We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Well, it happened this morning in Clinton NJ. Sitting at a red light, nobody behind me, nobody coming at me from any direction. Light turned green, I turned right..... now I'm being pulled over. What the ...? I was being written up for failing to signal my turn.
My question is this, if there is nobody to signal your intention to -- no cars behind me or coming at me and no cross traffic -- is it still a crime not to have your blinker going when you're stopped at a light? In other words, am I likely to beat it in court?
The law probably says that turns need to be signaled and does not allow for extenuating circumstances. You can find the exact working in law books at your local library.
Sounds like your arresting officer got his/her butt chewed before the shift began. Began the day in a foul mood.
>Police officers get graded on the number of things completed - investigations brought to the DA, arrests made, or, for traffic officers, citations (tickets).
The officer may not have had his/her tushie chewed - maybe just eager to get the month's/week's stats up. It does sound VERY minor.
Find out what your fine is, and whether you can get it excused by going through traffic school or something. Then find out how uptight your auto insurance policy is as to points on your record. After all that, figure out the rate you normally charge for work, and decide. You might well be able to get the fine excused or reduced if you can point to your exemplary driving record and outline why you didn't think signaling was needed; but if you get a hanging judge, you'll have wasted a day in court.
Wandering OT: I had a friend back in the late 1960's who rode his BMW motorcycle to work daily in Philadelphia (and I mean daily - summer, winter, rain). On the first day of the helmet law in Pennsylvania, he went out to his bike, carefully strapped his helmet on his knee, and took off. The officers who'd been waiting for him of course ticketed him. When he went to court, he pointed out that (a) the law stated that a helmet must be worn but did not specify where, (b) he'd been riding for 30 years (grew up in a motorcycle family, and was then somewhere in his 40s), and (c) in all those years, the only injury he'd ever had was to the knee in question; so he'd worn the helmet where his experience told him was the most vulnerable place. The judge agreed that he had a point about the phrasing of the law, but declined to make a constitutional finding and suggested he could appeal. He paid the fine.
>I'd follow as many cops as I could and videotape them while they change lanes and turn without signaling. Then show it to the judge. The police need a new motto: "To Curb & Collect." Good luck, maybe the judge will reduce it to something like improper parking. At least that's what happened to me many yrs. ago when I pulled out of a parking lot without stopping.
A bit OT -- I have noticed that turn signals here in NJ may not mean what I think they mean. After I moved here from Chicago, whenever I turned on my blinkers to signal a lane change, other drivers seemed to interpret it to mean, "Speed up on this side of the car."
>Ellis, While it really stinks that you got caught doing something that is completely logical. Why bother signalling to no one? You will probably lose in court. After all, can you prove that there were no other drivers on the road?
Afraid to say it, but when it comes to traffic court, you are guilty until proven innocent. Good luck on such a clear violation.
I would go to court and plead that you had a bad signal and did not know it until the officer pointed it out. Buy a new bulb at the auto store and bring the receipt with you.
Brian in Brighton
In Colorado, signaling just gives the opposition an idea of what you're about to do. Best idea is just to cut the guy off :-)
>Lots of people get off tickets, but it is normally a technicality related to the improper filling out of the ticket, or other stuff. Try one of those local ticket services where you don't pay if they don't reduce or eliminate your ticket. You could also see if there is anything lower you can normally plead to, though that sounds pretty low to start with. I once got charged with dangerous driving when I rear ended someone. The officer said to plead it out to following too close, and that is what the court accepted. Apparently they had a special on dangerous driving that month.
>I used to live in Clinton, so I suspect that I know the light you were at (aren't that many!)
1.) Where was the police car in relation to you? He/she would need to be able to clearly see your right turn signal to know that you didn't signal (which also means that someone was around, right?) If he was sitting on the left side of the street, you might be able to argue that he couldn't see if you did/didn't have a blinker on...
2.) You probably won't beat the ticket, but you may be able to bargain down to something lesser. A lot depends on how you acted after he pulled you over and how the judge is feeling. You'll want to waive as many points as possible, since it's the insurance that is the killer, not the fine. Expect to go to court to do that- and be cordial when you do.
3.) Whatever you do, tell the truth! If you didn't have your blinker on and he's got you on video, you don't need to add that to your current headache. Your goal should be simply to minimize the insurance issues downstream. The Township of Clinton thanks you for you contribution, but they don't care too much about the insurnace company...
Good luck, and keep yourself out of hot water in the future!
>The judge told me that the way the city had written the ordinances, he could not dismiss the ticket unless I could prove that it was written in error - ie: put on the wrong car or something - no other reason was allowed. Could have been saving a baby from a rabid pit bull and I still would have had to pay the $150 for parking the wrong way in an alley.
The way I see it, this was a cheap "get out of jury duty for life" card.
>Steve, it was the intersection right at Exit 15, where the main drag turns right to the I78 ramp. The cop was sitting in the gas station at the corner, so he could see that I didn't bother to signal.
I appreciate everyone's suggestions, but I have the feeling it's going to be much more expensive to fight this than to pay it. (I'm assuming this can't be a very expensive fine, but we'll have to see about that.)
>Growing up in California, I was taught to hand signal as follows: arm out straight to the left meant "turning left;" arm pointing straight up meant "turning right" (not, as Trekkies might think, "about to get beamed up"); arm pointing straight down meant "stopping." When my dad had a Peugeot 403 on the lot for a while - first car with a sun roof I'd ever seen - I will confess that I was, for a bit, signaling turns by sticking my hand out the open sun roof and pointing right or left, fortunately never in front of a police officer who'd been raised in Clinton, NJ.
Then I got to Michigan and had to learn that sticking your arm out the window (pointing down, as I recall) meant "I'm going to turn left, turn right, or stop. You get to guess." Not that anyone in the Detroit area used hand signals much, except for one that seems universal in American cities. Michigan practice still makes no sense to me, though it would be a stretch to blame the state of American car manufacturing on hand signaling practices...
>I usually consider these kind of tickets as karma tickets. One for all the times I wasn't caught ... sort of a light reminder to watch the leadfoot. If I would consider you a rolling roadblock, disregard ;)
>Ellis, there is a local speed trap not too far from here (Wakefield). They give everybody a speeding ticket. You don't even have to stop, they will just throw one in your window if its open. You go to court and tell the judge your sad tail and if he likes your looks he reduces it to a non-moving violation. In other words, no impact on your driver's license (points) and no impact on your insurance.
I would look into reducing it to Improper Equipment or whatever the local equivalent is. Buy a bulb and claim the signal was broken. Pay the fine and be glad you weren't busted for more.
On a section of 295 that goes through Hopewell, VA for about a mile they have set up a new speed trap. Hopewell has actually bought cars and hire part timers to run the trap. They are giving out $40,000 a moth in tickets. I find it irksome. There is no reason to do this other than to suck revenue out of the crowd. It impedes the traffic so badly that the local State Cops actually do pr9 test rides though there. They occasionally set up three wide and ride through at the speed limit to prevent anyone speeding. I was working down that way daly and had to be very careful to go through there. On one occasion they came flying off the shoulder to go after someone and nearly hit me. I braked and swerved to avoid it. Too bad they didn't hit me, I could use a new truck. Local news ran a story on it. The Sheriff was very smirky about it. NO NO, there was no profit motive about it. The fines did not even go to the police department. I wonder how that federal investigation of the police dept. is coming?
So, If you drive through VA, don't use 295 if you are in a hurry.
>The cop made me turn it on just to make sure. I guess he'd been bitten by that defense before. This operation definitely struck me as a revenue generator, as I clearly was no threat to anyone in this case. All I could think was, "Hey, there are trucks right there on the Interstate doing 80 mph in a 55 zone, there are bozos passing on the right and weaving in and out of traffic, why me?"
>The law says you must use a turn signal. It doesn't require anyone to be present to see it. Your out of state plates identified you as a good target.
The same is true when you make a left turn across a lane of traffic. You must yield the right of way to all oncoming cars even if they were in the next county and doing Mach 2 before they hit you. Been there with my daughter, done that, paid the fine plus court costs.
>Whether you did or didn't isn't the issue any longer. If you have a look at the code on the back of the ticket, it will identify it as one with points or without points. Forget about the fine. You are stuck for that.
I had a ticket about 15 years ago for making an illegal hand signal to the a-hole that was tailgating me. Unfortunately, I had flipped him off 3 times when I realized he was a State Trooper. There's no talking your way out of that ticket.
The fine was reduced becasue I drove to Cape May (yeah, all the way down there!) to show up in court. One of the tickets was thrown out, and the other was dumbed down... saved me a bunch of money on fines. I think "Failure to signal" is a 2 point ticket in NJ...
The bigger issue is if there are points and you get an insurance surcharge. For three years, I paid about $300 extra for the finger I gave that guy. You need to work out a strategy to fight the ticket and have it "commuted" if it has points. I would try the "there wasn't any traffic to signal to and I didn't know I still had to" defense and ask for leniency (if your record is clean, you should be able to get some kind of break...) Wear a suit, be polite, and hope for the best (ticket turned into something with no points)
>Did you signal it ? Sorry. When Dad taught me to drive Mom's '68 VW Bug He did, in fact, beat me untill I signaled EVERY turn even when the only other road user was a black & white (holsteen) out in the middle of a corn feild.I still, to this day, signal my intention to do ANYTHING ! I just KNOW he'll find out !