Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

china hand planes vs Lie N

Posts

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#26

different company

wb

>AM General makes the military HMMWV, or Humvee.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#27

FWW's Chris Cochnour . . .

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>has tested the WR plane at http://www.taunton.com/finewoodworking/ToolGuide/ToolGuideProduct.aspx?id=32552

Read the short test carefully, very carefully. Basically it is like my saying of a student, well, yes, he passed. (gentlemanly C or slovenly D?)

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#28

Re: Let's not loose the perspective....

Fred Davis

>Talk about timing Jesper, one need look no further then this month's FWW for the "side by side test"

Give them a "A" for appearence and a "D-" for quality control.

So if you want a L-N/Stanley plane for about half the price, I hope you have a good Machnist in the family.

FredD

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#29

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Frank House

>I suggest that there is no great problem with copying an out-of-patent design. The unethical action is to deliberately make the copy look very like the original with intent to deceive.

"Passing off" is the technical term, though it strictly applies in the UK to registered designs, not patents.

Frank.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#30

Lee Grindinger

Man, capitalism sucks

Lee Grindinger

>Whoever thought an economy should be based on a free market system should have their head examined!

Sheesh!

Lee

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#31

Moses Yoder

Re: Man, capitalism sucks

Moses Yoder

>A free market system where everyone is working off of the same dollar would work a lot better.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#32

Lee Grindinger

A single world currency?

Lee Grindinger

>Moses, a single world currency would place all control over the value of goods and currency (same thing in a single world currency) in the hands of one central bank.

Are you sure that's a good idea?

Many blame central banks for the current situation. American, European, British, Japanese and Canadian central banks manage the value and availability of their respective currencies. How are they doing so far?

I'm surprised you'd so readily give this responsibility to an agency even further removed from you than the FOMC (Federal Open Market Committee) is. Imagine your bank's lending practices being managed and dictated by an agency much further removed from your world than it is now.

Lee

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#33

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

Charlie Self

>OK. According to Jeff Forbes, Woodcraft's president, a manufacturer came to them with the products. Jeff was a wee bit upset by my implying otherwise, so he emailed me to set the record straight, which I've now done.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#34

Re: Ditto for other stuff in the store

Rob Lee

>Hi Wilbur -

The difference there - is that we designed those bits, and own the tooling...there's nothing wrong with made in China product - they do represent 1/4 of the planet's population after all...

Our preference is to always manufacture in North America - and we do a lot of it. There just aren't always manufacturers that are willing to do the work though. To get small runs done, China is the place to go...they're quite happy to have the work, while many domestic manufacturers won't even quote.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#35

Re: Let's not loose the perspective....

Charlie Self

>"The reason there was an explosion of Biesmeyer clones was that the founder of the company decided to not enforce his copyright. The reason he did this was because he felt like it would be too expensive to fight all the lawsuits that would come up from copyright unfringement.

In his case I don't think he lost marketshare and was probably a wise choice."

I don't know where you got that story, but there are several problems with it. First, it was a patent, not a copyright. A patent, which is for mechanical and other inventions, protects for 20 years, usually (drug companies manage to get them for longer). A copyright, for intellectual properties, protects for the author's lifetime plus 100 years (thanks to Walt Disney Inc.).

Bill Biesemeyer started a machine shop in 1978 specifically to market his T-Square fence. I don't know for sure he patented the fence at that time, because he'd been selling hand-produced fences for several years before that. In 1995, he sold the company to Delta.

Any patent would have run out long ago, probably in '98 or a bit earlier. It has been just over a decade since the explosion in clones took off, if memory serves.

I have no idea what fence has the best market share at this point, but, in fact, when he started, Biesemeyer had the ONLY T Square fence, thus he had 100% of the market share for that unit. Today, it is split among at least four makers, though I'm not sure the Jet/Powermatic version is sold separately, while the Biesemeyer, the HTC and the Grizzly vesions all are.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#36

Re: Man, capitalism sucks

Alex Grigoriev

>There's been an economy NOT based on free market system. In Soviet Union. It failed big time. The only thing non-market (fully state-owned and controlled) economy can produce well is ICBMs with nuclear warheads and other weapons. Any consumer stuff and food - not much. Because there is no competition in such economy. Nobody fails. Nobody wins. Nobody has an opportunity to succeed. I know that way too well. Imagine one giant monopoly, which you can't leave for better fate. You were not allowed to leave USSR. You WERE obliged to work, or go to jail.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#37

Re: Let's not loose the perspective....

Thomas S Stockton

>I probably got patent and copyright mixed up, not a lawyer but will gladly play one on TV and the internet.

The info comes from a article in issue 133 of fww By William Duckworth and parts of it say he patented his design in 1978, # 4206910 was issued 2 years later, after 4 years he decided to "deny the patent" to avoid any prolonged litigation and that it took over 10 years before word got around and clones began to appear.

Yes I was probably not correct about market share what i should have said was that it probably didn't hurt him financialy and product lawsuits are most likely very expensive. as for other fences I not sure when it appeared probably around 1985 or so but the unifence which is based on european fence designs was availble.

Tom

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#38

Lee Grindinger

Both systems rely on a fictitious element

Lee Grindinger

>Were the USSR truly based upon communism and it's lofty ideals executed by moral leaders for a moral society it would have worked beautifully.

Were Western capitalism truly based upon capitalism and it's lofty ideals executed by moral leaders for a moral society it would work beautifully.

Were wishes fishes we'd all have a fry.

Sadly, humans are flawed, we need supervision.

Lee

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#39

Re: Both systems rely on a fictitious element

Alex Grigoriev

>Socialist religion (they called it "scientific communism"; as a religion it didn't also tolerate other "deity-based" religions) proclaaimed that the people liberated from "capitalistic exploitation" will all strive for better work results, etc; that the social justice will bring an ideal mankind. In reality, communist regimes all went through "purification" phase, which consisted of extermination of "enemy" elements; as recently as Khmer Rouge regime in 1970-s.

Pure capitalism mantra ("small government, business freedom") assumes that self-organising forces of free enterpreneurship will reach equilibrum for the ultimate good. In reality, corporations always manage to achieve more leverage than smaller companies and consumers, requiring the government to set the rules for fair competition and consumer protection. For example, credit card companies can have you over the barrel - change the interest rate on the existing debt, etc.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#40

Lee Grindinger

Our philosophical ideals are greater than we are

Lee Grindinger

>Sadly, these "purifications" are still going on today, Darfur being one that is heinous yet attracts little outside attention because China is so powerful.

Just as the USSR was a distortion of communism, as is China, the USA is a distortion of both democracy (not really a democracy at all, it's a republic) and capitalism. It all may prove that we cannot live up to philosophies that we can imagine.

Perhaps socialism is the system our natures are best suited for while our souls reach for ideals we can't possible live up to.

Alex, I worked for a short time with a Czechoslovakian who had escaped his country with his family carrying nothing more than the clothes on their backs just as the Communists took over. Rusty and I used to talk politics and world affairs. It's good to do it here with you.

Lee

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#41

Re: Ditto for other stuff in the store

Fred Davis

>Rob,

if you were to peruse the current FWW article on those WoodCraft planes made China, you might want to rethink the "nothing wrong with made in China " comment.

They bought a #3and #4and #5 and #6 bench plane and a block plane from Woodcraft and Stanley.

He goes on to say "the appearance was beautiful, the machining was crisp.

Then he got down to the nitty gritty and said that "the chip-breaker was ground out of square and took twenty minutes to regrind and the frog was machined out of square , so the tilt lever had to be swung all the way over to compensate."

He checked the rest of the planes and found one more with the same problems, only difference being, the frog was machined out of square the opposite direction ;-))

I believe your product is ready to go out of the box , with out any corrections.

This is a significant difference, but like Gochnour said at the end of the article ,In use , after I reground its chip-breaker and learned to live with the lever tilt, the #4 performed as well as a high end plane, for about half the price. Of course, high end planes don't require such prep work to get them cutting properly"

FredD

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#42

Re: Ditto for other stuff in the store

wilbur

>Hi Fred,

There's one important difference between the WoodRiver Chinese made planes and the LV/LN planes. The WoodRiver planes are made to a price point that is 1/3-1/2 the price of the corresponding LV/LN plane.

Those WoodRiver planes could easily have been spec'ed to have the same quality of machining and performance that the LV/LN planes have. It is not beyond the technical capacity of Chinese manufacturers to make such a plane. The cost of such a plane, however, would be much closer to the LV/LN planes.

One thing that always seems to get lost in these sorts of discussions is that this really isn't a Chinese vs. US plane manufacturing issue. This is much more of a cheap vs. more expensive plane issue. As I mentioned before, the Lee Valley Forstner bits, which are manufactured in China, perform really well. They also cost twice as much as Chinese made Forstners that you can get from Rockler. I don't think that this is coincidence.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#43

Re: Ditto for other stuff in the store

Fred Davis

>Well Wilbur ,

now you have went and done it.

What I want to know is when, manufacturers starting turning out shoddy products and justifying it by saying , well their only half the price of correctly done ones.

It seems to me in this case at least , that it cost the manufacturer just as much to grind the chip breaker out of square and machine the Frog wrong as it would have to have done it right the first time and I bet the labor costs were the same also.

We used to see defective items sold as "seconds" not as well done as the competition and only half price.

This half price gambit , is like saying if you want it at a price point, would you mind if we fired all of the quality control people and sold you something you had to do over.

For instance , the #4 Bench plane was priced as I said in a earlier post at about half the the price of the L-N version , 106.00 I believe they said

I also would bet that you could not get a machinist to correct the bad machining on the Frog and square up the Chip-Breaker for the 106.00 you presumably were saving either.

On a personal note , every job I did as a Contractor or Cabinet maker, regardless of whether I made a lot or a little or lost my ass on , I did with the same dedication to getting the client what they paid for , my best effort.

So tell me is the shoddy , cheap approach to anything you care to name the rule now and if you object to what that way produces, you may be creating a international incident, be politically incorrect and unfair to third world countries the norm?

FredD

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#44

Re: Ditto for other stuff in the store

wilbur

>Hi Fred,

As far the cost to the manufacturer for grinding the chipbreaker out of square, I can't see how it wouldn't be cheaper to set up a tool manufacture run to have the chipbreaker "somewhat square" vs. "really accurately square". "Really accurately square" takes more time to set up the run, and a higher level of quality control, which means a higher rejection rate of the finished parts, all of which adds to the cost of manufacture and the final selling price of the tool.

If I understand you correctly, however, I think that we agree much more than we disagree. It's very apparent that we dislike the same thing: the process of turning out an inferior product in the name of matching a price point. In this case, it's a bench plane for about $100. Personally, I think that the prices that Lee Valley and Lie-Nielsen sell their bench planes for is a very fair price for what you get -- a plane that works well out of the box, and the customer support that comes with that expectation.

My point is that this often gets couched as a China vs. US manufacturing issue. Again, I'll say that it's not the country of origin that's the problem here. In this case, the problem is the expectation that you can have a quality bench plane that works out of the box for $100. I don't care where you make that $100 plane: China, the US, Canada, Eastern Europe, or Tahiti -- I don't think that it can be done.

If you found a US made bench plane that sold for $100, I'll bet dollars to doughnuts that such a bench plane would have the same issues with the squareness of the chipbreaker and the quality of the machining as these Chinese manufactured WoodRiver planes did in the FWW review.

On the flip side, I would also bet that if you manufactured a bench plane in China that worked out of the box the way that LV/LN planes do, the cost of that plane would be pretty close to the LV/LN planes. Maybe a little cheaper, but not enough so that you would steal any sales from LV/LN.

That's why I think that framing these discussions as an issue of the country that the plane was manufactured in is inaccurate, and that it really comes down to the attempt to sell a plane (or other item) at a given price point, and sacrificing quality in the process. This has nothing to do with political correctness, and everything to do with getting to the heart of the matter -- the choices we make as the ultimate buyers of the tools.

I think that you hit the nail on the head when you said that manufacturers turn out shoddy products and justify it by saying that they are only half the price of correctly done ones. Note that this applies regardless of where that product was made.

Also, note that for the most part, unfortunately, most people will shop only on price, and quite happily forego quality in the process. One only has to count the number of "Those LV/LN planes are ridiculously expensive!"-type comments in internet woodworking forums to come to this conclusion. Unfortunately, I also have to agree that the "shoddy, cheap approach to anything you care to name" seems to be the rule now for the most part. If it wasn't, this introduction of WoodRiver planes by WoodCraft never would have happened.

Re: china hand planes vs Lie N

#45

Re: Ditto for other stuff in the store

Fred Davis

>Hi back at ya Wilbur ,

Take note that I do not care whether China wins the contract on the planes or not, what I do care about and have stated many times is simply put , it cost's no more in any given operation you can think of, to get it right the first time and since right the first time is always the cheapest and fastest way , ergo, there you have the best possible of two worlds, a good product at a fair price and not one that needs special, expensive ,time consuming attention.

Beyond that I personally think L-N planes could be more of a "trophy "tool that someone here said not long ago about a TS that was well maintained and cared for.

I believe that a made in the UK Stanley plane , well tuned , like it should be , works for me as well as any more expensive ,but not necessarily better one.

This about exhaust my comments on quality in general and planes in particular , regardless of the country of origin.

FredD