Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

Posts

if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#1

if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

Ron

I'm building hobby headquarters in 2011, and I would appreciate some advice. North central Arkansas. Looks like the new bldg will be 44x32 with about 12x32 lost to a boat/rv bay. That leaves about 1000 sqft., but it's a bit square which limits the perimeter length. Maybe I should go 48x32. Inside this shop will be a small dust-limited corner "office" with heat/ac. Wood storage is in a separate shed. For my infrequent hvlp spraying I can empty the bay temporarily.

A CAD/arch. guy has been working on this, especially on the nearby new house, but back to the shop.

Thinking 10' ceiling for the shop part. Drywall ceiling & lots of lights. Wondering about flooring and elevation stuff! Concrete floor for the bay and wood floor for the shop? But the building site is quite level, so to allow support for a wood floor there's going to be a couple of steps up from the bay or from outside, right? Isn't that a problem for material handling and general in/out? I was thinking a garage-type rollup door for both bay and shop, but now I'm thinking of omitting the one into shop. Shop will have dust collection, but I don't know that I have the planning foresight or drive to put it in the floor at the right locations. Plus all my tools have wheels.

I know wood floors are supposed to be great for the feet&legs. I wouldn't know as I'm currently on concrete but have added rubber mats here and there.

Anyway, back to the major questions: floors and elevation? Thoughts? All is variable at the moment. A friend once told me that he made the mistake of building his shop after his house had depleted too much of his money, and the shop suffered. So I'm doing it the other way around. The shop will be completed before we even break ground on the house.

thanks for any advice,

ron

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#2

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

RobCarr

Have you considered a pre-engineered metal building? Ceco and Star are the 2 manufactures I'm familiar with.

I have one that is 50'x100' and houses my 8-car collection, a middle bay with tractors and lawn equipment and other junk, and the opposite end bay is my wood/metal shop. And best of all it's clear-span; no internal columns. I have about 12' clear at the perimeter ceiling height and 16' at the ridge. It's fully insulated and the end bays (cars/shop) are heated & cooled, there's enough seepage that keeps the middle bay moderate as long as the garage door is closed.

I originally looked at stick-built, tilt-up panel (which looks nicer, but cost more), and finally decided on the metal building - I could get about 2x the floor space for 1/2 the cost and that includes a finished drywall furred wall and lay-in ceiling.

Just thought I throw it out, because pre-engineered buildings are something most people might not have considered as an option. and you have a lot of flexibility with door/windows/skylights/garage door placement.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#3

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

RobCarr

I forgot to add that I have an wood floor in my shop area - the concrete slab was recessed to allow a 4x4x4 oak block laid end-grain up - best shop floor I ever had!

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#4

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

FredD

The metal building is a idea for those who can accomadate the startling difference in appearence from a conventional building.

We had Morton put up a enclosed Arena and attached barn and for animals is great.

I stick built my shop and for your floor I would suggest what I did.

Pour the slab monolithic and put in a fire wall separating the Boat Bay from the shop area.

In the shop area lay down treated 2x4's flat ,on 24" O.C and go over this with 241 plywood , which is 1 1/8th inc thick and finish off with a durable flooring like Linoleum , or like I did , tempered Masonite cut into 15 7/8th inch squares and coated with a two part Epoxy paint , been in use for 12 twelve years with no visible wear and easy on the legs and feet and warm in the winter when the shop is heated.

Scissor Truss's will give you a nice head room on ten foot side walls and a attic space for heat and cooling and wiring runs.

FredD

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#5

Using contractors?

John in NM

If you are and have a flat site, go with a concrete floor, you'll save labor costs. We just did a 1000' slab, and as some of the planned use of the building changed over time, I would have used a joist floor instead if not for fill added as the foundation trench was being dug.

While joist floors are maybe easier on the feet, definitely easier on the do-it-yourselfer's wallet (but not cheaper if you're hiring a crew), in the mean time I've traded a debt owed to me for a 12" jointer that weighs about a ton. Now its a relief that I have the concrete floor. That all probably sounds confusing, the point is that concrete's good points for a workshop outweigh its drawbacks.

If you decide you want wood after it's done, its easy to retro-fit as Fred describes. Do the tall walls and scissor trusses also, and you'll even have the head room to put dust collection and electrics in the floor if you so desire. Personally, I find 10 walls a waste of effort, but the ability to raise the shop floor like that would definitely counter the waste distaste.

I'm planning to use a lot of solar tubes and drywall/plaster the insides of my shop. The tubes are expensive starting out, but out here the sun is bright, almost always shines, and the tube can be retrofitted with a little light fixture, so I can light at night without installing anything fancy. Smooth finished white painted walls are definitely worth the effort I think, makes for a much more bright and cheerful work space. If you could see the dungeon I work in now, you'd know why that's important to me :D

For what its worth, we built the house before the shop, which meant putting off the shop for 5 years or more, but it also meant that we could afford to get the house livable before I had to go back to work. May not apply in your case, but you should consider the financial implications of the possibility of having a completed shop and no house - for us that made the decision obvious and easy.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#6

two pieces of data

bill tindall

You will never needs to pass into the shop with anything that won't go through a standard entry door. Such doors seal in heat and cooling, as needed, and seal out heat and cooling, humidity and rain.

I have heard this argument that wood is easier on the feet than concrete. Baloney. Does anyone really think their foot can tell the minuscule difference in compressibility of wood vs concrete if they are wearing a shoe? The only reason to go with wood is if you want access under the floor.

I am not fond of drywall walls in a shop. Walls are to hang stuff on.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#7

Re: two pieces of data

Barry Irby

Bill, I have wondered about the wooden floor Vs concrete floor for years. I wonder if there is any really scientific data on that? I tend to agree with you. How much different could a really solid wooden floor be from a concrete slab? Wouldn't good shoes cancel out all the differences?

And how could end grain blocks be better for your feet and knees than a concrete slab, especially if the blocks are over a slab?

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#8

Re: two pieces of data

FredD

Barry , one only needs to have worked on both to understand the difference.

There are many reasons why a wood floor is superior to a concrete one , I am surprised that you haven't noticed some of them, being a Home inspector and all.

The first thing many people will do is compare the cost and concrete is certainly the cheap one.

Wooden flooring is warm in the Winter , concrete isn't

.

Wooden flooring will not ruin the edge on a edge tool or destroy anything that a trip to a concrete floor will.

If concrete was equal to wood in ease of standing then the floor mat companies would be out of business.

If you fall on a wooden floor , you will be glad it was, a concrete one on the other hand.......

If you need to fasten a machine or fixture to the floor , it is a piece of cake if it is wood, not so much if it is concrete.

Your wooden floor will not develop shrinkage gaps or heave in cold weather if a dummy put it in, wooden floors are forgiving of week end warrior types learning the hard way.

Lastly a combination of both types as I have described is the best of both worlds and you would be glad to have one.

If you refer to your shop as a Cave , then maybe that's the best you can do .

If your looking for advice on how to approach the building of a shop , asking someone who has built more then one or two is a good place to start.

FredD

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#9

Re: two pieces of data

Barry Irby

Fred, To some extent, I was playing devil's advocate. I understand the advantages of wooden floors over concrete. One that is not well understood by many people is that the joists reflect slightly when you walk on the floor. This is what makes some floors feel springy or spongy. They (You know who THEY are?) claim that what you sense when you think a floor is springy is the shock wave from your step returning to your foot. Just hoping to learn something here.

All my shops have had Concrete floors. In my mind, shops are "supposed" to have concrete floors. Wish I had the money to build a new one bigger than I have with any kind of floor.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#10

keep it coming; I'm a sponge for this

ron

Thanks & I hope to hear all kinds of opinions.

To answer a few ?s:

Metal is out; not allowed by the homeowners assoc.

It's my retirement place, in another state, so a contractor will be doing most. Perhaps I can be there a few months per year over the next couple years.

Thanks for the reminder about drywall not being tool friendly.

Are you wood advocates going to let the concrete guys design my building? My current shop -- actually a 2-car garage sans cars -- is concrete so I don't really know any better, and I have no reference point.

ron

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#11

Re: keep it coming; I'm a sponge for this

Barry Irby

A couple of off the wall comments.

I have been through several shops and have looked at a number of plans for them Here. On thing I see often is that there is no area for the project itself.

My current shop is very small, a one car garage. I have a reasonably full complement of stationary power tools. So, I suffer from the "no place for the project problem". The current project is a head board for a bed that is 10' 8" long and 42" wide. We are temporarily using the room next door as an assembly area.

I have a garage door on my shop. It leaks energy, but it very useful. The table saw is 16' from the rear wall and about five feet from the over head door. I can rip a 16' board easily by opening the door and letting the board go out into the drive way. The width of the door pays off occasionally when cutting plywood.

My woodworking is varied. Sometimes I turn Christmas Ornaments on the lathe. Sometimes I build decks. I have fabricated trusses. Built a rose arbor that was nine feet tall to the ring and the ring was 12' in diameter. I Laminated bentwood arches of redwood that sprang from the circle and rose about 5'. The finial for it was 42" tall. My point is, think about what your projects might be and allow for them.

And, Strongly consider dust collection. I added it to my shop about five years ago and I can't imagine how I got along without it.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#12

Re: keep it coming; I'm a sponge for this

RobCarr

Just because it's a pre-engineered metal building doesn't mean it has to have corrugated metal wall panels - mine has metal on 3 sides, but the front (side that faces the house) is brick veneer. Another avenue is pre-cast concrete panels - they can be made to look like stucco, block or brick and with coloring added to the mix, it's hard to tell the difference from the real thing until you get up close.

My shop has drywall, but I had 1/4" plywood installed under it - that way you can put fasteners anywhere without worrying about hitting a stud it also makes the drywall less prone to dings. And it's a much cleaner look, but that's just my opinion.

The 4" wood shop floor works well for moving equipment or added new as you can route a groove in the bottom to run electrical conduit or air lines, etc.

I have a 10'x16' overhead door into the shop - there's not much that I can't build inside and worrying about getting out. :)

Someone else also noted about dust collection, I have one underfloor 6" duct that goes to the table saw... if I had better thought about it, I would have also run the one to the surface planer underfloor as opposed to overhead - partly because of aesthetics and partly because it's an 8' vertical run up to the ceiling and sometimes it get clogged, going down would take advantage of gravity to clear the chips.

It sounds like your in a built-up residential area, so this might not be a possibility - I'm in a rural area, so I can probably get away with it easier - but of you have 3-phase power available to you take advantage of it - not only for equipment, but 277v lighting is also more efficient.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#13

Go with concrete then...

John in NM

If a crew is doing the work, concrete should be cheaper for you, a joist floor is cheaper if you're just buying materials and doing it on your own time. You can always retro-fit later and have the best of both as Fred says.

I've never agreed with the anti-drywall arguments, but then I use hot mud (not the bucket stuff), so its easy to mix up a bit of that or some gypsum plaster and patch any dents. Studs are easy to find if you need to hang shelves, you get some measure of fire retardation, and it'll be a lot cheaper than any wood product except osb - which is not exactly well known for it's fastener holding capabilities, and frankly looks just hokie-god-awful when painted white. Should you elect to have drywall installed, it should be smooth finished and painted... smooth is much easier to patch.

I've heard of drywallers who refuse to smooth finish, and these are excellent contractors of whom to steer clear, they don't know their business :D

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#14

Re: Go with concrete then...

FredD

John hits two points right on, Drywall is not only the least expensive wall covering, the best reason for it is the Fire resistance it provides and in areas under Building code supervision is required, especially if the shop is attached to the residence.

It is also like John points out ,very easy to maintain, one caveat about using white paint, if you use a bright white you will be sorry , a off white like Antique White is much easier on the eyes. ..

Since Concrete once poured is prohibitively expensive to redo if you don't like how it turned out , make sure that doesn't happen.

More time spent on planning results in less time building and gives you a result, that you wished for.

Lastly the reason the Drywall contractors shy away from smooth finish , is because , like in California they are used to Textured finish which hides a lot of

of errors , like uneven wall surfaces.

Because of this and because they know smooth finish will not only not hide anything , but actually make it more obvious and having the skill necessary to achieve this quality of surface is one that they more then likely don't have.

FredD

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#15

lights? the most important part of a shop

bill tindall

You didn't mention the most important part of a shop-lighting-windows and artificial. If you intend to do any detail work-carving, hand cut dovetails, etc. you will need excellent lighting and more so if you are retired. I could "arrange the furniture" in any size or shape of shop to build fine furniture, but not if I couldn't see scribe lines or shadow on a carving. It takes a boggling amount of fluorescent fixtures to equal the light coming in a large window. A typical large lighting store will have a computer program to determine lighting requirements for a given size and shape.

Second most important- power. I would recommend 110 and 220 plugs everywhere as well as overhead 110 drops where ever the bench is to be located.

While new and uncluttered, paint the floor (and walls) a very light color. It will reflect light otherwise lost from above and boost illumination more than adding several more fixtures.

And finally, will someone arrange a statistically valid double blind test of whether someone with a shoe can detect concrete vs wood floor whilst wearing a shoe. Comfort wise, they can only be different if they are different in compressibility. Does anyone have data that suggests the force of a 180 pound person distributed over many square inches of shoe leather will compress wood!

A friend put white peg board on some walls. It has worked out well.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#16

Clint Searl

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

Clint Searl

Slab floor with 4 x 8 Advantech T&G 3/4 decking on 2 x 4 sleepers 16" OC on the flat. That's what I did and it's great.

Clint

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#17

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

Ryan Hartje

Lighting: We have a 24' wide shop with 3 rows of florescent fixtures running end to end the length of the building. Light levels were between 100 and 150 lumins, which is bright but my mom always appreciated it and you are never in shadow. We did go with a warmer lamp to help the color of things look better.

Floor: We are in an existing building that is mostly concrete and have many rubber mats. Your legs feel it by the end of the day if you don't stand on them. I have seen data on wood floor vs concrete but I'm not sure where now.

When thinking about dust, think about both at the machine and cleaning the air.

For the walls, I would lean toward OSB just because I tend to bump into them. Plywood under the gyp is a good option.

Doors: We have a double door into the shop which is handy. Residential overhead doors just don't seal. A compromise might be to have an overhead out to the boat bay. Make sure if you do have an overhead, you also have a man door next to it to minimize it's use.

Power: You can never have enough power. As we are in an existing building, ours is all in surface conduit but we have outlets every 8' around the perimeter with multiple circuits. I put in a few 220 outlets but have never used them. All of our large tools are hardwired.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#18

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

Bill Turpi in WNC mountains

Anyplace that there is an outlet, put in double-gang boxes. Put outlets at a convenient height, above, not behind and under stationary tools. Do not put power tools on lighting circuits. You want to be able to see that saw coast to a stop after the breaker trips. Use both flourescent and incandescent fixtures above rotating tools. Stop the strobe effect. Buy a ten year supply of regular incandescent bulbs while you still can! Use vertical drops instead of floor outlets. Floor outlets can trip you and gather dust. Put in twice as many outlets as you know you need. Insulate walls for HVAC. Put in plumbing for air lines with dirt and moisture drains at the end runs. Do not use PVC for air! Take air taps off the top of main lines. Put a roll-up air hose in the ceiling. Put in more air taps than you think necessary. Slope main air runs downhill to the moisture drains. Have dampers in HVAC to close off areas not currently needed.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#19

Amen to all but one......

bill tindall

I don't think you can buy a fluorescent fixture that flickers, now days. I think the GOV mandated electronic ballasts and they don't flicker or cause hum.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#20

Re: lights? the most important part of a shop

FredD

"and finally, will someone arrange a statistically valid double blind test of whether someone with a shoe can detect concrete vs wood floor whilst wearing a shoe. Comfort wise, they can only be different if they are different in compressibility. Does anyone have data that suggests the force of a 180 pound person distributed over many square inches of shoe leather will compress wood!"

This is a relatively simple concept Bill , certainly one doesn't need a R@D lab test to ascertain that putting your bare hand in flame or picking up hot iron would be very painful.

Nor is a test necessary to understand where pain comes from when your on your feet all day and how come.

Your confusing terms , Compression of wood is not the point , Deflection of supported wood floors, decks and so on is.

Concrete floors cause pain in the legs and feet because the concrete will not Deflect. It is absolutely unforgiving , so your weight is entirely absorbed by your footwear and feet and legs ,causing pain over years of walking on one .

Wooden floors supported by various beam or joist systems do deflect when walked on.

Any Carpenter can attest to actually seeing this when under the floor looking for annoying squeaks caused in many cases by the floor moving up and down as it is walked on , which is Deflection , not compression.

That's it.

FredD

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#21

Setting Up Shop

Merle

is a Taunton book that has most of the above and more. I highly recommend it.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#22

beg to differ

Chris Friesen

"I have heard this argument that wood is easier on the feet than concrete. Baloney. Does anyone really think their foot can tell the minuscule difference in compressibility of wood vs concrete if they are wearing a shoe? The only reason to go with wood is if you want access under the floor.

I am not fond of drywall walls in a shop. Walls are to hang stuff on. "

Heh...I'll disagree with both of those. I can feel a noticeable difference walking on a hardwood floor vs a tiled floor, and a concrete floor even more so. There is a small amount of "give" to wooden subfloor.

The other reason to go with wooden floors would be to reduce the thermal mass of the floor. This is useful if you need to heat the shop in winter and plan to leave it colder most of the time. By stuffing insulation between the floor joists it will be much more comfortable underfoot.

Lastly, drywall walls in a shop work great. I painted mine white and it improved the light levels noticeably even though I have a decent number of fluorescent fixtures. I put french cleats all along one wall to hang stuff on. The other walls have lumber racks, upper cabinets, tool storage, etc.

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#23

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

ron

Good stuff all.

Dust collection: yes, that'll be there; I have that now but will upgrade.

I also should do a shop layout so I can consider underfloor duct work.

Space to swing the rough wood around, like the garage door I rely on now: that's an important point that I've underplanned. Thanks. I'll work on that. I like the double door idea.

Drywall over ply. Deserves some thought.

Lighting. I've underthought windows and natural light.

FLOOR! I'm kind of leaning toward concrete and then tempering its harshness later with one of the mentioned wood systems, although this is not the same as joists. Will discuss this with a local contractor.

Good stuff Mr. Turpi!

I recall seeing that Taunton book. I'll get one.

Thanks everyone for their contributions. More is welcome too. I'll post pics of my "church" when it happens.

ron

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#24

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

Larry in NW OHIO

Ron If you think an idea of mine would be worth while I`ll tell you about it. When I buiolt my shop a couple of years ago, 16' X 20', I put in an overhead door. I really didn`t want to because of the cold winter air blowing in. But I figured a way to seal up the door without nailing it shut. I put 3 different weather strips at the edge of the door instead of just the one that is usually on them. It seals up the door very well. If your interested just email me and I`ll try and explain it. Good luck. Larry

Re: if you're planning a hobby shop and ...

#25

I would email u if I knew how, but ...

ron

Mine is ron-griffin@tamu.edu