concept remains.

Unfortunately, once someone has invoked The Law in any way, you get stuck with having to respond within the rules of The Law. If you don't, you can lose a case not on its merits, but on not showing up in the arena (court) or not playing by the rules.

If it was, in fact, a warrant as it's meant in California - a criminal charge - you might contact the DA, who would be responsible for prosecuting it, and, as calmly as possible, describe the situation to him/her, and seek advice as to what facts s/he needs to determine whether to proceed. If it is as ridiculous as you're describing, the DA might well be able to get the warrant quashed; prosecuting attorneys have enough heavy-duty stuff on the plate to spend time on nonsense.

Or you may need an attorney good on property law - sometimes that becomes a business expense (do I recall that this is a rental?).

If you are able to resolve the immediate issue, that doesn't mean you're not going to have problems. Sounds like someone who doesn't like the changes that are going on; or is trying to assert as much territory, physical or emotional, as possible, while she thinks the situation is in flux; or is a nutcase neighbor (always a possibility). If the first two, once this situation is resolved, you might see if you can calm things down a little and talk about what she really wants, then decide if that's within reason or not. If she's a nutcase, well, those are always hard.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: I find this amazing.....

Moses Yoder

There are all sorts of mental problems out there. She has one or more of them. Dealing with a mentally disabled person is very different from normal dealings. Even if you win a court case, chances are she will continue to cause problems. You will have to either laugh it off, move somewhere else, or figure out a way to get rid of her.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#11

Thanks for the replies....

Barry Irby

My understanding of the situation is that there is an 8' wide easement on my side of the line and a similar easement on their side. I had assumed that the neighbors fences were a decent indication of the back of the property. (I know its foolish to assume anything based on the location of fences, but the truth is, we knew the easement was there and had no intention of encroaching at all.)

One of her steps was to have the property pins for the back of our property located by surveyors. (We actually appreciate that, saved us from the expense) They were exactly where I thought they were.

Having the location in hand, she had her workers drive steel fence posts a couple of inches on her side of the line, but in the easement. Then they wired No Trespassing signs to them.

It turns out that our rotting fence panels were sitting about half on her and half on us in the easement. Based on my attorney's advice we dragged them back onto our side and hauled them to the dump. His explanation was that since we could drag them back without going onto her property we could and we did. The 4x4's were on her side and we left them.

I just had my son read the charge to me and it is that we trespassed from March 18th through May 7th. Not sure what that is about, but she only posted the property about two weeks ago and we have stayed off it since. My attorney told me it was nat a problem if she came on our property unless we had it posted. I have to assume that cuts both ways. Whatever right she had would have extended to us until she posted her property.

When I told the attorney I wanted to write her a letter his comment was that it was like wrestling with a pig. Everybody gets dirty, but the pig likes it.

The building is owned by The Edison Group LLC. She is not an attorney. I thought Corporations had to be represented by an attorney.

Other than the fact she has created a lot of uproar and ill will I have no complaint with what she has done. We were concerned the fence would blow over onto us, but she had that fixed, albeit a half a$$ed repair, it is less dangerous than before. The lavender paint is laughable. She has ended the feeding of the feral cats and they are fading away. The No Trespassing signs are loud and obnoxious, but who cares?

Turns out we already owned about twenty five little arborvitaes and are planting them across the rear and down the side. My son is planting them directly in front of the No Trespassing signs now that she has given us an indication of where a fast growing plant is needed.

difficult dealing with a lunatic.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#12

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Barry, do exactly like Lee has stated. He has given you some very good advice....put up the for sale sign and get out of the neighborhood.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#13

Crazy people refuse to believe they're wrong

GolfSteve in Calgary

A real lawyer may be able to shut her down, but the problem is that crazy people refuse to believe they are wrong and she will drag this on and on, costing you your sanity and $50,000 in legal fees to prove that you're right.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#14

A Note on Color

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Have your son's wife stop by the owner's place to say:

"I just wanted to thank you for painting the fence. Lavender is my absolutely favorite color, and I'm just so glad you didn't paint it in one of those icky redwood tones."

Then count the hours until it gets repainted. :D

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#15

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Hank Knight

Barry,

I'm sorry this has happened to you and your son. I've had the unfortunate "pleasure" of dealing with several wacko neighbors over the years, so I know exactly the frustration and anger you are feeling. Some people get incredibly exercised over their property rights - or what they perceive their rights to be. They go to great lengths and expense to protect their "rights," even when they are dead wrong. If you get drawn into a legal fight with them, you can end up spending a lot of money needlessly. My advice is to resolve the trespass warrant against your son as quickly as possible. You've gotten some good suggestions about how to do that. You may have to go to court. If so, so be it - do it and get it over with. Then ignore your neighbor. You have a right to enjoy your property, so go about your business and ignore her. That would be easier to do if you could wall her off. Build a tall fence, or, as others have suggested, plant a fast-growing hedge. Out of sight is out of mind. She'll calm down after a while and your life there will improve. If you let her drag you into a fight, she'll drag it our forever or until you move. She thrives on conflict and acrimony, so don't give it to her. The best way to strike back at her is to simply ignore her. It works, believe me.

My $.02. Good luck.

Hank

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#16

Prove it!

iew

Tell the people who served the warrant to "prove it". Tell her to "prove it", else pound sand.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#17

A.J. Hamler

And after that...

A.J. Hamler

And once you've proven her wrong, after all you've gone through she will still not believe she is wrong, and will continue to act accordingly.

I have a neighbor exactly like this. In fact, I will gladly trade mine for yours. I'm sure I'll get the better deal.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#18

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Barry Irby

You and Steve and the everyone else are right. I have wondered if crazy people know they are crazy?

We have tried to be good quiet neighbors all along. I have hauled away fifteen or more loads of trash out of this house and yard. We took down and threw away and old rotten privacy fence that was leaning on the chain link fence behind it on the sides. (Unfortunately there was no chain link fence on the rear.) We have taken down dead and dangerous trees that were not in the easement, but could have fallen into it. We explained that we had nothing to do with the feral cats and wished they would go away also. We did not complain when she sent workers to repair her rotten fence on Easter Sunday morning. We listened to her tenants when they complained that we had thrown away their cat feeding station and explained that it was their landlord that did it.

In most cases I understand why "the other Party" has a beef with me, but in this case I am grasping at straws. The best I can come up with is it has nothing to do with us. She has some problem, Real or imagined, and is taking it out on us.

We have tried to keep a low profile and be good neighbors. She sent the police. We explained that we were were just trying to clean up the property and make it better. The Police left, so she filed a warrant or whatever it is. Our approach has been to be kind and polite and leave her alone to go away ans settle down. So far that has not worked. I am still not interested in trying to best her in court or any where else because she is either crazy or mean spirited and we would never convince her that she is wrong.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#19

A.J. Hamler

The Hitchcock solution

A.J. Hamler

Hey Barry, Sir Alfred has a solution to our whack-job harpy neighbor problem.

Ever see the movie "Strangers on a Train?"

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#20

Re: And after that...

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"And once you've proven her wrong, after all you've gone through she will still not believe she is wrong, and will continue to act accordingly."

And she will blame "the idiot judge" and "the sleazebag lawyers" and "the stupid clerks" and "the dumb flatfoot cops" and "the flipping liberals [or right wingnuts]" and anybody else she can think of to avoid confronting the concept that her OPINION on how things should be just ain't the way the world works so she'll keep on throwing the used kitty litter over the fence into your garden.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#21

Well, at that point . . .

s mackay

. . . I play the "Quirky-Eccentric-Disturbed-Gulf-War-Veteran-Syndrome" card. My neighbor wanted to play the same "easment game" with me when I bought this house. He tried to bully the phone company into burrying HIS replacment,"drop" phone line in MY back yard (outside the right-of-way). They tried three times to dig up my back yard. I did my research, read documents and called the utility. Next time they showed up I was drooling and screaming and generaly carrying on. They burried his phone line in HIS back yard and he no longer speaks to me about ANYTHING. He thinks that the next time he winds up the "crazy, unstable GI" something BAD might happen. But then he is a nosey, trouble making jerk that I didn't want to talk to anyway. Civilians THINK they know how to play the "crazy-game". GIs, on the other hand, are expert. So long as you stay within the boudries of the law "crazy" ain't a crime. And it don't cost a dime. The nut job above knows this. And now I've let the cat out of the bag.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#22

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Hank Knight

You'll never convince her she's wrong. Trying to is not worth the emotional investment you'll lose in the effort.

My last neighbor problem involed a woman who moved in behind me and insisted on parking her car under my large hickory tree that overhangs her back yard. The first time I saw her park under it, I warned her that it dropped large hickory nuts that would damage her car. She ignored me; and sure enough, in the Fall, the tree did its thing and her car got dinted. She filed an insurance claim and tried to collect from me. My insurance company rejected the claim. She got her lawyer to call and threaten me with litigation. I asked him what she wanted and he responded that she would only be satisfied if I cut my tree down. My reply was "No dice, I like my tree." I offered to pay to retain a landscaper to design and prepare an alternate parking area in her yard, away from the tree. I figured that would be cheaper than a lawsuit. Her response was to have her parking place under my tree paved. Then she hired a tree company to cut the limbs off the tree that overhung her property - which she had a legal right to do. That didn't satisfy her so she sued me to require me to cut the tree down and we went to court. My lawyer commented that it was "the silliest lawsuit [he'd] ever seen." The judge must have agreed. To my great delight, he laughed at her and threw the case out on the grounds that the tree was only doing what hickory trees do and was not "unreasonably dangerous". End of story. After that, she groused at me every time she saw me, which I made sure was infrequently, and eventually she moved away. Now I have a nice neighbor there. Sometimes there's just no explanation for how people act.

Again, good luck with your current problem.

Hank

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#23

Hard To Ignore

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

the dead guy in Yossarian's tent, right Klinger? ;)

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#24

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Larry in NW OHIO

Hank I can`t understand how something like that can even get into court. She had to have a lawyer as stupid as she is. Larry

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#25

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Hank Knight

Larry,

You would be dismayed if you knew the number of really stupid things that wind up in court these days. I'm a defense attorney and I see it all the time. Several years ago I defended an employer in a case where the plaintiff/employee sued claiming my client unlawfully refused to grant her medical leave under the Family and Medical Leave Act to travel to the Philippines to see her family witch doctor. Ths suit was in spite of the fact that my client granted her personal (not medical) leave to go wherever she wanted for whatever reason she wanted. We got the case dismissed and the court ruled that it was a "frivolous" case, but it refused to sanction her attorney for bringing the lawsuit, even though the Rules provide for sanctions if a lawyer brings a frivolous claim. Until the courts start holding lawyers' feet to the fire, we'll continue to see this kind of expensive nonsense.

Hank