Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

OT Trespass Questions

Posts

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#26

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Stuart Johnson

Hank, There seems to be two, three or more sides to the lawsuit issue. There is the frivolous law suite. But, who is to determine if it is frivolous and what appeal is there if it is ruled frivolous? Texas is in the process of passing a law that will make the loser responsible for the the winning side's attorney fees. This is good until you realize no matter how justified the action the individual is not guaranteed to prevail or that final outcome will be greater than 80% of the amount requested. So the defendant wins $80,000 for a $100,000 suit then must pay his lawyer plus at least a portion of the other lawyers which might be some high priced corporate attorneys. Not because he lost but because he didn't prevail greater than 80%.

Then on the other side is the SLAPP (strategic lawsuits against public participation) where the corporation or organization threatens a lawsuit that has the potential to bankrupt the individual if they continue to speak out. It is my understanding there is usually no real intent to ever actually continue action into court. I think this was applied to a certain extent in a different woodturning forum.

Both types of action are warranted in certain cases but the ones that are making the rules are for the most part lawyers. And, they stand to win no matter what. In the meantime the private individual is left out in the cold.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#27

Re: OT Trespass Questions

Hank Knight

Stuart,

You are right, there are many facets to the problem of abuse of our legal system and many suggestions for how to fix it, none of which IMHO offers a good solution. Our system relies in large part on attorneys to act responsibly to police it and stop the abuse. It doesn't work, but I'm not sure it's any worse than the alternatives that have been suggested. We could talk about this for weeks but that discussion would completely hijack this thread. My only purpose in raising the issue was to point out that our legal system allows ridiculous, expensive litigation over the kind of problem the OP is experiencing with his neighbor, and there are probably better ways to handle the matter.

Hank

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#28

Good Fences make good neighbors

PaulSV

I would immediately build a solid wood fence, as high as is permitted, around the entire back yard, and then forget that she exists.

Another possibility: keep a video recorder handy, and any time she comes on your property, or starts to scream at you, start videotaping. It's amazing how people regulate their behavior when they know their actions are being recorded.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#29

Question for Hank & Mark or anyone who knows

Barry Irby

What exactly is "Trespassing". Is it putting your "person"/body on the other person's property? In this case, we have some 4x4's left on the wrong side of the line. Does leaving our stuff over there constitute trespassing? I suppose you could reason we must have trespassed to put it over there but in this case we could just as easily tossed it across the line without ever setting foot over the line. Seems to me that is littering.

This woman claims we trespassed from Mar 18 to May 7. While it may be that we stepped over the line once or twice, we clearly did not occupy the other side of the line for that long unless you count the 4x4's.

I called her neighbor in an adjacent commercial building today to see if he had any scoop on her. Boy did he light up. Turns out she has quite a reputation. He used the B word more than once. I am shocked.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#30

Re: Question for Hank & Mark or anyone who knows

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Barry, sounds to me that all your neighbors should get together and file for a Restraint Order against her from all of you. Sounds like she wants or demands to be the Queen Bee in the neighborhood.

The B word does sound appropriate for her. Then again, has anyone determined if she has any medical problems which might cause some of her imperfections with neighbors?

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#31

Re: Question for Hank & Mark or anyone who knows

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Barry,

Trespass is, essentially intruding on another's property. You cannot intrude until your are told, by voice or sign, that the owner demands everybody to stay off his dirt. By the same token, stepping over the line to retrieve your own property (the wood or a ball, etm.), while a technical trespass, will get the owner kicked out of any reasonable court perhaps with a judgement against you for a penny. Judges don't like this kind of stuff as they are seriously over-worked, underfunded, under staffed, and don't have time for these whackoes.

When did the signs go up? I thought you said it was after her hoopla over the cats and her putting up the lavender fence. Stepping over the line before that is meaningless. Go to court, tell the judge that the signs went up on May 7th and since then you haven't dared set foot in that zone. "Judge, Prior to her putting up her signs, if Ms. B had just said she wanted nobody to set foot in her area, we certainly would have honored her request. Prior to then we were just trying to clean up the mess that frankly, probably constituted a public health hazard. I guess we should just call the health department next time about the condition of her property. We have children who will use the yard, and we must insist that the area be kept safe for them. Wouldn't you agree?"

Still think thanking her for the lavender paint is a good idea. She'll be out there painting it some other obnoxious color in no time. Wait until she's about 75% done, then go gushing about her choices and ask where she buys her paint. Before you're done, the thing will fall over from the sheer weight of the paint slopped on it.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#32

Re: Question for Hank & Mark or anyone who knows

Hank Knight

Barry,

"Trespass" means a number of different things, all of which deal with unlawful or unauthorized acts. The definition that relates to your situation is the "unlawful entry upon the land of another." Generally, a landowner has the right to control who enters upon his/her land. One who enters upon another's land without authorization or the consent of the owner is entering unlawfully. Consent may be implied from the circumstances. If a landowner "posts" his/her land against trespassing, the posting removes any implication that entry is authorized without express permission. Every state has case law that defines when consent to enter can be implied without express permission. I don't know the law in your state, but I would argue that your entry on your neighbor's land was for the purpose of improving the property, so you assumed you had implied consent. But when your neighbor posted her property against trespassing, you understood that you no longer had her consent and did not enter upon her property again. This argument may not "square" with your state law, but it should show that any technical trespass you may have committed was merely negligent and not malicious - in lay terms: not a criminal act. Before you act on my remarks, I encourage you to consult with your attorney. I'm a labor lawyer, not a property lawyer, and I'm reaching back to law school almost 40 years ago.

Good luck!

Hank

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#33

Kneale Brownson

From years working in a mental hospital...

Kneale Brownson

I can tell you that disturbed women are the last to ever give up. I'd agree with the "flip this house" suggestion if the opportunity arises. If you make what becomes a public stink about it, you'll probably taint the property.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#34

And yet another question

Barry Irby

Does it matter that her property is a commercial property property. She has signs out front advertising the businesses. In effect inviting people to come onto the property.

Oddly, the zoning requires that she have a privacy fence to protect my property from eh impact of having a commercial property as a neighbor. If she had stayed on her side of the privacy fence she would have never known what we were doing and if she had given us a few more days we would have hauled away the last of the trash and there would have been no evidence we had been there, except it was cleaner than before.

Here commercial neighbor was lit up over the fact that she tried to manipulate the Sign ordinances to get more signage for her building by taking his sign. He had never put up a sign and when his tenants talked him into it, he discovered she had applied for his sign by forging a bunch of signatures. When he caught on and turned her in to the county, she had the sign erected over the weekend. The county basically said "Its done now and we are not going to make her take it down." He had nothing good to say about her.

I am still not clear on why she has attacked my son. There is nothing to gain. We constantly assured her we were not trespassing and had no intention of doing so. I Guess the B gene is irresistible.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#35

Re: And yet another question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Barry, You really need to speak to your attorney. He will know the standards for your state and area. Hank and I are not licensed to practice in your state and we are precluded from giving you legal advice.

Re: OT Trespass Questions

#36

Re: And yet another question

Barry Irby

I understand and you are correct, I'm just fishing for free advice and Ideas.