Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

Posts

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#26

It is not a BS scam, Forrest.

Basil

>In Ray's application it is getting close in my opinion, maybe, but not quite.

I'll try to keep this short.

The main advantages to a radial ply tire is less "heat buildup" and lower "rolling resistance". Dry nitrogen helps keep that temperture buildup lower allowing one to run a higher pressure to gain full advantage of the lower "rolling resistance" of the radial tire properties. It also protects the inner tire structure (carcass) from deterioration allowing the tire to be used over a longer time period. I will admit that for passenger cars I don't see a big need or advantage in the use of nitrogen under normal conditions and time periods. But then the tire manufacturer knows more about "his" tires and their proper use and maintance than I do.

"Rolling resistance" is measured like going up a hill, the more 'rolling resistance' the steeper the hill (and more heat). And 'heat buildup' can be extremely dangerous in load bearing tires that are found on trucks and heavy equipment where speed and max-load is critical to profits. In large mining trucks (especially of the 350 ton class, appox. 700 ton total wt.) with $30,000 to $40,000 thousand dollar per tire cost and fuel rates of 1,000 gallons and up per 8 hour shift, it becomes extremely important to run dry nitrogen.....all the time. Worn out but otherwise good tire carcusses can be recapped and used over and over again in these applications. Recapping doesn't happen to passenger tires anymore mainly because now the "recapper" is required to assume the liability for tire safety thereby relieving the original manufacturer of that liability. Lawsuits aren't a big problem for those "large" tire recappers but would be for smaller tires.

Now, if anyone wants to run nitrogen in your tires, here's what you can do. Go by a good Scuba diving shop, tell'em what you want to do, have then rig you up a regulator and 'air' hose to fit a nitrogen tank. You can get a nitrogen tank at just about any welding supply house or good locally owned auto parts store. .......and have at it.

Funny story....at least to me. The tires on my equipment weren't that large, 6' to 8' in diameter, 30" to 36" wide and cost $3 to $4 thou. each. They usually had no more than 60 psi each. I was told that at 60 psi they each had the explosive equivalent of 6 sticks of dynamite. For 30 years I worried about the one under the drivers seat blowing out and hurting someone. I put new tires under the driver or at least kept the best tire on the machine under the driver. I had 4 blowouts in 30 years, 3 under the drivers seat and I was sitting on every D*mn one of'em when they went out.....got a sore butt, jammed spine and the dangest headaches everytime......LOL Seems that little black cloud has always been with me.....LOL

Basil

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#27

bad air

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I was out at a local mill one day and a customer pulled up in a pickup truck and wanted some barn lumber. While loading, the sawmill owner looked at his tires with cord showing and remarked, "the air in these tires looks dirty. You had better replace them". I have no idea if the customer made it home with the overload. It was at this mill that I acquired the file.

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#28

Sorry guys but it's a scam whether

Forrest Addy

>Sorry guys but it's a scam on the consumer whether vast profits are reaped or not. People are being gulled and they are buying into it without looking into the issue further.

Don't believe me? Look at the gas behavior of air Vs nitrogen in a table of physical properties. The differences are in the small percents and their effect in service is indetectible to the user in terms of performance, maneuver, or longevity.

Permeability through rubber? Same. Loss of essential rubber volitiles to the inflation gas? Same or there abouts. Oxidation? Possibly but are there any figures cited? No.

Is air purged from the tire when its being filled with nitrogen? Not that I've seen meaning the O2 partial pressure in a nitrogen filled tire is 1 PSI instead of about 3 @ 30 PSI.

Look at the service history of using air in tires over a century. I've owned cars where the only loss in tire pressure was their pressure check in the annual rotation. I've seen tires taken off after 10 years in service and their interiors were blemishless.

Nitrogen in tires is a scam in that the benefits claimed are significant (or HUGE! as some would have it) when in fact they are vanishingly small. It's a bandwagon thing. If Bird's Eye claimed that wrinkled peas are more healthful and contain more anti-oxidants than smooth peas, other food suppliers will scramble all over themselves to jump on the wrinkled pea bandwagon.

Don't get me wrong. In certain applications where the last increment of reliability hangs in the balance (space shuttle etc) nitrogen tire inflation is probably indicated. For ordinary over the road tire service, air and nitrogen are interchangable in terms of performance and longevity. Got no air but you do have nitrogen? Go ahead and use it. Got nitrogen filled tires and the pressure is low, make it up with air if it's handy.

My point there are no supportable quantitive benefits to distinguish air from nitrogen for inflating road vehicle and RV tires. Everything I've seen on the topic is claims and assertions; no hard scientific evidence. Until I see an authoritative paper citing side by side controlled experiments saying otherwise I will hold the opinion that there is no measurable advantage in using nitrogen or air for automotive and RV tire inflation.

Then there is the fact that nitrogen is a by-product of air reduction and most generated is vented into the air. I can't help but think the clever marketers in the air reduction industry would love to find a niche for all that nitrogen they so expensively separate from the valuable oxygen. Tire inflation would be a start but first you need a shill issue to extoll alleged virtues. Looks like a duck. Walks like a duck.

If you choose to inflate your tire with nitrogen, that's fine. Makes for a nice brag to mystify the yokels. If you're pursuaded to do so by marketing or hearsay, you're allowing yourself to be gulled. If it costs you extra money, you're being scammed.

http://blogs.consumerreports.org/cars/2007/10/tires-nitrogen-.html

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#29

Re: Costco does this at no charge

Jay St. Peter - SoMD

>I suspect that Costco must have had some sort of tire lawsuit at some point. The nitrogen must just be another part of their lawsuit paranoia. I've had them refuse to put the correct size tires on 3 different vehicles. One did have aftermarket wheels with larger than stock wheels/tires. The other two had factory upgraded wheels that weren't in their computer for the trim level I had. Their policy is very strict on what size tires they will put on a vehicle.

Based on their offerings to put tires that were too thin on my vehicles, I am certain the people working there have little knowledge and blindly follow their computer. Pointing at the sticker on the car that says what size tires should go on there didn't help, they were still only willing put thinner tires on. These days their prices aren't good enough for me to bother with the drive there and the chance they won't put the tires on my vehicle anyway.

Jay

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#30

Re: I've heard it's because of the crappy Alum

Brian in Brighton

>The wheels of most cars today are aluminum. I have a problem with the wife's 97 Dodge in that the aluminum has corroded slightly on the inside and the tire can't get a good seat. I have to fill 2 of them every 2 weeks or so. They go from 32 to 20 psi in that time. What the tire company says is that with the air being pumped in over time from dealers, service guys, tire guys and the like that some water vapor and other stuff has gotten into the wheel and is creating a problem on the inside. I have had the tires swapped and replaced and the problem still persists. That tells me that the aluminum wheel is to blame. My Uncle in Mass also had the same problem with a 94ish Honda he had. Slow leak, but no leak in the tire. Maybe the stem is leaking where is seats into the wheel? All I know is that it makes perfect sense that this is something that would be a fairly recent problem since aluminum wheels really became popular in the last 20 years. So, I'm sorry Forrest, but perhaps there is more going on here than just a scam. You didn't notice it on your 78 Ferrari 308 because it probably has had only 1 tire change in it's lifetime. This is a problem that seems to come with age.

My other thought was that this was a northern thing. Has anyone down south had this same problem with a 10 yr old car?

If they want to fill the tires with a nice dry nitrogen than let them. Car collectors have been doing it for a while. Now, if someone says to fill them with Helium so that they are lighter, run away. Hydrogen, run really fast :-))

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#31

Everything you wanted to know about gullibility

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>This ConsumerReports.org link that Forrest provided is the most telling aspect of the whole thread, so far as I'm concerned. Now I'm not a huge fan of CR, because I don't think their tests are always as good as they could have been, but under the conditions they tested and described, I think the results provide all the proof needed that the nitrogen is a waste of resources. Far more disturbing to me, however, was reading the comments posted below the test results. One person reported 2-3 MPG improvement upon changing to nitrogen! C'mon—even the most fervent claimant to the nitrogen regimen doesn't claim that. Others were just as ridiculous. But they believe…

Take a look. A cross-section of Barnum's Mantra is in place there. They could all be Stereophile magazine subscribers. Green Magic Marker, anyone? Radio Shack clock radio, anyone? Fifteen or so years ago there were people claiming (with others agreeing) that use of the first on the edges of CDs improved their sound, and acquisition of the second would…I don't remember—I think it was supposed to smooth out the ripple in the AC or something. It's bad enough those people think tube audio with its built in harmonic distortion sounds better than solid state. Or that $1,000/meter interconnect cables sound better than $5 ones at Stereo City (or the equivalent).

Rod

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#32

Re: I've heard it's because of the crappy Alum

Bill Howatt

>The leaks are indeed caused by the deterioration of the wheel area that seals against the tire. Up here, where salt is used on the roads, it is probably the big culprit. The interior of the rims away from the tire bead area don't show any corrosion problems. Also, wheels are not pure aluminum but an aluminum, magnesium, whatever alloy so who knows what reations are going on. Alloy wheels also have a coating put on them, at least the outside, to keep them shiny and over the years this coating can become damaged letting corrosion start beneath it.

Putting nitrogen into tires may have a very slight, IMO, benefit but compared to other factors I think it is mostly BS, after all, air is 80% nitrogen to start with. The light gases such as helium and hydrogen will permeate the tire easier but the amounts are small.

Bill

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#34

Ohmigod! They're relentless…______

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>

Re: OT: Nitrogen Filled Tires??

#35

Corroding aluminum

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>In the northern portions of the country, they routinely sprinkle the roads with salt in the winter so we can drive a summer time speeds. The salt gets all over the cars. Many new cars, particularly the SUV's have aluminum wheels. When the tires are mounted, the balance them and put on clip on weights. Until recently all these weights had steel clips to hold them on. Conincidental with the weights being put on the clips cut through the surface anodize of the aluminum exposing the non-anodized material under it. The combination of steel, salt water and aluminum creates galvanic cells which speed up the corrosion of the aluminum. These cells stay active for long periods of time because the moisture is trapped between the rubber and the rim. After a while the corrosion stays bubbling the aluminum letting in more salt and moisture. Once the corrosion reaches the inside of the tire, air starts leaking out. Naturally when you get new tires the weights don't end up in the same spots so new areas of corrosion get started. On my '96 Explorer, I had to add air to all four wheels weekly to stay within 5 psi of the proper inflation due to the advanced corrosion where several sets of wheel weights had been.

They now have wheel weights that have teflon coated clips which are designed to reduce this problem on aluminum wheels and you can even get, if you ask for them, glue on weights.

Lee