Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

I hurt myself and I want some money

Posts

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#26

A.J. Hamler

A factor no one has mentioned yet

A.J. Hamler

If I understand correctly, he hurt himself using a saw without flesh-detecting technology, i.e. a SawStop-like device. He sued, and won, blaming the company for not having installed a SawStop-like device.

Now, here's the thing: This accident occurred in 2006, at which time genuine SawStop saws were available, but he used -- and hurt himself on -- a Ryobi without the technology, and thus blames them. Since he apparently wanted a saw with that technology, why didn't he get a SawStop saw when they were available? And, having made the choice to get a saw without it when one with it was available, how is that Ryobi's fault?

A.J.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#27

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

FredD

John ,

from running construction jobs for years I have enough accidents done by others to their selves to fill a book, but None were rewarded for it and some got fired for it.

I watched a three year apprentice Carpenter demonstrate a quick way to change a Skilsaw blade , he had not done it before , just thought it up and wanted to impress the guy working with him.

His shortcut consisted of placing the new blade on the diamond arbor , start the bolt by hand and then placed the saw wrench on the bolt head and triggered the saw.

It tightened up the bolt in a flash and scraped all of the hide off of his knuckles on the saw base.

He got his check that night before he really ran up a Workman's Comp premium.

What I am saying is I believe you will never live long enough to educate people to the point where they won't hurt themselves or stop juries from awarding huge sums to people for acts of stupidity .

The system as it is presently constituted guarantees rewards for incompetence and rarely gives a pat on the back for responsible behavior in the work place or elsewhere.

FredD

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#28

Re: Negligence

Chris Friesen

True riving knives will be legally required on new saws soon, so all the major manufacturers now have them available.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#29

Steven Antonucci

I bet their lawyers did a great job with jury pool

Steven Antonucci

"Sir, do you know anything about power tools?" Yes, disqualified...

"Sir, do you believe in Darwin's Theory of Natural Selection?" Yes, disqualified...

"Sir, do you believe that stuipd people should be protected by legislation and awarded huge sums of money when they circumvent common sense?"...

I'm willing to bet there wasn't a single woodworker on that jury, or they'd still be debating it...

steve

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#30

The other side if this holds...

Craig Daymon

...is that I might be able to sue VW because my Jetta doesn't have accident avoidance or "night vision" capabilities like the higher end Mercedes. Or anyone else that hasn't spent $100,000 on their car. Boy, and the auto makers thought they had it tough before this!

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#31

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

Chuck Kettler

As I recall, MacDonalds won the hot coffee lawsuit on appeal and the plaintiff did not receive compensation. I hope this case will be appealed and the company steps up with some high power legal beagles.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#32

Good Morning, Mr. Justice Holmes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Craig, you've almost reached the famous jurist's outlook on things. While we, as a society, set a goal of having people live up to their agreements, the Law has developed somewhat differently. Dubbed The Bad-Boy Theory of Contracts, Holmes (Oliver Wendell, not Sherlock) reasoned as follows:

If it costs less to breach one's contract and pay damages to the other party rather than perform the contract, we encourage people to breach their contracts because it is economically more efficient to do so.

The reasoning doesn't translate to products liability, however, because the damages caused by defective products can far outweigh any possible profit the company might have made.

With all that said, posters in this thread know nothing about the real facts of the incident in question. The assumption is rampant here that the plaintiff was stupid, careless, etc., in operating the saw. When a trial's fact evidence is completed, juries are given detailed instructions on the applicable law by the judge based on precedents going back many years. If the trial lawyers for the two sides have done their jobs, the jury has an accurate picture of the facts, and will usually reach a good conclusion. If, however, Ryobi's attorney did a poor job, the jury would get a one-sided view of things, but must work with what they've been given. You can bet that both sides put seriously qualified expert witnesses on the stand, so the view that "a woodworker testifying" would have changed the outcome is most likely a bit silly.

BTW, last time I checked, the Saw Stops all had Euro-style riving knives that prevent kickback. Quite different from the POS spltters on US machines. Ask a European woodworker about kickback and you're likely to get a blank look as their saws don't have the problem because of their riving knife's design.

Peace

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#33

The reason for the assumption

John in NM

"The assumption is rampant here that the plaintiff was stupid, careless, etc., in operating the saw"

This assumption is typically made from experience, both in the operation of table saws that have often had the guards removed, and in the witnessing of accidents and discussions with people who've had accidents. I've personally witnessed two and had one (just with a biscuit joiner fortunately). The assumption of carelessness is usually accurate in this experience - though certainly not polite to point out publicly.

Another poster pointed out that anyone with any table saw experience would be immediately ruled out as a juror - because experience would probably lead them to conclude that operating a table saw is inherently dangerous and that it is in the operator's interest to take precautions. Such a juror would also probably know that there are methods of use, aftermarket products, and freely available plans for fixtures that reduce the risk and thus often used by careful saw operators. Yes it is the defense lawyer's job to make these points - but it seems to me that juries are incapable of understanding them.

There is something fundamentally wrong with a legal system that awards huge damages to a plaintiff when it also dis-allows jurors who have any practical experience with the subject at hand. The typical argument is that they are not impartial, but in so limiting the jury pool, one is stacking the deck in favor of stupidity. Does the legal system really benefit from jurors with no practical experience? Human beings are NEVER impartial, and one might as well flip a coin as expect a rational decision from a group of jurors who are selected based on their ignorance rather than their experience - they are not impartial either, just ignorant. I would much rather be judged by experienced individuals, as I could reasonably expect a fair judgment from them, and could be satisfied either way it went.

Few if any of the posters in this thread know the particulars of this case, myself included. It is very likely that the accident could have been prevented by Ryobi's adopting sawstop's braking technology. But it is also very likely that the accident could have been prevented by the saw operator paying attention to what he was about. Why should the operator be rewarded for his faults when the manufacturer is penalized?

Why does the injured individual always seem to be immune from negligence?

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#34

Re: The reason for the assumption

FredD

Well stated and my thinking exactly

Plus what if the Plaintiff had be drinking or doing drugs , or day dreaming, where is the evidence , you think he would volunteer such information.

As for Juries being selectively chosen on any number of reasons , is never called what it really is, Jury Tampering.

Companies that specialize in getting you a slam dunk Jury for which ever side , I think are guilty of doing something a individual would be charged for , Jury Tampering, can't say it enough and it is only available to those who can afford it , discrimination by any other name ........

FredD

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#35

Re: The assumption

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

" . . . anyone with any table saw experience would be immediately ruled out as a juror . . ."

Another assumption with no support. Were I the plaintiff's trial lawyer, I'd have tried to pack the jury with woodworkers, hopefully with a couple of "2-finger Jakes" as they would have the pain of their injury and loss burned in their brains and subconsciously, if not overtly, welcome an improvement that would have protected them from their own stupidity or carelessness.

"A guard removed . ."? Now there's an opportunity for a law suit . . A safety "feature" that can be defeated by simply not putting it on to begin with. How's about a table saw that won't even run without the guard installed? What? Oh, won't do dado cuts? Too Bad, so sad, learn to use a router to make those cuts; not as fast, but far, far safer.

For those who like to grouse about our "legal system" of trials and juries, understand that less than 3 percent of civil cases filed ever go to trial in this country and something less than half of those are tried to a jury. The vast majority of claims are settled or otherwise disposed of long before anyone dips into the jury pool.

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#36

It is good to have a professional perspective

John in NM

I'm surprised you'd want woodworkers on the jury, but you are after all the professional here and have a better idea how to expect jurors to react. I would be surprised if those jurors would award a large damage settlement for the plaintiff, as most previously injured woodworkers I've talked to acknowledge their own responsibility for the accident. Perhaps I just expect too much consistency from people in general - quite likely given my previously stated cynicism regarding their ability to think impartially.

As to guards removed - I say that because I have not used a table saw with a guard since I was in high school. The half dozen or so small professional shops that I've either worked in or visited friends working in, none have factory guards on the saws. The two large factories I've visited of course had all the proper safety equipment, not being small enough to fly under OSHA's radar. This is just the unfortunate reality of most of the woodworking world. There is probably a higher percentage used in amateur shops as they are less concerned with speed, and the saws see so much less use that the guards don't get broken as quickly. I would also imagine there is a much lower level of complacency from most hobbyists. Say what you will, stupid, foolhardy, flat out wrong, but that's just the way it is in my experience. Of the two accidents I've witnessed, one had a guard installed (high school shop) and one did not.

I think we do realize that very few cases are settled by jury. Cases settled out of court don't seem to get much press, and don't seem to be discussed on this sort of forum. Could that be due to more reasonable dollar amounts when settled out of court?

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#38

Re: It is good to have a professional perspective

FredD

"I think we do realize that very few cases are settled by jury. Cases settled out of court don't seem to get much press, and don't seem to be discussed on this sort of forum. Could that be due to more reasonable dollar think we do realize that very few cases are settled by jury. Cases settled out of court don't seem to get much press, and don't seem to be discussed on this sort of forum. Could that be due to more reasonable dollar amounts when settled out of court?"

The lack of press or information surrounding the settlement of a lawsuit is more then likely because the settlement is sealed , not disclosed by either party during the process. Violation of that agreement carries predetermined penalties.

As you say it's nice to have Mark's professional opinion, on how to stack a jury in your client's favor.

My Professional opinion as a Carpenter, cabinet maker , contractor is simply this .

I would never find for the plaintiff in a case like this where he obviously (to me anyhow) tried and succeeded, to place the blame for his error on a company whose product is no different then all of the rest of the saw makers except one.

This is tantamount to saying only one saw maker has a safe product , all of the rest are deficient, therefore you shouldn't own one and if you do , you should immediately get rid of it and buy the one that a jury supposedly of the parties involved peers has declared to make yourself safe from yourself.

If the saw how somehow turned itself on and bit him or harmed him in any other way in which he had no control , then the saw maker is on the hook.

Requiring people to be responsible for their own actions and accepting the consequences thereof and not looking for someone else to blame, has somehow been lost in the ranting and raving and lying that goes on in a courtroom, classroom and sometimes in a workroom.

FredD

Re: I hurt myself and I want some money

#39

Steven Antonucci

Not really an assumption?

Steven Antonucci

Mark-

Anyone that has ever touched a tablesaw SHOULD know to keep their fingers away from the sharp spinning blade. Lacking that common sense, you should be smart enough to not own a tablesaw.

Perhaps the right thing for a manufacturer to do would be to include a DVD of instructional video in the proper use of the saw, with a small section on what happens when you do it wrong. If I made saws for a living, I would also include push sticks and plans for build a crosscut sleds in the box. I suspect that it could be done very cheaply, and would lower the cost of liability suits by avoiding some of them all together.

There are two kinds of personal negligence in this situation. The first kind is the "didn't know" kind, where some Joe Wannabe buys the saw with no knowledge because he's watched HGTV and DIY (some of those guys are scary!). He cuts off his fingers because he didn't know you could actually hurt yourself with the saw if you didn't know how to use it.

The second kind is "didn't care", and this is the guy who is told that something is dangerous, stupid, or potentially deadly but does it anyway. Not an awful lot can be done to protect these folks who freehand cut, rip without a pushstick, or operate it with a six-pack lunch in them. You could give them the DVD, and they'd make fun of it as being "beneath them".

If I were on a jury, I'd be more sympathetic to the first guy, but still less inclined to award them any money for their pain. Short of requiring people to take a safety class with their purchases and/or obtaining a license, I think that the only time I could award liability would be in a "failure situation" where the product completely failed to work as designed.

A tablesaw is designed to cut whatever touches the blade. As the owner of ten healthy fingers, it is your job to make sure that they never touch the blade. You can bet when the SawStop patent expires, we're see a lot more of these types of safety features...

S