Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

OT Traffic ticket

Posts

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#26

Ellis Walentine

The only suit I own...

Ellis Walentine

>...is my b-day suit. :-) Oh, yes, and my old Speedo. I don't think I'm going to win any cases dressed like that.

I probably won't beat the rap, but if it saves me two points, I guess that counts for something. OTOH, I don't know if PA even records those Jersey points, and they amortize in a year anyhow.

Depending on where the courthouse is, I might just go for the not-guilty plea. Do they have a "technically guilty but effectively not" plea?

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#27

Every cloud......

Neal in San Jose

>The turn signals on my car have been intermittent for the last month or so (I know that sounds like a joke - but you know what I mean) and I've been procrastinating getting them fixed. I just made the appointment. Thanks, Ellis. Hopefully, next time you won't have to do anything quite so dramatic. Neal

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#28

Re: The only suit I own...

wilbur

>If you plead not guilty, and lose, the judge will in all probability not show you any leniency in fines or points.

If you show up to court, plead guilty, and have a good story, you are much more likely to get a reduced penalty. Here in East Brunswick, if you go to court and plead guilty, oftentimes they have you sit with one of the town prosecutors then and there to strike a deal.

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#29

Re: The only suit I own...

wilbur

>Also, in 39:4-126 of the NJ state law:

=======

Signaling before starting, turning or stopping

A signal of intention to turn right or left when required shall be given continuously during not less than the last 100 feet traveled by the vehicle before turning.

=======

No exceptions made for you being the only car at the intersection.

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#30

Re: OT Traffic ticket

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Sorry about your ticket Ellis.

If there was no one to signal to, then no one would have seen that you didn't signal, so you wouldn't have gotten the ticket.......

They must have been below quota last month......

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#31

Bart Goldberg

Re: OT Traffic ticket

Bart Goldberg

>I'd fight it. The law should never overrule common sense IMHO. If there was no one there to see you signal, then make your argument to the judge. I would also question if the cop was able to see you make that hand signal that he wasn't looking for :)

Good Luck

Bart

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#32

I'm no lawyer…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>…but I think I could argue this one. The statute reads, in part:

No person shall turn a vehicle at an intersection unless the vehicle is in proper position upon the roadway as required in section 39:4-123, or turn a vehicle to enter a private road or driveway or otherwise turn a vehicle from a direct course or move right or left upon a roadway, or start or back a vehicle unless and until such movement can be made with safety. No person shall so turn any vehicle without giving an appropriate signal in the manner hereinafter provided in the event any other traffic may be affected by such movement (emphasis added).


The whole statute can be read here but the really pertinent part is highlighted above. Reading some of the paragraph following without the above qualification could very well lead someone to believe a signal was required at all times.

I'd argue the heck on this. Mark?

Rod
Addy Protocol: Not only am I not a lawyer, I don't even play one on TV.

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#33

But You're No TRIAL lawyer�

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Judge: "So, Mr. Walentine, Patrolman Timmons says you failed to signal for a turn. Is that correct?"

EW: " Well, judge, I wouldn't say 'failed', more like decided I didn't need to because I checked and there weren't any other vehicles within a 100 yards to signal to. I think the statute says to signal only 'if the movement will effect other drivers' or something like that, so I didn't."

Judge: "In fact, Mr. Walentine, you're perfectly correct. It does say just that."

Judge: "Officer Timmons?"

Officer Timmons: "Judge, from my vantage point I observed 2 vehicles exiting the interstate from 190 feet to the left, one pick-up about to enter the roadway behind the subject vehicle from the gas station where I was located at the time, and a panel truck approaching the intersection from the opposite direction at about 400 feet."

Judge: " Mr. Walentine, I know the location is a busy intersection, especially at that time of day. Are you sure you looked carefully before deciding not to use your turn signal?"

EW: "Oh yes sir, I looked in all directions."

Judge: "Guilty as charged. Mr. Walentine, it's a good idea just to make it a habit to always use your signals, if nothing more than to avoid 2 points on your record. NEXT CASE!"

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#34

Use the tree falling in the woods argument!!

Frank in Forest Hill

>

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#35

Re: The blinker was working

Barry Irby

>Smart Cop, Beat you to the punch. Here's what you do. Tape a fuse puller to the fuse that controls the blinkers. Keep it there for the next fourteen years until you get stopped again. Very quickly pull the fuse.

The thing that bothers me about this type of law enforcement is that it isn't about anything other than revenue. We have a street locally that got a bad reputation for accidents and people getting hurt. They have cranked down on it and slowed the traffic down and gotten the accident rate way down. Fine with me. Everybody benefits. But the one I mentioned about the speed trap on 295 has nothing to do with slowing traffic and reducing accidents. There weren't any accidents. It's a waste of police time in terms of reducing crime. I'd like to see the public slow down through there just to leave them holding the bag for the cars and salaries.

They just ran a story on the local news about Petersburg having a traffic light that has a red arrow pointing to the right. We have a right turn on red law. The local cops are giving tickets to people who turn right on the red arrow. Apparently there is no (clear?) definition of a red arrow. Some cases have been dropped when challenged, but plenty of people have been fined.

My point is, you are guilty because they say you are. Nothing to do with justice or law enforcement, only revenue. The double whammy aspect bothers me too. Insurance costs more if you live in the wrong zip code and then goes up if you get busted for running a red light. You get fined by the court and pay more for the insurance. Wait, wasn't I already paying more? That red light was in the same zip code. Wasn't I prepaying for the privilege of living near it?

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#36

Ellis Walentine

You made your point, counselor :-)

Ellis Walentine

>I guess it'll always be my word against the cop's. But I once had a ticket thrown out because the cop didn't bother to show up in court.

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#37

No Shows

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The Cop Shop and Traffic Court are in the same building in Clinton, and court appearances are paid time (or overtime) for dos Boyz-in-Blooo.

So, are ya Feelin' Lucky . . . |;-}}}}}

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#38

Re: OT Traffic ticket

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Oh, man....what a bummer Ellis. Hope you find a way to beat it.

:(

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#39

Re: I'm no lawyer�

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I'm no lawyer either. But, after 20 years riding crotch rockets I've had more than my share of traffic court appearances. Only once have I seen an officer no-show (never in my case), so you were very lucky there.

The times I do see people (including myself) get out of a ticket is when they have a vaild and reasonable argument. I'd say Rod's argment is pretty good.

But, it is a hassle and insurance doesn't usually raise your premiums for minor violations. Overall, I'd give you a 50/50 chance with Rod's argument. Just do your research and show up with the statute printed and highlighted (suit not required, so put away the speedo). IMO, judges tend to reward intelligence and reason in traffic court.

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#40

Ellis, move west

Don in Northern Arizona

>In Arizona, turn signals are totally optional. That's not what they tell you in defensive driving school (Yes, unfortunately, I almost have a post graduate degree in defensive driving), but that is the truth. I once was traveling behind a black & white with no turn signal on who was sitting behind a civilian with no turn signal on. One went right, the other went left no one went to jail.

Don

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#41

Looking at it from another angle . . . .

Pete in Holland, MI

>Since nobody was there, do I need to signal?

Since nobody was there, did I need to stop at the light/sign?

Since nobody is there, do I need to stay on my side of the road?

Since nobody is there, to I need to observe the speed limit?

Most laws are written with disregard to the traffic currently being encountered. If you open up that door, a lot of judgment calls create a lot of gray area in deciding right & wrong (both the owner/operator, and the police). Practice makes perfect, thus turn the blinker on at every lane/direction change that may affect other drivers, even if they are not there. If this action is automatic, then you won't create a traffic problem when you should have had it on, but were distracted & didn't put it on.

This, from a guy who often drives home late at night, sitting totally alone at traffic signals, wondering the same thing.

Pete

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#42

Ellis Walentine

Good points, Pete

Ellis Walentine

>After reading Rod's post, I went back and confirmed that the law actually states, in the case of turn signals, that "No person shall so turn any vehicle without giving an appropriate signal in the manner hereinafter provided in the event any other traffic may be affected by such movement. In other words, they are leaving it up to the motorist to decide whether it is necessary based on whether or not other traffic will be affected. The stoplight and stop sign laws and the speed limits don't allow for such user discretion. That's why I think the intent of the law (actual wording notwithstanding) is for common sense and reasonable judgement to prevail. If the officer had let common sense prevail, he wouldn't have bothered to stop me.

I think Mark's scenario is probably right, though, and all the patrolman will have to do is say I'm lying. Still, the thought of paying exorbitant insurance rates for the next several years because of this makes me inclined to respectfully plead my case. We'll see.

Anyhow, I'm sorry to clutter up the boards with this endless hand-wringing over something as OT and trivial. Thanks for your input and words of wisdom.

Ellis

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#43

Truth Not the Issue

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Boss,

The cop won't call you a liar, he'll merely point out that there were/was traffic which you didn't see (the truck in the gas station in my scenario). You could, of course testify in great detail about how many directions you checked, you paint a picture of your head spinning around to all points of the compass, but it still won't save you from not having signaled to the "guy you didn't see." With both you and the cop testifying truthfully as to what you each did (or didn't) see, you pay the fine unless YOU can prove that the cop is lying.

sorry Boss

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#44

Re: Good points, Pete

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>"Anyhow, I'm sorry to clutter up the boards with this endless hand-wringing over something as OT and trivial."

It's not clutter, it's interesting. Good luck with da judge!

PC

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#45

Re: Plead Insanity

Brian in Brighton

>You could say that you had been thinking:

..about rain forest destruction

..you're Uncle Louie who had just been confirmed with Swine Flu and how you're not feely very well

..the current state of the economy

..how much you lost at the illegal poker tournament last night

..how much you miss your late great dog who died when you were 5 and your dad lied about how it "ran away"

..Arlen Specter

..the imminent control of Congress of your party, the other party (it's a crap shoot if the Judge agrees)

..the war in the Middle East, Iraq, Afghanistan, etc etc

..your cousin who was just kidnapped off the shore of Somalia

..how you had a huge chipout in a piece of prime AAAAA grade quilted maple

..the US response when the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor :-)

Or just please brain dead because you missed your morning coffee, saw the cop and thought you would test his skills.

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#46

Maybe Not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>One of the state sanatoriums [Hagedorne] is only 4 miles from the court. I've been there on a pro bono assignment; Ellis would not care for the accommodations.

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#47

Re: Good points, Pete

bob marino

>Ellis,

Just another thought to possibly save you time and/or apprehension. Call your insurance company and ask what is their policy if you get 2 points on your liscence (I think that's the penalty?) and what if the points were aquired from another state (NJ). You may be surprise and releived to learn that there may be little or no financial assessment attached.

I have a NJ liscense and got a ticket for "running through" a red light 2 years ago, wasted a half a day going to court and "pleading" my case to the judge, paid a fine, got assessed 3 points from NYC, but those points never went on my NJ liscence - or at least I was not penalized with increased insurance premiums.

As to your original "infraction" - wtf ever happened to a police officer (after stopping you and checking your liscense to make sure you don't have any negative history) offering a friendly warning?

This type of ticketing is not about ensuring/maintainig traffic safety, it's about police/traffic quotas and collecting town/city county revenue, pure and simple.

Bob

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#48

A Lot of Naysayers

Rick Christopherson

>Ellis,

There are far too many naysayers in this thread that expect you to roll over without a fight for a ticket that is completely ridiculous in the first place. That is not how our legal system works. Granted, if the Judge is just as anal as the cop, then you can't win, but it can't hurt you to try.

In court, attitude and preparation is everything. If you go in there with the attitude that you were �shafted� by the cop, or that the Law is wrong, then you will lose. But you can still go in there and fight it. If it is a good Judge, he/she will even assist you.

When called up, without admitting guilt or innocence, ask that the charge be dismissed. Even if your arguments are wrong, it won't hurt you so long as you don�t demean the court in the process.

State that the charges should be dismissed because the allegation �does not fit either the letter of the law, nor the spirit of the law�. This give you two talking points, and make sure the Judge knows that you have two talking points, so they hear you out on both. Since you are not an attorney, you are probably best to begin with the �spirit of the law,� just in case the �letter of the law� argument is legally incorrect.

State that the spirit of the law is such that the turn signal is so that other �drivers� are aware of your intentions, yet there were no other �drivers� on roadways which would be in need of knowing your intentions. State that there were no vehicles approaching your position from ahead, behind, left, or right. Even though the officer observed your vehicle, he was not on a roadway, but was instead in a parking lot, and was not in need to know your intention. (All non-roadway traffic must yield to roadway traffic.)

Contrary to what others have said, the officer cannot simply invent facts after the fact. If he states that he observed a vehicle approaching from the exit ramp, then on cross examination ask him why this was not stated in his original report. He was thorough enough to confirm your blinker operation, so why would he not note other vehicles in his report. Set him up by showing how thorough he was, and then question why he could miss such a major observation in his report. Regardless, even if a vehicle is off in the distance, it does not automatically need to know your intentions, if your intentions will be carried out long before they approach your position.

Oh, as a side argument, you could question the officer as to whether he was in a position to observe hand signals from the driver�s window of your car. It makes no difference whether you did or did not hand-signal. If he cannot prove that you did not hand signal, then he cannot prove that you did not signal your turn. Hand signals are still legal forms of signaling in most, if not all, states. Remember, you are innocent until proven guilty, and he needs to prove you guilty.

The second talking point goes to the letter of the law, and this is where you can attempt to argue the wording of the code that a previous poster quoted. Because this was an exit ramp and you were making a right-hand turn, no other approaching vehicles from any direction would be impacted by your decision to turn or not.

Vehicles to the right or left have right-of-way, so they do not care (are not impacted by) your decision to turn, and I assume the entrance ramp ahead of you was a one-way road. That leaves vehicles behind you that are impacted. If they existed, they would still be required to stop regardless of your intention. Nevertheless, as you stated, there were no vehicles behind you. A vehicle in a parking lot is not impacted by your decision.

In the U.S. legal system, it doesn�t matter whether you are guilty or not, but how well you can play the game.

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#49

Re: A Lot of Naysayers

Rick Christopherson

>Oops. After rereading what I wrote last night, I just realized that you do not want to bring up the notion of using hand signals, as this is an argument that you would make if you were pleading not guilty. You do not want to plead not guilty because you will lose. You are asking for the charges to be dismissed, which is not the same as pleading not guilty, so you do not want to make a defense that you might have signaled. Doing so would diminish your stance on asking for the charges to be dismissed.

Re: OT Traffic ticket

#50

Ellis Walentine

Hmm

Ellis Walentine

>The ticket clearly gives me exactly two options: 1) Plead guilty and pay the fine; or 2) call at least 7 days in advance of the court date to notify the court that I plan to plead not guilty. "Ask for dismissal" isn't on the list, so I'm guessing they need to know if I'm going to show up in court so they can put the cop on notice that he has to show up and make his case. It says, "If you fail to notify the court, it may be necessary for you to make additional court appearances." Humbug. What a racket.

I do appreciate your suggestions, Rick. I just have to remember to retain my composure as I humbly beg to differ. Oh, and I won't lie about making hand signals that I didn't make, so that's a non-issue. I have to win or lose this one on its merits.

There could be a sighting possible here. :-)

Ellis