Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Have you seen this -- square square

Posts

Have you seen this -- square square

#1

Have you seen this  --  square square

Gary Smyth

I don't often get really, really ticked off but this email alert sent me off the edge this AM. A square for $169. Now, I get quality, and I get profit, and I get that I DON'T have to purchase it, but I wouldn't mind a good square, or two, if I knew what I had was dead on. Maybe $10 - $15 is too little for quality, but $169.00? Why can't companies who make squares make one that does what it's supposed to do. I'm talking to you Stanley, Empire, Miller's Falls, Mayes, Harbor Freight, et al. Yea, I know all about squaring up a square drawing lines. flipping the square, hitting it with a punch etc. But why should I do that when we buy the square to begin with BECAUSE IT IS A SQUARE. Isn't there someway to stop this madness? Why must I or any of us pay a premium for something that is supposed to be something but is not? This is a travesty.

And while I'm ranting why doesn't every hardware store in the country have a registered jig that will tell you if a square is square? Every tool counter ought to have something that is dead on to let the buyer know that a square purchased is correct.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#2

Re: Have you bought this?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

But they didn't list the optional rosewood carrying case lined in fine Corinthian leather.

Yo, you're a woodworker. You are expected to live by two rules:

1. We're all just one tool away from excellence. [Don Geiger]

2. He who dies with the most tools, wins. [Anonymous]

Remember when the economic model for lagging sales was to drop the price, shave your profit, keep your quality, and make more of the product?

You've cited a lesson in the new model which is make less and charge much more because there are fewer people with discretionary income so you've got to soak them for as much as you can at every opportunity.

I've had and used the same Johnson framing square for 40 years. It's square, but it's not red and doesn't have a nifty edge guide. ;)

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#3

PT Barnum was right

paul in AZ

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#4

their is a  3- 4- 5 rule to see if it is square

del schisler

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#5

Clint Searl

Q: What's the difference between....

Clint Searl

....a Stanley 1/4" chisel that costs $7.95 and a Tasai 1/4" Damascus dovetail chisel for $258.00 +S&H?

A: About $250 +/-

Clint

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#6

Why even have a square????

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I find the unknown to be far more adventurous. ;-)

Tom

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#7

Re: Q: What's the difference between....

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

There are some who, I'm sure, would disagree with you, Clint. All of those being Tasai purchasers, of course. But looking at the mortises cut by sharp chisels you won't find a difference.

If you find a difference in the chisels it'll be because the guy who spent $260 for the tool takes the time to sharpen it correctly.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#8

That's Why

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

You get to have two photos in the Mug Shots Gallery, eh?

I figgered it had to be something like that.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#9

Re: Why even have a square????

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

It is a freeing moment when you realize no thing has to actually be square it only has to look square.

Robin

Ps. same applies to flat.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#10

Re: Q: What's the difference between....

wilbur

Actually, there are measurable differences in hardness, edge retention, ease of sharpening, and how they feel in use, between the Tasai chisel and the Stanley chisel. Whether that difference is worth an additional $250 is a completely different matter, of course.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#11

The 80/20 rule

paul in AZ

You can get 80% of the way to perfection with 20% of the money or effort. Its the remaining 20% that costs. Whether it is worth it is up to you.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#12

God said so . . .

s mackay

Dad is/was a tool & die maker. Precision is his life. I asked all the same questions of him. You pay the big bucks for starrett because they said its square. Everyone knows them, everyone trusts them. If they say its square it must be so. When God was building the universe he had a Starrett square. Trouble is that once it leaves the factory door it is no longer so. All bets are off. The value plummets and the only person who'll promise that it is square is YOU. As to some new tool outfit that wants to claim they are the squarest of the squares . . . Heck ANYONE can say that because once it is out THEIR door . . . SORRY ! If they manage to stay in business for fifty or a hundred years I MIGHT consider them . . . if starrett goes under before then. I'll trust my fifty year old Lufkin over ANYTHING in ACE Hardware.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#13

Moses Yoder

Re: I saw it at Harbor Freight

Moses Yoder

This is very interesting to me. Somebody complains about the lack of quality in new Stanley tools as compared to old, and most people agree with them. Now someone complains about the cost of a good quality tool and most people agree with them. I wonder what gives?

As far as Clint's idea that an $8 chisel is the same quality as a $250 chisel, I just have to shake my head and go on with my life. There is no hope that the two of us will ever agree on the subject. He can continue to buy new Stanley chisels for $8 at the Orange Borg, I will continue to buy my $1 Witherbys at garage sales. Next time I use one, I will have to keep in mind the steel is just as soft as the new Stanleys. Lets see if I can convince myself.

If there was no market for good quality tools, we would all be buying tools at Harbor Freight. Then the question is posed, why own a table saw when you can do the same thing with a portable saw and a straight 2x4? The next question then is, why do quality work at all? Why Bother? Whats the purpose? We are all going to die sometime, then what purpose is there in doing good work? And if there is a reason to do good work, shouldn't it be done with good tools? What are good tools? What is good work? Therein is life.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#14

Re: God said so . . .

Jesse Cloud

Actually, Starrett was founded in 1880 in Athol, Mass and has been in business continuously since then. So, by your standards, they should be a safe bet.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#15

Appropriate precision

Jesse Cloud

I think part of the issue is that the products most of us make don't need to be square to a great deal of precision or square out a long length - we are mostly willing to clamp the bejeebers out of that last corner to make it fit. ;)

If I had a square like that, I would probably not use it on many projects (I have a concrete floor and butterfingers), but it would be useful for setting up machinery and jigs, cases where a small error becomes cumulative through repetitive use.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#16

Bing Bing! Cliche Time . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"The poor workman blames his tools."

"Good tools don't make a better product or a good workman. They just make it easier for a good workman to make a better product."

"Tool outlines on your shop wall rack don't make you a better craftsman, but they do let you eliminate one place to look for the tool you can't find."

Peace y'all

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#17

Disagree some

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My first chisels were 1970s Craftsman - 1/4" and 3/4", because those were the beginner sizes recommended by the books I read.

They would have made excellent paint can openers, but as chisels, they weren't much. Poor steel, poor balance. I stepped up to Marples chisels, but when I scored my first vintage chisels at a garage sale, I began to understand what a chisel was meant to be.

Can't speak to the super-high-end chisel you used as your comparison point, but there ARE quality differences, and price CAN indicate some of that difference, at least at the steps from bottom end to intermediate prices.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#18

Clint Searl

It looks like....

Clint Searl

....$250 will buy lots of self-esteem. :\ :b

Clint

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#19

(outlines) ROFL !

s mackay

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#20

Yes Sir ! . . .

s mackay

But my heart still belongs to Lufkin.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#21

Re: Appropriate precision

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Amen, Jesse. That said, I will continue with my much less expensive and way precise enough drafting triangles.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#22

The Path To Peace

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

1. "Square" is the intersection of 2 straight lines or 2 straight planes at exactly 90�.

2. All space, and hence everything in it, is curved.

3. Ergo, since there are no straight lines or planes, there is no such thing as "square."

See, wasn't that easy?

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#23

Re: Have you seen this  --  square square

Dale Penkala in Mid-Michigan

I noticed that Gary hasn't posted sinced he 1st started this thread but my suggestion Gary is if you want the square give it to a toolmaker and ask them if they can take a dust on the long blade for you. I'm a toolmaker and do this for myself and anyone that asks me to sqaure up a square (or any other item) for them.

Personally I wouldn't pay that much for a square no matter what brand name is on it. It's been my experience that even starrett or mitutoyo products need to be touched up at times and yes even when there brand spanken new.

Dale

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#24

David Barnett

If it IS square...

David Barnett

...I can't see how $169 is overpriced -- not for 16" x 26". I'd sure want to test it and return it if is wasn't, though. Good optics and good measuring tools are no place to scrimp, but they absolutely have to stand up to scrutiny and verification. BTW, Woodpeckers has been steadily earning a well-deserved reputation for their precision tools and quality control, and this from a confirmed Starrett fan.

Whatever you do, Gary, don't become a machinist! :)

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#25

That's why I use......

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

....highly figured woods. Distracts the viewer with mesmorizing optical illusions!

T.