Re: Copycats
nailshooter
>>Woodworkers are trained from day 1 to copy others' work. Norm Abrams >and his producers have built his show around just that premise, as he >treks around to antique shops for stuff to make. His measured drawings >of the resulting "projects" are therefore intentional take-offs of the >work of others. Of course, the drawings are his (or his production >company's) work, and are perfectly legitimate as well as being >copyrighted, but they are, notwithstanding, copies of the original >antique.
********************
An excellent point. This very issue has been beaten to death so many times for the last few years I am surprised it still comes up. Among the legal literati, it seems the consensus of opinion is the old famous "one off, not for sale" idea that will protect most of us from any problems. I don't think anyone cares about someone cooking up a couple of chairs in their basement shop and using them or having them as gifts. I would think that you would have some problems selling the chairs as "Frank Lloyd Wright Chairs" or more exactly, "Falling Water Chairs".
As for the the Amish do what they do.. beats me. Someone would have sued the crap out of them by now if they had a case. That particular design is very common and mass produced by the Amish, and sold all over the world. Yet, no problems.
This whole issue of proprietary rights has been beaten even harder by the angst some turners feel, and you can read the archives of this site on the woodturning forum to see what I mean. It has been addressed on every forum and site I visit or participate in, ad naseum. The turners wrestle with the idea that they should give credit or pay homage to just about anything they turn that is round! (Not a lot of choices on the lathe, either!)
From all the legal opinions I have seen posted on this subject, I think the intent (and certainly the practical enforceability) of the law is that you not sell an exact copy branded with a name or copyright protected logo.
Robert