Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

Posts

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#26

Never see one in my shop...

SonnyEdmonds

>...I ain't even begun to wear out my tablesaw.

And dought I will in what time is left.

I don't change tools like it's my underwear.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#27

JL

LOL - but it is perfect

JL

>especially if certain people get into woodworking. Of course if you sold the saws at a Starbucks, you'd get even more business :).

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#28

Granite ... Radioactivity... Kitchen

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I figured any radioactivity found in the kitchen would be from the microwave oven :) LOL

Looks like everyone agrees that granite, as well as other natural things, is somewhat radioactive, but it also seems the vendors say it's safe and the media says it's not.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#29

More on kitchens.....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Funny you should mention that.

Apparently Halogen lights (like the kind that are popular in your home, escpecially the kitchen) emit the same sort of sun burning (cancer causing) UVA or UVB radiation as the sun.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#30

UHMW

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>To take the slop out of my crosscut guide, I attached a piece of UHMW tape to the sides. It slides like it was greased and the tape hasn't shown any signs of wear after years of use.

UHMW is used to line dump truck bodies so the dirt and gravel slides out and doesn't wear the steel. It shold hold up well on granite if the granite is cut and smoothed.

Lee

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#31

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

Mark Webster

>Pete,

I am now the proud owner of a Steel City granite top table saw. Once I get it together and use it some I will let you know what I think.

Mark

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#32

Science is what says its safe...

John in NM

>I'll leave my opinions of the media for another day ;)

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#33

Ellis Walentine

Now there's a thought. :-)

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#34

Not just granite

Curt Harms

>There's little or no granite in S.E. Pa but radon gas in basements is an issue.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#35

Re: Granite, shmanite

Charlie Self

>Jeez, guys. Try the same thing with cast iron, will you? Have something nearby to put the pieces in.

One major feature of granite: no rust.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#36

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

Charlie Self

>Some months ago, working on a book, I talked to Scott Box about granite tops on table saws, and what I then saw as the greater fragility than cast iron.

The tops are webbed, have steel inserts for bolts. Small chips and digs and cracks can be epoxied (I'd guess you cannot do the same with cast iron because of carbon inclusions, but it may be possible). Tables can be ground excpetionally flat--the flatter the top, the more it costs, of course. Check Grizzly for granite plates and their costs.

And it cannot rust. If you use wax on this top, it's to decrease friction, not to protect against humid air.

I didn't think to ask him about miter gauge slots, but my bet is, if the slot chips or wears, it can be reground and a steel or iron section inserted.

I've got one of the Tool City hybrid saws on the way--it may be sitting in a trucking terminal 40 miles away as I write--with the granite top. While I'm not going to deliberately try to mangle it, I will try to remember to check back here in a few weeks and let you guys know what the top is like in use...especially since I've got similar saws, with cast iron tops, coming from other makers.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#37

Very weak radioactivity

Al Goldstein

>I can verify that the amount of radioactivity in granite is very small. SWIMBO became concerned when she read in the newspaper that granite was radioactive. I brought home a geiger counter to check our granite tops.

I found a very small bit of radioactivity in several localized areas of the granite. To give you an idea of the amount of radioactivity I found - there is a tiny radioactive source mounted on the side of a geiger counter that is used to test if it is operating. The reading I got from these areas in the granite was much smaller than the reading from the tiny radioactive source (that can easily come very close to one's very private parts). I can't remember exactly how much smaller was the granite reading, but it was definitely less than 1/10 of the tiny source reading.

So SWIMBO is no longer concerned and neither should we.

Al

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#38

Hmmmmmmmmmm...Zircons

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi,

It's been interesting following this thread as I was a geologist and understand a great deal about the petrology of granites.

A granite is a plutonic body that can contain a wide variety of trace elements localized and evenly distributed in it's matrix, all depending on the phase relationships of the source magma chemistry and cooling history of the granite (I will avoid going into a discussion on phase diagrams and Phys Chem here).

Some granites can contain some minerals that have radioactive components, for example zircon is a very common mineral that contains some U235. I worked in a geochronology lab for 4 years age dating rocks using minerals that contained U. Zircon was easily the most common U bearing mineral in granites from around the world. While zircon is a silicate, it contains trace quantities of U. How much? Ball park we'd usually needed 200 pounds of a typical granite to yield about 2 grams of zircon. In the 2 grams of zircon we'd be lucky to get 0.002-4 grams of U. The radioactive component is almost undetectable. We used mass spectrometers to analyze the ratio's of U 235 and Pb 207 to calculate the age of a sample. Other minerals that are associated with radio active elements in granite are significantly less in abundance and with even smaller amounts of U 235.

Just my experience

Take it easy,

Jim

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#39

Jim, ---You Rock!!!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#40

Interesting ! . . .

steve mackay

>I usually blow off "Don't worry about it". Its very cool someone tried it. I remember when Chernoble (sp?) melted down. Was in Germany and they said "Don't worry about it" and locked up all the detection equipment. Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm. We "snuck" one outside just for kicks. Yes Virginia, we SHOULD have worried about it !

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#41

More mineralogy...

John in NM

>I understand that these days baby powder is made of cornstarch (sucks up moisture), whereas old-timey baby powder was talcum powder - made of ground up talc, a serpentine mineral. If you want it for an inert dry lubricant, talc is going to perform much better than cornstarch.

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#42

zircon

John K Jordan

>Yikes, I didn't realize zircon had that much uranium. Since naturally occurring uranium is generally only .711% U-235, you must have been working with some nearly ghostly traces!

In the 70s I worked for a company called US Nuclear (long defunct) and for a few years ran a little metallography lab. The uranium we used was enriched to over 90% U-235, a level requiring guards in bullet-proof areas, metal and SNM detectors at the entrance, and the material stored in a vault with strict criticality measures. (These days it would require extreme anti-terrorist security measures.) We alloyed the U with aluminum and some other components and manufactured elements for research reactors, rolling the alloys into aluminum sandwiches. My job in metallography was to measure the grain growth across the aluminum boundaries. Talk about a pain sanding and polishing!

Uranium doesn't put off much radiation in the form of gamma, the most damaging. The biggest hazard is with alpha radiation and that's only if you make uranium dust and eat or inhale it. I don't think I'd worry too much about trace amounts in granite. It would probably be far more damaging to take an airplane flight once a year than to work with a granite saw every day.

JKJ

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#43

Humm, Peeling off Packing Tape?

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Seems like I heard or read something recently that someone had found that they could produce X-rays by peeling packing tape off of the roll. So it sounds like that may be more to worry about than your granite tops.

Would be the pits to work in shipping somewhere for years, to suddenly find that you glow in the dark, or couldn't get on an air-plane. ha

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#44

Zoning in Zircons

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Hi John,

I do not know anything about the enrichment process, I suspect that in itself was a science un to its own. You are correct of course about gamma vs alpha. I suspect a lot of the source natural U that you had on hand was from Canada, it's in relative abundance here, the source of what was used in 1945 I have read in two bombs that changed history.

what I am familiar with is on a different scale, Zircons grow in zones, like layers in an onion. Each zone grows as a event of geological significance happens. We were able to take a zircon crystal and analyze each layer and get a significant age of formation. The effect of that was that we could piece back together the geological history of a region, map out events and structure. The trick was being able to remove layers carefully with out destroying the host crystal.

Photobucket

This is a zircon in a host granite, contained in a crystal of plagioclase. You can see the zones of growth, perhaps 2 of significance. As you know U decays to Pb, with a half life of about 4.3 BA, each zone will have a different ratio of each allowing for unique age calculations as well as cooling rates.

Fun stuff, sure miss it, working on the new Airbus A350 now (2012 FF), kind of a different world of focus.

Take it easy,

Jim

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#45

Re: Zoning in Zircons

John K Jordan

>Jim,

Very interesting. I had no idea of the value of zircons for this. Makes me wonder what stories other minerals could tell.

I worked in the uranium business for many years, both in that job and from a different angle in the enrichment business. There I was doing some computer work for a think tank lead by the guy who developed the theories and wrote the book that allowed some of the enrichment processes to work, not only uranium. I later wrote a lot of related software including a SWU calculator still in use today (a SWU is a round-a-bout measure of the amount of work and value expended in separating an isotope - it's not just the final assay of the product that matters but the assays of the feed and waste streams as well - gets a little complicated. I later traded all that for 3D modeling and visualization of various technical things, including some on isotope handling.

As much fun as it was and as interesting, I still highly recommend this retirement thing. Feed the goats, ride the horses, saw the wood collect the honey, drive the tractor - it's a rough life but someone has to do it!

JKJ

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#46

Re: More mineralogy...

Fred Davis

>You can get it both ways, I use the Talc base baby powder, and in the past when I actually worked for a living I used Corn starch to dust my hands when installing White ceiling tile to keep off finger prints.

Fredd

Re: Granite tops on tablesaws - - Field reports ?

#47

Re: Humm, Peeling off Packing Tape?

John K Jordan

>NPR ran a story on the scotch tape x-ray emission a few weeks ago. Sounds interesting and if it could be made to work effectively would suggest a breakthrough for diagnostic medicine in poor parts of the world.

BTW, it normally takes a different type of irradiation (normally neutrons from a fission reactor or particle accelerator) to make you radioactive, i.e., turn you into a gamma emitter Can't do it with x-rays, AFAIK. Kill you, though.

JKJ