regarding 'off topics'
Chris Hays
There are WAY too many 'off topics' posted here!!!Is this a woodworking forum???
Mr. MODERATOR where are you???
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
regarding 'off topics'
Chris Hays
There are WAY too many 'off topics' posted here!!!Is this a woodworking forum???
Mr. MODERATOR where are you???
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla
Friends ask friends for info and advice. I consider the people on WoodCentral to be my friends. I will offer help and advice if I can and ask if needed.
If there is something posted I am either not interested in or can't help I just go to another posting and read that.
I have read a lot of information I didn't know before here on this forum and hopefully have contributed some.
Read Ellis's greeting on the Home Page and it seems to suggest anything decent can and should be discussed here.
Still the best website I frequent every day. My $0.02.
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Larry in NW Ohio
Chris If you go through the posts and give a good look at them, we wouldn`t have much to read if it wasn`t for the OT posts. I like to read them. I have learned a lot from the OT posts. Where else can you go to find out how to fix a washer, or find out where to go to fix that washer. Or if you are going somewhere, what you can go see from someone that was there. I personally like it. Larry
Answer: Not Exactly
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Wood Central is a community of people, connected via Internet, who happen to share a common interest, that being woodworking in its various forms. It is definitely NOT "rec.crafts.woodworking" so if you're seeking a site with endless repetitions of "what saw to buy", you've not found it here on Wood Central's boards. WC moderators are not some amorphous group of Nazi SS whose job it is to keep the Board pure and free of extraneous subjects brought up between friends who are willing to help others with their knowledge and experience.
You should also note that most everybody uses the preface of "OT" when they're posting non-wood questions or messages. You may simply skip those.
Of course, there is no computer virus yet disclosed that forces peoples' computer to connect to this site and then drags them through the extraneous messages.
I'm with Larry on this subject.
Marv
Thank God ! . . .
steve mackay
I can no longer count the times I've been in deep doo-doo on a project, RAN to WC and had my bacon pulled out of the fire by the unlimited knowledge represented here. AND the willingness to share it. The next ime water is GUSHING from the wall OR I'm trying to atatch crown molding to thin air I know I can get saved. " God Bless All Here ! "
A contrary view of the situation
Bill Tindall
Over time I have gotten to know and appreciate the depth and breadth of knowledge lurking on this forum. And over time people have gotten to know me, I hope appreciating the fact that I attempt to share useful woodworking knowledge when I can.
Now, suppose I have a painting question. I know there are professional painters on this forum. Perhaps I have helped one of them with a wood question. If I pose a question about paint I likely will get an authoritative answer from someone I know and trust.
Alternatively I could go to the "painters Forum" presuming there is one. I have asked questions on forums where I was a stranger and the results are not often useful.
Bottom line: I am willing to trade my time and knowledge for that of others. If Forum Rules prevented me from getting help from my friends with a plumbing question then my enthusiasm for participation is diminished.
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Claudia Hayward
As a regular reader and occasional poster I learn a lot from the OT posts. Since woodworkers are diy-ers by nature, a lot of the OT stuff fits really well - even though it's not directly related to woodworking. There's a lot of the woodworking stuff that I pass by because I'm not interested in that particular topic. No different than passing by OT posts if you don't want to read them.
I'll second the motion, Mark.
doug f, san clemente, ca
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Doug Ridley
About OT posts-- I'm fer 'em
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI
Chris,
I am sorry that you feel this way.It has been suggested several times to create an Off Topic Board.
Every time the majority of folks chime in to please keep it right where it is on the main message board.
Woodworking is the common thread that brings us all here to WoodCentral.The off topic posts give us insight into our friends that we would not see otherwise.Think of it as one of the threads that we weave into the blanket that makes WoodCentral a community,not just a forum for woodworking.I like to think of it as a virtual coffee table where we all can sit around and discuss what is on our minds...not always woodworking.
And if Ellis and the other moderators spent the days and nights weeding out posts this wouldn't be a very friendly place and I am sure they have plenty of other pressing issues each and every day.
I,too have learned several things from reading the off topic posts,you never know when a random bit of information is going to become useful.I am hoping that when I get to the answer in Final Jeopardy,with a boatload of cash that the topic has been discussed here so I have a shot at phrasing the proper question.
Andy
This is a family ...
Mike Farinella
and a fellowship with an incredible knowledge base. Any and all are welcome at my house anytime. 
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Larry in NW Ohio
Chris Now we do not want you to feel unwecolme, you are more than wecome to your opinion. WC . I don`t know how long you have been coming here, but this is the way WC has been since the begining. We do hope you want to stay, but this is the way we are. Larry
Not your mother's "wreck"
Rod Peterson�Ormond Beach, FL
> It is definitely NOT "rec.crafts.woodworking"…
Sadly, even "the wreck" eventually was overwhelmed with OT posts (mostly political and not even my politics). Although I had posted there since '96 or thereabouts, I finally gave up last fall when I moved to full time Linux use. Yes, I could easily employ a Linux based newsreader (there's probably one native to Ubuntu and already installed), but it got so tiresome the last several months I was there I decided it wasn't worth the few nuggets that occasionally appeared.
The big difference between the wreck and WC? Politics—more precisely the lack thereof. All one has to do is spend some time on a filter free medium like usenet or FaceBook to find what horrifyingly disturbing views some otherwise pleasant people can hold. Religion, of course would be another one. However, my comparison was to the wreck, and there wasn't much religion ever injected into discussions there.
Keep those two topics out of special interest fora, and your chances of civil discourse are elevated by an order of magnitude. Most others, as has been noted, have an element of interest to many, despite occasionally not being germane.
Rod
P.S. Isn't it just rec.woodworking—no "crafts"?
The responses are much too kind
Clint Searl
Vitamins *LINK*
Tom Dunlap
Many years ago I was listening to fund raising week on a favorite community radio station in the Twin Cities. The host shared a comment made by a friend. It was said that KFAI played 'Vitamin Music'. Since we need lots of varying doses of vitamins to stay healthy it was important to have KFAI bring lots of music in varying doses to our musical diet.
For me, WC provides woodworking doses in large amounts. The OT topics are the trace elements. I feel fortunate to have the knowledge source here for my woodworking questions. My knowledge of how trees grown, die and can be harvested is useful as an OT occasionally. A very minor trace element.
A friend of mine and I host a forum for arborists. We have the 'Tree Free Zone' setup, along with lots of other forums, to keep a different order. I like the social feel that I encounter at WC. This is my go-to forum for woodworking info. What I can't find here I then head to Google for help. It's rare that I ever need to use Google. Along the way, I've learned sooooo much from OT posts. I know that my vitamin intake is in balance!
Keep the OT in WC!
TreeBuzz
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Barry Irby
I too like the OT posts. I am reasonably sure I am at least as guilty of making OT posts as anybody here. (I think Ellis gave me an award for the most OT post ever.)
I read a lot of them and learn something from many. I like it when people help me and the "cost" is that I try to help others. I assist with an answer if I can.
Another thing, I have never seen a description of what the exact topic is here. Wood Central is pretty broad. Are we discussing furniture only? What about kitchen cabinets? Installing Hardwood flooring? For building a residential door? Or a deck or a Deck Railing? A fence? Or the whole house? Or how about incorporating something other than wood in your project?
Welcome to Wood Central. Join us and enjoy. Read what you would like and ignore the rest. Take what you need and share what you know.
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Justin Szeliga
Shouldn't this post have had an OT at the beginning? I'm just askin'......
You've A Stonger Stomach Than I
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
I dipped in there from time-to-time about 9-10 years ago and took it off my list very quickly. The flame-wars were rampant even back then. Like CB radio, give someone their anonymity and the bucket-mouthed racists come out of the woodwork, but call it free speech.
ps I seem to remember it having "crafts" in the URL, but I could be mistaken.
Everyone's mileage varies, every forum's different *LINK*
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I visit about four woodworking related fora - here, WoodNet, Sawmill Creek, and Old Woodworking Machinery (OWWM). WoodNet and Sawmill Creek rarely go off topic, at least on the messageboards I read (I just realized, in preparing this answer, that both these places have off-topic boards - but I never visit them, so didn't even know). OWWM kind of stays on topic, but there's a lot of puns and low - not crude, just low - humor in response to serious topics.
I like the sittin' around tellin' stories element to the off topic posts here. I've gotten a lot of help, and been able to give a little. If there were an off-topic board, I doubt I'd ever visit it for lack of time. I skip over the topics that don't look interesting; there's no Ouija board spirit* controlling my fingers.
When my dad died in 2004, the support I got here was of tremendous help. I'd hate to have felt I had to post that message over in a separate place, away from the center of discussion. I consider WC my home forum, a lot because the digressions and humor feel like my dining room table at holidays, but with way more woodworking content.
Final comment (at least at the moment...): a few of the responses here have attacked Chris for his post, subtly and not so subtly. It's clear some folks feel insulted by his suggestion, but let's be better than that.
If you'd like to, stick around, Chris. Ignore the OT posts; enjoy the ones related to what you like; offer up pics or discussions of your work, questions about what you're struggling with in the shop, and contributions to threads. If the OT posts are driving you around the bend, visit other fora where off-topic stuff doesn't appear on the same boards as subject-specific stuff; not every shoe fits every foot. Whatever you decide, make sawdust or shavings and have fun in the shop.
*I keep bumping up against the realization that what I think are normal cultural references are either a demonstration that I'm old and out of it or U.S.-specific. If you were asking yourself what the heck a Ouija board spirit is, see the link.
http://www.museumoftalkingboards.com/WebOuija.html
Re: regarding 'off topics'
FredD
Ken has said it well Chris ,
I mean where else could you see a Chicken house with artwork that changes with the seasons,(that reminds me I have to put up Spring) or what Monroe the peacock is up to ? ;-))
FredD
Re: Subtlety and Not
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Bill, your points are well taken.
However, Mr. Hayes, after posting a single question under the screen name of "fixitgood" below, purported to invoke The Moderators (you included) to clean up what he obviously sees as a forum he doesn't care for.
How long he has lurked here, I cannot tell, but the concept is pretty simple. "If you don't like what you see, that's okay. Just go some place else."
There are many folks on this board who are dedicated not just to the craft, but also to improving their personal skills in an atmosphere of acceptance and support through relationships formed on a number of levels. Mr. Hayes' question on end table finishes bespoke a search for short cuts compounded by a lack of interest in gaining real understanding. With that attitude, Wood Central isn't the best place to pose "how to" questions; there is far too much expertise on this board for short attention span inquiries.
Now, if Mr. Hayes is in a learning mood, and is willing to take the time required to take advantage of the time that others here put in to properly answering a particular "woodworking" question, I'm sure he'll get a much different response.
Re: regarding 'off topics'
Gary Smyth
For my first year at WC I didn�t get it. Too often I posted without doing research beforehand. Occasionally I went �outside the lines� of woodworking and never was I rebuked for doing so. The people here were very accommodating of a rookie on the site. Over time my �enthusiasm� for participation checked itself. I began to respect the site and I make effort to keep my questions related to woodworking, building, repair, construction, asking for sources, and the like. I think that most people here do the same.
That being said, I do notice a lot more OT posts lately. Many of them are not what I feel are woodworking related. My personal feeling is that this site is not the office water cooler. Posting to post is not, in my opinion, a good thing. Now after all of that, I must say that of the OT posts I learn much. Through the OT�s I�ve seen some remarkable things that someone thought was interesting or important. I hope that participants continue to tell us stuff and also to exercise control. And as for me, if I do have a question, wood related or not, if I feel as if I�m in a bind I would not hesitate to ask for an opinion at this site. Someone posted earlier that they trust the responses on WC. I do too. I would much rather read a response answer here than most any other site on the web. The people participating are patient, knowledgeable, willing to walk you through a problem and never rude. Bottom line, I�m for the OT�s, they add a little spice and I do not believe any abuse is near.
This is my "general store front porch"
Joe Pack
I can get any woodworking question answered here. I can shoot the breeze about nothing. I can get a good laugh, and I can get a shoulder to cry on if I need it. I never need fear being flamed or made to look foolish, even if my question is basic or even dumb. I come here for information, but, most of all, for friendship. With that in mind, the "Off Topic" posts are part of what I come here for. I read some, skip some and even post some. But they are part of what makes WoodCentral different than Sawmill Creek, rec.wood, etc. I read those too, but come to WoodCentral several times a day to check in on friends I will probably never meet in person, but who are friends just the same. The OT posts have helped make those friendships, probably more so than the technically oriented posts. I can get technical information in a dozen places, but get a chance to make friends in very few. WoodCentral is one of those places, and I enjoy it just like it is...OT and all.
Stick around. WoodCentral may grow on you.
Re: This is my "general store front porch"
Howard Norman
I agree completely Joe. I come to WC several times a day. In the past year I have done very little woodworking but I still come to WC. I have met in person probable no more than a half dozen people from here but there are many more that I feel like I know.
howard