Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Posts

Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#1

Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Rob Overton

>I am trying to build this straight back chair. Would it be alright with the assembled body to use 1/4" fluted dowel as a connecting devise for the 3/4' stays, Or whatever you the back, to the top and bottom of the back?

Thanks for your input. Sincerely,

Rob Overton Houston, Texas

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#2

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Technically....ya know...they should be mortise and tenons, but dowels can work. However I would beef up the diameter of the dowels to 3/8".

Tom

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#3

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>It is not ok for you to build the chair at all. It is a design licenced by the FLW foundation to another manufacturer. I would suggest that you use it as the foundation and inspiration for your own original design.

There is no distinction to making one for your own pesonal use from making one to sell, they are both a violation of copyright.

Robin

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#4

Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Rob Overton

>Thanks, I had thought about that. Will do it. Thanks

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#5

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Rob Overton

>i really appreciate your concern, BUT, if it is recognizable as a FLW chair after I get through with it... shheesssh... Never happen. Just an inspiration for my chair...

Rob Overton

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#6

Re: Chair

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Rob,

Copyright issues aside, the dowels will work but you may have an issue with keeping the square spindles aligned. If, however, you route a 1/8" deep channel in the stiles (top and bottom) into which your spindles will just fit, your spindles will be perfectly aligned and will stay that way even with round dowels making the joints. Of course it won't look exactly like an "real" (or licensed) FLW chair . . . . .

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#7

Re: ?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I must have missed the original post or something like that; I am not sure what chair he is talking about and don't understand your comment that the chair is copyrighted. All of the Amish chair manufacturers in this area build chairs that mimic the Wright style. Perhaps it is time to call in the local police?

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#8

Re: ?

Kirk (KC) Constable

>I call phooey. Add a decorative plug somewhere.

Somebody should license Sam Maloof's rocker design, then sue the THOUSANDS of folks out there making their own... or least the people making a living giving classes on how to build it.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#9

Re: ?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>The oringinal chair that sparked this thread is a protected design with all licencing agreements being held by the FLW foundation. It is perfectly legal to make a c chair in the craftsman style or one that is inspired by a FLW design, but to copy or nearly copy one is a violation of copyright law. Sam Malloof has chosen not to enforce copyright protections of his designs, that is his choice and you are free to make your own choice about your own designs. You are not free to make those choices about someone elses copyrighted designs.

just for refrence the way the chair is constructed, the choice of wood and uhpolstery material are irrelivant to the copyright and changing any of these is not enough to avoid infrngement. You must make significant changes that show original thought for it to quallify as an original derivative design.

I am not tryng to be cirical or condescending but just trying to explain why it is ok to make a copy of a Sam Mallof chair and not ok to make a copy of a FLW chair.

Robin

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#10

Toucha My Chair, I Breaka You Face? *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The FLW chairs (and tables) and a host of other modern "Classic" designs by famous designers are made by an Italian firm by the name of TEKNO. At the link, click on the Brit flag, go to "classics" and take your pick from a who's who of 20th century art and architecture. Now the site doesn't say that the designs are "licensed" or that its products as "official" reproductions or, for that matter, that any one of those pieces is copyrighted.

Looking at the Tekno site, the casual woodworker would certainly be given the impression that there is no restriction on use of the designs. Since copyright is different than patent rights where the design is on file in a searchable database maintained by Gov, I think the FLW Foundation and Tekno (if they are the actual licensed design-user) are going to have a rather difficult time enforcing their alleged rights, especially against our friend Rob here. Put the design out there while acknowledging you're not the originator without notice that its use by others is restricted, and it's likely that you've lost the "protection" of the copyright.

In fact, if you read the Tekno site (under "legal info") you'll find a statement that none of the designs shown are restricted or copyrighted. Might want to check your information, Robin. Tekno is pretty specific in their statements about copyright. Not likely they'd make a mistake like that with so many designs by such a bevy of famous artists.

mm


TEKNO

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#11

PS - FLW Licensee

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The actual licensee of the Frank Lloyd Wright trade mark is Copeland Furniture at the link. Licensing the registered trade mark is very different from licensing the design of the object it gets put on.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#12

Re: PS - FLW Licensee *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Opps Lost the link


Copeland

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#13

Re: PS - FLW Licensee

Steve Schoene

>Don't a number of the furniture designs pre-date 1912? Wouldn't they be out of copyright protection, which I understand has now been extended to 95 years total duration.

It's an interesting issue. Lots of museums seem to think that the 18th. century antiques are under their copyright control, when it seems to me that they only control access to them and the use of the museums name.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#14

Re: Licensed Use

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Steve,

You're asking a legal question regarding "intellectual property" that is way outside my sphere of practice. There are several other attorneys who read this board who could probably answer your question.

We had a go-round on this issue not too long ago either here or on the turning board so you might want to check the archives on New Yankee Workshop topics.

mm

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#15

Re: Toucha My Chair, I Breaka You Face?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>First off there are no "alleged rights under copyright, All rights are specific and clearly spelled out and even signed in international trade agreements by all major countries except China. Most conflicts arise because one party doesn�t think that another�s protected rights apply to them.

I read the Tecno legal statement with interest. I noticed that it was an Italian judge who ruled that they are not infringing on any protected copyrights. It goes on to further state that each foreign customer is advised to check their own local laws and that they take no legal responsibility. Sounds tike they have bought and paid for a judges decision that is separate from the accepted international law on the subject and they know it.

I find it very curious that so many people are looking for justification to violate another�s intellectual copyright rather than pony up the $$ to buy a copy of what they like or to use that design as inspiration for their own original design. Copyright protection for a design is very specific with the only grey area being if the copyright has expired.

Just out of curiosity where do you stand on downloading unlicensed software, or copying DVD�s and CD�s?

Robin

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#16

Copycats

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Woodworkers are trained from day 1 to copy others' work. Norm Abrams and his producers have built his show around just that premise, as he treks around to antique shops for stuff to make. His measured drawings of the resulting "projects" are therefore intentional take-offs of the work of others. Of course, the drawings are his (or his production company's) work, and are perfectly legitimate as well as being copyrighted, but they are, notwithstanding, copies of the original antique. I may be out on a limb here, but I rather doubt the NYW company has looked up the decendents of the craftsmen who originally built the items being copied and is paying them a royalty for use of the designs. Oh, please don't reference me to time limitations and such, that's not the point at all.

Since you asked, I neither download nor copy software which I have not purchased, nor do I share it, nor do I copy DVD's or CD's, except to put together listening cd's with selections from original albums which I have purchased.

This is less about intellectual honesty than it is about merchandising rights. The FLW Foundation's "store" lists "FLW Collection"[circle R] men's ties and nite lights for sale ($45 & $25}. Frank designed many things, but not nite lights and neckties.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#17

Re: Copycats

nailshooter

>>Woodworkers are trained from day 1 to copy others' work. Norm Abrams >and his producers have built his show around just that premise, as he >treks around to antique shops for stuff to make. His measured drawings >of the resulting "projects" are therefore intentional take-offs of the >work of others. Of course, the drawings are his (or his production >company's) work, and are perfectly legitimate as well as being >copyrighted, but they are, notwithstanding, copies of the original >antique.

********************

An excellent point. This very issue has been beaten to death so many times for the last few years I am surprised it still comes up. Among the legal literati, it seems the consensus of opinion is the old famous "one off, not for sale" idea that will protect most of us from any problems. I don't think anyone cares about someone cooking up a couple of chairs in their basement shop and using them or having them as gifts. I would think that you would have some problems selling the chairs as "Frank Lloyd Wright Chairs" or more exactly, "Falling Water Chairs".

As for the the Amish do what they do.. beats me. Someone would have sued the crap out of them by now if they had a case. That particular design is very common and mass produced by the Amish, and sold all over the world. Yet, no problems.

This whole issue of proprietary rights has been beaten even harder by the angst some turners feel, and you can read the archives of this site on the woodturning forum to see what I mean. It has been addressed on every forum and site I visit or participate in, ad naseum. The turners wrestle with the idea that they should give credit or pay homage to just about anything they turn that is round! (Not a lot of choices on the lathe, either!)

From all the legal opinions I have seen posted on this subject, I think the intent (and certainly the practical enforceability) of the law is that you not sell an exact copy branded with a name or copyright protected logo.

Robert

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#18

hb

Re: ?

HB

>EVRERYTHING is legal until you get caught. Just don;t get caught - be sure to throw a blanket over the chair next time you have the copyright police over to your house for dinner.

I believe that copyrights are overrated when applied to a hobby craftsperson making a one off for their own use.

HB

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#19

Re: ?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>They may well be overrated, HB, but they apply nonetheless.

However, copywrites must be valid for enforcement to be effective. There is no clause to exempt anyone. That means the 'hobbiest' has as much protection under the copywrite laws as do larger corporations.

Here size does not matter. The validity of the copywrite does matter.

So when you copywrite a creation of your own, there are no exemptions for someone to use your creation without permission/compensation to you - should you choose to enforce your copywrite. Applies to Sam Maloof, Frank Lloyd Wright, and YOU!

And enforcement is at the discretion of the copywrite holder. There are no "copywrite police."

For the right thing to happen, depends only on you and your good conscience.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#20

Also Depends

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>on how much money you have to spend on the litigation, Carol. I know several folks who've "gone the route" and gotten judgments vindicating their rights. Notice I said "judgments" not money; the uncollectable judgments that cost them thousands in legal fees and costs to obtain, will merely hang on their walls.

Before you decide to enforce your rights, you better make sure the Bad Guy's got some bucks to pay you in the end. Otherwise, all you'll have to show for your copyright is a stack of paper, most of which will be bills. I've yet to meet a copyright litigation lawyer who works on contingency fees, but then I've met pretty few of those guys anyway. Beware the guy who tells you "I'll take their g-d socks and sell'em if I have to to get you your just money damages." It ain't gonna happen.

|;-}

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#21

Good grief Charlie Brown.......

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>and all you wanted to do was make a simple chair with a straight back!! I say proceed...use them dowel rods for the back...of course some New Englander chair makers might get antsy...but proceed anyway...and use all the 90* angles in the thing that you want...I don't think that Frank Lloyd holds a patent on 90* joints...but whatever you do call it an Overton when you're done.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#22

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

Geoff (in Madison)

>Hey Robin,

What about if some FLW designed furniture (built by is favorite furniture maker) came with a FLW house, but doesn't have a makers label or other copyright markings. Did every design of his get swept up into the giant copyright vacuum or are there instances where his client might have ownership. Some of FLW's stuff is so uncomfortable I can't imagine anyone wanting to copy it.

Just curious.

Geoff

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#23

Re: Uncomfortable

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Take the chair in question for instance. The seatbox is "stuck" on the front of this architectural set of spindles in such a way as to deny the piece any organic unity as furniture. The bead at the bottom of the seat box serves only to break any flow of the legs, choping the design elements into a bunch of mismatched pieces stuck together to create an effect rather than create a piece of furniture to actually be used by people. On a basic level, its also a heavy borrowing from the Stickly brothers' designs, but without the simple grace their work encompassed.

While I love his architecture, I'm no fan of much of his other stuff.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#24

Re: Also Depends

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>True.

Same situation with patents. If you don't have the bucks to defend them, don't bother spending the money to get them.

Re: Frank Lloyd Wright chair

#25

Strange

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>In a system supposedly designed to foster and protect creativity and individual effort, eh?

Kind of makes those inventors' service commercials into a joke. So much for building better mouse traps.

mm