Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

Posts

SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#1

SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

Pete in Holland, MI

>Guys -

Am curious on any feedback that purchaser/users of the SawStop tablesaws can lend to the group.

I am concerned that damp wood (like treated lumber) will trigger the mechanism? I know there is an over-ride switch on the saw for this, but at what point do you know when to turn it on/off ?

Has anyone had a false triggering of their saw due to the type of material being sawn?

What's the recovery cost if the mechanism after a trip?

I understand that this mechanism does a great job stopping the blade, but wrecks it in the mean time.

What's going on out there guys ?

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#2

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

Bri in Mtl

>Am curious on any feedback that purchaser/users of the SawStop tablesaws can lend to the group.

I am concerned that damp wood (like treated lumber) will trigger the mechanism? I know there is an over-ride switch on the saw for this, but at what point do you know when to turn it on/off ?

- When the saw is off the safety system is still on but the cartridge won't fire. So you can touch the blade with your wet wood and see if the red light comes on.

Has anyone had a false triggering of their saw due to the type of material being sawn?

-Not me. Others users have due to the blade hitting their miter gauge or something similar.

What's the recovery cost if the mechanism after a trip?

-New cartridge is about $80 and probably a new blade. Some blades are still salvageable though. If the brake fired due to a SawStop "save" and you send the cartridge back to SawStop for analysis they will send you a new cartridge no charge.

I understand that this mechanism does a great job stopping the blade, but wrecks it in the mean time.

-See previous reply.

What's going on out there guys ?

-More and more people and companies are purchasing them. It's a great saw. The riving knife, which tilts and moves up and down with the blade is another reason to purchase this saw.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#3

Another related question

Chad Pearson

>Every time I have seen a Sawstop demonstration (TV or intertube) they have been slowly feeding the hot dog into the blade. I would love to see a hot dog test where the hotdog is moved into the blade very quickly (like a kickback scenario).

cp

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#4

Re: Another related question

Chuck in ND

>Reuseing the damaged blade is not recommended because of what happens to the brazeing that attaches the teeth.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#5

Look here..  *LINK*

Bri in Mtl

>


SaStop High speed

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#6

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

John E in SC

>Saw video recently (Fine WWing, I think) where someone tested exactly what you are asking - results: wet would did NOT trigger it. Metal (a staple in the end of a board, a common scenario) DID. They also forcefully threw the hotdog at the blade to mimic a kickback scenario - result was a larger nick than you see on the classic "slow feed" video, but still fairly minor, and an awful lot better than you would get from a regular TS (probably wouldn't need more than a bandaid). I don't currently have one, but in my mind, the only reason not to is the price. If I had time to do more woodworking, I would have one.

My 2 cents.

John

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#7

SawStop and high speed contact *LINK*

wilbur

>I've posted this before, but I think it bears repeating.

I was bored once and ran through the math regarding how much damage could be done if your body was slammed into the SawStop.

The SawStop system stops the blade in 5 ms. My wrist is 3 inches wide. If I was to deliberately chop off my hand on a SawStop, I would have to get those 3 inches through the blade in 5 ms.

If you do the math, you'd have to be hitting the blade at 34 mph to do this.

This is actually a worst case scenario, and is assuming that the blade is cutting with the same efficiency throughout the 5 ms period. Remember, the SawStop mechanism also drops the blade under the table, and the blade is being slowed by the brake, so it probably isn't cutting as well towards the end of the period of contact.

Now let's look at the scenario of getting hit in the stomach with a piece of wood from kickback and falling face first on the blade. For the average person, there's about 3 feet of vertical distance between your head and the surface of the tablesaw.

Suppose the force of the blow was such that you immediately passed out, and you had a dead fall onto the blade. If you drop an object, it takes 0.45 seconds to fall 3 feet. In this time, you'll accelerate to a speed of 4.4 m/s. This works out to 9.8 mph -- much slower than it would take to chop off my wrist on a SawStop. At that speed, you'll travel into the blade only 0.8 inches in the 5 ms it takes to stop the blade. That's still a bad cut, but much better than the alternative. Realize that this estimate of the depth of the cut is exaggerated. The blade will be braking as it slows down in that 5 ms, so that the amount of time that the blade is traveling at a speed sufficient to cut human tissue is even less.

Let's take an even more ridiculous scenario. Let's suspend a woodworker from the ceiling of his shop and drop him directly on a SawStop. In order to chop off a hand at the wrist, he'll have to be going 34 mph when he hits the blade. In a dead fall, it will take him 1.5 seconds of free fall before he reaches that velocity. A dropped object will fall 39 feet in 1.5 seconds. This means that you would have to drop a woodworker from a height of 39 feet onto a SawStop before he develops the velocity needed to chop off a hand at the wrist.

(This is, of course, assuming Earth gravity. Someone else can do the math for woodworkers on Jupiter.)

Of course, Wood Magazine had to go ahead and make a video of a hotdog making high speed contact with a SawStop, making my brilliant analysis somewhat redundant. :@)

But it's interesting to note that their test resulted in a 1/4" deep cut in the hotdog, which is less than my dead fall scenario.


Hotdog making high speed contact with a SawStop

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#8

Re: Another related question

Neal in San Jose

>I have probably seen a dozen live demos of the hot dog trick. I've seen the video demo, and all I can guess is that they are trying to go slow enough that you get a chance to see what happens. At the store where I bought mine, Sawdust in Santa Clara, CA, they usually use a piece of plywood and push it thru a lot faster than I would for a normal cut. It still doesn't make much of a cut on the hot dog. I have not fired the cartridge in mine, and only know one person that has. A student at one of Sawdust's classes reached across a dado blade and brushed it with her finger after she had turned the power off and the blade was coasting down. She admitted she didn't even realize she had set it off until the instructor came running up. She did require a bandaid but was able to continue working on her project.

Speaking strictly for myself, having a Saw Stop squatting in the middle of the shop has made me more safety conscious. It is the most effective "Think Safety" sign I've ever encountered. The analogy I use is that my old car's safety equipment was limited to seat belts. My new car has anti-lock breaks, stability control, air bags, full time four wheel drive and probably some other stuff I've forgotten, but I don't regret any of the extra cost and I hope I never test any of it. It does give me a little piece of mind in this nutso CA traffic

I'm sure I wouldn't try and reuse a blade that had been thru a firing. That is a violent stop, and the teeth that slam into the aluminum block would certainly be suspect in my mind. Having a carbide tooth fly off at speed might ruin my day! Neal

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#9

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

Patrick Schupbach

>There is an excellent review w/video on the Lumberjocks website. You can find it under tool reviews. Hope this helps.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#10

Re: pro-SawStop semi-rant

Dave Mount

>I've had a SawStop for a little over a year and have been nothing but pleased with it. I haven't set it off. On a couple occasions I have disabled the brake because I was concerned that the interior of a piece of wood might be wetter than the end when I tested it against the blade without the saw going (interestingly, the opposite of what the Wood mag demo showed).

I have yet to hear of what I'd call a false trip. Some people say the brake going off when they hit a screw is a false trip. I disagree, this is the saw doing what it is supposed to (in my opinion). If it didn�t go off when it hit a screw, I�d be worried it wouldn�t go off when it was my finger instead of a screw. Do people really think the saw should be able to tell the difference?

Somebody else mentioned this and it sounds silly, but it's true. Naysayers (who don't own the saw, BTW) claim having the blade brake would make you less conscious about safety around the saw. Like another poster, I've had the exact opposite experience, in that having the saw has made me even more conscious about having my fingers close to the blade. It sounds ridiculous to say you think, "Boy, I better keep my fingers away because I don't want to have that brake go off" -- like somehow that�s worse than cutting off a finger. But in some way, that is what goes on in the back of your mind.

As someone else also said, the riving knife is probably as big a safety feature as the brake. The whole saw is well made � as much as I liked my Unisaw, the SawStop is a better saw even without the brake.

The false trip rationalization/argument is a non-starter. If false trips were common, we'd have heard about it -- in fact the "anti-SawStop" crowd would be trumpeting it everywhere. And even if it did happen occasionally, it would still be cheap insurance against the worst case scenario. If you can afford a $4K saw, then it's really silly to be worrying about losing $50-$100 bucks on a false trip, one of which has yet to be reported.

I'm not sure I've ever seen a topic where people have had stranger risk/cost/benefit analyses. There are lots of people around who have had bad injuries on the TS that would have been prevented by a SawStop, many of which have posted on this very board. Unless I'm mistaken, there hasn't been one of them posting, "Gee, I'm sure glad I didn't waste $4K on a SawStop, cutting my body was a way better deal."

Not everyone can justify the admittedly much higher price of a SawStop and I don't blame them for choosing another saw. Others have it in for the company because they don't like some of the history (or at least their reading of it) -- that's fine too, they don't have to buy one (incidentally, much as I like the technology, I wouldn�t favor the gov making it mandatory). But when I did the math, there was no other conclusion I could reach than that I should buy the saw.

In the couple weeks between when I ordered it and when I received it, all I could think about was the potential irony if I cut myself on my Unisaw while waiting on the delivery. If you're on the fence, just go ahead and get it � get it right now. Think of how stupid you'll feel if you have an accident on your current saw while you're stewing around about whether you might experience a false trip on a SawStop someday.

I'm sorry if this sounds like an infomercial. I've no connection with SawStop or any vendor that sells them, other than the fact that I own one.

There are people who don�t wear seat belts in their car, even though that costs them nothing. That�s their choice, but it�s not mine.

Best,

Dave, who thinks it was $4K very well spent.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#11

Re: pro-SawStop semi-rant

David G. Sparks

>Thanks for all you said. I agree with you. I bought a Powermatic model 66 not long before the Sawstop came went on the market. I wish I had waited. The Sawstop is a great saw, and an excellent safety concept. If they ever figure out a retrofit for other saws, I'll buy it.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#12

Re: Another related question

Howard Acheson

>That was done. A hotdog on a stick was swung into the blade. The damage was estimated at about 2 stitches and not enough penetration to reach the bone in a finger.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#13

Re: SawStop - - FAQS & prices here.

North of the Border

>This Sawstop site offers info. / answers to most faqs, including pricing.

http://tinyurl.com/28sajc

The basic model costs about $2800 but it seems it only runs on 200 - 230 V and above. Unless you already have 200 V power supply in your shop, you must add more to the base price.

Let's hope sawstop safety mechanism or the like will become a standard feature for all tablesaws and will be more affordable for amateur woodworkers. (I saw somewhere the riving knife will be a standard part of all tablesaws after 2011 to be sold in the US.)

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#14

Re: pro-SawStop semi-rant

Chuck Lenz

>Almost the whole thread sounds setup to me. I supose some of you would pay $750 for a SawStop circular saw too huh ? Give me a break.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#15

Yeah but...

Bri in Mtl

>That's the price with no fence, extension table, dado cartridge and dado insert, or mobile base(which is awesome), plus there are extra shipping charges dependant on where you live.

Mine was well over 4K. No regrets whatsoever.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#16

Re: Well Chuck, if I'm a shill. . .

Dave Mount

>then I was placed with quite a bit of foresight. If you take a moment and do a search of the archives, you'll note that my posts on this board go back to 2003 (and Badger Pond before that), and I never once mentioned a SawStop until after I bought one, like I said, a little over a year ago. I think those posts will also make clear that I'm just a woodworker like anyone else. There are guys over on the hand tool side that spend $5K on a handplane. That's not something I do, but I don't think they're a shill just because they talk about the plane and why they think it's worth it. And I enjoy hearing about why they think it's worth it.

In answer to your question, if a SawStop circular saw was available, and if I used a circular saw with the frequency and personal exposure that I do a tablesaw, I would gladly spend $750 for one, because the math would be same.

If it's not worth it to you, that's cool. But I don't think it's right for you to translate your personal skepticism into accusing me of being a shill, nor to imply that you think someone willing to spend money on safety is foolish.

Work safely,

Dave

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#17

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

Pete in Holland, MI

>Cool dialog thus far. Seems the saw has a good track record for doing pretty much exactly what it was designed to do and nothing more. Kudos to the engineers that came up with and perfected the system.

This device is purely "insurance". It makes the saw function no better, but those who have it will surely appreciate having purchased it if the time ever came when their hand accidently enters the cutting zone. There are recent threads on this site that attest to the fact that accidents DO happen in our hobby. Nobody likes paying for insurance on your car/home/boat/etc. Some nay-sayers have attested to that. Sometimes, insurance is required. Other times optional. Depends on how much risk you want to take on. Most of us pay 1000's of dollars over our life time to insurance companies and may never have to make an insurance claim.

Some of us can afford the saw, others can't afford, or justify it. Those who had contemplated, then purchased the cheaper saw, and later on, had an accident, will surely kick themselves in the ass over that decision.

It is an interesting observation that feedback from some is that they watch their fingers MORE with the Sawstop, for fear of tripping the mechanism and costing money to recover from the trip. Seems being thrifty can sometimes make you look at things a little safer than in the past to avoid costing yourself money.

Keep the user feedback coming.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#18

Re: pro-SawStop semi-rant

Sean Troy

>I can't find a single post where Chuck has something positive to say. Smile chuck, lifes not all that bad

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#19

I'm becoming a convert

Eddie Pacheco; San Jose, Ca.

>I just started working P/T at TAP Plastics and they have switched to the SAWSTOP saw. I have a Rockwell cabinet saw and I find the SAWSTOP to be a more quiet machine. It uses a ribbed or Poly-V drive belt in the primary and secondary drives. Plus you gotta love that Dale Ernhardt black paint scheme.

They have a fairly comprehensive manual and they also warn that if a finger or body is rapidly introduced into the blade a deeper cut may result. That's fair.

We did have a situation Sat. where the saw shut off at the start of a cut. Via the code on the green and red LED's on the front switch box ( nice feature by the way) we were able to determine that we had too much plastic shavings around the cartridge. Due to the static electricity, from cutting plastic sheets, not all of the shavings (sawdust) get sucked away by the dust collector via the saw's nifty dust chute. We cleaned out the shavings and we were able to power up and run the rest of the day. This area of the saw had not been cleaned out in a long while. We have now made it an area to check every 2 weeks.

The fact that there have been no miss triggers with the amount of static charge around that saw says a a lot about the electronics. Also it should be pointed out that you don't just plug in a SAWSTOP saw. The manual has a very specific wiring diagram dictating hard wiring to a power source. Proper grounding and proper wiring are key to the reliability of the safety system.

For DADO blades you do need a different brake cartridge. I'm curious now, how the standard cartridge will work on the new box joint cutting blade combo from Freud. (I think it's Freud that has this product) SAWSTOP advises against blade stacking.

The minor things I don't like about the saw is that the graduated scale for the fence can wear out and in some areas, on the saw I used, the graduated markings have been chipped off. I also think it's a bit of a hassle to remove the throat insert. For a hobbyist scenario it isn't too bad. In a shop I think it slows down things a lot.

On my home saw I have the Brett OSHA overarm guard, and I like my setup, but I have to say that just from a few days of using the SAWSTOP saw I like it enough to put it on my short term wish list.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#20

Re: Well Chuck, if I'm a shill. . .

Chuck Lenz

>Dave I don't recall pointing any fingers at anyone directly. It just seems a little odd to me that this saw is being brought up in other forums as well at the same time. A company that is trying to force something down my throat I'm not real happy about. The reality of it is if you want to talk safety, most people don't put the blade guard on their saw, some don't use push sticks. I even had an employer in a cabinet door shop that I was thinking about going to work for laugh at me saying that I didn't need to use a push stick. Go on a construction site and see how many blade guards on circular saws have a door shim jambed in them to keep them open, or air nailers with the safety removed. While I'll admit all these practices are not safe, I will say they are rampant. There also seems to be a large percentage of people that don't read owners manuals. How many people use safe practices when it comes to dust in the shop, such as dust collection, air filtration and a good dust mask? How many people that buy the SawStop are going to use it in the overide position for fear that they will trip it and have to buy a new catridge and a new blade ? I was a meat cutter for 17 years, a hobbyist woodworker for almost 30 years, I still have all my digits and they are all complete. I've been lucky, but also, I don't let people push me into working fast and careless, I fully respect the tools I use, on occassion I have had some close but mainly what I would call stupid moments, ones I don't forget. If you don't have your mind on exactly what your doing in the shop, then you need to back off, take a break, get away from it. Accidents will happen, and being afraid of them is a good thing. If someone has the money to buy these saws fine, I don't, and I don't see it as being practical in a hobby that your lucky if you can make $10 an hour with no bennies. I don't even think a cabinet saw is practical for what I do. The goverment shoves enough crap down my throat, I don't need this too.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#21

Re: pro-SawStop semi-rant

Chuck in ND

>Sorry Sean, but some of this stuff gets rediculous.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#22

SawStop

Howard Norman

>When I look at the cost of a SawStop I know that I could never afford one. I believe that any power saw has the potential to seriously injure someone. I doubt that I would buy one even if the cost was 10% of the present cost. If someone has that kind of money to spend on a saw I would say do it if it makes you happy but don't expect the average Joe to go along with you on such a purchase.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#23

Re: Well Chuck, if I'm a shill. . .

Bri in Mtl

>You said " on occasion I have had some close but mainly what I would call stupid moments, ones I don't forget. If you don't have your mind on exactly what your doing in the shop, then you need to back off, take a break, get away from it. Accidents will happen, and being afraid of them is a good thing."

This is a reason for many folks to get a SawStop.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#24

Re: pro-SawStop semi-rant

McKay Sleight

>You said,"Somebody else mentioned this and it sounds silly, but it's true. Naysayers (who don't own the saw, BTW) claim having the blade brake would make you less conscious about safety around the saw."

I have three saw stops, and although they are a good saw, the fact is that people ARE less safe. I have six activations in the last year at the school to prove it. Prior to that in 28 years I have never had anything more than a couple of stitches from one student who was not following safety procedures. After the last activation I shut the saws down and everyone had to re-take the 27 question safety exam that I have on the TS. So say what you will, people are thinking in the back of their mind that they do not need to follow safety procedures. No amount of legislation by the lawyers that produced the sawstop will stop someone from being stupid.

Re: SawStop - - field feedback ? ?

#25

The Issue with dados is......

Howard Acheson

>....the diameter. The dado brake will be required for any 8" diameter blade or multi-blade tool I believe. Of course, contacting SawStop will get the official answer.