Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Question for those smarter than I.

Posts

Question for those smarter than I.

#1

Question for those smarter than I.

Marv

Regarding the oil gusher in the Gulf....if BP could create a even opening at the open end of the 20" pipe, would it be possible to lower say, a 50'diameter metal disc down and lay it flat down onto the opening? Would the mile of water above the disc hold it down tight enough to shut off the gusher? It would be a matter of mathamatics to figure out how large a disc would be required to overcome the pressure of the gusher spewing out of the pipe.

The disc would be lowered down on edge, then laid down when it got down to the gusher. In theory, the weight of the water above it, would slam it down onto the opening of the 20" pipe

Just a theory... :\

Marv

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#2

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

Barry Irby

I doubt I am smarter, but that has never stopped me before.

It probably would not work. At least the weight of the water on top of the disk would not contribute to the solution. Since there would be water under it and over it, the pressure would be nearly equal. The weight of the disk would probably not be enough to stop the leak. The steel disk would weigh less under water than it does in the air.

Think about how and hwy a vacuum bag can be sued for veneering. If you just put your stuff in the bag, nothing happens even though nearly the entire atmosphere is above it. Seal the bag and suck out he air and you get tremendous pressure. If you could seal the disk to the bottom of the ocean and suck the water out from under it, you idea might work.

Am I the only one that is bothered by them burning the oil? My Grandmother is spinning in her grave. You don't waste stuff. We need the oil, that's why we let them go out there and drill the hole in the first place. Why the heck don't they take the oil to the refineries right there near the coast and refine it and give it to me so I can burn it in my car? I know they claim the burning process is very efficient and does not produce much pollution, but My brain says they are trading water pollution for air pollution and global warming. Does not make sense and is wasteful.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#3

I doubt I'm smarter

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

seems to me that, since any water below the disc is at equal pressure to that above, there's not enough pressure differential to keep it there; and the oil in the well is clearly at a higher pressure than the water, or it wouldn't be spewing out.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#4

Not the only one bothered by the burning oil, no

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I keep envisioning the air pollution involved - I doubt they've got any catalytic converters on the ship. While it's important to get the oil out of the water, it seems to me they're trading one pollutant for another by burning it.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#5

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

Marv

I'm bothered by everything having to do with BP. Why the hell save some of the oil and burn some of it? Makes zero sense. And what are they doing with all the globs of oil that's being picked up on the beaches? And what are they doing with the oil they are skimming? And why did they spray dispersents on the oil slicks? It's all still in the water, just smaller particles, making it more difficult to collect. How stupid is that? They won't collect even a fraction of it and it will eventually come ashore. Must have been a rocket scientist who came up with that idea.

Ok, Barry and Bill.....I think I'm with you guys regarding how the disc idea wouldn't work. Sorta like the robots that go down there to work on the well head. They aren't being pushed down toward the bottom, they just kinda float around down there. Lots of pressure all around the hull of the robot, but the pressure doesn't effect it's up or down movement. My theory was based on the diameter of the disc and the amount of water weight on the top surface of it, not depending on the weight of the disc. The thought came to me in an early morning dream. So much for early morning dreams. :D

Marv

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#6

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

Larry in NW OHIO

Barry I thought about that as soon as I saw that they were going to burn it off. If you can burn it why the H--- can`t you put it on a ship, they sure got enough of them out there, and bring it to a refinery and give it to us. Of course if they would out it on a ship, they would probably take it to Japan or some such place. Larry

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#7

No

Bill Tindall

The head pressure at the ocean floor is about 3000 pis according to my friend the petroleum geologist that keeps me appraised of the situation. The only way to stop the flow is what they are doing. Drill a parallel hole to intersect the leaking pipe just above the oil bearing layer, pump these pipes full of drilling "mud" which is heavy enough to overcome the reservoir pressure and then add cement to seal both pipes. Later they will come back with a production platform and drill through the cement with a smaller hole, insert a pipe and transport oil to the surface.

BTW, the target pipe is magnetized with a small current and the drill head headed for it has a magnetometer that detects the target location. They can nail a 12" pipe at 25000 feet with no problem. This drill bit will bore through the original pipe so that muc can be added from the bottom to eventually fill the original pipe, which will enable cement to be added for a seal.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Well, for some back-of-the-envelope calculations as to what the disc would need to weigh, here are some numbers for you:

Size of pipe: 20" diameter

Cross-sectional area: 314 sq. in.

Pressure of oil in the well: I've heard everywhere from 15,000 PSI to 40,000 PSI, so I used 20,000 PSI for the calculations (easily doubled if the well pressure is 40,000 PSI).

That means that the force of the oil in the well on anything covering the pipe is about 6.3 million pounds. (area x pressure) This does not factor in that at that depth, water is much more dense, somewhat offsetting the weight of whatever material the disc is made of, since buoyancy is based on the difference in densities. So lead at 2000 feet deep in sea water is not as heavy as lead here on land (the density of air is negligible).

Either way, it would be a BIG disc... if you use lead, and don't factor in the buoyancy effects (above my pay grade), 6.3 million pounds of lead would make a disc a foot thick and roughly 100' diameter. Or, you could use a sphere of lead about 26 feet in diameter.

Jason

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#9

The porblem with second guessing

Bill Tindall

There are technically sound reasons why all the "obvious" solutions talk show hosts and forum participants come up with aren't such good ideas after all. The most ignorant that I heard was setting off a nuclear bomb to "seal the well", which in all likelihood would have fractured the rock even more and set off a real gusher. Excepting the politically motivated response of our government, what is being done is the best that the collective wisdom of the world's petroleum scientists and engineers know how to do within the limits that various government regulatory agencies will allow.

To answer one of your questions, if the oil is sufficiently dispersed to maximize its surface area, it will rapidly chemically and biochemically degrade.

We have a retired petroleum geophysicist in our club that keeps us technically appraised of the goings on. He has drilled in this area, but because it was a few years ago it was in more shallow water.(1000') As the technology advances the drilling proceeds to deeper water(5000'). It sounds like science fiction the things that can be done to get oil out of the ground under extreme conditions. And these things come with some risk. It has been shown that BP took more risk than was prudent and they are, and will be, punished in the market place, having already shed half the value of the company.

There are some good web sites with technical information (the WoodCentral's of petroleum engineering), if anyone is interested in the challenges of drilling in a mile of water into very young crumbly rock, or stopping this leak.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#10

a porblem

Bill Tindall

The leak is in the blow out preventer and it is estimated to be very small hole but getting bigger due to errosion. There isn't any way to plug it/seal it. If the entire pipe cross section was leaking the flow would be astronomical at 3000 psi. BTW the well bore at ground level is 36", necking down as the well deepens.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#11

The reason the oil is at a higher pressure...

John in NM

The oil bearing formation is also under the weight of many thousands of feet of sediment, so it's at a much higher pressure than the sea water at the head of the well. This is what makes the well so hard to plug, but also what makes oil extraction in undamaged wells relatively easy.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#12

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

Barry Irby

I find the burning of the oil after they have captured it to be offensive. Wasteful. It's a finite resource and we need it and they are burning it.

I have to admit I wondered if the weren't burning it because it was easier and because if they sent it to the refinery people would be saying things like "BP is profiting form the spill by selling the oil" or "BP does not wan t fix it because they are making money off what they capture". By burning it they can not be accused of profiting.

As far as the dispersants go, one of the things you hear is "the solution to pollution is dilution." Dilute most anything far enough and it ceases to be a problem. But, at this scale I wonder if you are getting the dilution necessary. How long will it take for the oil in the gulf to degrade if they keep dumping in millions of gallons a day? At some point we are going to have a giant puddle of oil soup. Seems to me, anyway.

I would like to know more about how they do all of this. I did not know the wells were twenty inches in diameter. Now Bill says they start at 36". I am hearing things about a pipe within the pipe and grouting the outer pipe. I was amazed by the robot that had shears beg enough to cut a 20" pipe. Impressive to me.

I think that it is amazing that the apparent ultimate solution to this is a "bottom kill" and that after using the fantastic technology of drilling a guided hole with magnetometers and what ever, they pump "mud" and Cement into the hole. Ancient low tech materials to solve a modern problem.

And yes, the nuclear bomb was the dumbest idea I have heard.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

3000 PSI?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Is that all the pressure the well is at? I thought it was more along the lines of an order of magnitude greater (or did you just have a typo there?).

Even though the whole cross-section of the pipe isn't leaking, everything below the cut is at roughly the same pressure (I'm sure there are SOME pressure losses along the length of the well between the reservoir and the cut pipe). So, once the pipe is capped off at the cut, the pressure on that cap is pressure times the area of the opening the cap is covering.

Jason

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The reason for the nuclear option...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

If you look up (the late) Red Adair, you'll find he was a master at fixing burning oil wells on land--usually using dynamite. I think he was involved in putting out a bunch of the wells Saddam Hussein's troops ignited in Kuwait as they retreated in '91.

If you've ever see video of an underground nuclear blast, you'll remember that it creates a crater as all the dirt and rock around the device "liquify", kind of like a mudslide, and end up occupying less space after the blast, sinking down into a newly-formed crater. And, the nuclear device proposed wouldn't have to be one of the many-megaton warheads we have on our missile arsenal, but could be even smaller than the ones we dropped on Japan.

Of course, the risk is that the blast cracks the crust away from the well and opens up a new, potentially larger leak. Apparently that risk percentage was too high for the nuclear option to be considered (I think it probably got more hype from the media than serious consideration from BP and the gov't).

Jason

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#15

Well . . .

steve mackay

I think your right on the money. The list of options is, about, TWO. If we dwell on this burning thing the last option is (from "Trashcan Man") The BIG Fire. Choice one : let the pros work on it. Choice two : nuke the gulf of mexico.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#16

Re: The reason for the nuclear option...

Barry Irby

I might be wrong, but my understanding of what Red Adair did with dynamite was to blow out the fire, not seal the well. They set off an explosion and literally blew the oxygen away from the fire long enough for it to extinguish. Not sure, but I think that is what happened. After the fire was out they turned off or capped the well.

I did see a TV show where some company mounted a jet engine on a tank chassis and drove it as close to the burning well as they could and fired off the jet. Then with remote control they backed it closer and the blast of air from the engine blew out the well fire. They portrayed it as very effective.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#17

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

Craig Daymon

I'd say the simple answer might be that the oil is gushing because it has more than the weight of the water pushing on it. It has another additional several thousand feet of earth pushing on it. The gusher is just the point of release.

I think the bigger question for me, and I'm giving no free ride to ALL the oil companies who have done deep sea drilling without proper safety procedures, is why we don't hear more about Halliburton in this mess? Halliburton is the same company that has received billions in no bid contracts since ex-ceo Dick Cheney was in office, who sent substandard helmets to our troops, who over charged the government hundreds of millions, who is poisoning our national water supply with their "fracking" process (PLEASE watch the HBO documentary, "Gasland") and who was using substandard cement to cap the well (as part of the regular process, not to fix the problem) in the gulf when the BP well blew.

The gulf problem is minor compared to what they are doing with "fracking" and what it is doing to our water and therefore our food supply. Ellis, this problem is one that might be right in your backyard.

-Craig

(Gasland got me so irate when I was watching it I had to stop it half way in and call my brother to rant.)

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#18

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Correct as far as I know...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I was just using the dynamite as an example that explosives aren't necessarily the worst thing in the world when it comes to oil well problems.

I had not heard of the jet engine solution.

Jason

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#19

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

FredD

This mess in the Gulf is the worst environmental disaster yet and to make it even worse, it likely could have been prevented.

That rig of BP's had 761 safety and equipment violations in the same time period that their competitors had as many as eight and as few as one.

That alone should guarantee a prison term for both the company and the Department of Interior inspectors who looked the other way.

It bothers me a lot to see us as a nation ,willing to destroy wildlife habitat, wetlands , marshes and make life for endangered species even more on the edge of extinction ,just so a foreign corporation can drill for oil in a place that never should be allowed and pay the princely sum of 2 cents per barrel to the Government as a tax.

This particular company has demonstrated arrogance on a level not seen by anybody heretofore and allowed to get away with it.

Lying to the United States Congress is a criminal offense, yet they seem able to do it on a near daily basis and get not even a slap on the wrist.

If and when this run away oil well is capped , the Gulf coast will suffer for years and years,economically and environmentally.

Most of us had put the Valdez disaster in our mental archives and got on with our lives, this one should be the wake up call for the Nation and Congress to re-access the priorities of our quest for a rapidly disappearing resource.

We will be able to survive without the oil industry if the Government and Industry make the effort to reduce our dependency on it .

The Environment and the Animal Kingdom will suffer irreparable harm in the destruction and extinction of a way of life for thousands of people who make a living from the Sea and the life forms that live in it.

Just a effort like the one expended on getting a man on the Moon would go a long way.

BP's stock going down by half is hardly a punishment, I would like to see them gone from the Gulf, rigs and all.

FredD

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#20

references to technical discussion of pressures

Bill Tindall

http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2010/07/06/science/06drill_graphic.html This reference discusses the drilling strategy and technology planned to seal the well.

http://www.theoildrum.com/node/6609#more This reference discusses pressures at the oil bearing rock layer, and at various places in the equipment at the sea floor as well as oil flows and the issue of errosion potentially drastically increasing flow.

Wall street Journal Friday May 28 as well as either the day before or the day after issue (I can't find mine to be sure) has extensive article on the details of what happened as well as a detailed description of the well and how it was being drilled and capped.

This well was an exploration well. Its objectives were to see what was down there(answer, a big pool of valuable oil) and obtain loads of technical data on the rock, oil and gas. It was the plan to drill the well, log the information and then seal it with cement. Later, and entirely different "production platform" was to be moved into place over the well to develop it for production.

The problem with speculating and second guessing the situation is that the information in the nightly news provides insufficient technical details about the situation to make informed hypotheses.

For example the issue of flow. At first BP stated XX barrels per day of oil was leaking. Later the news reported a larger number, implying that BP was hiding the "true" value. When in fact there are many factors that could cause the flow to increase over time, or decrease.

I'm no fan of BP. Their corporate strategy was short term profit to enhance stock price, a philosophy I abhor. It worked for a while as evidenced by the fact BP stock carried a substantial premium to their competitors. They were the darling of the oil patch investors, and hated by competitors for their business strategy. Not just this well, but they blew up a refinery killing several as well as other episodes that could be blamed on taking short cuts for short term gain.

But, don't presume what they are doing to fix the situation is stupid until you have studied the technology involved sufficient to make an informed opinion. The survival of the company is at stake and that focuses attention on doing one's best. To calm their investors, many who think the company may not survive, BP will be doing everything technically possible to report the well is capped by the mid year investors meeting and 2nd quarter report. If Exxon knew some better way to proceed, BP would be shoveling money at them to get the information or equipment.

What the government is doing, if not stupid, is at least politically driven, not technology and economically driven. Cleaning the water is hampered by the fact that government rules require that the cleaned water during this emergecy be cleaned to the same standard as water dumped in routine situations. This limit, limits cleaning rate. Not allowing foreign vessels to help pleases the domestic union but doesn't increase clean up capacity. Forbidding export of domestic oil to foreign markets does not increase domestic availability or lower domestic price; in fact the opposite is true. I'll leave it to an oil trader to report/explain the reasons why. Or, just believe the opposite is true because it is a populist thing to do and it doesn't require effort.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#21

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

Craig Daymon

I'm not necessarily in disagreement with you, I just wanted to point out Halliburton's dirty hands in yet another crime against America. I did state that ALL the oil companies should have to insure realistic safety plans for deep water drilling. I have heard the reports that BP has the worst record and for that should have the most severe punishment, but it also sounds like NONE of the oil companies are working with real disaster plans in place. (Though, the walruses in the gulf are safe.)

If you take a good look at the area impacted by drilling something like 400,000 natural gas wells since 2005, when the "Halliburton Loop-Hole" was signed into law protecting natural gas exploration from the clean air and clean water acts, and you see just how much of the nation is impacted, it may very well take the number one natural disaster trophy away from the gulf. That is, looking at it as one incident and its impact on water supplies, livestock, agriculture and humans.

There is no way the gulf is going to be cleaned up for a very long time and I am very sorry for the folks down there who hope to get back to their normal way of life in anything short of 25 years. Still, it is isolated to the gulf. Take a good look at how much of the nation is impacted by "fracking" and realize that their free from prosecution. Also remember that Halliburton is the same company that was using substandard cement at the gulf site just hours before the disaster began. BP will be punished, but Halliburton continues to get away with murder. They sent faulty helmets to OUR TROOPS!

Don't let any of those responsible off the hook for the gulf, but Halliburton is responsible for destroying this country from multiple fronts.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#22

So where is John Wayne when we need him?!

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Yeah, yeah, I know--passed on to that great western or hero movie in the sky. But what was that movie about oilmen who cap dangerous, fire-breathing oil geysers and put out the fires and contain the oil? I know that was on land (and a movie), but we need some heroes like John Wayne and Jim Hutton (can't seem to picture John Wayne in a wetsuit or a little submarine) to go down there and cap that sucker!

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#23

Hell Fighters . . .

steve mackay

The Red Addair (sp?) Company. Now THERE was a scary dude.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#24

HBO the font of balanced information?

Bill Tindall

The purpose of HBO is to present stories that will make one so upset they call their mother. I would suggest broadening ones information quest before writing the congressman to ban tight gas formation development.

There are vast methane deposits that are located in rock too impermeable to enable useful production rates. New technology enables this rock to be hydraulically fractured and the resulting cracks propped open with something porous, with walnut shell being a preferred material. Gas flows into these cracks where it can be collected. An exploration well is to be dug soon in development acreage that includes property I own.

The potential benefit is an abundance of methane that could be used to heat my home cheaper and cleaner than coal generated electricity that I currently use. The risk is contamination of water. I am not interested in eliminating my need for energy. It remains to be seen if the process can be done where the reward is greater than the risk. Coal miners are already dieing so that I can have electricity, so the current situation is not benign.

I am satisfied that sufficient precautions are being made with this exploration so the risk to me is less that my perceived benefit. I could change my mine based on data that comes to pass as this process is tested further. If you live in CA you don't have a horse in this race, so stay out of it. The acreage in consideration doesn't involve most states. For those whose property is directly affected, it will be well to keep informed so that informed decisions can be made.

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

#25

Re: Question for those smarter than I.

FredD

I wasn't commenting on your post Craig , though it seemed fair and balanced to me ;-))

My post just happened to be stuck below yours which I guess is a predetermined rotation.

I did take time to look at your Wood Blog and you definitely have a Mechanical bent to your thinking which is a good thing.

Aesthetics aside , I do prefer hollow grind to any other for a couple of good reasons , but that is just me.

FredD