Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Posts

Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#1

Oneida V3000 is on the way!

David Sparks

>After much research and asking a lot of questions I've finally ordered an Oneida V3000. The Recession Buster package they're offering comes with a HEPA filter that seemed too small. I talked to the owner of Wynn Environmental, and he said I would be fine with the standard filter that normally comes with the V3000. It is a larger filter than the HEPA one included in the package deal. I talked the Oneida sales rep into substituting the cheaper spunbond filter in place of the more expensive HEPA filter but was unable to get any price break. Oh well! I probably should have ordered a Clear vue, but I didn't want to do the extra work to get it set up. I was also concerned about the noise level and wanted to be able to move the cyclone around a little until I figure out where everything will work best in my shop. Thanks for all your help with this decision. I'll let you know how the V3000 does when I get it.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#2

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Larry in NW Ohio

>Your going to be happy with it. I have the 3HP Industrial unit. That`s what they called it about 6yrs. ago. They change things around every once in awhile and call put a different name on it. It sounds like a really nice outfit. Good luck. Larry in Ohio

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#3

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

David G. Sparks

>Thanks, Larry. I'm looking forward to getting the cyclone. I've been using an Ace 2 hp that sits on top of a 55 gal. drum for years. The V3000 is going to be a big improvement. Have a good day.

Dave

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#4

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Larry in NW Ohio

>David What kind of piping are you going tp put in? I used S&D pvc and really like it for the ease of use and especially when you want to redo things and you will some day redo things. Larry in Ohio

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#5

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

David Sparks

>Hi Larry,

I'm going to use 6" SD pipe eventually, but I'll be dragging the flex hose for a little while. It's going to take me some time to puzzle out how and where the piping will need to go. It's all kind of overwhelming. Thanks for your help.

Dave

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#6

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Fred Davis

>Send Onieda a footprint of your shop and the proposed location of your equipment and they will design a duct system , no charge.

Also will recommend the type of duct used and why some is not a good idea.

FredD

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#7

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Larry in NW Ohio

>David How big is your outlet on your cyclone? If they have an 8" outlet then you should come out with an 8" for a few feet also and then drop down to 6". But since you are only going to use flex for now 6" will be good untill you go for stationary system. Also you should think about blast gates when you put in you piping. I built mine and I would suggest doing that when you get that far, it`s so easy and I think they are better, and I also put automatic openers and closers on them so I wouldn`t leave some open or forget to open them. It`s so nice not to have to walk around to open them, and they didn`t cost so much since I made them from various parts. Good luck. Don`t the days seem like they are a lot longer waiting for nice toys. Larry

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#8

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

David Sparks

>Larry, the inlet on the cyclone is 6". I appreciate your input. Homemade blast gates would be better and cheaper. Have a good day.

Dave

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#9

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Darin in Victoria

>Anyone know how the V3000 compares to the 2.5 HP Gorrilla? I'm contemplating getting one of these units (or Clearvue, or build myself) at some point and the cost difference comes out almost $500 CDN difference.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#10

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Paul Andrus

>I've received my new V3000,and am waiting for Oneida to send me the shop layout.Is there any advantage to using the metal spiral pipe vs. the PVC? The extra cost is not a big issue, as I'll be doing woodworking for many years,and static buildup is an issue.I'd rather spend a few dollars more and not have to ground the PVC. Any thoughts?

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#11

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way! *LINK*

mdclor

>Paul,

I used PVC for my system. Yes, static does build and I don't think there is a way to ground it since the PVC is an insulator. However, I think the cost of using metal is more than a few dollars. Once you get the design from Oneida price it both ways. One disadvantage of PVC beyond the static issue is the lack of long 90* elbows. I solved that by using 2 45* elbows with a short straight section in between them. I think PVC is easier to work with when changes need to be made to your layout, but that might be just me. For everything you want to know and more about dust collection, check out Bill Pentz's site.

HTH,

Merle


Bill's site

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#12

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I used PVC and saved hundreds of dollars. If cost isn't an issue, go with metal. It's probably easier to deal with overall anyway. Especially if you buy all the parts made to fit together from one place. With PVC, there's lots of fiddling to get blast gates, pipes, flex tubing, and other stuff working together.

Jay St. Peter

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#13

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Fred Davis

>You bought the best Paul so finish with the best.

Oneida's spiral metal duct swirls the air thought the duct with considerable less turbulence then just straight wall pipe can do.

In addition they make very good blast gates and different connectors for any application , once you get these then your set.

For not to much more money , you can get remotes , I have three , two in stationary places around the shop and one in my shop apron.

Saves a lot of walking.

FredD

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#14

Oneida ducts swirl air

David Hammelef

>I never heard the Oneida ducts are not smooth on the inside?

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#16

Re: Oneida ducts swirl air

David Hammelef

>That looks relatively smooth in there. Nothing that is going to cause the air to swirl.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#17

Re: Oneida ducts

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>are more rigid that straight/smooth HVAC pipe. The spiral dimple imparts a bit of dimensional strength to the pipe to resist crushing with a thinner grade of metal. To actually spin the airflow in a tube that large you'd need vanes on the interior that would decrease the flow substantially and probably just pile up with debris on the trailing (leeward) edges.

S&D PVC is way cheaper, much easier to run, quieter and just fine for intermittent home/small shop use. Metal ducting is better for commercial/industrial systems that run continuously with heave debris streams.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#18

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Barry Irby

>I don't have any side by side comparison experience. I ran SD PVC because it was readily available and cheaper, much cheaper. In a one man shop I usually only have one gate open at a time. so 6" and 4" ducting seem like enough. I spent a lot of time on Bill Pentz site and scratching my head. I worked hard to put the blast gates in convenient places and used the Long Ranger ones with the remote switches so that turning on a machine is a two step process, rather than three steps. My shop is in a single car garage so none of the runs are very long, probably not over 20', but I have had no trouble with static. I have had very minor shocks off the flex going to my Performax occasionally, but my cat has shocked me worse in winter. Almost not noticeable. The Danger of a static dust fire has been disproved and is non-existent in a home shop.

The plastic pipe was easy to work with and handle and light weight. The metal might be tougher to cut and heavier. There were issues with making connections. There were no standard sizes, who knew four inches could be such a variety of sizes? But it was just a head scratcher and a PITA. Once you solved it in one place, the same solution worked every where. Can't imagine I would be any happier with with a metal system, works great.

One thing I started doing that may be helping with the static. I ran a piece of foil tape through some of the pipes in the top side and then ran a strip along the top on the outside. Ran a short screw though each coupling to tie it all together, physically and electrically and grounded one of the screws. Only did a little of that before I got tired of it, but it may be helping.

Don't those metal pipes have a rubber gasket in the couplings? How do they maintain the ground?

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#19

The Static Boogyman Just Won't Die

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>PVC is a fine insulator that can't be grounded. Any static charge that builds up on the plastic surface will not "travel" more than a 1/8" to a grounding wire or tape, so if you feel the need to ground your ducts, use metal ductwork. You can confirm this simple principal buy tightly wrapping a nice copper grounded wire (say about 24 ga.) around the outside of your PVC duct in a spiral with 12" between the wraps. Leave it for a month or two, and then look at it. You'll find that the mild static on the plastic has attracted the very fine dust from your shop air in the same way that an electrostatic air cleaner works in a forced air heating/cooling system. But you should also see a light strip about a 1/4" wide running along under that copper ground wire.

Keep in mind, however, that this static spark thing is more Internet myth than anything else. There have been no documented fires in home/small shop systems caused by static sparks. Reason being that, while there may be a little static and a little "pop" spark generated, the actual spark is no where near HOT enough to ignite anything like wood dust, especially in the concentrations of a home/hobby shop. There HAVE been fires in small DC systems caused by burning chips and dust or hot metal shavings coming off a working blade and landing in a dust bag and then fanned by the airflow to get/keep things going. If you're smelling smoke coming off your blade, you'd do well to check your DC bag.

The other factor is the length of time the system is actually running. Static can build up to sufficient levels in large systems that are CONTINUOUSLY RUNNING for 8-12 hour shifts which is one reason why such systems are always done in metal. Also why production exhaust systems for finishing areas are completely separate. Intermittent home systems simply don't have the opportunity to build heavy static charges because of their short run times and small debris streams. PVC is an insulator but not a battery; as soon as you turn the thing off, any charge present begins to dissipate in the air quite rapidly.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#20

Re: Oneida ducts swirl air

Fred Davis

>The number of air handling "expert" opinions on the subject of dust collection on this site is absolutely amazing.

You can tell right away they have been in Cabinet shops and studied the subject intensely.

I can't imagine a need for metal ducting after browsing the learned discourse here on advantages of plastic versus metal, it's nothing short of astounding.

I think I will call up the Engineer at Oneida and ask for my money back.

I was laboring under the impression that since every shop I have worked in and every one I have owned, had metal ducting and was required by the city in which they were in, that was the standard approach to dust and chip collection , even Oneida strongly recommended it.

So one can see how I must feel about being led astray all of these years.

FredD

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#21

Re: Oneida ducts swirl air

Larry in NW Ohio

>Fred Is it any wonder they recomend it, THEY sell it. Not to say they are wrong. But I`ll tell you if some unscrupulous WW would have a fire in his dust barrel under one of Oneida`s DC, you would see lawyer`s lined up outside his door. That`s not meant to put down lawyer on this forum, just the not so honest ones. Oneida has to cover their butt`s just like all the other company`s in this country. Larry

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#22

Re: Oneida ducts swirl air

Fred Davis

>Larry, if a woodworker were unfortunate enough to get a fire in his dust collector , why would that make him a "unscrupulous WW" ??

As for the recommendation of metal duct by Oneida, why would they recommend something less then what is required in every city I lived in.

Of course they may be in cahoots with the code writers, never thought of that.

On the other hand all Cyclone manufacturers sell the metal duct , probably foremost because it is required by Fire Marshal types in commercial Cabinet shops which is the only kind I am familiar with.

FredD

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#23

Re: Oneida ducts swirl air

David Hammelef

>Fred,

There are lots of things required by code for professional buildings that are overkill for a home.

I was only questioning your swirl comment.. Which appears to have been a miss statement. There ducting does not impart any air swirling effect it is smooth on the inside.

As for the PVC vs Metal debate... its been on going for years. Lots of knowledgeable people here and elsewhere have studied it.

My opinion based on that research a spark from the duct work causing a home explosion is most likely not possible and if it is, it is very very very very small. And decreases if your only running 1 or 2 hrs a day. Which I am. Of course I don't have my cyclone hooked to anything right now. When I did it was PVC of course its all of 10 ft long.

If there were any recorded event of PVC causing an explosion you bet the Oneida and others would have it on their websites.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#24

Re: Oneida ducts swirl air

Larry in NW Ohio

>Fred I`m sorry, I reread my post and see I must have had a brain fart, as usual. I wanted to say, If a WW would have PVC for DC and had a fire that there would be an unscrupulous lawyer somewhere that would take someone to court. The way I hear about some lawsuits go, and I don`t want to start something here, that some lawyers drag everyone from the maker of the DC to the person that sold the WW a bolt and nut that would connect the DC to the saw. It just doesn`t make any sense. Again I`m sorry I wasn`t very clear in my post. Larry

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#25

"Nuts & Bolts Litigation" [long]

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Perhaps to make some sense of it for you, Larry . . .

In any suit arising out of a possibly defective piece of machinery, known as "product liability" in the law, the action is primarily based upon contract law and the express or implied warranties that go along with the sales contract. Therefore the injured person, who only has a contract with the guy he dealt with (called "privity of contract"), must sue his vendor as the primary defendant. He then "sues up the privity chain" to wholesalers and others in the distribution chain because if he omits one who may be actually at fault, his case could easily be dismissed with no compensation for his injury. Everybody in the chain, in turn, brings a claim for indemnification against everyone else. The net result here is that the Court may have 3 or more insurance companies for the various parties negotiating a settlement and apportioning the damages and costs relative to who actually did or didn't do something that caused the harm. Without all those "players" in the game, in becomes very difficult, if not impossible, to resolve the case with the blame placed where it should in the context of a single action which is much more efficient than 3, 4 or 10 independent cases in 6 different courthouses which might produce conflicting results creating an even bigger mess.

Suppose I buy a JET table saw from Joe The Tool Guy in my town. Joe has preped the machine for me and, nice guy that he is, puts it in my garage at no extra charge. I plug it in and turn the saw on only to have the arbor promptly fracture into 4 pieces allowing the blade to rip through the cover plate and my hand. After I get out of the hospital, I go after Joe, who has primary responsibility for selling me a defective machine, and JET who issued a warranty on the machine itself that gives me, the end user, certain rights. Joe claims against JET for selling him the defective machine, and JET claims against Joe for faulty preparation + goes after Tae-Won-Do, Inc., the Taiwanese foundry who made the part that failed. Tae-Won, in turn, goes after Too-Bad-So-Sad Corporation, who provided the quality control services that missed the defective part, plus Schlunk LLC who made the cover plate that was supposed to prevent the blade from leaving the saw cabinet in case the arbor broke. "Wait," you say, "Why the hell do all these guys have to be in your law suit?" Well, remember that somebody's going to have to pay my damages; probably JET's insurance company, who will then seek to be paid back by whomever was responsible. But anyone and everyone who is potentially liable for any part of that money has an absolute right to contest how much I get paid for my mangled hand before anyone holds them responsible. This includes my friend Joe. Why? Well Joe put the thing together and delivered it to my garage, and Joe may have overtightened that arbor nut or something else that actually cracked the casting. I, of course, don't know that until after the whole thing sorts out between the various defendants.

As is often said, "It ain't a perfect system, but it works better than anything else we've come up with so far."