Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

Posts

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#26

The difference is...

ScottS

>The difference is that Dave knows EXACTLY how much it costs to replace a blade ($100?) and brake ($80) if he triggers the SawStop. He might not keep lots of extra blades and brake cartridges on hand, so he also knows that he'll be shutdown for some amount of time if the brake triggers.

Do your students know the cost of triggering the mechanism? If they trigger the blade brake, do they immediately get a new blade and cartridge? Perhaps they'd be more conscious if you passed the "cost" of a firing along to them in the form of a fee, a bad grade, or being banned from using the TS for some period of time? If there are no consequences to triggering the blade brake, I wouldn't be surprised to find that students aren't focusing on it...

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#27

Re: interesting data

Dave Mount

>Hi McKay--

Interesting that you've had that experience. I guess it should be a surprise that different people would respond differently, and a high school shop would likely include personalities of all flavors.

I should also clarify that it's not worrying about the expense of tripping the brake that makes think about it, it's more just a gut reaction than a conscious thought. It may also fade with time. But apparently I'm not wired the same as some high school kids, and that's probably OK with me. I definitely don't feel as invincible as I did at that age.

Thanks for responding,

Dave

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#28

Re: The difference is...

McKay

>Students are minors, and so they are legally incapable of any action that would force them to pay. Yes, I do ban them from the equipment, but docking a grade would be extremely hard to justify in a court.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#29

Re: Well Chuck, if I'm a shill. . .

Kirk (KC) Constable

>I thought the 'forcing it down our throats' part was over, and he lost. Now he's just selling what most folks consider to be a saw that's superior to all similar competitors, and with the safety stuff as a bonus.

I didn't like the strongarm tactics years ago either... and swore he'd never get my bizness... but things change. If I need to replace my Xacta saw, it'll be with a SawStop.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#30

With all due respect, Chuck

wilbur

>With all due respect, Chuck, to say that the whole thread seems like a "setup" and then when someone calls you on that statement to qualify it by saying, "I don't recall pointing any fingers at anyone directly," is pretty weak. If this thread is a "setup", then you're implying that the people in this thread who have written positive things about the SawStop are participating in the setup.

If this isn't clear, think of the opposite position. If I said something along the lines of, "I bet that arguments against the SawStop are setup by Jet, Powermatic, Delta, and General", and if you took umbrage with that statement, would you be satisfied with me following up by saying, "Oh, I didn't name you personally, Chuck."

One other point. You said, "A company that is trying to force something down my throat I'm not real happy about."

If that's the case, I really hope you don't use Microsoft Windows. After all, they've been convicted of antitrust behavior.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#31

It has its limits/issues.

Ed Snow

>None of which really affects one all that much.

First let me say that I really push the limits of what can be done with a tool.

1. Zero clearance inserts, I can't find them, the ones they sell have way too much play and are zero clearance for only a few minutes. I wish I could figure out how to make them (I wish I had the time to figure out how to make them) If you have to have it you have to put an auxiliary mdf top on the saw, plunge through it then make your cuts, this is only for ripping, crosscutting with a sled is zero clearance.

2. You can't stack blades with spacers for multiple ripping cuts or cheek cuts on tenons. I imagine you might be able to with metal washers but I have yet to be that desperate.

3. Some thin kerf blades don't work but some do, the literature is contradictory.

4. Blade ring, this saw is the worst I have ever used with regards to this. I do not know why, the blade does not matter. Riving knife in, riving knife out. Fence set dead parallel of kicked out a few thousandths. No fence only crosscutting. Forrest, amana, freud, tenryu full kerf/thin kerf none of it makes a difference.

5. The riving knife is 1/8" too tall from the manufacturer, the adjustments provided are not enough to accommodate all blades so you have to modify it.

6. You can set the brake too close to the blade and it will fire when you start the saw, kills the cartridge but not the blade.

7. They should have put a uni-fence on it.

8. It is not a 14" saw, well not yet. 12" is in the pipeline.

9. The arbor is 1/4" too short.

Note these are not issues of one saw, I work on four of them.

Despite that, it is a great saw the problems that is has are none that make it a poor tool. It is not the best cutting table saw I have ever used but it does the job as well as a 10" powermatic/general/delta cabinet saw (which I also use). At the end of the day, I try to convince all of the students who ask me as well as anyone else that this is the only saw they should consider buying.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#32

No. 1, 5, 6, 7 7 & 4?

Bri in Mtl

>1. ZCI -I don't quite understand this. I find that you can adjust the insert to the point where it's so tight it's tough to take out.

5. I had the same problem when I installed my WW II. Then I discovered that all blades are not the same diameter. The SawStop blade had a bigger O.D. This was brought up when somone wanted to make a box to hold his saw blades.

6. Never heard of the brake firing if it has been adjusted to the right gap(thickness of a nickel)

7. I find the SS fence to be great. They give you the option of buying or using your own fence preference.

4. I'm not familiar with the term "blade ring".

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#33

Re: It has its limits/issues.

Barry Irby

>Ed, Thanks. These are the first realistic criticisms I have ever seen of the SawStop. I don't own one, but if I could, I would buy one. I think it is the first piece of technology that has been applied that has real safety benefits and I have recommended it over and over.

Some of your criticisms would not affect me much. I did not think the saw was "perfect" but all I ever heard was that it was as good as or better as a basic saw than the competitors but with the added safety benefits. It does appear that the safety features add a few draw backs or extra steps.

What's with the zero clearance throat plates? Would they cause it to fire? Are they any harder than any others to make?

I have heard that the mechanism will fire if you touch the blade and turn it by hand. Is that true?

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#34

Re: Zero clearance throat plate

Dave Mount

>Hi Ed--

Interesting post. I haven't experienced everything you wrote about, in particular the blade ring. I also haven't had the problem with the riving knive height. Although the factory setting was too high for my Freud and Forrest blades, the adjustment range was enough to get it positioned correctly. I only have one thin-kerf blade, a junker I only use to cut dirty wood, but works fine with the detection system. Clearly you have experience with a wider range of blades than I.

With regard to the zero clearance issue, I called SawStop about this. For those who haven't seen it, the factory throat plate is zero clearance in the forward two-thirds of it, but the opening is about 1/2" wide at the back, I believe to provide clearance for the blade guard. I agree this is not great as there's a tendence for thinner pieces to catch on the edge of the throat opening. Anyway, SawStop said I could take a dado throat plate, slit it for the riving knife and use it as a full length zero clearance plate. I ordered an extra throat plate to do this, but I haven't slit it and installed it yet so I can't report on how well it works.

Best,

Dave

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#35

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

Chuck in ND

>Wilbur, when would all the safety devices stop ? Just about every piece of woodworking equipment is dangerous. We are allready paying for some safety devices that very few people use, like blade guards on table saws, why would a SawStop be any different ? People are allways going to find a way to get rid of or bypass safety devices that hinder production. One way to kill this hobby off is to make it financially out of reach for most people.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#36

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

wilbur

>Hi Chuck,

Everything you say are reasonable concerns regarding whether or not one would purchase a SawStop or not. There are also very strong arguments as to why buying a SawStop would be a great idea.

But none of this has to do with your comment about this thread being a "setup", which is a comment that you should probably retract. It's one thing to make arguments for or against the purchase of a particular tool, but it's another thing entirely to imply that people having an opposing viewpoint have some sort of hidden agenda.

And I'll repeat that if you are so concerned with companies shoving products down our throats against our will by using anticompetitive tactics, you should not have a computer running Windows. Microsoft engaged in and was convicted of illegal activities to maintain their position in the marketplace. What Steve Gass did may have been distasteful, but it wasn't illegal. If you use a Windows computer, that's a bit of a contradiction between what you say and what you do.

As for me, I've avoided the tablesaw safety issue by not having a tablesaw in my shop. :@)

But I can say that if I were to get one, I would get a SawStop. And if I didn't have the money for one, I would do without and put money aside until I did.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#37

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

Chuck in ND

>Wilbur, I don't think I owe anybody a apology. I look through several wood forums daily and it just struck me rather odd that in the last couple days the SawStop has become the topic. I don't personally know all these people in the forums, do you ? I don't think a lawyer that tries to get richer by forceing people to buy and or use a product that he sells through legislation probably isn't in the best interest of anybody but himself. I'm just a basic average low to middle income guy trying to weather the tough times of the economy right now. Would I like to have a shop thats every woodworkers dream ? Sure I would, but right now thats not going to happen nor is it neccesary. I think alot of these forums get all wraped up in who's got the biggest and more expensive tools rather than where it should be, and thats what you can do with you got, no matter what it is. For instance, just because you own a Harley doesn't turn you into a instant biker, and owning a Humvee doesn't turn you into an instant expert at 4 wheeling. Some people have got more money than brains, but they sure look good. Persopnally I think the lawyers and the rich have screwed and used this country up enough, they don't need to do it to woodworking too. Now excuse me while I go whittle something on the front porch in my rocker.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#38

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

Chuck in ND

>I also think that if the SawStop even without the safety feature is as good as a saw as some people say, which I don't doubt, they look nice on the outside, ( I'd have to look inside of one and compare it to a Unisaw first to know for sure ) they should offer the saw with the safety feature or without the safety feature but still be able to upgrade it with the safety feature if someday you feel you want it, and or can afford it, give people a choice. I think they would be more successfull with the friendly aproach verses the cram it down your throat tactic.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#39

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

wilbur

>So, does your computer run Windows, then? Because that's exactly what Microsoft did with Internet Explorer -- cram it down everyone's throats, and not giving people a choice as to whether they should use it.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#40

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

Chuck in ND

>I don't remember saying that Bill Gates was my hero. But I do know that it's affordable for most people to use the internet.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#41

Unfortunately..

Bri in Mtl

>...some laws have to be "rammed" down people's throats for their own protection. Seat belts, smoking, speed limits, alcohol limits, and probably a host of others that I can't think of. In Europe btw, riving knives are required by law on tablesaws.

I'm one of them that has to have some laws rammed -I don't go over the speed limit not because it's dangerous, because I don't want a ticket.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#42

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

wilbur

>So, to summarize:

You have a beef with Steve Gass and SawStop, because he tried to cram SawStop technology down everyone's throat, even though the methods he used were legal even if they were distasteful.

You don't have a problem with Bill Gates and Windows, even though Microsoft was found GUILTY of cramming Internet Explorer down everyone's throat and maintaining their monopoly position in the computer world by using ILLEGAL anticompetitive tactics, partly due to the fact that your computer was affordable.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#43

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

Chuck in ND

>Wilbur, I certainly don't have the time to think of everyone that I think has played unfair in the bussiness world and post it, thats not what this thread is about. Let me see if I can explain it in another direction. Wood working right now is not exactly growing in popularity, do it yourself home owners that want to fixup their homes are. A good majority of those people at best are looking at lower priced jobsite saws, not cabinet saws. For the few people that want to get into woodworking there is a sea of good used equipment out there to buy before people will spend that kind of money. I will tell you right now, the day that I'm forced to buy a $4000 table saw or anything else like SawStop would like to see because of safety will be the day I will hang it all up, and I'm sure there will be many more low to middle income people that will follow. As I said before, makeing equipment so expensive that the average person can't afford it is one way to surely kill this hobby off. Especially in this economy. None of it adds up, then to top it all off, who's going to enforce this new law ? If you want to get serious about reduceing accidents in this country without ruining it for others we should be looking to these TV shows that give people the impression that they can remodel a kitchen by themselves in a day with no carpentry experience, no experience with tools or useing them safely, and no patience, thats what needs to be corrected. All the safety devices in the world won't save some of these people.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#44

Re: Wow. What a list

Brian in Brighton

>While I have nothing to do with SawStop, but am looking forward to having one, I would encourage everyone to think about safety products. All you have to do is be nearby when someone cuts their hand apart to understand. If you think safety is second to cost than you will most assuradly cut yourself one day.

I spoke to Steve Gass many years ago when he was just getting the legislation to try to go thru. I signed his petition, and am proud of it, not because I want the government in my business but because Steve went to every major saw maker in the world and they would not touch his device because of potential litigation. Litigation that would show that they have been making unsafe products for years. I find it stupid on their part and would have been the first to adopt the technology into my saws, if I was making them. Now the other saw companies have opened themselves up to lawsuits to failing to implement safe technology. The legislation he had written allowed a saw company to come up with ANY stopping technology. They would not be constrained to his design or idea. The naysayers out there who hate this idea always seem to be the same people who refuse to wear a seatbelt because the don't want some government official telling them what to do. They won't wear one because they might roll over in a ditch of water and drown or some other cockamaimy story.

We all got to deal with the fact that it took 30 years and finally a government mandate to get airbags and seatbelts into every car. The hundreds of thousands of people who died without them paid for the few morons who stood in the way of safety crying about a few dollars cost or that they would not be told what to do by some g-man in a suit. BTW: Airbags are sold to the factories for less than a decent dinner for 2. This is what the car makers thought the customer's lives were not worthy of back then.

If there is proven technology that could take the number 1 most injury causing tool and make it safe than that is something the government should seriously consider mandating. Not to be more intrusive, but to be more cost effective to society as a whole. My friend cost $80,000 back in 1992 to get 4 fingers fixed. He did not amputate them completely, but did a lot of damage. Add to that the cost of him being out of work for months and it surely is worth the $4000 vs $2500 for a cabinet saw.

Enough said.

Brian in Brighton

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#45

Re: With all due respect, Chuck

wilbur

>Chuck, a while back you said, "It just seems a little odd to me that this saw is being brought up in other forums as well at the same time. A company that is trying to force something down my throat I'm not real happy about."

It certainly seems that unfair and underhanded business practices was what you were making this thread about. That was the first thing that you brought up.

So now that you know about Microsoft's illegal business activities, are you going to do anything about it?

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#46

Okay Guys....

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Chuck and Wilbur,

I think this going no where anymore....so....lets all move along please..

Thanks,

Jim

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#47

Re: Wow. What a list

Sgian Dubh

>"Steve went to every major saw maker in the world and they would not touch his device because of potential litigation

Brian, I wasn't aware that apart from approaching the well known American based brands he'd also gone to all the European saw makers as well, eg, Altendorf, Martin, Felder, SCMI, Rojek, Perform, SIP, Record, Robland, Axminster, and others too many to list.

Are you sure about that? If you're correct I find it interesting because I've heard nothing regarding SawStop technology being fitted to bench or table saws, either voluntarily or through government legislation. I'm pretty sure our European governement(s), eg, the EU are much fonder of safety legislation than the Americans are. There would have been some buzz in my industry I'm sure, but so far not a peep in any of the trade journals or on the grapevine that I can recall. Slainte.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#48

Lee Grindinger

Yeah, but

Lee Grindinger

>If you wish to compare Sawstop to automobile safety shouldn't you start with mandatory licensing and competence tests like there are for automobiles?

Honestly, if everyone had to prove competence to own a table saw there would be far fewer accidents.

Lee

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#49

Blade ring.

Ed Snow

>Blade ring is best described as what happens when a system (the blade/cutting process) develops a vibration and how it is then released or dumped. Similar to how a glass can break when its natural resonance is matched with a sound. However, a blade being metal and malleable just dumps the excess energy without breaking resuming its preferred state, temporarily.

There are other blade issues that just cause a bad cut like the arbor not being concentric to its rotational axis or just bad blades but in this situation you have a nice cut then the blade rings creating a divot then the nice cut resumes until this situation is propagated again.

And yes it actually makes a sound, the blade rings like a bell for a very brief moment.

I apologize if the exact physics terminology is incorrect or missing but that is what is happening, I am not and engineer or physicist and it has been a while since I have taken any of those types of classes.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#50

Re: Yeah, but

Chuck in ND

>Another concern I think would be in a shop full of other employees running equipment at the same time. When the cartridge gets triped it sounds like a shot gun going off and could make everyone else in the shop jump or flinch, causeing more accidents.