Good Morning, Mr. Justice Holmes
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
Craig, you've almost reached the famous jurist's outlook on things. While we, as a society, set a goal of having people live up to their agreements, the Law has developed somewhat differently. Dubbed The Bad-Boy Theory of Contracts, Holmes (Oliver Wendell, not Sherlock) reasoned as follows:
If it costs less to breach one's contract and pay damages to the other party rather than perform the contract, we encourage people to breach their contracts because it is economically more efficient to do so.
The reasoning doesn't translate to products liability, however, because the damages caused by defective products can far outweigh any possible profit the company might have made.
With all that said, posters in this thread know nothing about the real facts of the incident in question. The assumption is rampant here that the plaintiff was stupid, careless, etc., in operating the saw. When a trial's fact evidence is completed, juries are given detailed instructions on the applicable law by the judge based on precedents going back many years. If the trial lawyers for the two sides have done their jobs, the jury has an accurate picture of the facts, and will usually reach a good conclusion. If, however, Ryobi's attorney did a poor job, the jury would get a one-sided view of things, but must work with what they've been given. You can bet that both sides put seriously qualified expert witnesses on the stand, so the view that "a woodworker testifying" would have changed the outcome is most likely a bit silly.
BTW, last time I checked, the Saw Stops all had Euro-style riving knives that prevent kickback. Quite different from the POS spltters on US machines. Ask a European woodworker about kickback and you're likely to get a blank look as their saws don't have the problem because of their riving knife's design.
Peace