Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Oneida V3000 is on the way!

Posts

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#26

Re: Oneida ducts swirl air

Fred Davis

>No problem Larry, and your right , anytime a personal injury looks like a retirement act to a Lawyer , then you know.......

As for the turbulence in smooth tubes versus spiral , that is Oneida's engineers comment.

I never had any intention of getting in a plastic is better because it is cheaper argument, because it isn't allowed in shops.

Dust collection is regulated in one form or another by Fire Marshals using the cities adopted year of the NFPA standard 664 document.

They go into fire spread rates, finely divided dust collection (dust under 420 microns , and in most if not all cases , a cyclonic system is designed , blue printed and signed off on by a Mechanical Engineer.

Explosive dust control is a complete chapter, whether you can return filtered air from the outside cyclone to keep in the heat in the winter is another arguement, that you have to prove your filtering system is check valved and so on. Read some of it , it will make your head ache .;-))

That is where the Engineer at Onieda comes in.

FredD

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#27

There Oughta Be A Law

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Well Fred, for someone who obviously holds lawyers in contempt, you certainly waste no time going to the law books to cite regulations that are almost always written by lawyers, and most often follow some "personal injury" (or wrongful death) law suit brought by some other set of attorneys (whom you also mock) to correct deficiencies in safe working conditions or real and present dangers to the health and welfare of all of us. Americans are one of the most regulated societies on the planet which follows from the old phrase that is the title of this post.

So, in your search for regulations, fire codes, and engineering papers applicable to dust collection systems in manufacturing facilities and commercial shops, did you happen to run across any that apply to home and hobby shops that the people on this board should be aware of? Before I put in my system, I checked my area and even asked code officials here and found nothing, so I, for one, would absolutely like to know about this, and will be the first to applaud your effort. If there is, in fact, the looming risk of fire in PVC ductwork that you and the boys up at Oneida appear to rely upon, it certainly seems (OSHA aside) that some statutes or regulations would have been adopted long ago to prevent such use by clueless homeowners, especially given the expanding use of such systems by hobbyists over the last 20 years.

Even more curious is the complete lack of prohibition of PVC systems by homeowners' insurance companies who are, after all, hyper sensitive to any risk of loss and damage, are always seeking ways to avoid paying claims by having their policies carefully drafted by more lawyers, and are the ones who will have pay when Joe Woodworker burns down the house because of his ungrounded plastic-piped vacuum.

Come to think of it, shouldn't we also be outlawing residential central vacuum cleaner systems as well because they ALL use that same static electricity-generating flammable PVC piping? Especially since such installations all have live wires strapped along the piping for outlet switches and/or powered accessories which may be able to induce a charge on the plastic beyond that generated by dust and air moving through the system piping.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#28

Standard spiral duct...

John in NM

>Thats exactly what it looks like, most major cities have a business or two that make it. I had understood that it was made as a spiral for strength and ease of manufacture, never heard the swirling one before. Could be plausible, differential equations was a very long time ago, so I won't attempt to evaluate that one :)

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#29

Re: Spiral Pipe *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The manufacturer mentions a lot about increased strength with less weight and reduced cost with thinner gauge metal, but they don't say a word about swirling airflow or why that is somehow a benefit.


Spiral Duct Co.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#30

Re: Spiral Pipe

Fred Davis

>Mark , your my Hero , keep up the good work.

Why, I would ask if a system or a tool , or a machine or wiring or ducting was deemed more safe done to specs in a commercial shop , why would the same wiring , ducting , machine , tool , method of work be just as safe , done in a cost cutting , compliance avoiding approach in a hobby shop , one some have converted the attached garage to in some cases.

Ask your friendly Home Owner Insurance Agent that question.

FredD

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#31

Me? A Hero?!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Just trying to help some fellow woodworkers, Fred. It is the nature of this board after all.

BTW, I've no doubt that metal ducting will work just great in a home shop, and for those who need or want to spend the money for it, all's well. In fact, I have clients who, in their multi-million dollar apartments in Manhattan, put up the same stuff up for their HVAC etc. because it goes with their decorating style of "industrial chic."

But for the rest of us peons trying to save our scheckels for the doctor bills in our old age plus pass something along to our kids when we go, PVC seems to get the job done for a whole lot less (1/5th) money.

There are way too many vendors out there who use fear and half truths as sales pitches. Sure PVC will burn (and metal won't), but unless the system is done wrong, there's nothing in the duct to burn to begin with. Yes, static discharges have caused fire and explosions in industrial settings (and grain elevators), but never in occasional use home woodshops. People read about a static spark causing a fire, get a little spark off their tool, and right away think their shop is about to explode unless they go through some fancy rigamarole with grounding systems and elaborate stuff all because some engineer truthfully says, "static sparks cause fire in dusty environments." They don't tell you about how strong (hot) the spark must be. They don't tell you how saturated the air must be with what kind of dust or vapors for it to be possible to explode. If they did, you probably wouldn't be buying their stuff.

Remember, "A half truth is the most pernicious of lies because it can't be disproven, only explained."

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#32

no one mentioned PVC here....

John in NM

>Perhaps you're thinking of another post.

If you have something more to say about spiral duct manufacturing, I'd love to hear it. We installed this stuff in a shop I worked for, and I was really impressed with it. Its a readily available, relatively low cost product, and the companies that make it can usually help you out with system design.

I am way out of touch with Oneida's product line these days, when we installed the spiral duct, Oneida was selling this really fancy snap locking stuff, but no spiral.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#33

Re: no one mentioned PVC here....

Fred Davis

>John ,

glad to hear a real life experience on the subject other then my own.

As you said , it works very good , I have had a Onieda industrial cyclone with Oneidas spiral duct for about ten years, I think the spiral was all they were including in the bid, works for me and many others .

Oneida contrary to what you may hear , has to follow accepted industry standards for what they design ,manufacture, and sell.

Like I said in another attempt, it's regulated, NFPA code , Fire Marshal, building official enforcement.

The duct is snap together, which really pleased the installer. End of this thread for me.

FredD

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#34

Don't mistake me...

John in NM

>I have no dog in the metal/PVC fight and I am categorically not interested in listening to your interpretation of industrial building and fire codes and wether they apply to residential structures.

I was hoping there was some substance to be discussed re airflow that someone with better math skills than my own could shed some light on. As far as I know, air and material carried in air will always spiral in a round duct to some degree. I would imagine the effect is proportional to air velocity, and I would further imagine that dust and chips will act to limit the effect by slowing down the airflow, adding friction with the pipe walls and turbulence within the airstream. I've seen this method used to deliver coal dust fuel to a burner at a portland cement plant, so I'd guess there's quite a bit of study thats been done on the subject.

I did go and look at Oneida's site. The spiral pipe was not an option last time I looked - more than 10 years ago, but I may be mis-remembering. I do remember thinking those clamps were pretty neat, but cost prohibitive for our application. The duct installers used screws and tape.

Re: Oneida V3000 is on the way!

#35

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Fred, I forgot to mention that if you were to "covert" your garage as you mention, it will void your homeowner's insurance regardless of what kind of ductwork you might have. That policy insures a home, not a commercial venture or a manufacturing site I've had several consults with people who found themselves on the icky end of an insurance company's policy limitations club after a loss. It's tough to have to point out the liability exclusions and "gotchas" in the reams of fine print on "page 90, paragraph #744(a)(6)(zzz)" of a policy they never actually read, and simply relied on what some insurance agent told them only to find out that whatever the mutt said is meaningless and not binding of the insurance company. "But nobody ever told me about that!" or "But the agent said. . .!" is the cry, and it's very rough to see the tears well up when they realize that they've truly lost everything and have nowhere to turn but to start over from scratch.