Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Have you seen this -- square square

Posts

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#26

Dude....yer freakin' me out! ;-)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#27

Re: Have you seen this  --  square square

Chrispy400623

Whilst we are on the subject of accuracy, I have a 1988 Sears Table Saw with Beismeyer rails and Exacta fence, and Freud blade, does beautiful work. Many years ago I cleaned the surface (After a fire and resulting tons of water, hence rust) with a belt sander. One day I might check for flatness as a matter of curiosity with no intention of doing anything about it. Let's remember that we are woodworkers, not precision machinists!!

Have fun!

Chrispy

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#28

Ellis Walentine

What is...?

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for the advice, Dale. I wondered about how you "take a dust" on a square blade? Is that a grinding process?

Ellis

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#29

Some thoughts on "squareness"

Howard Acheson

No matter how much you spend for a device, you still don't know if it is square. I ran a large tool and die shop and we purchased a number of Brown & Sharp and Starrett devices and some of them were not "square". We had "standards" that our quality department periodically had validated by an outside service that we then used to verify the worker's tools.

One day, one of our designers brought in two plastic drawing triangles he had purchased at a local art supply store. He had them compared to our standards and they were as accurate as the tools could measure. The triangle cost a couple of dollars each. They would certainly serve very well as the "standard" in any woodworking shop to validate and/or adjust other devices.

An excellent way to validate the accuracy of the plastic squares is to use two squares on a flat surface. Get a $10-12 plastic 30-60-90 drafting square. To prove it's exactly 90�, take two to a glass counter, put the shorter legs on the counter and face the longer legs away from each other and butt them together (like a teepee). If the legs exactly butt, you can assume you have two perfect 90� angles. Using one of the plastic squares, do the same thing using your other tools. Any that mismatch, means that the tool is not square. You can also take the plastic square with you whenever you go to purchase another tool. Keep your "standard" somewhere where it doesn't get banged up.

Finally, remember that the wood you are using will expand and contract a couple of thousands from one day to the other. Does't pay to get too uptight.

While we are at it, I also only purchase the cheapest of adjustable squares. I square them with a drafting triangle and an auger file until they are square across 10". And I own a Bridge City square that isn't that accurate. Stainless steel machinist's squares are only square until you drop them. I have had several over the years and each has found a away to drop to the floor.

The key is to NEVER use your best square on for day to day measuring. Use it only as a reference tool to verify your other day to day tools.

In a comparison test reported in Fine Woodworking Magazine a couple of years ago, the Stanley 46-123 square was awarded the best value. It's much less expensive than a Starrett and just as accurate.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#30

Re: Have you seen this  --  square square

Nelson

Precision is way overrated anyway.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#31

Is it any wonder?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

That accurate well made tools are becoming harder and harder to find?

After reading this entire thread, I find it interesting that:

No one has this tool yet, so no one is qualified to comment on it's quality or accuracy.

It's also interesting to see that most people seem to be insulted/intimidated by the asking price of the tool. Though compared to a 12" Starrett combo square, it seems to be reasonably priced for it's size.

As to a square being square out of the box, they are made out of roughly the same materials as your chisel and plane blades, and everyone knows that they need to be flattened and sharpened before you use them so why do you have a hard time understanding the same thing about a measuring tool? It needs to be checked against a standard before you put it to work.

People whine and complain that quality tools are becoming extinct, but when a manufacturer steps up to the plate to manufacture and advertise a tool as being of exceptional quality, (not to mention Made in USA), rather than cheering them on, It seems to have been decided that this tool can't possibly be as good as they say it is, or, that they should sell it for 50 bucks no matter what is costs to make, because that's what we're willing to pay for it.

Why not wait for it to actually get to market and then test it before berating the manufacturer?

Bob in NJ

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#32

Clint Searl

Re: Is it any wonder?

Clint Searl

Perhaps the underlying attitude, spoken or not, is that woodworking does not demand $169 worth of squareness. When I need a combo square, I reach for my 45 year old Craftsman that hangs next to the Starrett, which is akin to a vanity plate on a car.

Clint

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#33

Moses Yoder

Re: Is it any wonder?

Moses Yoder

Everybody seems to think $169 is a lot of money. I use more than $169 worth of gas in 2 weeks and don't have much to show for it. At least if I spent that money on a square I would have a square.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#34

It's Not Wonder

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Bob,

The sentiment you're taking issue with comes down to people expecting to get what they pay for. A framing square is not a technical piece of tooling with serious time put into R&D. It's a piece of metal cut from a larger piece. It's simple purpose (99% of the time) is the make a straight line at 90� to another straight line.

Marketing a $170 tool like this which will do a job no better than the $17 version on the rack at the Borg begins to take on the aura of NASA's $750 hammers, and tends to make a myth out of price being a function of actual quality. There is also the question of "if Stanley can make and market a square framing square for $17, what could this outfit possibly do that costs 10 times as much and be worthwhile?"

I have a friend who has a collection of Bridge City tools in his shop. He buys them because he loves the design and craftsmanship. Those tools, however, have Never been and Never will be, during his lifetime, Used. I seriously doubt you could even find a fingerprint on one of them. Working in his shop, he'll only use the Stanley and Blue Marples, etc. His lines are straight and square, his joints, properly tight. The point being here that my friend is honest in his extravagance.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#35

Re: What is...?

Dale Penkala in Mid-Michigan

Hello Ellis

Yes I guess its shop lingo. You clamp the small part of the square blade up to an angle plate that is square. Dress a grinding wheel on a surface grinder and take a light grind on the blade until it is just cleaned up.

Just to clarify on a "square" angle plate we use a cylindar square to actully check the angle plate. In our shop our standard is .0001" over the distance of the cyilindar square. This is checked on a certified surfacae plate and a .00005" - .00002" indicator or comparitor on a transfer stand.

I've been following this thread right along and Howard has a very good response about how we use our squares at work and also the way I use mine here in my shop.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages.pl/page/1/md/read/id/436315/sbj/some-thoughts-on-squareness/

One other comment I'd like to make is remember we are working with wood and not steel so tolarences and accuracy is a little different. At work I work as close as submicrons and that is what I'm used to. Its a way of life for me and the few that can work that close. I have to stop myself and say hey I'm working with wood here not steel and I'm not at work either. Its habit but I still have to tell myself even if I'm off a 1/64" or even a 1/32" its a very useable part. At least in most cases.

I hope this helps Ellis.

Dale

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#36

Moses Yoder

Re: Have you seen this  --  square square

Moses Yoder

I wish that O-ring on the space shuttle Challenger in 1986 would have been made with a little more precision. Seems kind of funny to fly into space on an aircraft built by the lowest bidder.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#37

Re: It's Not Wonder

Thomas S Stockton

Mark

It's kinda refreshing to hear of someone who is willing to admit that they own some of the high end stuff because they enjoy the design of it.

When I walk into someones shop and they have a big stack of festool or bridgecity prominently on display or all their machines are color coordinated and really expensive the first thing I look at is the quality of their work. It is real easy (if you have the money) to buy some really nice tools but it takes a lot of hard work and commitment to be able produce truly nice work.

I guess I'm old school in this regard. When I started making furniture a lot of the high end stuff wasn't available and we learned how to tune up old planes and make them work really well or we built our own. James Krenov used a wooden square he built himself because it worked and was more than accurate enough.

A lot of people say he who has the most tools wins, but I never agreed with it, I always thought that it was the person doing the best work that won.

Bottom line is do what you enjoy if you like buying really nice tools cool, but the truth is that you really don't need all those pretty shiny thing to build quality furniture.

Read up on some of the past generation Tage Frid, Krenov, Sam Maloof, Art Carpenter and Wharton Esherick. They all did great work with a pretty basic aet of tools.

Tom

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#38

The Most Expensive Tool In The World

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

will not prevent you from cutting the damn board precisely 1" too short. :D

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#39

And perfectly square

paul in AZ

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#40

David Barnett

Hammers, hearsay and heresies *LINK*

David Barnett

Why do you say that this "$170 tool", as you call it, will do a job no better than a $17 tool from a big box store? What job is that? Rafter framing? Before you answer that, Mark, do consider that the Woodpeckers square is not marketed nor intended to be a "framing square", truly an essential carpenter's tool, but a precision long-limbed square for use in cabinetry, picture framing, and other tasks which may demand or at least benefit from tighter tolerances than an off-the-shelf framing square can deliver.

Surely, you know how inaccurate and variable some of these framing squares can be. And while "It's simple purpose (99% of the time) is the make a straight line at 90� to another straight line" may be true, when you extend that line out several feet (commercial installations can easily run to double-digit feet) anomalies do show up and can make a difference. Not to everyone, perhaps, but to some. So just how square do you need or want that perpendicular line?

If it's really a matter of someone asking "if Stanley can make and market a square framing square for $17, what could this outfit possibly do that costs 10 times as much and be worthwhile?", I'd say their ignorance indicates they neither know the limitations of many mass-produced squares or simply cannot appreciate and realize, that is to say, use the benefits of the more accurately-made square.

As for price; no, you're right, higher price is not proof of greater value and precision, but neither must it equate to wasteful government spending. Also, I'd bet there is more forethought and design in this tool than you may imagine, perhaps not what you'd classify as R&D, but at least some thoughtful industrial design and prototyping to get it right.

Another point, Woodpeckers gives a lifetime guarantee on their products, and will adjust or replace them at no charge short of outright abuse. How long will this company survive given today's economic challenges? Who can say? But at least they're making the effort to act in the manner many of have lamented passing in our lifetimes.

I think what Bob was saying is that criticism of this product has evoked extremes based on emotion and uncomfortable pricing rather than a clear evaluation of the quality of that product or experience with it. It is neither Harbor Freight nor a $750 NASA hammer -- and by the way, Mark, that was DOD paying $171.50 for a hammer* and NASA $600 for a zero-gravity toilet seat and lid -- probably cheaper than paying astronauts to chase floating Tootsie-Rolls in space. Such exaggerations, while rhetorically effective and entertaining, don't serve to arrive at the true value of a product, a product which may arguably deserve better than knee-jerk condemnation and ire.

Bob's saying (as I interpret his post) let's not prejudge a product in a harsh or negative light based on price alone, which is just as much a fallacy as thinking a cheaper product cannot be equally worthy. He's saying (and I'm saying) let's just be reasonable and not prejudge. Neither Bob nor I are saying you're a Philistine if you don't want, need, or appreciate the more-expensive square, just don't condemn it on its higher price any more than condemn another product for being inexpensive. [And I'm no tool elitist -- I own, use, and even like several Harbor Freight tools, and not only the non-precision kinds.]

As for "...tends to make a myth out of price being a function of actual quality", outright collector's fetishisms aside, that's a point well taken. The myth does exist in so many things and will likely persist in free market societies. Such perceptions are what keeps liquidity and movement, and yes, much of the fun in exercising our buying choices, whether it's futures contracts on commodities or squares from tool catalogs.

One good thing to consider, our free market allows you to vote with your needs and dollars. No one need buy this tool if a $17 dollar tool will serve them adequately, but if one wanted the more precise (that is, likely to live up to its promised tolerances backed up by the manufacturer to maintain these tolerances) square, one could have the option to purchase such a tool. And isn't that what's desirable? What we want? Options?

My way of thinking, options are a good thing and benefit us all. Woodpeckers will let the market decide, and they've had the foresight (yes, marketing and business both) to make this a limited "One-Time", as they call it, tool. I rather applaud them for their innovation and enterpreneurship, but that's just me.

Please consider, too, that while the benefits of one square against another may be difficult for some appreciate, even perceive, it's not superstition -- at least not superstition on the order of high-end audiophile speaker cables -- but is quantifiable, measureable, demonstrable and repeatable. This is not to say whether it is a difference that makes a difference to everyone -- just that it is measureable. Precision measuring tools do not require nor benefit from double blind testing. Only the actual or perceived need (or desirel, if you will) for such tools is subjective.

Just to offer another perspective from someone who has actually held and tried a Woodpeckers tool, read the review I've linked below. Although it's not the 16" x 26" square, it speaks to the quality of Woodpeckers' tools. A final note, one of their longer T-squares has made a positive difference for one art framer I know connected with the Ringling Museum of Art in Sarasota.

Frankly, after looking at the offerings from Woodpeckers due to this thread, there are at least two items I'm likely to order this week as they seem more convenient than tools I now use that are more intended for machinists** (and believe me when I tell you I'm one frugal bastard when it comes to tools, these days). :)

So maybe it is the rare woodworker who can get best benefit from these squares, which is why Woodpeckers is making so few of them before shutting down the line, but I still don't see why anyone should get their panties in a knot over someone making them, selling them or buying them -- especially when it's not money from their wallet.

*The $750 hammer is something of a myth in its own right, but is admittedly apocryphal when it comes to DOD procurement policies and bureaucracy (that was a non-sparking hammer with a highly specialized design for use in critical environments, not that it wasn't still overpriced, of course).

**An example, my Starrett 24" blade works with my combi head, but that's a very short leg compared to the new "One-Time" 2616 square, which is why I'm considering adding one of these to my order, as well.


T-12 Precision Aluminum T-Squares

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#41

Oh. Okay

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

David,

Perhaps I should have been more precise and serious.

Once that $17 Borg-rack square is determined to be actually square [all I need is a straight edge, a sharp pencil, and some paper for the test] it will do exactly the same job of marking a line / checking an edge at 90� as your $170 Woodpeckers Special. If my $17 tool is off by a hair, it's very simple to bring it within any tolerance that I am ever going to need to build any piece of furniture, or a roof for that matter.

Of course I was speaking rhetorically regarding the hammer; makes no difference really, does it? Thought the toilet seat was $20,000; must have been a different myth. ;)

My friend who buys the Bridge City stuff is "happy as a clam" with his collection. I, too, have several "expensive" tools; a very precise 30" steel rule that is only used to calibrate other measuring tools in my shop (so that they all "agree"), and a Staedtler protracting draftsman's triangle. Neither of them come out of their drawer very often, and then only to check the accuracy of the actual working tools.

But don't get me wrong, please. I wish the good folks at Woodpeckers all the success they can possibly stand; and happiness and satisfaction to you and everyone else who chooses to buy their square(s). Just kindly don't come back and say that your 90� corners are "more square" than mine because of that tool you bought for $170. They aren't. I get a bit frosted by merchandisers who market very expensive items as the be-all/end-all of the must-have department if anyone "truly wants to do quality work." I regard that kind of sales pitch as bunk.

Peace.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#42

Corollary

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The most expensive* tool in the world, and the hardest to replace if you break it, is right there between your ears; that, and those wiggly things on the ends of your arms.

*That's if you count all the money your parents put into raising you, particularly during those expensive teenage years.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#43

David Barnett

Well, Heck!

David Barnett

Why didn't you say so? :)

I completely agree with your Borg example, then. I've long used an out-of-square Craftsman aluminum framing square that's so out I do the flip test nearly every time I use it, divide the runout at the end of both lines and rule a new one through the middle. Usually good enough for most work (I said I was cheap).

"I get a bit frosted by merchandisers who market very expensive items as the be-all/end-all of the must-have department if anyone 'truly wants to do quality work.' "

I've seen amazing work from in Third World (oops! -- that may be 'Developing Nations', these days -- I'm not sure), where timber was ripped, albeit one-handed, on a circular saw blade protruding through an old table with no fence.

I'm undecided about the 2616 square, but I'm going to spring for the 32" T-square, as I'm cartooning a large text block in a slab of stone and it's kinda hard to correct errors in that stuff.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#44

Large T's

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

David,

You might be surprised at how accurate the sheetrock t-squares are, if they haven't been bounced around in the store. The one I got was off less than a 64th at 4'; not too bad, and cheap too. ;)

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#45

Re: Large T's

Dale Penkala

I ditto that comment on the T-square. I was very surprised at how close it was too!

Dale in mid-michigan

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#46

Re: Is it any wonder?

Chuck Lenz

I can tell you that my experience with Woodpeckers has been good. Awhile ago I was putting a router table together and bought their Aluminum insert plate and 8 pc aluminum ringset. Admitably it was expensive, but after alot of researching I decided that it was the best made, I seen too many stories of people that bought different brands of plates and were complaning about them bowing. To this day I still feel that it was money very well spent. Do I need an expensive frameing square ? probably not, but I have been eyeing over their aluminum rulers for awhile.

Re: Have you seen this -- square square

#47

Re: I'm also going to add that

Chuck Lenz

Just the other day I bought a used multi-purpose 5" bench vise for $20 that appeared to be in fair condition. Upon closer inspection when I got it home, I found 3 things wrong with it that affected it's use, and it took about 4 hours to get it to the shape that it should of been in from the factory. Thats right, poor workmanship at the factory, now the vise works very well. My point is that the vise retails for around $175 plus shipping on the net, it's not a cheap vise, and weighs in at over 50 lbs. In my opinion it's really depressing to see things going that way. The funny thing is after finding the problems I expected all the bolts to be metric on the vise and they aren't, they are all SAE. Now don't get me wrong, I'm not saying that Woodpeckers is that kind of company, but I do know that they make some top notch stuff and I respected for it. You've got to keep in mind that the framing square is a limited time single production run, there are alot of setup costs to be absorbed in something so limited. We should all know how that goes, most of us are usually makeing something that is custom and rarely make much profit in it, if we by chance just happen to make a respectable wage doing it should we be frowned upon ? Some day I wish that I could make a liveing doing what I like to do and not be treated like some evil guy thats trying to steal people blind.


img