Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Shop Lights keep failing

Posts

Shop Lights keep failing

#1

Bart Goldberg

Shop Lights keep failing

Bart Goldberg

>Hi All,

I have about a half dozen HD purchased, cheap 4 ft florescent "shop light" that I use to illuminate my shop. These are the kind with a flared out metal cover and that hang from chains from my ceiling.

For some reason, these lights, which don't get major usage, keep failing after about a years use. I have tried blowing them clean with compressed air, thinking this may correct the problem, but to no avail.

I am frustrated by these fixtures - I have other florescent fixtures in my home that I have had for 16+ years without ever having a problem.

Does anyone know why these fixtures burn out after such limited use?

Does anyone have any suggestions on how to correct this problem?

Any help is much appreciated

Regards

Bart

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#2

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Pete LaBelle

>Solved my similar issue by buying commercial-grade lights. Cost about 3x as much (bout $30 each), but are brighter and bulbs last longer too.

You get what you pay for !

Pete

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#3

Bart Goldberg

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Bart Goldberg

>Great - can you tell me what you bought and where?

Thanks

Bart

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#4

Re: Shop Lights

Jerry Gibbs

>on a related note, how do you calculate how many lights you need? jerry gibbs

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#5

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Don't buy "Made In China" typical chinese crap sold by a Borg!

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#6

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Chuck in ND

>Could it be that your shop wireing isn't grounded good ? Or the breaker isn't large enough on that circuit ?

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#7

Chinese ballasts!

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtnc

>

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#8

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Ken Krawford

>Bart,

I don't know if you live near or in a decent sized city but I found some fixtures on Craigs list. I was able to purchase 10 of the 4 bulb lights (including bulbs) for $80. A couple had cracked covers and were slightly dented but in my shop they work absolutely fine.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#9

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

steve mackay

>LOL ! I've got one HD in the laundry room and two in the shop. One of the ones in the shop has NEVER worked right. The other two have NEVER failed in 11 years. I think its like cars. Depends on what day of the week something was put together.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#10

Suggestion, and stop the China bashing

wilbur

>I think that the key factor in your description of your lights (half dozen HD purchased, cheap 4 ft florescent "shop light") is when you said "cheap". Cheap light fixtures = cheap ballasts = prone to fail.

Commercial quality ballasts are available at the local Borgs in my area. I have 4 foot, 2 bulb T8 fixtures that were labeled as "commercial" that ran about $40-50 apiece. But they run great, and from a lighting perspective, illuminate better than the cheaper models simply because they space the bulbs farther apart, which leads to more even light coverage. The cheaper models put the bulbs right next to each other.

By the way, the fixtures I have are made in China as well. Chinese products are not a priori of poor quality, if you are willing to spend extra for the better quality control. Cheap products, on the other hand, are cheap products wherever they are made.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#11

Compact fluorescents, too

Alexander Grigoriev

>On an unrelated note, those GE compact fluorescents that are sold with SC Edison subsidy (and also those sold by IKEA) don't last, either.

While those made by Sylvania seem OK.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#12

Re: Compact fluorescents, too

Larry in NW Ohio

>The best thing to do is if your planning to need lights in the near future is to watch for stores that update or a new store goes in. Watch for the fixtures, I got about 30 fixtures a year ago when a new store went in an empty building and they redid most everything in it. Like I said I got about 30 fixtures, bulbs and a nice electic heater that is doing a good job at heating my shop. I know this doesent happen all the time but keep you eyes open and ask for whatever looks usable. Free is good. One thing you may try for yours is go to ebay and look for some good ballests, I got some from a guy for like $2.00 a piece and they are the good ones. Larry in Ohio

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#13

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Gene Gauss

>My experience has been similar to yours or worse. I have a number of cheapo flourescent fixtures in my cellar shop and garage, some from Sears, but mostly from HD. Some (a few) have lasted for years, some fail in a year or less, and the last one I put in (from HD) made it for about a week before pooping in the bed. I've been watching Craigslist for commercial units, but haven't come up with any. However, my volunteer fire company is planning to replace the 1960s vintage 8' fixtures with newer stuff. I've got my dibs in on them when they take them out.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#14

Re: Suggestion, and stop the China bashing

steve mackay

>Right you are Sir ! I purchased two machines in the last year that were made in Asia and both are superior to the ones they replaced from the USA. Junk is junk no matter where its made. And junk made in the USA seems to cost more than everyone else's junk.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#15

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>I feel your pain. I had four fixtures each with rout bulbs that I left in my old shop when I sold it. I still regret that act of kindness since the new owners use my old 24x30 shop for storage and leave the dry as a bone basement empty.

I bought some cheap fixtures for my current shop and had the same problem. They would last a few months past the 1 year warranty and then the electronic ballast for one of the bulbs would fail. The store I bought them at didn't have any fluorescent fixtures with the old oil filled ballasts so I went to a local small chain that is an Ace affiliate and found some of the old style fluorescent shop lights with an oil filled ballast. The sad part is the cheapies cost just under $10 and the ones I have now were $12. Can't recall where either fixture was made.

Robin

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#16

Shop Lights keep failing - what temp?

Pat Riley

>What temp are your fixtures at? Standard "Economy" lights have ballasts made to operate at room temperature - above about 55 degrees F.

If you are using them in a cold shop, they may work flakily, take forever to start up, or work fine then die way too fast.

There are some lights designed for "Cold Environment" that should work great. They most likely will be about the price of industrial versions.

I doubt it would be worth it to replace the generic economy ballasts with cold weather ballasts.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#17

Re: Suggestion, and stop the China bashing

Chuck in ND

>I'd like to know what American made machines were of lesser quality than the Asian machines, and which Asian machines you replaced them with.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Maybe not directly relevant........

Jesper, Denmark

>But three names spring to mind, GM, Ford and Chrysler.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#19

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Pete LaBelle

>Bart -

Not sure what brand fixtures mine were, but when you go into Lowes or where ever you buy your lights from, compare the light output on all the fixtures. The commercial units are more often brighter. The $10 fixtures only put out about 2/3 the light output.

Read an article in a several year old Fine Woodworking magazine on florescent lighting. Author said the cheap fixtures have ballasts that do light the bulbs, but do so poorly. Not putting enough of the proper electricity to florescent bulbs ages them prematurely. I have to agree with him on that.

It's taken me quite a few years for it to sink in, but paying more for a better quaility item up front DOES save you more money in the future.

Pete

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#20

Mostly in the ballast ... sorta long

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>A couple of things to keep in mind about flourescent lighting.

The fixture is just a holder for the ballast. Cheap ballast=short life, even with some comercial fixtures OEM ballasts don't last as long as a good quality replacement ballast, they are not as tough either.

Personally, I hate 8ft lamps, they cost more per foot and are harder to deal with. I avoid High output lamps for the same reason plus with electronic ballasts the starting temprature issues pretty much go away. T-8 electronic ballasts start down to zero.

I change any old magnetic ballast that goes bad to a t-8 electronic. t-8 lamps are less expensive to buy and operate, the electronic ballasts cost less than magnetic ballast plus you can reballast a four lamp fixture with just one ballast instead of the two required for a t-12 magnetic ballast.

For my money Advance brand ballasts seem to be tougher than other brands I have used. One build I upgraded a few years ago with Motorola ballast had a high failure rate, I have had far fewer failures with the Advance ballasts.

One other factor that affects ballast life is the quality of power you get to your shop, voltage fluctuations are harder on electronics. I can't really explain those issues as I am not an electrician or engineer. I am responsible for maintaining the lighting in 200,000 square feet of buildings that vary in function from vehicle repair and chairlift terminals to retail and food service.

glc

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#21

Bart Goldberg

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

Bart GOldberg

>Na, these are all just the plug in type, and its a regular 15 amp circuit -

Bart

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#22

Bart Goldberg

Re: Shop Lights keep failing - what temp?

Bart GOldberg

>Hi,

Good question - however, my basement shop is a heated area - probably never get below 65 degrees. Mostly closer to 70 I think.

Bart

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#23

Griz for Craftsman

steve mackay

>

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#24

Re: Maybe not directly relevant........

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Sir, you are clearly ignorant of the quality of cars produced by the Detroit three. Perhaps you shouldn't comment unless you have that knowledge.

Re: Shop Lights keep failing

#25

Re: Not the time to be

Chuck in ND

>bashing American made products. This country is in enough trouble because jobs were sent overseas to slave labor. And I don't care what you say, American made is some of the best.