Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

china hand planes vs Lie N

Posts

china hand planes vs Lie N

#1

china hand planes vs Lie N

mike from american sycamore

>Have you sen the news from Fine Woodworking. Woodcraft takes all the Lie-Nielsen hand planes over to China and cops them to the T. I have a lot of respect for Thomas at Lie Nielsen and I am upset with WoodCraft for being so under handed! Lie Nielsen has been a major player for Woodcraft and now to get in return. Is it just me? I hate seeing an USA company like Woodcraft doing something that will hurt another USA company like Lie-N. Just my red neck opinion. How many more jobs will we lose to China>

Mike

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#2

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Larry in NW Ohio

>It`ll be the last time I do anything with Woodcraft. Larry

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#3

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Wow - that stinks. That really really sinks...

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#4

I Don't Like It Either!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Mike,

There will always be a good market for well crafted hand planes. We are in a competitive society, and competition should rule--eventually. Lee Neilson set the standard of excellence. I can't say that anybody who seeks to achieve or exceed that standard is deserving of negative reaction. I don't like it emotionally, but I can see it happening intellectually. Competition usually means better tools will result at a lower price for more wood workers.

George

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#5

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I have a pair of L-N low angle block planes and the "same" pair of Stanley's (albeit with Hock blades). One could say that the L-N's are a high end knock-off of the Stanley's, stealing some of the market. Whatever success the Chinese models enjoy, there's no philosophical difference between the L-N/Chinese situation and the L-N/Stanley situation.

If the quality of the Chinese planes is similar to the L-N's at a lower price point, it simply opens the market for those who wouldn't pay the L-N price anyway. And it gives L-N an incentive to improve its competitiveness.

Clint

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#6

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Dave Paine

>This does not sound good on the surface, but we need to consider the details.

A China plane, like other cheap planes, will attract certain buyers who look for the price alone. These buyers would likely not consider L-N or any of the higher priced planes.

My first plane was a #5 Record, before they were bought by another company and shut down. This cost me $80.

I have replaced the blade with a Hock blade and it now performs very well, except the sides were not ground to be orthogonal, and so this plane is not able to be used on my shooting board.

Users will soon find out such details.

After the Record, my other planes have been Lee Valley. Sorry L-N, your prices are too steep for me. I find Lee Valley to be my price/quality point.

My own observation is that I would not want to be given a cheap plane. Even a free plane is not worth having if it does not do the job for which it was designed.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#7

Re: China hand planes

North of the Border

>The world is flat! Sooner rather than later, we'll have Chinese imported cars running in N.A. The Hummer brand is being sold to a Chinese company which agrees to keep the plants in the US at least till 2011. I wonder if the Chinese buyer knows what he's doing ... may be the price is too good to resist (he's getting something we try to get rid of). At least the Chinese take-over is doing some good to the employment market in the US.

I guess with China being one of the biggest buyers of the US debts (Japan and S.A. are the other two), the trend of more and more Chinese-made goods and brands replacing American ones is unstoppable. These days, we are after Japanese cars and electronics but may be 20 or 30 years from now, we (or our children) could be chasing after Chinese products in the high end.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#8

Re: China hand planes

Fred Davis

>China has a long history of stealing, copying and otherwise taking shortcuts they couldn't or wouldn't do th R and D the originals owners did.

Just ask any movie or video company what the cost is to them.

My personal opinion is simply that it serves no useful purpose to reward their technology theft by buying it.

But that is just what i think.

FredD

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Let's not loose the perspective....

Jesper, Denmark

>The good old Norwegian that he is, Tom Lie-Nielsen recognized a need for quality woodworking tools and started a business based on the old Stanley designs, adding his own small twists and quality improvements. It is a small business in Maine and the idea of high quality tools found a niche market and his business grew.

Lee Valley did a similar thing, adding their own little twists, but based out of Canada.

There are similar other small companies, recognizing a need in the market for quality. Doug Thomson lathe tols is one that springs to mind.

Now, should we get exited over Woodcraft recognizing this growing interest in quality tools in our sphere of interest? On a global scale it is of no significance - it is a small market with very few employees.

Since the collective "we" generally like both Lie-Nielsen and Lee Vally tools, should we then be concerned on their behalf? I think not. I believe the effect will be that the new player on the high Quality tools will actually increase the market for these tools and benefit both Lie-Nielsen and Lee Valley as well as Woodcraft. The effect is like Supermarkets and other competing stores co-locating in malls. Look around at your local shopping areas. They are all bunched together, and it is a quite well known business fact that if you add more stores of the same kind to a location, they all benefit and their sales grow.

I think the same will happen here. People will get interested in the new planes and then compare them in the store. Some will opt for the lower cost and others will decide that they would really rather have a real "Lie-Nielsen Stanley Bedrock copy" than the Woodcraft version.

Now, if there is a real plagiarism issue, like the $5 Rolex watches sold in Hong Kong, there may be an international trade issue, which Lie-Nielsen will have to pursue. If not, someone will do a side-by-side test and I suspect that a merchandizeing company will have a very hard time controlling any manufacturer to make the same quality as the small privately run companies can by personal attention from a manager with a personal philosophy on how things should be done.

In the end it will turn out like the Delta/Jet/Grizzly/Harbor Freight versions of the Unisaw. The products will stand on their own merits. The consumer rules, you have the freedom of choice.

Now, how do I get down from this soapbox?

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#10

Re: Let's not loose the perspective....

mike from american sycamore

>very good points. I guess it was like when Porter-Cable launched their nail guns. I had always sold Senco and sold a few guns a year. I sold hundreds of the Porter-Cable because of their selling price and good quality. A lot more wood workers now use nail guns because they are affordable.

It just scares me that we are losing so many jobs and our country is hurting right now. Still the best country in the world to live! God Bless America!

thanks,

Mike

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#11

LN Probably Not Worried

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Cheaper hand planes are readily available already. If quality was not a concern and saving a few bucks was then I would not own a single LN plane. But quality is a factor for me so the Woodcraft planes will never find their way into my shop. I doubt LN is too worried about losing market share. Those who would buy the cheaper knock-offs probably wouldn't have bought an LN plane anyway.

Tom

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#12

Wood River ?

Don Orr

>Are you talikng about the new Wood River line of planes ? I really don't think Tom LN or Rob Lee have anything to worry about from these tools. And what about the new "high end" Stanley planes. Where will they fit in the mix ?

China is going to do what China is going to do because we have allowed and encouraged it with our buying habits. I'm guilty of it myself and not necessarily proud of it, but I'm not rich and have to watch my pennies and dollars. I try to at least buy from American companies so maybe some of it will help our own country. It's not easy even finding things still made in the USA. I saw an article recently that said something to the effect that America is still one of the largest manufacturers in the world. So maybe it's not all bad news.

Sorry-rant off now.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#13

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N *LINK*

Thomas S Stockton

>A question for you would it be any different if it was an american company doing the copying and producing it in the U.S.. In some ways that's what LN did with the Stanley bedrock planes, yes I know it was a discontinued design and he improved some things but it was still a copy.

That said the problem I have is that they build them to look almost exactly like the LN original, which can be confusing to the consumer same color handles but at least they didn't copy the bronze blade cap. In some respects LN proved that the bedrock design is up for grabs and can be copied, I really don't have a problem with this since Stanley abandoned the design in the 1940's I have a problem with them making it look very similar to someone else's product.

I have an even bigger problem with the knock-offs of Lee Valley's products because these are much more of an original design. Some are based on historic tools but they have created a very unique look and should be applauded for this. I think LN has done the same thing in some of their tools especially in recreating some more obscure tools and some of their original offerings.

I think one misconception is blaming the chinese for this, yes they pirate stuff like crazy but I would be willing to bet in both cases with LV and LN this was a western business person going to china with these tools and finding a manufacturer to knock them off.

For the record I don't own any planes from either company I have a couple of steel planes but mostly I prefer wooden ones I've made, although at times I've been known to lust after both of their low angle block planes.

My solution is to don't buy them and in the case of blatant knock offs avoid doing business with those companies that carry them if possible.

Tom


Fww short comparision

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#14

Re: China hand planes

Charlie Self

>It strikes me as a touch strange that GM was allowed to sell Hummer to the Chinese. IIRC, Hummer is the company that makes military vehicles for our services, something that could possibly create a problem at a later date.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#15

Re: Let's not loose the perspective....

Charlie Self

>It's not plagiarism. It also probably is not patent infringement, unless Tom Lie-Nielsen patented his changes to the old (and out of patent) Stanley tools. There is a considerable difference between copying a tool that is still under patent protection and copying one that has outlived its patent and is still profitably made. Consider the Biesemeyer fences, and the sudden proliferation of T square fences about a decade ago, when those patents ran their course.

I'd bet that there are a few people sitting out there aching to copy Lee Valley's Veritas planes, too, but I'd almost bet that Rob Lee has them protected to the hilt. There are some major design changes in those planes over the Stanley models they're vaguely based on, while it always seemed to me there were fewer changes made to the L-N planes, except quality of materials and workmanship, both of which were far better than was ever found on truly mass-produced planes. Both the Veritas and L-N planes are a major step up in quality and attractiveness, with the edge in the beauty contest going to the L-N planes, while I've found added utility in several of the Veritas models that don't exist in Stanley or L-N.

I'll take a look at the new Woodcraft offerings. I'm curious as to what kind of changes their "tool designers" might have requested.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#16

Re: Let's not loose the perspective....

Charlie Self

>There's more to the story of pneumatic nailers than just P-C, though. There were Taiwanese (pre-mainland Chinese) knock-offs of out of patent nail guns for years before Porter-Cable jumped in. Porter-Cable changed the methods of inspecting, and buying, for quality, forcing the makers to attain a specific quality level if P-C was to accept the nail guns.

That was a major part of the reason for the increase.

All of a sudden, that $280 framing nailer worked as well and lasted about as long as the competition's American-made $450-$500 model.

The increase in quality of manufacture was an important part of the puzzle, one that Porter-Cable, as far as I know, was the first to locate and use.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#17

Re: Let's not loose the perspective....

Thomas S Stockton

>The reason there was an explosion of Biesmeyer clones was that the founder of the company decided to not enforce his copyright. The reason he did this was because he felt like it would be too expensive to fight all the lawsuits that would come up from copyright unfringement.

In his case I don't think he lost marketshare and was probably a wise choice.

Tom

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#18

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Charlie Self

>Thomas, Yes, it would be different if an American company were doing the manufacturing. For one thing, most of the money would stay in the U.S. For another, and this is why the planes are made in China, there wouldn't have been enough of a price swing to encourage Woodcraft to make the effort. Not enough profit margin.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#19

Ditto for other stuff in the store

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I think the place is run by MBS's with the logical result. Look what happened to REI when the MBA's took over. I shop at Lee Valley.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#20

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Thomas S Stockton

>Charlie

I see it as two sepreate problems the first being the ethics of copying someone else tool design, is this right or wrong no matter where the tool is produced.

The second being having products produced overseas at a cheaper cost and also making it harder for western courts to intervene if ther is copyright or trade dress problems.

Yes they are both intertwined but in my opinion taking someone elses copyrighted tool design is pretty slimy no matter where the tool orginates and someone shouldn't be given a pass because the tool is produced in north america.

As I said in another post this probably isn't a chinese busineesman deciding to copy these tools it's someone from over here taking these tools to China to be copied.

Tom

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#21

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Norman

>There is a larger problem here. This handtool copying issue is but the beginning of a bad trend.

It appears at least to me that the ingenuity factor is a N. American thing and the Chinese at least at this stage of their economy, simply either copy or are asked to copy N. American designs.

Who knows, there might be a point in the future when we will be looking to them for designs.

Today however, the larger problem is these design infringements will probably slowly destroy the design movement in N. America.

Why go to all the trouble of designing a product, either a design or utility patent, and have it copied as easily as it has been.

There appears to be no regard for the respect of the existing N. American patent system.

If I were a product designer, I would be worried. I would also begin to make a case for protectionism where blatant copying and patent infringement has been revealed.

Design and innovation are the last bastions of the Western world's economic might and advantage.... take this away and I have no idea what we have left.

Today, the LN and LV brands have established a cachet for themselves. The owners are proud to own and use these tools.

Service and support also make these companies shine.

Not sure about the rest of the stuff coming our way.

Norman

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#22

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Charlie Self

>Thomas, What I understand is that WOodcraft took the designs overseas. It's possible that a Chinese manufacturer came to one of the WC product managers while they were overseas, or even got in touch through their agents, but for a range of tools like this, it seems likely WC was the advance party.

As to copying other's designs, the ethics of that are fairly clear. Patent infringement CANNOT occur after the patent runs out. If it did, you'd never get generic drugs, among other things. Patents generally run 20 years, something manufacturers and inventors know going in, so the fact that designs are copied 21 years down the road has been, or should have been, planned for. Such copying is not considered unethical, and it's certainly not illegal.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#23

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N - Except

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>"Whatever success the Chinese models enjoy, there's no philosophical difference between the L-N/Chinese situation and the L-N/Stanley situation."

Except that Stanley quit making theirs long before L-N started (re)making them.

Jim D.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#24

I voted with my dollar...

Ralph in Huntington Beach

>...by going to the Lie-Nielsen site and buying a new No. 3 Bench Plane, Bronze. I've got a few of their other tools, the large scraping plane, block plane, small shoulder plane and a saw, but this is my first bench plane from them. Can't wait for it to get here!!!

I've always wanted the #3 plane and I've spent untold hours tuning my new Record planes and didn't want to do anymore metal working, I just wanted a plane that I can take out of the box, quickly hone and use. And if they're like my other LN tools, I'll be able to do just that.

As far as the Chicom planes go...only time will tell.

Now, get out there and vote.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#25

Re: Ditto for other stuff in the store

wilbur

>FWIW, Lee Valley also sells a lot of stuff made in non-American countries, including China.

I bought a set of Forstners from Lee Valley. They are quite good. They were made in China.