Re: pro-SawStop semi-rant
Dave Mount
>I've had a SawStop for a little over a year and have been nothing but pleased with it. I haven't set it off. On a couple occasions I have disabled the brake because I was concerned that the interior of a piece of wood might be wetter than the end when I tested it against the blade without the saw going (interestingly, the opposite of what the Wood mag demo showed).
I have yet to hear of what I'd call a false trip. Some people say the brake going off when they hit a screw is a false trip. I disagree, this is the saw doing what it is supposed to (in my opinion). If it didn�t go off when it hit a screw, I�d be worried it wouldn�t go off when it was my finger instead of a screw. Do people really think the saw should be able to tell the difference?
Somebody else mentioned this and it sounds silly, but it's true. Naysayers (who don't own the saw, BTW) claim having the blade brake would make you less conscious about safety around the saw. Like another poster, I've had the exact opposite experience, in that having the saw has made me even more conscious about having my fingers close to the blade. It sounds ridiculous to say you think, "Boy, I better keep my fingers away because I don't want to have that brake go off" -- like somehow that�s worse than cutting off a finger. But in some way, that is what goes on in the back of your mind.
As someone else also said, the riving knife is probably as big a safety feature as the brake. The whole saw is well made � as much as I liked my Unisaw, the SawStop is a better saw even without the brake.
The false trip rationalization/argument is a non-starter. If false trips were common, we'd have heard about it -- in fact the "anti-SawStop" crowd would be trumpeting it everywhere. And even if it did happen occasionally, it would still be cheap insurance against the worst case scenario. If you can afford a $4K saw, then it's really silly to be worrying about losing $50-$100 bucks on a false trip, one of which has yet to be reported.
I'm not sure I've ever seen a topic where people have had stranger risk/cost/benefit analyses. There are lots of people around who have had bad injuries on the TS that would have been prevented by a SawStop, many of which have posted on this very board. Unless I'm mistaken, there hasn't been one of them posting, "Gee, I'm sure glad I didn't waste $4K on a SawStop, cutting my body was a way better deal."
Not everyone can justify the admittedly much higher price of a SawStop and I don't blame them for choosing another saw. Others have it in for the company because they don't like some of the history (or at least their reading of it) -- that's fine too, they don't have to buy one (incidentally, much as I like the technology, I wouldn�t favor the gov making it mandatory). But when I did the math, there was no other conclusion I could reach than that I should buy the saw.
In the couple weeks between when I ordered it and when I received it, all I could think about was the potential irony if I cut myself on my Unisaw while waiting on the delivery. If you're on the fence, just go ahead and get it � get it right now. Think of how stupid you'll feel if you have an accident on your current saw while you're stewing around about whether you might experience a false trip on a SawStop someday.
I'm sorry if this sounds like an infomercial. I've no connection with SawStop or any vendor that sells them, other than the fact that I own one.
There are people who don�t wear seat belts in their car, even though that costs them nothing. That�s their choice, but it�s not mine.
Best,
Dave, who thinks it was $4K very well spent.