Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

Posts

OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#1

OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

Ray Newman

>I purchased 4 Michelin tires for the van this week & noticed that the tire rotation window sticker advises that the tires are nitrogen filled. Guess that's the reason for the green valve stem covers.

But what advantage(s) -- if any -- does nitrogen offer over air?

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#2

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires?? *LINK*

Brian Aust - Nevada, IA

>This web site has a lot to say about it.


Straight Dope

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#3

Dry Nitrogen

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>Commercial aircraft tires are serviced with Dry Nitrogen because it is inert, and contains little or no moisture.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#4

USAF also. . .

steve mackay

>When stationed on air bases allways saw LOTS of nitrogen bottles and finally asked what all of it was for. Jet tires + inert gas = longer life. Don't know that I'd want to try and find it " in the wild " though.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#5

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>This sounds like another great tree hugger...the polar ice caps are melting...the earth is over heating...we're all goin' perish...theory. But what about all that nasty oxygen and moisture that is on the outside of the tire??

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#6

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

Jerry

>I checked that link. It has been a long long time since I took chemistry but I seem to recall that oxygen has an atomic weight of 16 while nitrogen has an atomic weight of 14. Also I believe each of these gases has two atoms bound together in a molecule. This all makes me think that the oxygen molecule is not "skinnier" than the nitrogen molecule. Ignoring the mass of any moisture in the air, pure nitrogen should be roughly 2.8% lighter than air.

Jerry

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#7

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

Doug Ring

>Nitrogen has been used for years in race tires (I'm also a kart racer) - primary benefit is that it is a known "dry" gas, and should result in less pressure increase as the tire/wheel combo heats up. Most of the larger tire shops now have their own nitrogen extraction systems installed for this purpose - no need to handle heavy bottles of the gas.

There was a big controversy in Formula 1 last year over a special gas compound that the Ferrari team was using in their tires. Turns out that they had been using (and all teams are probably using now) a mixture of multiple Freon types plus 50% carbon dioxide. Story is that they found both a reduced pressure change as the tire/wheel heated and cooled, plus the mixture allowed greater heat conductivity to the wheel. My bet is that, if you are in the Indianapolis or Charlotte areas, you could buy this now pre-mixed at the larger industrial gas suppliers.

IMO, nitrogen in road car tires is probably overkill - if you want to save gas, and increase safety, installing roadside pressure monitoring systems at freeway entrances would be a much better way to go, albeit somewhat intrusive.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#8

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Dry Nitrogen - the reason

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>The reason aircraft tires are filled with dry nitrogen is that those tires spend a lot of time, not rotating, in very high altitude, which is very COLD. Any moisture in air filled tires would condense and collect at the lowest portion of the tire, then freeze in the minus 30�~minus 100� temps at altitude. Upon rapid descent back to terra firma, the ice wouldn't have time to thaw, and the resultant impact with the runway, at nearly 200 mph, at landing would break loose the chunks of ice and send them rattling aroung the inside of the tire, possibly damaging the tire and rim.

Automobile tires have no need for this precaution.

Nitrogen in automobile tires is just another scam - sorta like 'hot wax' at the car wash. ;-)

Jim D.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#9

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

Larry in NW Ohio

>Why don`t they fill tires with helium, that way it would make the car lighter. You know I think I`m onto something. If anyone wants to patent my idea go ahead, I don`t anything out of it, Just the idea I`m helping out mankind:-)) Larry In Ohio

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#10

permeation of O2 vs N2 wrt rubber *LINK*

John K Jordan

>For more than you want to know, link below.

But still, I wouldn't pay to put nitrogen in my automobile tires.


Are Nitrogen Molecules Really Larger Than Oxygen?

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#11

Ditto and,

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Because nitrogen doesn't cause a pressure increase in tires. I'm sure some corporate/insurance lawyer thought it would minimize or eliminate any doubt about "uncalibrated tire gages" in the shop causing over inflation of a tire leading to a blowout on a hot day on the highway. "It couldn't be the shop your honor we use nitrogen. It was the tire!

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#12

conflict of interest?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Assuming the values quoted are reliable I have no quibble with the calculation. However, the calculation is not carried through to something practical. Namely, given a typical tire filled with nitrogen vs one filled with 80/20 nitrogen/oxygen, and assuming some normal ambient temperature.....

What is the tire leak rate in PSI/year for each fill gas? Note how this meaningful value is never provided in these testimonials. I can suspect why.

I have not found my air-filled tires leaking at an unacceptable rate other than when I ran a file though one.

The author's company benefits from providing compressed nitrogen to fill said tires.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#13

This is such a friendly forum

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I visit another forum that has, let's just say, less patient and friendly people here. It's a dirt bike forum and a question like this about the Nitrogen filled tires gets asked there from time to time and nasty (cyber) fights break out. There's alot of people calling other people "idiots" and worse.

I just like to say that I fill my tires with helium so that I can jump higher and get more air time ;)

I especially like that normal air already is 2/3 nitrogen.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#14

OMYGOD!

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Ray,

I understand its a safety consideration bacause nitrogen prevents run-out of the tire structure with respect to the vahicle axels. Those who have had to drive on snow, or in icy conditions, or ooozy mud know how critical it is to maintain constant directional tracking for optimium control. Having been an aviator, I value nitrogen's use in aircraft tires. A straight landing roll terminating on the runway was always beneficial for plane, pilot, crew, and passengers. I expect no less from my Mazda pickup truck, although no matter how much Nitrogen I pump into its tires, it has yet to fly. Its got the landing roll down "pat". Concur with helium.

What was it that PT Barnum said about one "being born every minute"? Or was he talking about Chrysler PT Cruisers? :<) ROTFLMAO

George

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#15

Re: This is such a friendly forum

Howard Norman

>>I especially like that normal air already is 2/3 nitrogen.<

More like 4/5 nitrogen.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#16

Maybe in Arizona....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>.... but in Atlanta, we have alot more CO2 and CO in our air :)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#17

Purest, distilled, essence of BS.

Forrest Addy

>Nitrogen in automotive tires instead of air?

Sorry but I'm not a nice guy. You can't be serious? It's a scam designed to sucker in the people who buy speed parts made of "billet" material, penis enhancement products, magnetic therapy, and Kinoke foot pads.

These promos sometimes sound like serious info that rational people could reasonably pay serious heed to.

Unfortunately in the past technical education in sciences and critical thinking had been all but abandoned in education and its today's shoppers that pay the price. We are becoming a nation of robotic consumers.

99.99% of these promos are scams. When it comes down with it it's just another "Oh, no! No Phone service. What you need is this sticker that makes your cell phone act like it has an antenna 4 feet long." $35 for a sticker. You have to admire the chutzpah.

What this country needs is people who loudly ridicule bogus products and laugh at people who buy them.

There may be certain critical situations where nitogen is preferred over air like in the tires of the space shuttle but plain ol' car and truck tires? Gimme a break.

Trust me, this is a gimmick to sucker in fad fops to the greater profit of tire stores everywhere. It sounds real technical and it might be a really cool point to brag on (Yeah I got nitrogen in my tire. Really helps in the cornering in my rusted out '83 Monte Carlo) but any benefit is down in the fourth decimal place - ie statistically unverifiable.

My suggestion is don't do it but if you do, don't talk about it. You spend good money for no gain and a loss of credibility as a discerning shopper and a technical evaluator. Too high a price.

As was said earlier there's one born every minute. If you decide to fill your tires with nitrogen remember the placebo effect and also remember there are informed people who will laugh behind your back at your credibility.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#18

Re: Maybe in Arizona....

Howard Norman

>This is composition of air in percent by volume, at sea level at 15�C and 101325 Pa.

Nitrogen -- N2 -- 78.084%

Oxygen -- O2 -- 20.9476%

Argon -- Ar -- 0.934%

Carbon Dioxide -- CO2 -- 0.0314%

Neon -- Ne -- 0.001818%

Methane -- CH4 -- 0.0002%

Helium -- He -- 0.000524%

Krypton -- Kr -- 0.000114%

Hydrogen -- H2 -- 0.00005%

Xenon -- Xe -- 0.0000087%

Ozone -- O3 -- 0.000007%

Nitrogen Dioxide -- NO2 -- 0.000002%

Iodine -- I2 -- 0.000001%

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#19

Costco does this at no charge

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>Forest, I can understand how some of this scam stuff would get you riled. This time, though, perhaps too much so. I purchased tires at Costco and they came inflated with nitrogen at no additional charge. The local cycle shop uses nitrogen also even on my lowly scooter tires. I'm sure for the most part they are doing it to cover their legal hide from a "improper inflation" type of court scene. Lots of time motorcyclists don't routinely check their bike's tire inflation and the result is a nasty fall on a curvy road. Here nitrogen, with its lower permeability through rubber, may minimize the chance of this. Of the few tire outlets that I've noticed, I haven't seen any banners bragging about using nitrogen.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#20

Re: Maybe in Arizona....

Ray Newman

>Considering that this is an election year, there is & will be way too much BS in the air!....

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#21

Re: Costco does this at no charge

Ray Newman

>Bought my tires @ COSTCO. I asked the guy who was installing them about it & he just said it was COSTCO policy to fill w/ nitrogen.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

No charge? I don't think so...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>TANSTAAFL. For the uninformed, that works out to, "There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free Lunch." Costco (or any other tire place) is not going to do this out of the goodness of their hearts. They may not make it a line-item charge, but pure nitrogen costs money to obtain, be it in gas cylinders or by purchasing a machine that separates it from the ambient air. And, if their costs go up, that's just another thing for them to make a percentage on, so your price goes up somewhere.

It's like the time I took my older work truck to the dealer hoping they could better track down a funky running problem. I had to wait for them to get done because they wanted to wash it up for me. I told the receptionist, "No thanks, I don't want to pay for that." "No problem--it's a free service we do for all our customers." I gave up. Never mind that if they didn't have to keep a $7/hr. lackey around to do that, their overall costs would be lower...

As for tire pressures, I do all my own, though very sporadically. Generally, the major changes in pressure are due to seasonal changes, in which case they all change about the same amount. Or, they leak, which is usually just a tire here or there (it will always be the same one losing more pressure than the others), and that's typically due to a bad mount, a nail or screw, or some other issue, nothing about air molecules leaching out through the rubber.

Jason

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#23

Nitrogen

Bill Pfahl in Virginia

>Having spent several decades in the airplane buisness I always understood the reason for nitrogen (being inert) in aircraft tires is that it does not burn, most transport category airplanes require high pressure tires. Having said that, I recall changing a main wheel tire on a DC-8 I was flying and noting that the recomended pressure was 250 PSI. Ergo, you still have a bomb at that pressure - shades of the Air France SST.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#24

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

Mike Parzych

>I'm going to fill my tires with helium. I figure it'll make them lighter, thus exerting less pressure at the rubber/road interface. This should allow me to get 125,000 miles to a set of tires. And if I hit bumps the car will glide thru the air for about 75 feet after that. That should be worth another 10,000 miles.

Damn.....I'm brilliant, eh?

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#25

Bill, quit filing your tires......

Barry Irby

>File your papers or even your finger nails, but not your tires. No matter how hard you try you can't make them sharper.

I have nitrogen in my tires. The way I figure, the air has been in there so long the oxygen has permeated out of there, leaving only the nitrogen and a little argon. Maybe I should air them up. No wonder they have bad breath.