Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

Posts

Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#1

Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

Pete LaBelle

>Steel City has been offering granite tops for their tablesaws now for several months. Just came from a woodworking expo where their saws were on display. There was a lot of interest in the feature, but everyone was asking if anyone had heard of anyone buying one and what they thought about it.

Thus: Are there any granite top saw owners out there yet? How do you like or dislike your choice?

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#2

Granite, shmanite

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I doubt that it would make any of us better woodworkers. Merely serves to differentiate the manufacturer.

Clint

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#3

What Clint Said

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Can be written in stone.

George

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#4

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Granite, shmanite

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Wonder what happens when somebody lays something on the table, then pounds on it - like driving a nail? Betcha the granite cracks - especially if the nail goes thru the wood and dimples the top.

Jim D.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#6

Does'nt sound like a good idea . . .

steve mackay

>for THIS accident prone child ! But I'm sure there are those who need "surface plate accuracy" on their TS.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#7

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

john lucas

>As someone who has had rust problems in my shop I welcome the idea. I have worked around granite sinks and workbenches in labs for years and they seem to hold up quite well. I would think they could be ground quite flat as well.

If anyone even thinks about driving a nail through a board on my table saw I would execute them so I don't think that's a realistic problem. Dropping something heavy and hitting a corner and chipping it would be my concern. Of course you could chip cast iron with an accident like this.

Now the Granite lathe they had at the IWF was a joke. They have take a mini lathe and made it non portable. I could see reducing vibration on a bigger lathe but then the stone would be much too heavy. I thought it was interesting but did not see the advantage of the granite in this case.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#8

cost

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It will be cheaper than cast iron .

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#9

Re: Granite, shmanite

Fred Davis

>I thought after getting yelled at for expressing doubt over the long term life of a Granite Saw top , I was a lone voice in the woods ;-))

I saw up close the mitre slot in the Granite top and it was cut into the stone as a "Tee" slot and left what I think is a very small amount of stone over the recess in the slot . therefore a inherent weakness,

But ........... having no long term anecdotal history on this " new and improved" approach to metal tops that outlast several owners/motors , what can one say?

FredD

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#10

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

Robert R Clough - Thorncraft

>I have no doubt the granite tops will work and do as they are told to do. However, I have right along thought of of Steel City's hype as being a marketing ploy.

I have read recently that granite is a possible danger for radioactivity. I have no idea if this is a serious problem or not. Of course, it might be a help in that the woodworker might not need lights to see.

(I must say that I am an Atomic Soldier. I took part in Upshot-Knothole, Encore, area 3 NV test site, 05/08/53, 27KTs. We were NOT told of any possible dangers. I understand I am being silly above.)

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#11

Granite ... Radioactivity?

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>I sure hope not, I have a bunch of Granite tile on my kitchen counters. I'm not really a tile kitchen kinda guy, but I do like the granite in the kitchen.

glc

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#12

Re: Granite ... Radioactivity?

Pat Riley

>Granite is radioactive, but in reality, it is pretty safe to say that it is only because background radioactivity in granite is just a bit higher than other options.

The fact that radioactivity in granite can be detected is more of a feather in the caps of the people designing Geiger counters. They are so sensitive these days that almost all standard granite will show trace radioactivity.

Dangerously hot granite is possible, but not really something that needs to be worried about.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#13

Re: Granite ... Radioactivity?

Tom MacGregor

>If you live over a mountain of granite bedrock as I do in central Vermont it's a good idea to test your basement for radon & test your water for it if you have a drilled well. I don't think you need to worry about the amount of granite in countertops or tablesaws.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#14

Pat's got it...

John in NM

>If one's worried about the radioactivity of granite products, I'd suggest staying out of any mountainous area and settling in Kansas.

Seriously though, granites often contain trace elements that are radioactive (very useful for finding the age of the rock), but would have to be thousands of times more concentrated to begin to be dangerous.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#15

To be honest..

Gary Camp, Bend, oregon

>I wasn't really worried. There isn't any Granite around here, just Lava rock, lots and lots and lots of lava rock. In my neighborhood I'd be lots more worried about vulcanism. The youngest lava flow in Oregon (about 1300 years) is only 30 miles South of my house.

glc

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#16

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

Rik - WI

>Next the manufactures will be trying to get us to light our shops with wall sconces and assorted smelly candles.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#17

Ellis Walentine

Not exactly a field report...

Ellis Walentine

>... but anecdotally relevant. When I talked with Scott Box, Steel City's president at the IWF show last summer, I asked him how many returns or damage reports they had had since introducing the new granite saws and he said the number was really negligible. I don't know what kind of warranty they offer on the granite, but apparently they haven't had to pay out on it very often.

I see granite as a pretty clever innovation for tablesaws. Granite can be ground very flat, it doesn't rust, it has a low coefficient of friction, and its mass helps dampen vibration. From a manufacturing standpoint, it is probably less energy and labor intensive to produce than cast iron and doesn't require a curing period before grinding. Nor does it warp or change shape after grinding. As a marketing hook, it's brilliant.

Ellis

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#18

question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have not seen one of these saws. How is the table slot handled? A steel bar rubbing on stone wouldn't last.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#19

Ellis Walentine

Good question, Bill

Ellis Walentine

>I'll contact the manufacturer and see if they have a good answer.

Ellis

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#20

Baby powder?

Basil

>What was the question again?.....oh, yeah, slot wear.

I guess some kid of lubricant would be neceeary to prevent wear.

A few years ago I saw A friend making multiple cuts (thousands actually) on a tablesaw with a jig he had made. The jig was basically made from a kitchen cabinet 'sink' cut out with the formica being on the bottom side. He took a little break from sawing and waxed the tablesaw top, reached over to a shelve, grabbed a container of Johnson's baby powder and gave it a good sprinkle. Dumb me asked, "Why'd you do that". He says, "Slide that jig now".

Boys, it was like it wasn't touching anything, no effort at all to slide that jig, slick as it could be. I keep a container of baby powder in the shop myself now.

Basil

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#21

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Yea, but....

Pete LaBelle

>I appreciate all your responses and speculation on the granite tops. We all have concerns. This is new technology. We were all scared when plastic started showing up on our power tools, but for the most part, it has been a good solution to weight & cost.

Thus far, nobody has chimed in that actually does own a granite top saw. Is there any owners out there? Are the concerns that many of us have legitimate, or just gut reactions. What do the users have to say?

Thanks !

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#22

I Think Fred Flintstone Had One.

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>or maybe it was Barney Rubble. I know it was peddle powered.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#23

oh the potential

John K Jordan

>I can see the future. Visit the yard and pick out a granite slab for a custom saw table in colors to coordinate with your shop decor. Your buddy will visit the shop and exclaim, "my what a pretty pattern in that Azul Imperial Vento, wherever did you find it?" "You MUST come by and see my new router table in Serengeti Gold, it SO goes with my safety glasses." They'll have to make zero clearance inserts in a variety of complementary hues for the sophisticated woodworker. The poor among us will have to get cheap imitation granite or make their own from poured concrete mixed with marble chips. Techies will go for the cool plastic slabs with embedded LEDs that change colors with the blade height. The accident prone will order something with a lot of red.

Don't tell my wife about this granite thing or she'll buy me another saw and I don't any more room.

JKJ

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#24

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Yea, but....

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Since you havn't gotten any resposes to you question I guess I will offer up my experiance which is more along the lines of cast iron vs granite. Every pattern shop has several surface plates. The shop I did my apprinticeship in had a 36x72, and three 24x30 since the shop first opened in 1919 the surface plates were all cast iron. Most of the shops I worked in had cast iron plates but I did work at one shop with a granite plate. I was hesitant at first and was told that everyone in the shop felt the same way. it turned out to be just as tough and durable. On the old CI plates if you drop something it can make a dent or ding that has to be filed and a divit remains. on a granite plate it will make a divit and it will need to be repaired with epoxy or it can be left alone but it wont need to be filed. I would guess that Steel City is using a similar grade to what is used for surface plates and it is plane in color and pattern and has a ver even and fine grain. If it were paired with a Saw Stop mechainisim it would likely be the perfect table saw.

Robin

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#25

Re: Not exactly a field report...

Fred Davis

>Gee Ellis,

just think of the possibilities,for instance, when you retire, you could have the Granite top engraved "RIP Ellis Wallentine" , for a future occasion ;-))

FredD