Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Electrical engineer . . .

Posts

Electrical engineer . . .

#1

Electrical engineer . . .

steve mackay

>48 and always wondered. If there is a "perfectly good" answer I'll die a happy man. Why are hospital outlets "upside down" ?

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#2

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Henry Higginbotham

>If you mean why is the ground on top, it's because that's the way it is supposed to be. Examine enough duplex receptacles and you'll find a few that actually have "top" marked on them, and . . . guess what?

From a practical standpoint, installing a receptacle with the ground on top largely prevents the broken plastic around the ground socket. More cords get stepped on than get yanked upward.

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#3

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Fred Davis

>If I remember correctly , NEC started mandating ground on top in the early eighties

This is intended to prevent shorts if a metal object slides along the wall on it's way down and strikes a plug inserted in the receptacle like a metal yard stick I guess.

It took electricians a few years to break a long instilled habit to put the ground down. At least on the jobs I was on and a lot of inspectors totally ignored it for a while.

As for Hospitals , the only ones I pay attention to have a locking device to prevent accidental disconnects.

FredD

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#4

Re: oh oooo ooh, I almost know

Brian in Brighton

>I think the upside down is to indicate a switched outlet. At least it is for homeowners.

On another note, the orange plugs are hooked into the UPS generators to let nurses know that critical equipment will be running in the event of a power outage. So plug your stuff into it during a storm.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#5

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Richard Jones

>NEC does not address receptacle orientation. However, some devices, particularly hospital-grade devices, are marked "top" or "up" and some hospital designers require the devices to be installed all one way. NEC does not consider this to be a safety issue.

As a general rule, NEC does mandate that you follow the manufacturers instructions if those instructions are more restrictive.

R

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#6

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Gerald Caryl

>It is becuse the whole word is turned upside down now !

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#7

THIS IS THE CORRECT ANSWER!!!

Frank in Forest Hill

>

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#8

MR. JONES GETS THE PRIZE!!

Frank in Forest Hill

>

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#9

Do I get on a 10 year membership to...............

Richard Jones

>..........the Lie-Nielsen Plane of the Month Club?

Sweet.

R

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#10

SORRY, 12 YR. MEMSHP TO HANDYMAN CLUB !

Frank in Forest Hill

>

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#11

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Gene Gauss

>The place I retired from began mandating ground on top after a metal sign slid down into the space between a plug and the outlet and shorted across the blades of the plug. I've installed all the outlets in my house ground up for the same reason. I hadn't heard that NEC has addressed this.

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#12

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Larry in NW Ohio

>As a maintanence person when I still worked a few years ago that is always the way I would do them, the ground on the top. I would catch more he-- for doing it that way. Larry in Ohio

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#13

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Bill Howatt

>Having the ground on top for your workplace's reason does make sense although I susupect it is a very rare occurance.

My house originally was wired with the grounds up and generally I find it a slight PITA. Most cords with angled plugs are designed around the ground being down or else you get a big loop.

Any outlets I replace get installed ground pin down.

Billl

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#14

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Alexander Grigoriev

>So far, all angled plugs I see sold are grounds up.

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#15

My thoughts and a question

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I have heard many reasons for the ground up and grond down argument. the sign or metal object falling down the wall was one line of reasoning, but I have to think that is relatively rare occurance.

I had also heard that the ground should be down so that if the cord is stepped on the ground would be the last part that pulls free from the circuit.

As noted most offset plugs look better with the ground down.

I've asked electricians and get both answers. I think it depends upon who trained them.

I think the NEC just says that the wires have to be correctly attached to the proper terminals.

I just walked around our office building and on my floor which was fully rennovated within the last 3 years. In one wing the outlets all have the ground up. In the other wing all the outlets have the ground down. I guess as long as they work it doesn't really matter.

Now for todays puzzler: If you mount the receptacle sideways, do the grounds go to the left or to the right?

Lee

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#16

install them sideways

John K Jordan

>Or just install two duplex outlets, one up and one down, so everyone's happy.

The ground-up would have made it more difficult for me to make sparks and blow the fuse by dropping a dime into the gap as a curious 6-year-old. (Of course, now that I think of it, the outlets in that old frame house were not grounded.)

JKJ

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#17

Hmmm...

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>When I was 11-12 I learned about making magnets at school by placing a piece of iron inside a coil of wire and connecting teh coil to a battery. I was fascinated with magnets and had a whole collection. I wanted to add more to my stash so I made a coil of some enameled copper wire and a toilet paper tube. I wrapped a few dozen turns around the tube, stripped the ends of the wire, put a nail inside and plugged them into the outlet. Did I mention that we lived in Spain at the time and all the outlets were 220? Well, the wire got hotter than H*** in a hurry just before the lights went out. I had a tough time explaining the burnt paper smell and blown fuse to my Mom. I don't recall if the nail was magnetized or not.

Lee

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#18

I believe the official advice

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>is to install the outlet with the neutral leg up. Since this leg is on the left, that puts the ground to the left too.

wish I'd known that when I rewired my old house more than a decade ago (I'm not sure I was consistent in wiring the several outlets in baseboards and stuff), but we don't have little kids, so I'll take my chances until I have to replace the outlets.

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#19

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Howard Norman

>>NEC does not address receptacle orientation.<

That is what I thought Richard but I wasn't about to take the time and effort to check it out. I have never liked the looks of the ground on the top installations myself. Just doesn't look right to me.

On another issue, this is a log home that I live in now. In log homes that I have seen the receptacles are normally horizontal with the ground on the right side. Not that it makes a damns worth of difference in that case but at least you want them to be consistent.

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#20

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

Richard Jones

>And I've always installed them ground down in all residential work, except for those pesky floor receptacles..............:) Ground up just didn't sound right............

R

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#21

Re: My thoughts and a question

Fred Davis

>Ground down is not a argument or a cosmetic preference, it is a code requirement in the State of California.

Beyond that , take a look at a GFCI receptacle, install with the ground down , makes the test and reset labels upside down.

We did a room addition for a Filipino couple who had the old folks live with them and the old man insisted that the windows and sliding door , not be directly across from each ,because of easy access for evil spirits, so we accommodated them.

Then the electrician installed a 40 amp four breaker branch panel in the room to meet the increased electrical requirements and at the house warming party , the client said his dad was upset with the installation of the panel.

He thought that the lower pair of breakers was letting the electricity flow though the room backwards because the lower breakers read upside down............

FredD

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#22

Re: Hmmm... magnets

John K Jordan

>That's pretty funny (in retrospect!) I did a similar thing at about the same age to try to make a magnet. But instead of plugging into the mains, I fastened one end of the wire coil to a metal plate and buried it in the ground at the base of our treehouse tree. I connected the other end to an old car radio antenna and fastened it as high in the tree as I could climb. My idea was that lightning would strike the antenna and make a very powerful magnet!!

Fortunately for the tree and perhaps me, lightning never came close.

I'd tear apart every old loudspeaker I could get for the magnets. What we would have given for today's supermagnets!

It's surprising the things we lived through. Like the time I discovered the explosive power of throwing a whole shovelful of fine coal dust into the furnace which set the basement on fire. Or the chemistry experiment gone bad in the bedroom which set the curtains on fire. Or the home-made hand grenades. Or the accidental zip gun that resulted in a trip to the emergency room. Ah, the good old days.

BTW, at the time I lived on the river just south of Pittsburgh.

JKJ, in east TN

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#23

Anthropomorphizing utilities

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"Ground up just didn't sound right."

I think there are maybe two reasons for the bias most feel toward ground down.

First, it's the way electricians started installing them back when they became available.

Second, with the ground down, the outlet makes a little happy face, while upside down, it looks like nothing at all; so it looks natural to have it down.

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#24

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

JerryBurns

>Think plumbing hot on the left cold on the right the power lead is on the left if you mount the outlet with the ground up ie hot wire and the neutral ie cold is on the right old timer told me that ie my dad

Re: Electrical engineer . . .

#25

Also...

John in NM

>Those little plug in circuit checkers are designed to work with the ground down, unless we assume the person using it will always be lying on the floor, underneath the outlet/tester, so that the lights are visible.

All the outlets at work are ground up, and they are a pain to check with one of those things.