Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
>Robin,
Please don't mistake my or anyone else's replies as a dispute with your basic premise. But copying of other artists' work has been a basic and standard practice for thousands of years, all as part of the training and learning process. You're not going to change that with a little "TM" or circle C. Onesie twosie copies in that context have never been an issue; it's the wholesale manufacturing of an original design that usually gets people's blood boiling and rightfully so.
Trained as a sculptor and art historian, I spent a lot of time working though this phase or that with stuff clearly recognizable as influenced by the work of others. Was I stealing? No, absolutely not. Instead I was learning different visual "languages", studying ideas and relationships, individual songs if you will, to see how different notes went together, hopefully in an effort to become accomplished enough to come up with my own song(s). I had my Rodin phase, my Hepworth and Moore "periods", even Giocometti and Degas and Gilberti with some Han, Ming, and Middle Kingdom thrown in for fun.
My wife loves Stickley stuff. We have purchased some of their pieces, but I've made others that are open to a charge of being derivative, yet they are quite different in some ways. I've even gone to a Stickley "store" with rule, pad, and pen and done detailed drawings of elements (just like Norm). There's no better way to learn than to immerse yourself in anothers design, put in on like a old jacket, and feel how it feels, where it's worn thin. Once you do that, you can begin to change things to suit your own idea while staying within the basic design vocabulary. Are the resulting pieces Stickley? Not at all, and someone sensitive to the originals will see the differences right away. I have no interest in make Stickley pieces, but I am interested in using some of his visual language.
I sense that you're a more "strict constructionist" than I, and you're more dedicated to protection by way of bright-line rules. Such rules are, of course, easier to enforce, but the cost becomes prohibitive, and ultimately becomes self-defeating because it stiffles artistic communication.
Yes, worry about pirating software and CD's and lifting the writings of others to be passed off as original work. But cut Rob and others like him a break from the literal concepts involved. His making a Wright chair, even an exact copy, will do no harm to the Wright Foundation, or Copeland Furniture, and may do Rob a whole bunch of good because, once he sits on it, he won't be tempted to make any more of them. He'll have learned that "pretty" and "famous" don't always translate as "good" just because some name-dropping reputed intellectual who talks with his teeth clenched expounds on what good taste is.
Peace |;-}