Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

regarding 'off topics'

Posts

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#26

Re: regarding 'off topics'

Jim Dillon

Chris,

Add me to the list of those who appreciate, and learn from, the many thoughtful OT posts. Just last week I was in the market for a new lawn mower and remembered that a past OT thread contained some useful information regarding that subject. I used the search function and found that thread and it proved helpful to me in my quest. Speaking for myself, I have learned as much from the OT topics as I have from the woodworking related posts. If an OT (or woodworking, for that matter) post doesn't interest me, I just pass over it. I hope Ellis continues to allow OT posts intermixed with woodworking related posts as it makes for a more interesting and enriching "community" experience. My 2 cents.

Jim

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#27

Re: regarding 'off topics'

Roy C. Gryder

Kwitcherbellyackin, Chris

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#28

Re: Not your mother's "wreck"

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Hi Rod,

I hope things are well down in Sunny Florida! I read your post and actually snorted out loud, I love line "to find what horrifyingly disturbing views some otherwise pleasant people can hold" :) Something about that turn of a phrase is funny to me. It's unfortunately very true, but a great phrase.

Take care,

Mike

Spending time with the lathe and the tablesaw in Apex, NC!

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#29

Re: regarding 'off topics'

Jeff in Gilroy

The large amount of off topics post started here when WC basically took over a former WW forum where OT posts were basically the norm.

I had posted a similar message (I suggested a separate OT forum for these posts) but that was shot down.

All the OT posts, while flagged as such, still makes it difficult to browse for WW stuff; WC kind of resembles a Facebook for WW's.

I actually use to browse WC everyday before the "merger" but now only come here every once in a while.

I don't want to eliminate the OT posts, I just want a better way to filter them out, automatically, if I am not currently interested in them.

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#30

Re: regarding 'off topics'

John in NM

Man, that was about a decade ago! I started frequenting this forum in 2002 and it'd already merged with BP. Time flies :D

I prefer having the OT posts in the regular messages forum rather than having the huge division into many sub-forums that some sites choose to do. Subforums are fine up to a point, but one site I'm on must have 30+, some rarely active. Keeping it all organized - moving posts to the proper subforum - must keep the mods very busy.

There's no rule that you have to read all the posts, and its easy enough to skip over what you don't want to read. I mind vague subject lines much more than OT posts.

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#31

Importance of titles to efficient communication

Bill Tindall

There are not but a few new posts each day. In most cases they are informatively titled. I have been an advocate of informative titling of posts for some time. It makes browsing the new listings quick and efficient and would seem to address your objection. If someone posted "a simple way to mortise hinges" and you were needing to mortise hinges, the posting would be easy to find, or ignore, if you had no interest in hinges.

I don't/won't "OT" a title. It seems silly if the title describes what the posting involves. No doubt the habit comes from fads in internet communication style which have done little to improve communication. A title "favorite restaurants near Yellowstone" should be apparent to all that the post involves restaurants and not hinges.

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#32

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Why the "OT"

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

"OT" is easier to filter while scanning than "restaurants near Yellowstone".

In my case, though, I love the diversity of interests, abilities and experiences here so much so that I am actually drawn to the OT posts.

Jason

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#33

Ellis Walentine

It just isn't that difficult...

Ellis Walentine

... to not click something that says "OT" in front. If what you're really complaining about is that there aren't enough woodworking threads to suit you, that's another matter. Even there, I submit that with 413,868 messages recorded on this forum alone in the last 11 years, there are darn few woodworking topics that we haven't touched on, and I do believe that the collective knowledge shared -- on woodworking and everything else -- is right up there with the best of the rest. We've got doctors, lawyers, scientists, artists and just about every other kind of professional here, united by our love of woodworking.

Our lives are not about woodworking all the time. The way I see it, woodworking is just the common denominator that binds a truly amazing and diverse bunch of people, young and old, of every political and religious persuasion and woodworking interest. Who better to discuss outside interests with than people who speak the same language, at least some of the time. The reason a lot of people come here is to broaden their perspectives in a friendly, intelligent, non-threatening environment, where everyone respects the others' interests and where that respect is enforced.

Many years ago, I noted -- I suspect correctly -- my observation that there is something unique in a woodworker's personality that enables him or her to descend into a basement or garage full of tools and materials for hours or days at a time, and to take real pleasure in the sounds and smells and tactual rewards -- not to mention the practical and spiritual rewards -- of this craft that we all share in common. It stands to reason that discussion on off-topic posts here would resonate with other folks who share this common affinity.

One more thing: Woodworking is not an end in itself, but a means to a larger end -- in the largest sense, design -- and we are not one-dimensional in the pursuit of that end. Whether we're designing and making functional objects or purely artistic things, we're using our problem-solving skills to start with a bunch of materials and problems and skills and design parameters, in the interest of ending up with a finished product. We take pleasure in the process as well as the result. That mentality can just as easily be applied to any number of loosely related problems such as you often see in the OT posts around here. By the psychological mechanism of generalization, we learn to apply seemingly off-topic knowledge -- engineering constructs, materials information, specialized techniques, processes -- to related areas as well. To me, as to the majority of our visitors, this kind of conversation isn't at all irrelevant. Even the posts of jokes and music and off-topic images of volcanoes and who-knows-what-else are posted by like-minded people who take inspiration and relaxation from these things.

You're welcome to visit and participate when it amuses you, or vote with your feet when it doesn't. The door will always be open.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#34

Re: It just isn't that difficult...

Howard Norman

Well said Ellis.

howard

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#35

'Nuff Said

Tom Rex in TX

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#36

Re: 'Nuff Said

FredD

One more Tom, if you will,

many patrons of WC have a career entirely unconnected to Wood Working and I find that many of those are very interesting to hear about and it doesn't interfere in the slightest to see them amongst the arguments we see from time to time about one way or tool that is better then any other.

Tips are a very productive slant on projects and the more the merrier.

FredD

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#37

Ellis Walentine

On another note ...

Ellis Walentine

... and squeaky wheels getting the grease and all, I will suggest to our developer that it might be nice to have an "Is Off-Topic" checkbox at the end of each post form, and a software hack that lets people set their preferences to *not* display such posts to registered users who don't want to see them. Thinking out loud here.

I might have to have a bake sale to pay for the coding, but it's worth asking the developer, just in case it's something pretty easy. My hunch is no.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#38

Re: On another note ...

Jeff in Gilroy

That would be ideal. There are times I don't mind "hanging out" and there are times I want to get down to business and see what is happening in just the WW arena.

I'm all about choice here.

P.S. My WC cap is proudly still hanging in my shop after all these years and is my "goto" cap when I need to work outside.

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#39

Jeff Mackay

Re: regarding 'off topics'

Jeff Mackay

Actually a "facebook for woodworkers" sounds like a great idea. It would involve some development, but a "what am I working on now" box might work really well, Ellis. And may eventually--if it's handled right--lead to additional traffic. And the domain name "woodworkbook.com" is available!

Think about it. To see the list of projects someone has completed, just look at their profiles. To ask a question about the design, just post a picture, an image of a drawing, etc with the question as a comment.

I think it's worth pursuing, what does everybody else think....?

Jeff

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#40

off topics's  off topics

del schisler

i find that OT ar more interesting than most post ?? been work working for probly 5o yrs but don't know everthing oh well onward

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#41

Very well said.

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#42

Facebook

Tom Rex in TX

A "poll" was taken sometime back about facebook. :D

Most of us agreed that we want nothing to do with facebook. >(

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#43

Re: Facebook

Marv

I keep in touch with my kids and grandkids on facebook. There's even a real time chat window where we can chat back and forth. I like it.

Marv

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#44

Re: Facebook

Bill Howatt

Turning club I belong to has implemented a Facebook page. I have never been on it and have no intention of doing so anytime soon. I realize things change but what I do now is more than adequate to burn up a lot of time on the part of my anatomy that needs more exercise.

Bill

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#45

Re: regarding 'off topics'

Theresa K

Simple, don't read the msgs with the subject line OT. It's really not too taxing to click or not click, as you choose.

I can't count the number of times I've read useful OT msgs, BUT

I CLICKED on the OT. Trust me, if there was an OT with 'hunting' in the line, I'd be skipping over that with the greatest of ease.

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#46

OT

Marv

OT could mean "On Topic" :D

Re: regarding 'off topics'

#47

Re: regarding 'off topics'

Bill Howatt

IMO, you have touched on what the primary issue really is. It isn't to OT or not to OT but writing subject lines that accurately describe what your post is about.

This applies to all posts, not just ones that might be considered OT.

Nothing more useless than a new post with the subject line saying things like:

A Question, Will this work, What would you do, Help, Oops, etc.

Bill