A Lot of Naysayers
Rick Christopherson
>Ellis,
There are far too many naysayers in this thread that expect you to roll over without a fight for a ticket that is completely ridiculous in the first place. That is not how our legal system works. Granted, if the Judge is just as anal as the cop, then you can't win, but it can't hurt you to try.
In court, attitude and preparation is everything. If you go in there with the attitude that you were �shafted� by the cop, or that the Law is wrong, then you will lose. But you can still go in there and fight it. If it is a good Judge, he/she will even assist you.
When called up, without admitting guilt or innocence, ask that the charge be dismissed. Even if your arguments are wrong, it won't hurt you so long as you don�t demean the court in the process.
State that the charges should be dismissed because the allegation �does not fit either the letter of the law, nor the spirit of the law�. This give you two talking points, and make sure the Judge knows that you have two talking points, so they hear you out on both. Since you are not an attorney, you are probably best to begin with the �spirit of the law,� just in case the �letter of the law� argument is legally incorrect.
State that the spirit of the law is such that the turn signal is so that other �drivers� are aware of your intentions, yet there were no other �drivers� on roadways which would be in need of knowing your intentions. State that there were no vehicles approaching your position from ahead, behind, left, or right. Even though the officer observed your vehicle, he was not on a roadway, but was instead in a parking lot, and was not in need to know your intention. (All non-roadway traffic must yield to roadway traffic.)
Contrary to what others have said, the officer cannot simply invent facts after the fact. If he states that he observed a vehicle approaching from the exit ramp, then on cross examination ask him why this was not stated in his original report. He was thorough enough to confirm your blinker operation, so why would he not note other vehicles in his report. Set him up by showing how thorough he was, and then question why he could miss such a major observation in his report. Regardless, even if a vehicle is off in the distance, it does not automatically need to know your intentions, if your intentions will be carried out long before they approach your position.
Oh, as a side argument, you could question the officer as to whether he was in a position to observe hand signals from the driver�s window of your car. It makes no difference whether you did or did not hand-signal. If he cannot prove that you did not hand signal, then he cannot prove that you did not signal your turn. Hand signals are still legal forms of signaling in most, if not all, states. Remember, you are innocent until proven guilty, and he needs to prove you guilty.
The second talking point goes to the letter of the law, and this is where you can attempt to argue the wording of the code that a previous poster quoted. Because this was an exit ramp and you were making a right-hand turn, no other approaching vehicles from any direction would be impacted by your decision to turn or not.
Vehicles to the right or left have right-of-way, so they do not care (are not impacted by) your decision to turn, and I assume the entrance ramp ahead of you was a one-way road. That leaves vehicles behind you that are impacted. If they existed, they would still be required to stop regardless of your intention. Nevertheless, as you stated, there were no vehicles behind you. A vehicle in a parking lot is not impacted by your decision.
In the U.S. legal system, it doesn�t matter whether you are guilty or not, but how well you can play the game.