Re: Let's not loose the perspective....
Jesper, Denmark
>The good old Norwegian that he is, Tom Lie-Nielsen recognized a need for quality woodworking tools and started a business based on the old Stanley designs, adding his own small twists and quality improvements. It is a small business in Maine and the idea of high quality tools found a niche market and his business grew.
Lee Valley did a similar thing, adding their own little twists, but based out of Canada.
There are similar other small companies, recognizing a need in the market for quality. Doug Thomson lathe tols is one that springs to mind.
Now, should we get exited over Woodcraft recognizing this growing interest in quality tools in our sphere of interest? On a global scale it is of no significance - it is a small market with very few employees.
Since the collective "we" generally like both Lie-Nielsen and Lee Vally tools, should we then be concerned on their behalf? I think not. I believe the effect will be that the new player on the high Quality tools will actually increase the market for these tools and benefit both Lie-Nielsen and Lee Valley as well as Woodcraft. The effect is like Supermarkets and other competing stores co-locating in malls. Look around at your local shopping areas. They are all bunched together, and it is a quite well known business fact that if you add more stores of the same kind to a location, they all benefit and their sales grow.
I think the same will happen here. People will get interested in the new planes and then compare them in the store. Some will opt for the lower cost and others will decide that they would really rather have a real "Lie-Nielsen Stanley Bedrock copy" than the Woodcraft version.
Now, if there is a real plagiarism issue, like the $5 Rolex watches sold in Hong Kong, there may be an international trade issue, which Lie-Nielsen will have to pursue. If not, someone will do a side-by-side test and I suspect that a merchandizeing company will have a very hard time controlling any manufacturer to make the same quality as the small privately run companies can by personal attention from a manager with a personal philosophy on how things should be done.
In the end it will turn out like the Delta/Jet/Grizzly/Harbor Freight versions of the Unisaw. The products will stand on their own merits. The consumer rules, you have the freedom of choice.
Now, how do I get down from this soapbox?