Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Kickback Happens

Posts

Kickback Happens

#1

Louie Lovas

Kickback Happens

Louie Lovas

>Well it finally happened, never thought it would but it did. I've read magazine articles, web stories and watched video demonstrations of tablesaw kickback. I work alone and have do so for many years and therefore I'm very safety minded. Last night I was just cutting a piece of 3/4 plywood. It was just 16" long, I needed it 6" wide for a jig I was making.

It all happened in a split second. Before I even knew anything was wrong or potentially going to happen, that piece of plywood kicked off the saw like a missile. It hit me square in the groin then rode up and slapped me in in the ribs. It knocked me flat on the floor with the wind knocked out of me. I was gasping for breath in agonizing pain.

I haven't had the wind knocked out of me since I was a teenager (I'm 49 years old). I was a dreadful experience. After a bit, I was able to shut off the saw and stumble into the house. My wife insisted we go to the hospital. They checked me out, took a chest X-ray to make sure I did not damage a lung or my liver (I was it on my right abdominal side).

In the end, I only suffered a few bruises. The longest lasting will be to my ego I think. I still can't believe it happened.

I've included a picture if the offending piece of plywood. I plan to hang it on the wall as a lesson to myself.

I firmly believe there is nothing wrong mechanically with my saw, I'm rather anal about alignment, and sharp clean blades. The only offensive is that I did not have my splitter in place because I was using a thin kerf blade and my splitter is designed for regular kerf blades only. Think I'll "fix" that issue.


img

Re: Kickback Happens

#2

Re: Kickback Happens

Downdraft table...

>I had the same thing happen, but with a dado blade.

I have no idea if the dado contributed to more force that your incident, but I didn't get injured like you did.

I took a hit to the groin, also...but it really was more to my inner thigh, and not the jewels, thank goodness, but I was bruised there for a long time.

I also didn't get the wind knocked out of me...no hit to the ribs.

But my board is hanging on my shop wall....as a reminder. Sounds like you will be doing the same.

Re: Kickback Happens

#3

Woops...

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>My name is not "downdraft table", as it saws in the post above!

I think that I messed that up with a previous post involving downdraft tables, and the website remembered my name from that post.

bg

Re: Kickback Happens

#4

Re: Kickback Happens

Michael J Bitetti

>My last kickback was purely the result of my lack of planing. It was an unusual bevel cut, right of the fence on a piece of red oak that already had a patern routed on the fence side. I realsized this was a bad idea at about the time the first inch of the 32 inch piece was fed into the blade. At about four inches in the kickback hapened. I didn't see a thing. The board hit the bed of the lathe bed (a Jet 1462, so it did not yield to the wood) otherwise I'm sure it would have passed through at least the (closed) drivers side window of my truck parked in the driveway outside of mt garage shop.

The board shattered into many pieces, one of them hit me from behind. Not a riving knife nor a splitter would have stopped this one and this was not my first kickback.

My first kickback, followed by being strongly re-enforced on this site, taught me to NEVER, EVER stand in the line of fire.

Mike

Re: Kickback Happens

#5

Re: Kickback Happens

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Your kickback may have been a result of a slight warp. this is not an uncomon problem, particularly on pices of ply in the 2'-3' size. they seem flat but as they are pushed through the saw they shift just enough to rock up and be caught by the trailing edge of the blade. It is rarely discussed but cutting warped wood on a table saw is one of the most dangerous things one can do. Your coments about a splitter are probably spot on.

thanks for sharing and glad it worked out as nothing serious injury wise.

Robin

Re: Kickback Happens

#6

JL

Ouch! Sympathy pains.

JL

>I had one incident with kickback on my old Sears Craftsman saw - kicked a board past me and into the basement garage door. Left a nice dent in it.

Re: Kickback Happens

#7

Been there, Done that!

Neal in San Jose

>The splitter/guard on my old Crapsman saw was a bad joke and thus seldom used, and the rip fence locked down on a front and a rear rail. It wasn't hard to "cock" the fence so that it was not parallel to the blade, so I got into the habit of checking for parallel to the blade. On one occasion I was cutting some 1/4 melamine w/o the guard and was one short. A little later, after changing the setup, I realized I needed one more. A quick - too quick - reset of the fence. I had the fence pinching toward the blade and as I made the cut, I could hear the motor loading up and I realized what was going on.

I thought I could let go with my left hand and hit the switch to kill the saw. WRONG! As soon as I lightened up the pressure with my hand, that saw snatched the melamine and shot it back. I was standing to the left of the blade and didn't get the full impact, but it still hit me hard enough in the right hip to leave a bruise that lasted for about a month. The melamine ended up stuck in the sheetrock right in line with the blade.

I did four smart things as a result. First; I put an ad in the paper and unloaded the Crapsman, Second; I screwed that piece of melamine to the wall right above the table saw just in my sight line as a reminder, Third; I made an auxilary paddle switch for my replacement saw that I can nudge with my left leg and kill power to the saw without moving my hands, and Fourth; I made it standard practice to use the guard if possible or at least the riving knife.

I was lucky. I'm glad yours' wasn't any worse.

Re: Kickback Happens

#8

I can't beat you, but I can give it a run

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Good Day Louie. It is good that you were not seriously hurt. However, I must admit that the design on your board looks familiar.

A couple months ago I was cutting tenons on legs, 2x3x26 inches actual measure, for my workbench project. Apparently I didn't have the maple clamped down tightly in the tenoning jig. About 1/4 the way through the cut the maple leg erupted from the jig, hit my glasses knocking out the lens(let hear it for polycarbonate,) a proceeded to leave a red mark on my stomach in the shape of block letter C. While it didn't knock me down, it surely got my attention, and can still see the mark on the stomach. (Lets hear it for trans-fats.) When the leg flew off the saw, it kicked the tenoning jig out of the track on the table saw. Those of you that have a jig know that they are heavy! Lastly, it took me 3 days to find the missing glasses lens about 10 ft. from the accident point.

You can believe that the tenoning jig got my undivided attention from there on!!

I needed an excuse to get new glasses anyway,

Ken....

Hang in there Louie, get up and ride that horse again. :-)

Re: Kickback Happens

#9

Re: Kickback Happens. Yup.

Don in Northern Arizona

>Louie,

I had my first kick-back experience several months ago. I was trimming a short piece of birch hardwood for a drawer, and foolishly I had taken the splitter off. I was wearing my ear protectors so I did not hear a thing as the piece I was trimming suddenly disappeared. Now where the heck did that go? I turned around and saw that it had gone across the shop about 12 feet, through a window while taking out glass, the screen, and a mullion. It finally came to rest about 18 feet in the back yard. Fortunately I was out of the line of fire, or I too would have been visiting the ER.

Don

Still saving for a saw with a riving knife.


img

Re: Kickback Happens

#10

Re: Kickback

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I try to take all the necesaary precautions and try to be safety conscious. And, I know there's probably some woodworkers out there that this has never happened to and some may have it happen all the time. ????

I gringe to think about the day it might happen to me.

Glad to hear your okay Ken. :-)

Ray

Re: Kickback Happens

#11

Re: Kickback - sorry Louie, called you Ken

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>by mistake.

Ray

Re: Kickback Happens

#12

Glad to hear you're OK.....

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>its happened to me as well...frightening how fast it can go so wrong...work safe (with that splitter)...never work tired...don't rush it...and don't let your thoughts drift.

Re: Kickback Happens

#13

Re: Kickback Happens

Jim Dillon

>Louie,

Glad only your pride was hurt and nothing more. I've had two close calls. I sensed something was not right as I started the rip cut and was able to carefully shut off the saw. Even that shook me up. I also was tired and in a hurry - both no-nos. You know the story, just get one more board cut and I can call it a "good" day in the shop. I like Robin's explanation regarding the plywood being warped slightly, but the piece could have twisted too. Thanks for taking the time to post and remind us to be careful!

Jim

Re: Kickback Happens

#14

Want to know why it happened?

Rick Christopherson

>I am sorry about the trauma you went through with your kickback. I had a similar kickback nearly 20 years ago, and since then, I have spent a lot of time analyzing kickbacks and photographs of Internet woodworker�s kickbacks. I have even been hired as an expert witness to analyze a kickback situation that resulted in the loss of several fingers.

Before I had even looked at your photo there was one aspect I knew I would find, but after seeing your photo, I noticed another, less common, aspect that contributed to your accident.

There are many different types of kickbacks, but the type you had is the most violent, and fortunately (or unfortunately if you have already experienced one), the most preventable too. I write these responses because �education� is the best way to prevent these kickbacks from happening. So I hope you take this for its educational intent, and not as a criticism.

First off, even though a splitter may reduce the impact of this type of kickback, it won�t automatically prevent it. In some cases, this type of kickback, if started, will simply fold the splitter right over and keep going.

The one common factor that you will find in nearly every case of this type of kickback is a low blade height, and that is what I knew I would find before even seeing your photograph. The low blade height is what permits the workpiece to ride up over the top of the sawblade, regardless how it is initiated.

The second contributing factor is that you were not maintaining a firm control of the workpiece. The reason why I know this is because the mark left on the bottom of the workpiece is a straight line. If you had been controlling the workpiece more firmly, this cut on the back would have had a curved shape. Human reaction times are not fast enough to get out of the way of this type of kickback, and the lack of a curved shape tells me that you had already stopped controlling this workpiece from the instant it began to move backward.

This reduced control, coupled with the low blade height is what permitted the back of the workpiece to be lifted by the sawblade. By any chance were you using a push stick? Using a push stick on too wide of a cut will result in reduced control of the workpiece, and I have seen many of these where this was the primary cause.

Re: Kickback Happens

#15

Re: How hi do you want the blade

barry vabeach

>Rick, I didn't understand all of your post, but my question is how high do you suggest the blade should be to reduce the risk of kick back? Are you suggesting it should be a certain distance above the top of the wood, or should you leave it at maximum height at all times. If it makes any difference, on my saw I have a true riving knife set within .004 inch of the blade. Thanks Barry

Re: Kickback Happens

#16

Louie Lovas

Re: Want to know why it happened?

Louie Lovas

>I want to thank everyone for reading, sharing their own experiences, words of encouragement and of course thoughts on prevention. I really enjoyed all the stories, glad most of them just resulted in a few broken windows and bruises.

Rick, thanks ever so for the insightful comments. I think you are dead on with your reasoning. My blade height was low, just enough for the gullets to clear. In retrospect, I also believe I was not maintaining firm control of the piece. I had made that simple rip cut hundred's, even thousand's of times, my thoughts drifted to the next steps in the jig I was making.

As I had mentioned in the original post, I did not even realize anything was wrong until the damn thing slammed into my groin. Boy I knew it then!

I was not using a push stick, it was a 6" wide cut so I had plenty of clearance between fence and blade.

Just to be on the safe side, I've already made two new wooden splitters (fit into my custom made zero clearance table inserts) tonight.

Re: Kickback Happens

#17

Re: How hi do you want the blade

Rick Christopherson

>I try to avoid stating a specific height for the sawblade because it depends on the type of blade, the type of wood, and the type of cut. You will frequently hear people say to raise the blade to the bottom of the gullets. I don�t normally argue over this topic because it is at least better than the rationale to keep the blade no more than 1/8 to 1/4 inch above the wood. In reality, there is no basis for this �gullet� methodology, as the gullets have nothing to do with the function of the sawblade over the top of the workpiece. Moreover, the types of blades with very shallow gullets (i.e. more teeth) are also the ones most susceptible to a low height.

So even though I don�t normally argue with keeping the sawblade to the bottom of the gullets, I don�t agree with it, but it is better than the other alternatives.

Generally speaking, and without specific regard to blade type or material type, I believe that an average height of 3/4 inch above the wood is a reasonable height. Learning where the height is best for the specific situation is part of the process of learning this craft.

Re: Kickback Happens

#18

Anyone else think.......

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....Rick oughta be a contributing editor to the articles section ?

This is the very stuff that makes the articles section worhwhile to EVERYONE IMO.

Thanks for the post Rick !

Re: Kickback Happens

#19

Re: Thanks rick - NM

barry vabeach

>

Re: Kickback Happens

#20

Re: Want to know why it happened?

Larry Marker

>I totally agree with the high blade philosphy. I also am a firm believer in Grr-Rippers. I have a pair of them and use them for every rip cut, big or small.

Larry

Re: Kickback Happens

#21

Re: How hi do you want the blade

Sgian Dubh

>Rick, here in the UK there are legislative reason for setting the blade height such that the gullets just clear the wood. It relates to the safety equipment standard on table saws here, ie, the riving knife and crown guard. Keeping the saw blade gullets just clearing the wood as recommended by the British Health and Safety Executive means you can't slip your fingers between the top of the wood and the underside of the crown guard.

In any case there is no need to get your fingers that close as the use of bird's mouth type pushsticks prevents it. And of course there is the different fence type used on saws which don't extend beyond the saw blade for ripping operations. This helps enormously because wood can't bind between the fence and the blade after the cut is complete, along with the additional safety provided by a crown guard and properly set riving knife.

However, I agree with you that a low set blade isn't ideal for cutting wood. I prefer it set higher for the the reasons you've mentioned.

In the end, I believe the biggest causes of table saw injuries in the US are down to poor working practices, lack of understanding of the causes of accidents, the bad habit of using the machine without any form of guarding and the use of table length fences. I developed a genuine dislike for US configured table saws during the period I had to use them. I disliked approaching a saw I'd set up earlier with the splitter and whatever safety kit I could find hiding in dusty corners in the workshop to discover it had all been removed by another woodworker. In the eighteen or so months I worked for US companies, prior to setting up my own furniture business in Houston, I witnessed more table saw accidents than I've seen in the rest of my 35 year woodworking career. Slainte.

Re: Kickback Happens

#22

Blade forces on workpiece

Bill Howatt

>I tend to keep my blade well up out of the wood often almost as high as the blade will go. My reasons are the forces put on the workpiece by the blade. If it is high, the cutting part of the blade puts a downward vertical force onto the workpiece. Putting the blade just above the stock puts a significant horizontal force into the workpiece towards the operator. Higher the blade, the less horizontal force. This even goes as far as saying if you can keep the stock on the table with a featherboard mounted to the fence it can't kickback under almost any situation since it can't ride up the blade to the top where the forces are all towards the operator. Hand holding is certainly not adequate for this approach!

Blade manufacturers want to give you the cleanest cut with minimum tearout and that is why the settings are stated with little blade above the workpiece. In my case of the high blade there is a larger component of vertical force (the one that keeps the stock down) contributing to a possible increased tearout situation on the bottom of the workpiece. A sharp blade and perhaps a zero clearance insert would minimize this. In practical use, I don't think the tearout is an issue with a decent, sharp blade.

If you have the sense to use a guard, a high blade poses no more risk. This brings us to another reason for low blade settings - no guard in use so the blade is kept low in an attempt to minimize accidental contact with hands.

Bill

Re: Kickback Happens

#23

Au contrair

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>However, at the back of the blade where the kick back starts, the blade is not pulling the material down it is pushing it up. Your argument about more verical force and less horizontal keeping the wood where it belongs,doesn't necessarily apply at the back of the blade. A higher blade height may have altered the trajectory, but would not have prevented this incident. This kickback did not start at the front edge of the blade, the cut was complete and the wood some how moved back into the blade to engage the teeth. If you look at the cut edge, burn marks may reveal that the piece was being pinched as it was being cut, but you can't see that edge in the photos. Attempting to pick up the piece before the blade stopped or leaving the piece lay on the saw table too close to the blade so that the saw vibration moved it into the teeth may have caused this accident.

Lee

Re: Kickback Happens

#24

Re: Au contrair

Rick Christopherson

>Lee, Even though I do not agree with Bill regarding raising the blade as high as he suggests, your rationale regarding the height of the blade at the back of the saw is not correct from a physics and engineering stand point. The lower blade height will make it easier to lift the workpiece at the back of the blade.

I apologize, but I don't feel like getting into a long dissertation on this topic tonight, but I do have a simple analogy that should help you understand the physics behind this assertion.

Consider a set of steps rising 36 inches high, and you want to drive up them with a bicycle. Which is going to be easier, riding up 12, 3-inch steps, or 3, 12-inch steps? Clearly you know that it is easier to get up the smaller step, even though the total height elevated is the same. This is the same reason why a low blade height will have a greater tendency to lift a workpiece than a higher blade height.

Again, I do not condone an unusually high blade height.

Re: Kickback Happens

#25

An issue with blade height and splitter *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Another reason I like a high blade is because it reduces the "ineffective" space between the end of the blade and the splitter.

As shown here: Link

Happy Woodworking!


http://www.webstorehouse.com/happywoodworking/Tabl