Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Posts

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#26

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>For anything to be protected by copyright law it has to have three things; the owner of the copyrights name, the year the design was created and the copyright symbol. These things need to be placed in a normally viewable area, the bottom of a chair is fine but the bottom of the feet in not. If these three things are present the design is protected even if it was never registered. The courts have ruled that even without registering a design if it has those three things that the designer clearly intended for copyright protection to apply to it. If the design is not registered the designer can sue for damages.

So right about now you�re asking "what�s the point of registering a copyright?" the added protection of a registered copyright is that you can then sue to recover legal fees in addition to damages. Also a registered copyright is needed in order to license a design.

I agree 100% about the uncomfortableness of most of FLW's furniture and think that that alone would be reason enough to use it merely as inspiration for an original design.

Robin

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#27

Re: Copycats

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>I'm pretty sure most of us learned the fallacy of the "everyone else is doning it" argument with the "jumping off a clif" analogy. as for being 'trained from day one to copy', I am not so sure of that. I don't get NYW where I live but the few times I have seen it I seem to remember Norm saying someting along the lines of "on our version of this clasic piece..." and enevitably the piece is so old or generic that it is not protected by copyright. add to that that the piece alwasy has a few changes from the original. to me that is more of using something for inspiration. I do thing it should be the responsibility of the woodworking magazine industry to help educate their readership of copyright protection and which of the pieces pictured in their pages is free to be copied and which ones are not. Same for the shows and DVD's

The NYW has only been on the air for 25 years, if you go back in time another 25 years to 1957 it was normal and legal for there to be a white and colored drinking fountian in public places. I don't think anyone today would think that we shold not have passed cilil rights laws. I don't mean in anyway to cmpare copyright infringement to the importance of civil rights. I am merely poininting out how a societies thinking changes over time. The hobby woodworking community is relatively young and with the introduction of the internet it is rappidly changing. Copyright protection applies to one off as well as mass produced work. we will continue to have these discusions until people begin to recognize the law as it is written or collectively work to change that law.

Robin

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#28

Re: Copycats

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have to take many of the opinions stated with a smile. I worked for 39 years as an Engineer for Emerson Appliance (originally Mallory Controls). Our division was one of the smaller Emerson groups, but we had our own litigation attorney and a Patent attorney on staff. I designed and built (or had built) many automated assembly and testing machines during my employment. Several had innovations that allowed us to be the largest supplier of certain products (brake switches to GM) etc. I never had any machines patented as the lawyers agreed we could not protect the patents. Believe me the corporation had "deep pockets" so it wasn't a money issue. It was determined that if we patented the machines, our competitors would then have working drawings that they could use to build a very similar machine - saving them the expense of development. We instead considered these machines "proprietary" and did not allow photographs of them to be taken, and covered area's of them with opaque material when people were given tours of the plant. It is rather odd, but "benchmarking" has became a buzzword for many programs involving design improvements. This term really should be "copying" as it involves the purchase of competitive products, then the inspection of these products to determine what portions of the design can be used ("copied") to develop your product. The Patent attorney is involved to determine what can be "copied" and what changes must be made to avoid extensive litigation. Of course our corporation had a large full time staff of attorneys kept busy either defending or instituting cases involving patent infringement. During my involvement in some of these issues, I found that most of the patent /copyright protection is dependent on fear - in the majority of the cases where a warning of infringement action was issued, the attorneys knew they wouldn't or couldn't prove a case. I do not intentionally "copy" any item, but certainly am not worried any case will be brought against me if I do.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#29

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Robin,

Please don't mistake my or anyone else's replies as a dispute with your basic premise. But copying of other artists' work has been a basic and standard practice for thousands of years, all as part of the training and learning process. You're not going to change that with a little "TM" or circle C. Onesie twosie copies in that context have never been an issue; it's the wholesale manufacturing of an original design that usually gets people's blood boiling and rightfully so.

Trained as a sculptor and art historian, I spent a lot of time working though this phase or that with stuff clearly recognizable as influenced by the work of others. Was I stealing? No, absolutely not. Instead I was learning different visual "languages", studying ideas and relationships, individual songs if you will, to see how different notes went together, hopefully in an effort to become accomplished enough to come up with my own song(s). I had my Rodin phase, my Hepworth and Moore "periods", even Giocometti and Degas and Gilberti with some Han, Ming, and Middle Kingdom thrown in for fun.

My wife loves Stickley stuff. We have purchased some of their pieces, but I've made others that are open to a charge of being derivative, yet they are quite different in some ways. I've even gone to a Stickley "store" with rule, pad, and pen and done detailed drawings of elements (just like Norm). There's no better way to learn than to immerse yourself in anothers design, put in on like a old jacket, and feel how it feels, where it's worn thin. Once you do that, you can begin to change things to suit your own idea while staying within the basic design vocabulary. Are the resulting pieces Stickley? Not at all, and someone sensitive to the originals will see the differences right away. I have no interest in make Stickley pieces, but I am interested in using some of his visual language.

I sense that you're a more "strict constructionist" than I, and you're more dedicated to protection by way of bright-line rules. Such rules are, of course, easier to enforce, but the cost becomes prohibitive, and ultimately becomes self-defeating because it stiffles artistic communication.

Yes, worry about pirating software and CD's and lifting the writings of others to be passed off as original work. But cut Rob and others like him a break from the literal concepts involved. His making a Wright chair, even an exact copy, will do no harm to the Wright Foundation, or Copeland Furniture, and may do Rob a whole bunch of good because, once he sits on it, he won't be tempted to make any more of them. He'll have learned that "pretty" and "famous" don't always translate as "good" just because some name-dropping reputed intellectual who talks with his teeth clenched expounds on what good taste is.

Peace |;-}

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#30

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>It is just as wrong for an individual hobby woodworker to make one unauthorized chair as it is for a manufacturer to make 1000 unauthorized copies of the same chair.

I too studied art and it was never ok to copy another artist. It is true that we are all influenced by others but we are all influenced by different artist and often even different pieces of the same artist will appeal to different individuals. It is the combination of all the things that influence us that contribute to each artist�s unique visual vocabulary.

My designs are my livelihood; they are what distinguishes me from the other talented furniture makers as well as all the skilled craftsmen that build from plans. By condoning Rob's building of an unauthorized copy of a FLW chair because it really won't hurt the FLW foundation is also condoning him as well as others that it is ok to copy one of my designs or the designs of one of my talented furniture maker friends. I can assure you that none of us who make a living with our designs wants any one to make a copy.

There are plenty of designs that are in the public domain and if anyone is in doubt they can certainly ask just like than do about all the other questions answered on this list, and like all the other questions it will most likely help others as well.

Robin

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#31

Copying

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I am wondering how long a design need be protected from copying. Frank W. was born in 1867 and died almost 50 years ago at 91; it could be that a daughter from his 4th wife is still living. Fallingwater was built in 1939 and was in poor shape when I visited in 1971. So what is the longevity of a design made in 2008? Are you planning the RC Foundation? Is there a market for licenses?

I am often asked to copy stuff for my business. I am currently copying a piece made in 1792. I'm glad the maker didn't have any qualms about copying other's designs because he did a superb job, probably better than the original which was copied by many others also.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#32

Re: Copying

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Warren,

Our friend Robin is not wrong in his concept. If he comes up with a unique design for something, puts his intellectual sweat into it, and takes pride in his accomplishment with the expectation that he'll also have the opportunity to make a living producing it for sale, he has every right to be pissed off when some Chinese sweatshop puts 500,000 knock-offs on the street at a quarter of the price of his base cost.

His conflict arises out of the clash between human ethics and human economics. The capitalist concept (and our legal system) encourage people to breach their agreements and contracts if they will loose less money by paying damages to the other party that they will if the complete the deal. That is pure economic efficiency. Yet we have this underlying concept that if you make an agreement, you should carry it through, and complete what you promised to do. Using somebody else's design for something is not intellectualy "honest", but it is very "efficient". In this country we espouse to value individual effort, the "self-made man", and the "build a better mouse trap" concepts. We don't, however, subsidize our artists who are forced to work 2 or 3 jobs to get by and fund their art on the side. It is a dichotomy impossible to reconcile.

Now I haven't seen Robin's work, so I'm not in a position to judge or comment, but woodturners and potters operate under an unwritten maxim, nobody "owns" a shape because over the last few hundred thousand years they have all been done already; in ways and variations too numerous to count. But that doesn't mean that we can't still do them and bring fresh vision and innovative application to their use.

Hey, Dude, I've got these fine fine Rollex watches. A special purchase at only $250, guaranteed for a distance of 1000 meters, and each with a certificate of authenticity in a lined presentation box. Interested?

|;-}}

PS: BA - Art History - the first art major to graduate from F&M (1969)

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#33

Re: Copying

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>Just as there are different types of patents there are also different types of copyrights. The one that applies to furniture is a design copyright and thanks to Disney's concerns about Mickey Mouse falling into public domain design copyrights were recently extended to 95 years.

There is definitely a market for licenses but it is not an easy game to break into. I really prefer to make things so I have never been motivated to market myself as a designer only. I do have a friend that is pursuing that end of the furniture game with limited success, but she enjoys the business end more than the making end so I think she will eventually do very well.

A piece made in 1792 would most definitely not be protected by copyright. In fact I would question if it would have ever been and if so it would have been for a much shorter period of time.

I am guessing you have been asked to make a period reproduction, which would be an exact copy. I think that some people get caught up in using the word copy to mean that they use the same leg detail from one designer and the drawer detail from anther and the carved accents from a third. This may not be in their minds an original composition but it is also not a copy of a single design. When you mentioned that the original maker copied someone else�s design I am curious about how much of an exact reproduction it is?

Period reproductions are not my bag but I still enjoy seeing them, please post pics.

Robin

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#34

Re: Copying

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>I really don't see the issue of copyright infringement as a clash between human ethics and human economics. I don't belive our legal system encorages people to breach their contracts if they will gain economicaly by doing so. Many contracts have breach clauses such as auto lease agrements and cell phone service contracts. But exorsising the early termination clause of a contract is not breaching it it is still compleatuing the contract under the orignial terms that both parties signed to. In the case of copyright infringement neither partiy signed to any terms, rather one party is violating the law and stealing from another. as far as I know stealing has never been condoned or accepted by any part of our culture.

In ceramics and turning it is true that shapes themselvs are not original and as a result they can not be copyrighted. In copyrighted china for example it is not the plate that is covered but rather the actual design of the glaze and decoration, the composition if yu will that is covered by the copyright. Simialrly in furniture a slab of wood supported bu any noumber of posts, a chair, can not be covered byu a copyright. What is covered is the unige artistic aspect seperate from the function of the piece. This can be dificult really understand but it is the design or style of the chair that is protected and not the chair itself. Of course this means that the chair must be distinctively different in its design to quallify for a copyright.

There will always be woodworkers who prefer to work from plans drawn up by others, the paint by noumber's crowd. There is notheing wrong with this and they are not lesser craftsmen for their design prefrenses. But I really think it is incumbent on the wodworking publighing sector to take a leadership role in the discussion of authorship of design as well as perhaps an educational role in design itself. After all there are only so many ways to cut a mortise and write an article about it so how about writing about the design of the parts being mortised.

Robin

Ps: MFA-Spatial Art, SJSU (1993)

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#35

Re: Copying

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Thanks for the information, Robin. It sounds like I can market Mouse Ears in about 15 years.

I must say that attitudes are rather different in the circles I travel in. People around here would take a dim view of someone who complained about copying. There is more an attitude of free market, free flow of trade and free flow of ideas. I also don't think that a lack of copyright laws stifled design or creativity or craftsmanship in the 18th century.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#36

Re: Good grief Charlie Brown.......

Rob Overton

>Hey, I just want the lady that ask me to do this to have a "straight back chair". That's what she wanted that's what she gets.......

I don't understand her medical problem but she has one. She has not been able to find a chair that met her specs. I told her that if no one else came forward I would build one. SO............ I found this thing.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#37

Re: Good grief Charlie Brown.......

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>Rob...I hope you are able to fashion a chair that will be helpful to that woman...thats whats really important now...as Red Skelton use to say in closing, "God Bless".