Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

OT Have to do some Plumbing

Posts

OT Have to do some Plumbing

#1

Alan Young

OT Have to do some Plumbing

Alan Young

We bought a claw foot tub at a big flea market about ten years ago and it's been sitting in my small barn ever since. Well time has come that we want to install this tub in our upstairs bathroom. Our house was built @1895. The plumbing to the bathroom is galvanized. I'd really rather not have to replace the plumbing all the way back to the water heater in the basement 2 floors down. So I am exploring my options.

No1 What are the connection options going from galvanized to copper? I know I cant join these directly because the disparate metals have corrosive reaction or something of the like.

No2. What about Pex? can I make a connection from the galvanized to Pex?

If we need/have to replace the galvanized supply lines back to the basement, is Pex or copper a better idea.?

I'm sure I have many more questions but being able to narrow down the options is a start...

-Alan

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#2

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

Barry Irby

You can buy Di-electric (sp?) couplings that will allow you to connect copper to Galv. They have and internal plastic sleeve that separates the two metals.

You can also buy fitting that will allow the connection of PEX to Threaded pipe. I am not a big fan of PEX, but that's a personal thing. (I'm turning into an old fuddy duddy and PEX looks too much like Polybutylene to me, and PB was a disaster.)

You will need a crimping tool to connect the PEX, but Lowes has one you can buy for about $130 and it has several sets of jaws with it to allow you to use different sizes of pipe. In spite of my personal reservations, PEX is a good choice or renovations. You can often fish it in in places that would require demolition to install copper. I suspect this will be the first of many upgrades if you live in an older home with galvanized pipe, so having the crimping tool is not a bad thing. But, if you don't want to buy one, you can rent one.

One other thing, Chrome Plated brass is the classic material for this connection. Have you considered that?

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#3

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

del schisler

Water in How about the 1 1/2" drain ? Today standard is 1 1/2" What does that go into ? maybe 2" coupling at the wall Or maybe gal. ? Shouldn't be to hard to get it installed I wouldn't go with pex They make conectors from copper to gal. Take a good look at it They make everthing needed to do the job Just take's some time to get it done

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#4

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

steve mackay

My parents bought a similar vintage house when I was growing up. It was a wreck when we moved in and my childhood consisted of renovation and remodeling "by owner". I've always been thankfull for that. Not that any of this makes me an expert or anything BUT . . . replace your lines (hot & cold) with copper WHILE YOU HAVE THINGS AND WALLS TORN UP. . . NOW. All the way to main supply and water heater. Doing it one room at a time isn't as painfull as you might think. AND you'll get better and better at it every time. You'll also have the piece of mind that your runs are tight and dependable. No late nights wondering if joints are holding inside your walls. No wondering when you'll open the walls BACK up to finally replace the whole thing. As to PEX . . . for ME, the jury is still out. But I grew up on copper.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#5

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

Larry in NW OHIO

Alan I just finished doing a little plumbing putting in my on site water heater. It took a little to do but it was made a LOT easier with the fittings I used.They are something called "STA Tech" they are a push on and lock on. You can take them off and reuse them. I got mine @ Menards, but HD and Lowes has basicly the same thing but made by someone else. They have all the fittings you need. I used them and I really, really like them. They really make plumbing very easy. They work on PVC, copper and Pex. Larry

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#6

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

Barry Irby

Lowes and HD have fittings called Gator Bite and Shark Bite. They are very similar if not identical and one sells one and the other one sells the other. They would like the Sta Tech you are talking about. I have used them and I like them, but they are SUBSTANTIALLY more expensive than conventional fittings. Three or four or maybe five times as much. IIRC Tees were about $9. Handy when you are in a bind or don't want to solder, but they would really add up in cost.

My personal first choice is still copper unless there is well water that can destroy it in as little as fifteen years.

And you are correct. Often the ancillary work of tearing open walls and ceilings is more expensive than the plumbing, so do the plumbing and wiring and insulating while you have the walls torn open, if you are tearing out the interior.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#7

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

John E in SC

I kinda agree with this as well. Don't know how old your galvanized pipe is (betting pretty darn old!), but galvanized tends to rust on the inside, with the result being that the inside diameter of the pipe gets smaller and smaller with time. I was trying to help a lady from church a while back that had an older house with galvanized pipe. The water to her kitchen sink had just quit flowing. To make a long story short, the galvanized pipe (which looked fine on the outside) had basically filled up with rust to the point that the water couldn't go through. I couldn't even stick a screwdrive down down in the pipe! Would hate to go to all that trouble piping a new tub, and then have your water flow slow down so much you'ld never be able to get it full! I've done copper and PVC before, and both are pretty easy to work with. Might as well do it right while you've got access.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#8

A Note on Copper

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Not to make more work for you, but this is an opportunity to upgrade your plumbing out of the 19th century.

If you decide to run copper, make sure you use only type L which has the blue ink marking on it. Box stores also sell type m (red ink) bur no worthwhile plumber will use it for anything other than low pressure hot water heat. My house was built in the 80's when NJ was allowing type M for all residential plumbing. Acid water was chewing up the thin pipes that were starting to pin-hole. I ripped out the entire lot and repiped in type L.

Several friends are contractors and construction consults, and they have each had PEX installed in their homes with relatively little in the way of wall repair. Nice thing is that the stuff is run from manifolds in the basement with a "home run" line (no branches) to each fixture, Makes it very easy to isolate a faucet without having to shut all the water off.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#9

pinholes

John in NM

I looked into the problem about 5 years ago when trying to decide on a line material for our house. As I recall, there was no clear geographical correlation either on the large scale (national) or even down to some neighborhoods having problems and others not. The most plausible explanation I've heard to date is that they're caused by water softener use.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#10

Re: PEX

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot ID

Hi Alan!

I am a die-hard PEX user! I am not a plumber by profession, but I have re-plumbed three houses with PEX now, and I have installed in-floor radiant heat in my shop using PEX, and I have not experienced one leak in all the connections I have made, over the past ten years. I highly recommend it.

I use the Wirsbo PEX, and I own the tool to make the connections, which was the big investment. The connectors are either brass or plastic, and hook up to galvanized just fine.

The first place we re-plumbed was a cabin we had up in the mountains. It took us three days to remove all the old galvanized pipe that was clogged up after 35 years of very hard water. It took my Wife and I one afternoon to plumb back in all the connections using the PEX. This cabin was one we shut up and turned the heat off for the winter, and we never had the PEX leak due to freezing.

At the big box stores you can buy short lengths of PEX, and they also usually have fittings that do not require a special tool. Nothing could be easier than snaking a piece of PEX in there and making a connection. And it beats the heck out of soldering a copper connection! After using PEX, you couldn't force me to go back to using copper!

I don't know if this offsets all those who boo-hooed PEX, but I hope it will at least have you consider it fairly as an option. Good luck!

Scott.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#11

Re: pinholes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Usually cause by several reasons. First is inferior pipe that has point defects. Next is acid water which slowly erodes the copper, literally dissolving the metal. Third is abrasion of suspended material in the stream; these leaks usually occur on the outer radius of bends where the abrasive action is most pronounced. A combination of 2&3 has a fairly rapid effect on the pipes.

I had pinholes as the thin pipe was being eaten up from iron-acid water that also held a lot of calcium for truly hard water. Cutting the pipe to replace a section confirmed how thin the copper had become as it took little for the cutter to puncture the pipe.

Issues were solved (after putting in the new pipe) by putting in a calcite neutralizer, followed by a sodium-free softener, and lastly, a whole-house filter.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#12

Re: pinholes

Barry Irby

There are actually three grades or thicknesses of copper, K,L, and M. Generally K was restricted to commercial jobs and L was for well water and M for City water. Type M on non corrosive city water is generally thought to last about sixty years. This is assuming the water has been treated and the chemistry balanced and filtered to not destroy copper. As I mentioned before, some types of well water will destroy type M copper in as little as fifteen years. Obviously, it would be wise to have your water tested and treat it and filter it to extend the life of the pipes. If you are going to work with copper, be sure to buy fittings that match the thickness of the pipe.

CPVC plastic pipe is suitable for both hot and cold water in supply service and appears to be unaffected by well water or any water chemistry where the water is considered Potable.

PEX is also unaffected, but the fitting are questionable. Evidence is emerging that some water chemistry is very hard on and is destroying the brass fittings.

Plastic pipe, CPVC and PEX impart little or no taste to the water. I think there Si a question about other chemicals diffusing into the water.

In many cities the water chemistry is adjusted to not destroy the remaining lead water pipes so that little or no lead leaches into eh water.

We don't know enough about the effects of the various metals and chemicals from the plastic diffusing into the water we drink. It is a good idea to not drink water that has been standing in your pipes. You should be flushing the system in the morning before you drink from them.

Also, you should not be drinking the water from your water heater at all. Cook with cold water and heat it on the stove.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#13

Re: PEX

R Payne

I'm split on PEX. I've worked construction and see PEX being used in two ways. One is with a manifold, the other is with connections along the run.

I don't see a problem with the manifold system.

But putting connections in I don't like. All the connectors I've seen go inside the pipe. That reduces the water that can flow through that connection. I think that is a bad idea.

If I couldn't put in a manifold and make long runs, I'd stick with PVC/CPVC (especially on well water) or copper if the water chemistry allows.

Just my two cents.

ron

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#14

Alan Young

I VERY MUCH appreciate the comments

Alan Young

I realize topics such as this can produce varying opinions. This information is of great value to me. I will probably take a few pics this evening to detail the situation.

Thanks...

-Alan

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#15

Re: Two (or more) styles of PEX couplings

Gary Camp, Bend Oregon

When we moved the house the plumber used Pex with Stainless steel band clamps. The other style that I know is the Wirsbo with an expander and a seemingly more involved system. I have had no problems in two plus years with the band clamps (they have also been used sucessfully in the soft drink industry for years). The only down side I have seen is on my out door faucets. 1/2" supply, internal fittings and 200 plus feet of hose = reduced flow. I will be replacing my outdoor faucets with 3/4" supplies and 3/4" self draining faucets in the near future. My house is plumbed with a 3/4" supply running the length of the house with everything tee'd off. The band crimping tool runs from 85 to 130 dollars. At work on soft drink lines I have used end nippers very sucessfuly to crimp Oteker (sp?) clamps

glc

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#16

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Chuck Lenz

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#17

The cause of pin hole copper leaks

Bill Tindall

I attended a lecture a while back given by some bio-whatever from Oak Ridge National Lab. He claimed the pin hole leaks were caused by corrosion induced by a colony of bacteria. As such they would only occur where non-chlorinated water was used and they would be most prevalent after the allowable lead content of copper was reduced. Does this information agree with people's observations?

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#18

Drinking Water?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Interested to here the why on not drinking pre-heated water, and if your reason agrees with my info.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#19

Re: The cause of pin hole copper leaks

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Haven't heard that one, Bill, However bacteria in piping is a common problem with stored supplies. It is standard procedure that before any copper is installed that a wad of cloth be soaked in straight Clorox and pulled through the pipe to kill any bacteria present.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#20

shark-bite   Push fittings At HD   

del schisler

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#21

Re: Drinking Water?

Barry Irby

What I have been told is that the temperature inside many water heaters is not hot enough to INSURE that bacteria won't grow in the tank. That the temp really needs to be up near 140 degrees. This bit of info was a generalization and I have been carrying it around in the dim recesses of my brain for at least 25 years. Probably even more true now that so many people turn the heaters down to 120 or 110. Had not considered the Chlorinated vs. non-chlorinated water, but that makes sense.

I was told that "pseudomona" (whatever that is) could colonize the tank. This matches up with the article on Legionnaires Disease. I thought Legionaries was associated with Air Conditioning and the condensate from that, but maybe it finds a wise range of temps to be acceptable.

So, the explanation I got was that the water in your heater was essentially stagnant and might sit in there for days and become contaminated. Thus, you should use cold water and heat it on the stove to cook with. Also, since the water tends to sit in the pipes over night, before you drink or cook with the water, even the cold, you should run it enough to flush the system and get "fresh" water out of the main. There are many potential sources of contamination including high levels of lead in the brass in faucets and solder joints. So flushing the system after it has been standing while makes sense. You have to depend on your neighbors to use enough water to keep the main fresh.

A couple of other issues. There are these heating systems where they install an oversized water heater and use it to heat water to heat the house. (Apollo, Hydro Heat and one or two others.) Instead of the boiler heating your domestic water, your domestic water heater was heating the house. One of the things necessary for the systems to be acceptable is that all the components have to be rated for Potable water. So, In winter, a small circulator (pump) sends water through a coil in the the AC air handler and returns it to the water heater. The same fan that works for the AC blows the heat into the house. A potential problem is that when you switch to AC, whatever water is in the loop remains there until Fall. I am not sure that any systems have become contaminated, but the potential is certainly there. There were discussions about putting a timer on the system that cause the pump to run for a few seconds occasionally to circulate enough water to keep it "fresh", but not enough to mess up the AC. I have never seen a unit with such a set up.

Another problem I run into several times a year is the "rotten egg smell" in the water. In the hot water only. The anode rod in the WH breaks down Puts magnesium into the water. Bacteria live of the magnesium byproducts and produce sulfur dioxide that stinks of rotten eggs. This is usually in houses that have been sitting empty for a while and may go away when you start using enough water. If not, you can have a plumber chlorinate the tank. If that fails you can have the magnesium anode changed to an aluminum anode. I am not sure this is a dangerous condition, but I don't want to cook with it or drink it.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#22

Re: Legionair's

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

is the key.

This has arisen because many local plumbing codes mandate the heater be set at 110� to prevent scalding injuries. 110�F in a light-tight wet environment turns out to be the optimum set-up to breed several kinds of bacteria. Anyone with untreated well water is susceptible and it goes beyond drinking as you're getting a face-full in the shower.

I keep my gas-fired heater set at 145� which does wonders for the dishwasher's performance. I also have both my well and heated water tested every other year.

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#23

Me too! ...

Mike Farinella

No matter what I do to fix it, it always gets worse and I end up replacing almost everything. On a positive note, it has enabled my wife to learn the Italian language (not the kind you can repeat though). ;)

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#24

Never do plumbing when the stores are closed!

Bill Howatt

Re: OT Have to do some Plumbing

#25

Re: Legionnaires

Barry Irby

Go down (UP?) to the Posts by Tom Dunlap about setting his water heater to Pilot and the One "Crazy talk" by Jim in Burlington, ON on July 11, 2010. An article on Legionnaires.