references to technical discussion of pressures
Bill Tindall
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2010/07/06/science/06drill_graphic.html This reference discusses the drilling strategy and technology planned to seal the well.
http://www.theoildrum.com/node/6609#more This reference discusses pressures at the oil bearing rock layer, and at various places in the equipment at the sea floor as well as oil flows and the issue of errosion potentially drastically increasing flow.
Wall street Journal Friday May 28 as well as either the day before or the day after issue (I can't find mine to be sure) has extensive article on the details of what happened as well as a detailed description of the well and how it was being drilled and capped.
This well was an exploration well. Its objectives were to see what was down there(answer, a big pool of valuable oil) and obtain loads of technical data on the rock, oil and gas. It was the plan to drill the well, log the information and then seal it with cement. Later, and entirely different "production platform" was to be moved into place over the well to develop it for production.
The problem with speculating and second guessing the situation is that the information in the nightly news provides insufficient technical details about the situation to make informed hypotheses.
For example the issue of flow. At first BP stated XX barrels per day of oil was leaking. Later the news reported a larger number, implying that BP was hiding the "true" value. When in fact there are many factors that could cause the flow to increase over time, or decrease.
I'm no fan of BP. Their corporate strategy was short term profit to enhance stock price, a philosophy I abhor. It worked for a while as evidenced by the fact BP stock carried a substantial premium to their competitors. They were the darling of the oil patch investors, and hated by competitors for their business strategy. Not just this well, but they blew up a refinery killing several as well as other episodes that could be blamed on taking short cuts for short term gain.
But, don't presume what they are doing to fix the situation is stupid until you have studied the technology involved sufficient to make an informed opinion. The survival of the company is at stake and that focuses attention on doing one's best. To calm their investors, many who think the company may not survive, BP will be doing everything technically possible to report the well is capped by the mid year investors meeting and 2nd quarter report. If Exxon knew some better way to proceed, BP would be shoveling money at them to get the information or equipment.
What the government is doing, if not stupid, is at least politically driven, not technology and economically driven. Cleaning the water is hampered by the fact that government rules require that the cleaned water during this emergecy be cleaned to the same standard as water dumped in routine situations. This limit, limits cleaning rate. Not allowing foreign vessels to help pleases the domestic union but doesn't increase clean up capacity. Forbidding export of domestic oil to foreign markets does not increase domestic availability or lower domestic price; in fact the opposite is true. I'll leave it to an oil trader to report/explain the reasons why. Or, just believe the opposite is true because it is a populist thing to do and it doesn't require effort.