"Nuts & Bolts Litigation" [long]
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Perhaps to make some sense of it for you, Larry . . .
In any suit arising out of a possibly defective piece of machinery, known as "product liability" in the law, the action is primarily based upon contract law and the express or implied warranties that go along with the sales contract. Therefore the injured person, who only has a contract with the guy he dealt with (called "privity of contract"), must sue his vendor as the primary defendant. He then "sues up the privity chain" to wholesalers and others in the distribution chain because if he omits one who may be actually at fault, his case could easily be dismissed with no compensation for his injury. Everybody in the chain, in turn, brings a claim for indemnification against everyone else. The net result here is that the Court may have 3 or more insurance companies for the various parties negotiating a settlement and apportioning the damages and costs relative to who actually did or didn't do something that caused the harm. Without all those "players" in the game, in becomes very difficult, if not impossible, to resolve the case with the blame placed where it should in the context of a single action which is much more efficient than 3, 4 or 10 independent cases in 6 different courthouses which might produce conflicting results creating an even bigger mess.
Suppose I buy a JET table saw from Joe The Tool Guy in my town. Joe has preped the machine for me and, nice guy that he is, puts it in my garage at no extra charge. I plug it in and turn the saw on only to have the arbor promptly fracture into 4 pieces allowing the blade to rip through the cover plate and my hand. After I get out of the hospital, I go after Joe, who has primary responsibility for selling me a defective machine, and JET who issued a warranty on the machine itself that gives me, the end user, certain rights. Joe claims against JET for selling him the defective machine, and JET claims against Joe for faulty preparation + goes after Tae-Won-Do, Inc., the Taiwanese foundry who made the part that failed. Tae-Won, in turn, goes after Too-Bad-So-Sad Corporation, who provided the quality control services that missed the defective part, plus Schlunk LLC who made the cover plate that was supposed to prevent the blade from leaving the saw cabinet in case the arbor broke. "Wait," you say, "Why the hell do all these guys have to be in your law suit?" Well, remember that somebody's going to have to pay my damages; probably JET's insurance company, who will then seek to be paid back by whomever was responsible. But anyone and everyone who is potentially liable for any part of that money has an absolute right to contest how much I get paid for my mangled hand before anyone holds them responsible. This includes my friend Joe. Why? Well Joe put the thing together and delivered it to my garage, and Joe may have overtightened that arbor nut or something else that actually cracked the casting. I, of course, don't know that until after the whole thing sorts out between the various defendants.
As is often said, "It ain't a perfect system, but it works better than anything else we've come up with so far."