Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Workmanship question.

Posts

Re: Workmanship question.

#26

Re: Workmanship question.

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

>When I finish a project I stand back and look at it and think.. I MADE THAT! It doesn't matter if it's a lopsided birdhouse or a swivel top box made from a leftover piece of 2x4. I made it myself. I took some wood and measured it, cut it, shaped it, joined it, and finished it. Sometimes from a plan. Sometimes inspired by the folks at WC. Sometimes off the top of my head. But the finished product is something unique to me.

Room for improvement? Of course! I realize I'll never be a David Marks, or Norm Abram, or Ellis Wallentine, or even come close to the craftmanship that I see on WC every day. In the meantime I'll keep on turning out my Wabisabi* projects and try to make each one better than the last.

*Wabisabi: The Japanese principle of imperfection. (Google it)

Re: Workmanship question.

#27

A very wise man.

Victor Parisian

>That explains why you've lasted for as long as you have.

My buddy from Indiana who married right out of High School told me they have been happily married for 30 years now...30 out of 41 years isn't bad.

Victor - going on 29 in Houston.

Re: Workmanship question.

#28

Re: Workmanship question.------WebKitFormBoundaryj

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA------WebKitFormBoundar

>Virgil,

I see each and every mistake in my work as though highlighted in day-glo orange. In actual fact, I am fairly good at fixing mistakes to make them look look enhancements to the original design, but to my eye they all remain glaring. At least that is what my LOML tells me (I suspect she is somewhat biased); other recipients of my work have yet to comment on my fixes, and for some odd reason I neglect to point them out. Oh! the vanity of it all!!

I am in awe of much of the work I see posted here, and aspire to attain something approaching the skill level demonstrated. In comparison, much of what I build looks crude to my eye. Nice to have a goal, though!

Top of the season!

Jim

------WebKitFormBoundaryjKZXGVP54WSOW+va

Re: Workmanship question.

#29

ALWAYS Virgil...ALWAYS...!

Hikmet C. Sakman

>

Re: Workmanship question.

#30

Re: The "Reality Checker"

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Oh man....are we married to the same woman?? Bwahaha!

Re: Workmanship question.

#31

Re: The "Reality Checker"

Doug Ridley

>Your wife related to mine?

Re: Workmanship question.

#32

Re: The "Reality Checker"------WebKitFormBoundaryU

Glenn Madsen---in SF Bay Area------WebKitFormBound

>And when, as now, I'm doing her kitchen, the message is triply clear.

------WebKitFormBoundaryUxSP+va988A1AeAS

Re: Workmanship question.

#33

Yes, but ...

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA

>I see lots of flaws in my pieces. Now, what is interesting to me is that I can look at a piece I made several years ago and notice new flaws. Now, this may seem bad, but in fact it isn't. It means I am learning and that I know more now than I did earlier. Hopefully, I won't have the same errors in my next piece. I don't ever feel bad about my flaws, if I've made the piece for someone else (even for money). Very often, what I see as a flaw is virtually unnoticeable to anyone else - if our table top cracks, we'll replace it, but that tiny bit of tearout on a routed edge is often hard to see. I was just sitting at a poker table I made several years ago for a friend and I noticed that my grain selection was terrible. But, I didn't know about that when I made it. Everyone who sees the table loves it, and I still really like it, but well, the grain selection could have been better.

I love seeing other peoples pieces. Especially here, over the years you can see how people are improving and changing. I'm glad that when we discuss the pieces here we often talk about design, the challenges, the use, the finish, etc. That allows all of us to grow as we discuss our work. 5 years ago I wasn't as good as Tom or Ellis or our other masters here. Now, I'm still not as good, but I'm better than I was, and that's important.

This is a learning effort that spans decades. I'll guess that Tom has been working for a good many years now. I'm happy that we all keep improving as the years go by.