Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Taking a poll on DC

Posts

Taking a poll on DC

#1

Taking a poll on DC

Larry in NW Ohio

>I got courious from the post down the way from LGranber. I`d like to ask everyone about your dust collection pipe, what kind do you have S&D PVC or metal and why?

I have S&D and always did, because IMHO it is extremly easy to work with and a person would have to really try to cut your hands or anything else with it. Also IIRC from Bill Penz DC site the air slides thru it better, you get better CFM`s. Also when you move machinery around it is much easier to redo PVC. In my before life I worked with metal in a woodworking plant and I hated it. It was hard to cut and handle. Of course I`m courious what other think and why. Larry

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#2

PVC

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Larry - another vote for PVC. Cheap, lots of fittings and easy to work with. Metal is nice, but at 3 times the price, it just makes things too expensive.

Doug

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#3

PVC

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#4

Re: PVC

Glenn Madsen

>I like an element of danger in my life. ;-)

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#5

Re: Taking a poll on DC

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I use 4" S&D pipe. I wish they made 5" as I'm sure the 4" is restriciting my DC which has a 5" inlet a bit. I use pvc because it is cheap, easy to configure and reconfigure.

After the first few days of use, the static disappears and there is no need to ground it. My pipes won't even wiggle the hair on your arm, if you hold your arm close to the pipes, after running my planer for 20-30 minutes at a time.

Lee

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#6

JL

Metal

JL

>I had PVC in my old shop. It worked well. I ran 12 gauge bare stranded wire through the pipe and it was fine.

I opted for metal in my current shop. My mains are all 6". I step down to either 4 or 5 inch at each tool. It was easier to handle the metal overhead than lengths of PVC. I also have some "interesting" bends - it is easier to do an adjustable elbow than cobble something out of PVC.

If I had to do it over, I would consider doing it in PVC - but metal does work.

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#7

Re: Metal

Paul Andrus

>I've also read Bill Pentz's site,and have chosen to use PVC also.I purchased an Oneida 3hp cyclone,and they did a free shop layout,but I found a better layout; diagonal layout,1 long run with drops off for each of the 5 primary tools;in this arrangement order.The dust collector will be in one corner,the in this order respectively;

Table saw,5'pvc,jointer,3'pvc,router table,5'pvc,planer,4'pvc,band saw.A wye at each drop with 5"with as little hose as possible.

The table saw will have the blade guard to help capture the top dust.

The reason to put the table saw first if for it's constant use,and the amount of ambient dust it creates.

The PVC is green,but I do not have the schedule number with me.It is recommend not to use to sch.40,as it is too thick and quite overkill.

The wye's are about 35.50 each, and the 10' length is 12.50 ea.

So, to summarize, the entire cost to pipe in 5 major machines will be approximately 300.00. Not bad.

Paul

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#8

6"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>S&D PVC with bends made up with two 45� and a straight such that the radius of the curve is at least 18" (if not 24) with all joints non-glued but metal taped. Machine connections are 4" except for the cabinet for the chopsaw that pulls the whole 6, and the table saw which is 4" under and 3" over. Haven't done a static pressure test, but the velometer "pegs" on its 2800 fpm stop at the end of the line.

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#9

Re: Taking a poll on DC

Barry Irby

>I also have the S & D pvc. Much lighter in weight than the schedule 40 plumbing stuff. Used it because it as available at the borgs, yery convienent, easy and much less expensive than metal. It did require some head scratching to get all the parts to fit. Who knew "Four Inch" could mean so many different things? Works very well, no issues with static. Have to work at it to get a very slight shock. My shop vac OTOH Sometimes knocks me on my butt. Lowes had a much better selection of SD fittings than Home Depot. And there are adapter/filler rings that alow you to use SD pipe with plumbing fittings, but schedule 40 plumbing fittigns cost several time what sd fittings cost. I used a 6" trunk and four inch branches. Changed my TS to a five inch branch (Hose) and could not tell the difference, so I went back to four inch.

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#10

PVC

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>Cheap, and easy to work with. Joints are taped so I can reuse every fitting when I move into a larger shop...someday. :)

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#11

Re: Taking a poll on DC

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I have mostly PVC with a few metal sections. I both agree and disagree. The problem with 6" S&D PVC is it is pretty heavy. So, hefting 10' pieces up and down from a high ceiling is a bit of a pain when rearranging the shop. With a crimp tool, metal can be easier to rearrange in that you don't have to buy connectors and such. OTOH, I hate cutting sheet metal.

Jay

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#12

PVC sans glue . . .

steve mackay

>PVC is cheap and easy to work with. I keep a section or two "in stock" so if I get that "hair" to move a machine or station I just hack a new chunk and throw 'er in. And not glueing it together makes a new chunk or clearing stopages or clogs easy.

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#13

Paul Kramer

Metal

Paul Kramer

>I too, have an Oneida system that I got with the layout. I have it in the floor. It was a snap to install BUT it is an absolute bear to do revisions. I did the whole silicone sealing thing with the screws to decrease the likelihood of serious losses due to leaks. I'm not sure what I would do next time. I may never get a next time so it's moot.

Paul

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#14

Re: Taking a poll on DC

John McGaw

>PVC which is easily fabricated, cheap, available locally, and sufficient to the task vs. Metal which is difficult to work with, expensive, must be ordered from far away (at least if you live in a place like Knoxville) and is overkill for a small shop like mine. No contest really.

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#15

Re: Taking a poll on DC

Chuck in ND

>I think the metal ducting LGranber was talking about has couplers and is easy to work with. If he can afford it, why not ?

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#16

Re:Keep them coming

Larry in NW Ohio

>Thanks to all that are responding, I hope we get a bunch more, we may learn something new. Thanks again Larry

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#17

Re: Taking a poll on DC

mdclor

>I went with PVC for virtually all my collection system. I was forced to buy some of the green S&D to use with schedule 40 fittings, IIRC. There was a slight diameter difference so I used Gorilla duct tape on the green tubing to get a tight fit with the fittings. I thought that I would apply the metal tape over the outside to make the joints air tight, but discovered that if I was careful with the duct tape and applied the correct number of layers of duct tape, that wasn't necessary; it seals up just fine. I did use a rubber hammer to drive the tubing into the fittings. I am happy with the arrangement and am glad to have been forced into it.

HTH,

Merle

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#18

Metal

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I have an Oneida 2 hp cyclone with Oneida-designed metal ducts. Metal does cost more and is a pain to cut, agreed.

In my case I was looking for a quick install time. I didn't want to waste time with fittings that almost fit but not quite. As someone else posted I had a few odd turns that the adjustable elbows handled easily. After a few months with the original plan I made a few additions and changes which went well. I'm very happy with the way it turned out.

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#19

Re: Metal

Fred Davis

>I have a Oneida system and one thing about their instructions , they are crystal clear on using pop rivets instead of screws for fasteners.

The sheet metal shop I had install mine used screws and I pointed out the caution about screw points catching material and clogging the system.

Two weeks later they got to come back and remove the screws and install the rivets , after a mess of long plane shavings hung up.

Haven't been clogged since.

Turns out that after a little conversation , this was the first DC system installed by that firm.

So it was a learning experience on the value of reading the directions first, I guess you could say;-))

Silicone or a simliar material around the fasteners , like you said , combined with metal tape are well worth the effort.

FredD

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#20

Re: Taking a poll on DC

chuckbeck in cent il

>I don't like pvc or metal, I frugally remove 4" x 10' empty cardboard carpet rolls from the dumpster at the local flooring store. They usually dump a lot of nice 1/4" 'ultraply' plywood scraps too (like 2' x 2' scrap totally useless). It tapes up really nice, it slices really well with handsaw or bandsaw and fits over my flex tubes with minimal slack.

chuckbeck

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#21

Re: Taking a poll on DC

Pete in Holland, MI

>PVC here.

PVC has a good snug fit without glue. Just drilled and shot a couple screws into each joint and haven't looked back. Wish my main trunk line was greater than 4" though, but was limited with some obstructions in the basement ceiling.

Pete

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#22

Re: Taking a poll on DC

Thomas S Stockton

>I've used both plastic and metal. I prefer the metal, I used the snap lock pipe from Onieda and found it to be not very much more than plastic. I wouldn't waste my time with silicone it's messy and I personaly hate the smell. I used aluminum tape supper easy to apply and about the same cost as caulk.

Tom

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#23

Re: Taking a poll on DC

Chuck in ND

>For the 2 hp Cyclone DC I bought, the company recommends no less than 26 ga metal ducting, which is readily available at my local hardware store. Personally I think it's a toss up in price on plastic verses metal ducting. Plastic pipe may be cheaper, but plastic fittings are more expensive and not adjustable. For the little difference in price, I'd rather have the piece of mind that metal offers.

Re: Taking a poll on DC

#24

Re: Taking a poll on DC

Fred Davis

>