Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Workmanship question.

Posts

Workmanship question.

#1

Workmanship question.

Virgil Johnson

>A question for all woodworkers.

What do you see when you look at your work?

When I look at the pictures of Thomas Stocktons desk below I see perfection and a level of workmanship that I cannot match. To me my work always looks crude no matter the effort I put into it.

Do you look at pieces of your work and see what are flaws to you and always think you could have done better?

Re: Workmanship question.

#2

Re: Workmanship question.

Bill Roland (Mt Juliet, TN)

>I always go by what SWMBO says. If she likes it then nothing else matters. I know that after almost 48 years of marriage. That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

Re: Workmanship question.

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Workmanship question.

Clint Searl

>It's impossible not to subjectively compare one's work with others', both in terms of workmanship and design. I can and do admire others' workmanship regardless of style or design, but I recognize my fabrication limits and have gotten over any envy about it. My attitude is that cutting the perfect dovetails is like being the baton twirling champion of the universe...it's still baton twirling.

Workmanship compliments design, but cannot overcome bad design.

Clint

Re: Workmanship question.

#4

I see a goal

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I know pretty much what I can do, but that has definitely improved over the years. It's good to have someone better to show me what can be done.

Re: Workmanship question.

#5

Re: Workmanship question.

Barry Irby

>I see my flaws. I set my own standards and don't sign my work until I think its good enough and I don't let it out of the shop until I am willing to sign it. The standard varies. If I am working n a deck, the standard is different than for a desk. Even after I sign something I still see the flaws no matter how minute they are. Sometimes I am surprised at how other people react and don't see or mention the flaws. My standards are higher than theirs, I hope. Perhaps they are too kind.

Re: Workmanship question.

#6

PS,

Barry Irby

>Another aspect to this is design skill. I have or can muster the workmanship to copy great designs. It's the design/inspiration department that really challenges me. Show me the plan and I can build it. Show me the blank design pallet and what you get won't be as good.

Trying to come up with a plan for a platform bed and two sets of night stands right now.

Re: Workmanship question.

#7

answers

Bill Tindall

>What do you see when you look at your work?..... Initially I see things I could have improved, either in design or execution. This is a problem of the amateur woodworker. We typically only build something once so there isn't an opportunity to refine the piece. But, this first impression soon fades as the piece is put to use and in no time the piece looks fine to me as well as others.

When I look at the pictures of Thomas Stocktons desk below I see perfection and a level of workmanship that I cannot match........... Baloney! It may be that you, and certainly I, can not come up with such innovative designs, but there is no reason we can not match the execution if we have the will to practice and take care in execution. What has changed in my woodworking over the years is improvements in fit and finish, motivated by seeing what others can do. This improvement has been the result of raising the standards for what I want to achieve and not be satisfied with less. Learning to use hand tools for precise fitting has resulted in the biggest improvement in my execution of pieces. Anyone that doesn't/can't use hand tools for fitting needs to take a class or acquire a mentor to acheive these skills.

Do you look at pieces of your work and see what are flaws to you and always think you could have done better? Certainly, and I will bet Tom does too.

Re: Workmanship question.

#8

Re: Workmanship question.

John McGaw

>I see every imperfection because I know that they are there and doing so is the way my personality works. Sometimes I learn from my mistakes but not always.

My late step-father did some of the crudest hack work you'd ever imagine. He didn't notice anything wrong -- that was the way his personality worked.

What you see depends on your outlook and unless you can change that or the quality of your work you will see it the same every time.

Re: Workmanship question.

#9

Re: Workmanship question.

Terry in Edmonton

>I am very aware of all the flaws in what I make and when I make a new piece I do my best to not repeat them. This leaves me with a new set flaws to consider the next time. Each piece therefore gets better and my skills improve with each set of flaws. When I see something that really impresses me I try to find all the flaws in it. No matter how good a craftsman is, their work can always be improved on. Hopefully this exercise will teach me to be a better woodworker even if I never reach the skill level of the masters.

Re: Workmanship question.

#10

Re: Workmanship question.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Virgil,

Don't "argue" for your limitations lest they become yours. Tom's desk and a host of other fine pieces posted on this board over the years are merely evidence of their makers' basic skills [which you can learn], and their dedication to improve through consistently pushing beyond their current comfort zone.

I've turned my woodworker's eye on some very high-end and expensive pieces of furniture in exclusive retail settings and been able to find errors with little difficulty. There ain't no such thing as perfect, and if it is your goal, you'll always be frustrated and disappointed. Tom used the word "intense" so you can bet that his making the desk carried a fairly high degree of stress. Most people don't want that kind of an experience in connection with a hobby or pastime. Is the final product worth it to Tom? I assume so because he posted it.

You can always pick out your mistakes in any one of your pieces; you already know they're there. Chances are Tom knows about a few "issues" with his desk just the same way. Being intimidated by others more skilled than you will only makes it more difficult for you to improve, and will decrease your enjoyment of what you're doing now.

Relax. Enjoy. Take classes. You'll get better at your own pace and have just as much fun.

Happy New Year!!

MM

Re: Workmanship question.

#11

Ellis Walentine

Complexity vs workmanship

Ellis Walentine

>I've seen some of your work, Virgil, and you definitely have the ability to do superior work. I'm wondering if you are daunted by the complexity, rather than the workmanship, of Tom's most recent piece. Workmanship aside, complexity makes the work more involved and more demanding, but it's all parts and pieces. Anything you don't already know how to do can be learned. With practice and repetition, we learn what *not* to do as well as the shortcuts and tricks that make the difficult seem easy.

How do you eat an elephant? One bite at a time. The journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.

Ellis

Re: Workmanship question.

#12

Where I'm coming from on this subject.

Virgil Johnson

>Perhaps I should explain that I'm not feeling sorry for myself but merely curious about how each person views their work and what they see when they look at an example of fine workmanship(workwomanship):-) If I did attempt to match that level of complexity I'm sure I would never think it as good even if it managed to be. Seems like a lot of us think alike in this regard. I guess its human nature..?

Bill explained it pretty well saying when you start using a piece you get over what you think are flaws. This has been the case for me. Woodworking is one of many hobbies for me at the moment and I critique myself pretty hard at all of them.

Re: Workmanship question.

#13

Yep! Same here!

Tony - Memphis

>Glad its not just me!

Tony

Re: Workmanship question.

#14

Re: Workmanship question.

Fred Davis

>"Do you look at pieces of your work and see what are flaws to you and always think you could have done better"

Absolutely.

Nearly any housewife I did a Kitchen for could spot a flaw across the room and not be bashful about telling you. ;-))

I venture to say most if not all woodworkers are thier own worst critic.

If you want another opinion , put your best stuff in a juried show and see how it goes.

FredD

Re: Workmanship question.

#15

Re: Workmanship question.

Fred Davis

>Concerning dovetails , I always reserved perfection to "packing your own Parachute and working on a Bomb squad"

Anything less is a bad happening"

I think poor design is a lot like Art , it is in the "eye of the beholder".

On the other hand a good design badly executed is terrible.

FredD

Re: Workmanship question.

#16

Clint Searl

Re: Workmanship question.

Clint Searl

>So, good hitting beats good pitching every time, and vice versa.

Clint

Re: Workmanship question.

#17

Re: Workmanship question.

Thomas S Stockton------WebKitFormBoundaryAt+6o7QFm

>If possible I really like to go back and look at my pieces a few months after they are delivered, because by that time I have forgotten most of the flaws. When I talk about flaws most the time it is a detail that didn't work out as well as I liked or something I had to redo because it really didn't work out.

Making something like the desk is really just breaking things down to basic operations I've done many times before. For me making a fancy set of kitchen cabinets takes more head scratching and figuring than building a desk because it is something I don't do that often, so it is not imprinted in my brain.

The desk isn't perfect there are things I would do differently although the changes would be subtle and I wouldn't really know what they were until I started building.

James Krenov has a great quote in one of his books about perfection that i wish I could find but it talks about the goal of reaching perfection and how it should remain elusive because once you reach it there is nothing left to do

Re: Workmanship question.

#18

Clint Searl

Re: Workmanship question.

Clint Searl

>Or for real honesty, ask your newest friends what they think of your work. They'll all say it's so beautiful and tell you that you're really handy.

Clint

Re: Workmanship question.

#19

Or, they might say....

Barry Irby

>"You had really nice wood." I wonder if they know how brutal that is?

Re: Workmanship question.

#20

Amen

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>

Re: Workmanship question.

#21

Re: Workmanship question.

Larry in NW Ohio

>And in the very next breath they`ll ask you to build them a table and while you were at it and have time come over and look at a leaking faucet. Don`t need friends like that. Larry

Re: Workmanship question.

#22

JL

I see a goal in which to aspire.

JL

>I don't do the same sorts of things. I do mostly chairs and the occasional simple tables, nightstands, desks, etc. Mostly I do Mission and Shaker style for the non chairs and Windsor for the chairs. Once in a while I do something more ornate - but that's not really where I'm at.

I see the flaws. The leg that is too thick, the spindle that needs a bit more taper. I also see the good things. But I view my furniture that is something to be used. It will be knocked around. The cat will end up barfing on it (hopefully NOT scratching it). I make it so it will stand the abuse/use. It will hopefully look good - if it doesn't, I've got a burn pile out back.

Re: Workmanship question.

#23

The "Reality Checker"

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I cannot achieve a perfect piece. Reminds me that those who weave oriental rugs will always weave a flaw in the pattern so as to show that only their God is perfect. As for me, I know where every tiny flaw is on each piece. But even if I feel I have made a piece with no noticable flaws there is always my wife. She has an uncanny ability to look at my work and before saying any compliments will zoom right in on flaws and point them out. God love her...she is right....but that doesn't stop me from saying D'oh! ;-)

Tom

Re: Workmanship question.

#24

Re: Workmanship question.

Jim Dillon

>Virgil,

Your question is interesting and thought-provoking. If I can look at something I did and feel pleased with how it turned out (regardless of the "flaws") and a sense of pride, then I am happy. When I look at the work of others who are far more accomplished, I look with admiration at the effort it took to achieve what it is they did. And if the design is pleasing to my eye, even better. But, I do not feel envious or feel like throwing in the towel and finding a new hobby. I use work like Tom's (and MANY others here at WC) to show me what is possible and to raise my standard further the next time.

During a major project I keep a daily log of what was accomplished and the time spent. At the end of each project I devote a page, or two, or three... to mistakes made, and what I would do different next time. While I never do a major project more than once (my rule), I like going back and reviewing past mistakes, hoping that I won't make the same mistake again. Doesn't necessarily work, but I try 8-).

Jim

Re: Workmanship question.

#25

Re: The "Reality Checker"

Thomas S Stockton------WebKitFormBoundaryAt+6o7QFm

>My favorite is when my wife comes in the shop and looks at something and says "you aren't going to leave it like that" doesn't do it very often but when she does I listen and think about it