Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

I hurt myself and I want some money

Posts

I hurt myself and I want some money

#1

I hurt myself and I want some money

FredD

I am really glad sometimes, that I have nearly lived my life out without major damage which I attribute to being alert.

I am sorry that the guy mutilated his fingers, but I am even more sorry that he got rewarded for it.

http://www.finewoodworking.com/item/25130/man-wins-big-money-in-tablesaw-lawsuit

FredD

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#2

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

Brent Smith in Montreal

Well, at least it's good to know that Gass feels good about it.

"There was a lot of personal satisfaction when the verdict came out."

This ranks right up there with the lawsuit over spilling hot coffee in the lap while driving!!

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#3

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

"Flesh detection technology"? I think when I was in college I once dated a girl equipped with "flesh detection technology". ;-)

T.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#4

JL

LOL - I encountered that in high school...

JL

or was that "hand detection technology"??

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#5

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

Larry in NW Ohio

The problem is no one is responsible for their own stupidity. Also untill the juries stop giving out all that money, or whoever it is, this is just going to keep going. If the lawyers see that they may not win they will not take such a lawsuit. Larry

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#6

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

Wayne Carson

Problem is he will still hurt himself on something else. Maybe a hitting his finger with a hammer because it doesn't have a guard on it sort of like the coffee. And people wonder why things cost so much!!

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#7

So who made the decision

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Who forced him to buy that particular brand of saw that was not equipped with "flesh detecting technology". Did he also buy a cheap car without ABS or Air bags? Seems to me he made a choice and then had to pay for his error. He chose to buy a saw without the latest technology and that never implied that it was capable of protecting him. >(

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#8

Re: LOL - I encountered that in high school...

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

Hey guys, I doubt if that is what is meant here. (But it was fun!!!!)

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#9

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

I am appalled at this also. I saw nothing about an appeal at FW. I certainly hope there is one.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#10

Couple of other questions no one has asked..

John Cotten

1. Was the man trained on saftey techniques and how to properly use a table saw. Was he ripping with a fence or free cutting, was he cross cutting, WAS HE USING A PUSH STICK? How did he manage to cut his had so severly.

(For those who are wondering what free cutting is, it is ripping without using the fence, which in trim carpentry and flooring work is sometimes required to cut long angles, irregular angles or curving or 's' shaped cuts when scribing to a wall or floor.)

2. The thought of it becoming manditory to have a saw stop like devise on my saws scares me. I have 4 tablesaws, one site saw, two in my cabinet shop, plus a sliding panel saw for most of my casework. Only one of my saws potentially could be retrofitted with a sawstop if required. The others would have to be replaced. The panel saw has two blades, a scoring blade and a primary saw blade. We are talking in 30K+ to replace all four of my saws. Where am I to come up with that capital?

3. If we really wanted to make a tool that needs a saw stop, my table saw would not be my first choice, but my miter saws would all have one.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#11

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Y'all want to cut the seat belts out of your cars and disable the airbags as well. After all, you should have been more observant and careful in your driving so that you could have avoided the other deadbrain. 2-car crashes that are completely the fault of one driver are about as common as hen's teeth. Oh, and since your injuries were your fault too, don't be looking to sue for damages. That's going to make my car insurance go way down, thank you.

But let's not stop there,

Remove all the GFCI wiring from your houses and all the other safety features built into the rest of the stuff you take for granted every day and will scream "bloody murder" if they don't work to protect you from your own carelessness (notice I didn't say "stupidity") or that of your spouse or coworker. You don't think all those safety features and things magically got there because of the kind hearts and social consciousness of the people who made the items, do you? Really? They got included because the maker figured out that it was cheaper to include them than it was to pay for the damages those products would cause without the safety add-ons.

Any idiot can walk into the "tool coral" and buy a power tool that has the capacity to kill or maim him horribly, take it home, and, without the least bit of training, proceed to make something, including his wife a widow. Yup. He's an idiot. His family's loss is all his fault. And now the rest of us can subsidize his family on welfare because, being an idiot, he had neither life insurance nor savings to provide for them in his absence.

The table saw manufacturers made a deliberate choice not to adopt the Saw Stop" device. There are hundreds of millions of dollars in medical costs and productivity days lost in this country due to table saw injuries every year. We, as a society, can chose to absorb those losses, conveniently blaming them on the injured people, or we can take advantage of readily available preventative means, and perhaps improve the quality of life for all of us.

There's a reason that most schools have replaced their shop saws with Saw Stop units. If I had a kid hurt because he didn't know enough and wasn't properly supervised in the school shop, you can bet there'd be hell to pay if they could have prevented my kid going through life with half his fingers. I send my kid to school, I expect him or her to be protected from harm.

So what if a couple of babies get killed by those drop-side cribs. They were good enough for my kids who survived just fine. Those parents must have been stupid of something.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#12

Steven Antonucci

Reading between the lines

Steven Antonucci

If I were the SawStop guys, I'd be personally looking at every one of these cases and helping the plaintiffs. If you can't convince the companies making the equipment to improve their products to improve safety, maybe you can make it painful via litigation for negligence.

I'd bet that the SawStop folks make a pretty darn good expert witness on the stand.

Steve

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#13

Negligence

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

The classic definition is it is that omission to do something which a reasonable man, guided by those ordinary considerations which guide and regulate human affairs, would do, or the doing of something which a reasonable and prudent man would not do, in either circumstance posing and unreasonable risk of injury to others and which risk could be prevented by choosing the opposite course of action.

My father made his living representing injured people. I was groomed to follow him, but soon found out that "P.I" law was not for me. I discovered a good half of the clients were either faking or grossly exaggerating their injuries and alleged damages, and most of them had wildly inflated expectations of money recoveries commensurate with lotto winnings. Not something I wanted anything to do with.

I followed the early stages of the Saw Stop invention and marketing and spoke to several people about it. Turns out that most all saw-makers (US or Asian clones) could not use it unless they completely re-engineered their machines. Neither the true European riving knife nor the Saw Stop could be adapted to the saw elevators and trunnions, so they turned their backs on them.

They've managed to squeeze another 12 years out of 70-year old technology, but I suspect their days are numbered.

Sooner or later, things will change.

The Saw-Stop guys might make good simplistic witnesses to the effect of "with my thingy you'd have all your fingers and it only costs $150 more." But that doesn't account for the millions in the costs of re-engineering, redesign, and retooling from the foundries all the way to that machine shops that will be required to use the device effectively on all saws.

It will come, but it will take time. How much time will, in part, be determined by how much the delays will cost the tool makers.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#14

Dale Lenz

Bet your right!

Dale Lenz

Have an old Walker-Turner TS, it's been serving me well for 25+ years but I still lust for a new Powermatic, Unisaw or General. Thinking, I need to go ahead and get a new TS before I'm forced to buy a SawStop thingy with a new saw :\ .

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#15

Out of Left Field

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

John,

Don't expect the Federales to be pushing you, OSHA is very slow. Expect the push to come from your insurance company and/or workman's comp carrier who will be the first ones tagged when somebody gets hurt.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#16

Juries often award, but then it's overturned

ronster15

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#17

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Galen Vetterick

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#18

Re: I hurt myself and always try to hide it!

FredD

Since the article mentioned something like fifty similar cases pending, how far away can a class action be, bandwagon time folks, I will see it advertised on the telly .

"if you or a loved one was dumb enough to stick your hand in a machine, saw, router , shaper, disposal etc. call us , we have operators standing by"

There's a lot of breast beating about how we need Tort reform, don't hold your breath.

FredD

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#19

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

I bet this same guy who sued Ryobi doesn't wear a seat belt and doesn't have smoke detectors in his house either because "Nobody has the right to tell me what to do".

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#20

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

George Koch

I wonder how/when they will require the sawstop technology be applied to the meat slicing machines at your local markets. Too much! George

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#21

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

John Lucas

Fred They were redoing an office in our building last year and the workers (foreign guys) were using the table saw without a fence. I'll bet if he gets hurt he will sue for big money unless he's illegal. I had to turn my eyes and leave, it scared me.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#22

The trouble is...

John in NM

There are still a few people in the world who figure if you want to be safe all your life, you shouldn't do dangerous things. This is the flip side of the prudent man argument that the legal profession doesn't ever recognize, and that leads the rest of us to argue with lawyers :D. There are some safety innovations that are largely beneficial, like seat belts and perhaps fences around swimming pools. There are others - like outlets with little covers (not required yet as far as I know, but a proposed change), codes for railings, and lead free bullets - that are just plain stupid.

What I believe Fred is trying to say is that there are a lot of prudent men (and women) using table saws all their lives, not injuring themselves, and not apparently involved in figuring the value of fingers. It is quite understandable that such prudent people rebel at the thought of some idiot mis-using a product and then getting paid a lot because the company was negligent in providing safety features. I think a lot of us old and young grouches would be satisfied if the negligence awards did not go to the guy who cut his finger off, as in most cases that would keep the lawsuits from happening.

Of course I have no illusions about convincing you that there is any merit to this argument :D, so there is no need to respond seriously. From a practical point of view, voicing opinions such as these is an activity whose real value is limited to avoiding jury duty.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#23

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

AZ, Colorado Springs

It's only partially, "I hurt myself, ..." The other part is the glut of lawyers seeing (& seeking) opportunity in these kinds of cases, with contingency fees: "You got hurt, let me argue your case and get 1/3 of YOUR award." The lawyer suffers none of the pain of the injury, but takes a profit from it. To ensure some fairness for the injured party, and to assure himself of a good annual income, he's gotta argue for an enormous settlement each time.

Similarly, the saw manufacturer has to be represented by a lawyer. HIS lawyer produces (manufactures) nothing, but collects his fees out of the profits of the manufacturer.

If someone knowingly sells a defective or malfunctioning product (like pet food with melamine contamination, or the thread a few weeks back about computer operated cars which may not input the drivers' commands properly) that needs to be dealt with. In the case of a table saw purchase, especially for home/hobbyist use, you gotta be careful what you're getting YOURSELF into. In the case of tools on the jobsite, the employer ought to provide training, but the employee also bears responsibility. Of course, enter the lawyer to argue for re-arranging these relationships so as to pin ALL the responsibility on the guy with the deepest pockets.

I'm not trying to malign all lawyers, but when a product liability case goes to trial, the truth is left on a peg in the cloak room.

An anecdote on careful use of power tools: when I was in Saudi Arabia (in the USAF), we had to ensure that contractors complied with US safety standards. It was common to see electrical tools with no plug on the end of the cord; since there is no standardization of outlets there, the workmen would just shove the wires into the socket. Our projects incorporated the outlets common in the US, so we forced the workers to install three prong plugs. I was in a hotel in Cairo and saw a guy walking off an elevator with a big 1/2" drive D-handle drill, trailing a cord with bare wires. I knew how he was going to use that.

FWIW, Andy

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#24

My fear would be complacency

Craig Daymon

First, if I was spending SawStop amounts on a tablesaw, I would buy a sliding table.

But, sometimes wood has moisture (especially since I also turn) and I don't want to keep buying brakes and blades because the wood was wet (moist enough to conduct electricity and trigger the brake).

Most importantly, the brake does not protect me from kickback, but it might make me complacent. In the FWW thread linked to, there was someone who said he had a SawStop and does things with his saw that he would never do otherwise. Well, that's just STUPID!

These are power tools! They have sharp blades! They can be very dangerous! If I learn to use proper techniques and caution, I can be safe. I don't think this clown that won the lawsuit was being cautious or using proper techniques. I also think he was asking a little much from a saw that probably cost him less than $200.

Then again, my father severely damaged his left hand when his wedding ring caught the blade while he was trying to push a thin strip he was ripping against the fence. Of course, he should have been using a feather board and a push stick, but if it's worth a few million the damage is already done. (Then again, his saw is a Craftsman contractor's saw and is probably 40+ years old.)

What I'm saying in the last paragraph is simply as tragic as these things are, they happen. There has got to be some way to avoid these sort of inappropriate lawsuits, some way to give uninformed jurors information to make proper decisions in these cases. That said, I DON'T think awards should be limited in size. It is known already that Microsoft has a corporate policy to evaluate whether they can make more money by breaking the law, getting sued and paying a fine than doing things right the first time. When you can make billions and be sued and fined even 100 million, you've still made a heck of a profit. (Sort of seems like Toyota was taking on the same game plan.)

Done rambling.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#25

Re: I hurt myself and always try to hide it!

Pat Evans

If you saw the guy drill a hole in his hand, you're lucky he didn't sue you for not stopping him. :)