>I've always wanted a nice Combination Square and find myself looking at Starrett Combo Squares.
A Few years back a guy I knew that worked in a Machine shop said they were really over priced and most machine shops used other brands that were the same quality and accuracy if not better. I just don't remember what the brands he mentioned were. Basically your buying the name with Starrett.
I'm not sold on Starrett but I would like a high quality Combination Square. Anyone have any suggestions or just stick with Starrett?
>Starrett has a very nice satin chrome blade. It makes it very easy to read. To me that alone is worth the price. You can also buy the version with a hardened head which makes it very robust against bumps and accidental drops (not that you should ever do that). Plus the accuracy. Starrett often is the standard against which others are measured.
Other good brands are Brown and Sharpe and Mitutoyo.
>Since receiving my Starrett combination square as a Christmas present, I have literally used it on every woodworking, carpentry, and metal-working project I've been involved in. While your machinist friend may be correct about the price-quality ratio, the machine shop where I trained was stocked with Starrett combination squares. Granted, most were the less expensive 4" and 6" models rather than the 12" I normally use. Price-wise, Starrett seems to be cheaper than Mitutoyo or Browne and Sharp which are the only other brands I'd be tempted to consider.
Given the amount of use I've gotten out of it over the last five years, I consider the Starrett 12" combination square I own to be a bargain. If I lost it, I wouldn't think twice about replacing it...
>Starrett layout tools are definately worth the money. They have a fit and finish that does not translate to pictures in a catalog. But the real reason Starrett tools are worth the money is their accuracy never has to be questioned. Go with the forged and hardened head it is haqs a nicer feel.
>Old Brown & Sharpe tools are as good or maybe a little better than Starrett. I'm not familiar with the new B&S but I have some of their older tools, probably from the 60's. I'm sure if I was running a machine shop I would look for a good quality tool that's less exepensive. For my home hobby shop if I can afford the Starrett tool I'm certainly going to because I know what I'm getting and it will be accurate and last longer than I will. Cry only once.
>Ray, in the end you're the only one that can decide this question. To that end, I will relate my experience. I started out over 25 years ago with two squares - a 4-inch Starrett, passed on to me by my father, and a 12-inch Craftsman combo I bought at Sears. I built a whole bunch of stuff using them as they always fulfilled my needs.
Through the years I found my 4-inch Starrett invaluable and kept it in my apron pocket to have it handy. In fact, I used and relied on it so much I finally broke down and bought another. I keep this one hanging on a board with my other layout tools and it sees constant use during projects along with my other one.
Finally, when I had some spare change and because I liked my small Starretts so much, I ordered their 12-inch combo to replace the old Craftsman I'd been using for so long. As soon as it arrived and I got my hands on it, there was no question in my mind that I was holding a far superior tool to what I'd been using. The weight of it, the way the blade slides in the head, the finish on the blade, and the way it's marked all scream quality. Every time I pick it up I'm reminded just how good it feels to be using a top quality and accurate tool.
My old 12-inch did a good job and I have to give it credit for that. However, once I felt and saw the difference of the Starrett, I'll never go back or think twice about buying other tools with their name on them. I also have a 4-foot Starrett level that I've had for years and love to use.
Bottom line - there are a few other brands available with good reputations for accuracy that may become your choice based on price. Again, that's your call. However, one thing you can count on beyond anything else is Starrett is the standard by which all the others are judged and their name is synonymous with quality and accuracy at a price you can justify!
>I bought and started using my Craftsman in the mid-60's. Three years ago I bought a Starrett to replace it. They hang next to each other on the end of my workbench. The one I most often reach for? The Craftsman! In twelve inches, it's just as accurate as the Starrett. That's all that woodworking requires.
>First see if your are worthy of such a fine tool, Look at your machines to make sure they won't disgrace such a fine instrument.....:-) All kidding aside buy the Starrett if you want it and can afford it. Having worked in a machine shop I would not consider another brand.For the average home shop its overkill but worth it.
As others have said once you hold/use a Starrett,Brown & Sharp,or Mit. the quality and feel becomes apparent.I have Starretts in 4",6",12" and 24" some were purchased new,others on E-Bay and used tool shops.Check the Link below,Walt is a great guy,excellent tool hunter and I've never been disappointed with any purchases I've made thru him.
>No matter how much you spend for a device, you still don't know if it is square. I ran a large tool and die shop and we purchased a number of Brown & Sharp and Starrett devices and some of them were not "square". We had "standards" that our quality department periodically had validated by an outside service that we then used to verify the worker's tools.
One day, one of our designers brought in two plastic drawing triangles he had purchased at a local art supply store. He had them compared to our standards and they were as accurate as the tools could measure. The triangle cost a couple of dollars each. They would certainly serve very well as the "standard" in any woodworking shop to validate and/or adjust other devices.
An excellent way to validate the accuracy of the plastic squares is to use two squares on a flat surface. Get a $10-12 plastic 30-60-90 drafting square. To prove it's exactly 90�, take two to a glass counter, put the shorter legs on the counter and face the longer legs away from each other and butt them together (like a teepee). If the legs exactly butt, you can assume you have two perfect 90� angles. Using one of the plastic squares, do the same thing using your other tools. Any that mismatch, means that the tool is not square. You can also take the plastic square with you whenever you go to purchase another tool. Keep your "standard" somewhere where it doesn't get banged up.
Finally, remember that the wood you are using will expand and contract a couple of thousands from one day to the other. Does't pay to get too uptight.
While we are at it, I also only purchase the cheapest of adjustable squares. If needed, I square them with a drafting triangle and an auger file until they are square across 10". And I own a Bridge City square that isn't that accurate. Stainless steel machinist's squares are only square until you drop them. I have had several over the years and each has found a away to drop to the floor.
The key is to NEVER use your best square on for day to day measuring. Use it only as a reference tool to verify your other day to day tools.
In a comparison test reported in Fine Woodworking Magazine a couple of years ago, the Stanley 46-123 square was awarded the best value. It's much less expensive than a Starrett and just as accurate.
>In my opinion - yes, definitely! If you take reasonable care of it, it should last you a lifetime, so a few dollars extra gets spread out over a lot of use.
BTW, unlike some tools, the Starrett prices do fluctuate with the market, watch for a good deal. I bought one earlier this year for $65.
>I got one for a reasonable bid off Ebay earlier this year. It was an old one from the 40's. When I checked it against my Stanley and Craftsman combo squares I found that they all matched up precisely. I then had it checked against a friends brand new engineer's square, and found it to be "spot-on". The thing is...it just feels so much better to use it. It has the weight that feels right, it locks so easily and solidly, and has "the look" that just says quality! Since getting it, it's my go to tool for all my measuring. If I ever need to replace it I'll get another Starrett without even flinching!
Another (more useful & much cheaper) Option *LINK*
Garrett in Victoria
>is the Stanley 46-131 16" combination square made in England with easy-to-read Satin Chrome face. Mine is absolutely true, and the 16" rule is a surprisingly wonderful convenience. Currently $12.66 on Amazon. (Only 5 left.)
Yes, you are paying for the name/reputation when you buy any Starrett tool. But thats not all you are buying. As was mentioned, you might run across one of their tools that is not perfect, however, that can be said about most anything.
From most of the previous posts, you are probably getting an idea as to which combination square to buy. Gonna cost you more but doesn't it feel good to instantly know you have something special in your hand when you first grab something of known quality?
A Starrett tool is probably "overbuying" for woodworking compared to what an accomplished machinist needs. Wood is just a bit more forgiving than metal.
When I was still a working guy before I retired, I managed machine shops. Before I would hire a machinist I would ask to take a look into his tool box. I learned more from that little exercise than talking to him for a half hour.
Your work is only as good as your tools, I'm sure you've heard that phrase.
I'm still using a Starrett combo square that I bought 45 years ago brand new. I never questions it's accuracy. Just grab it and Git-R-Done.
>While drafting squares may be wonderfully accurate I really don't think they are a viable substitute for a Starret combo. I suppose you could take a plastic drafting square and glue a ruler, a torpedo level and a scratch awl and a marking gauge to it and it would then be capable of doing what a combo can. Of course if you get the combo set with a protractor and center heads you will need to strap on a few more things to that clump of tools that started out as a drafting triangle.
The inexpensive Stanley that many have suggested as being accurate enough is just that, accurate enough. It does not however have a hardened and ground blade with etched markings. Sounds trivial but take a look at a few dozen Stanly blades and you will start to see some variation in the stamped rule markings, this is fine if it is your only marking devise but if it isn't it can lead to problems. Put the blade from the Stanley in your pocket and sit on it, see how well it slides in the head after it is bent. The precision ground blade of the Starrett can be used for reliable precision tool set ups. It will also stand on edge much better than the Stanly blade and is very difficult to bend.
Back to that plastic drafting triangle and its accuracy, one of the best ways of increasing your accuracy as a wood worker is to use a marking knife rather than a pencil. Plastic edges and knives don't mix well for very long.
A Starrett may not be the tool for everyone but to say that some cheaply made die cast and stamped tool, or a piece of plastic that doesn't do the same tasks is just as good as a precision tool made to last a lifetime is not really accurate. It really comes down to the type of work each woodworker does and the value each places on the quality of their tools.
Robin, who also owns a set of plastic triangles and a plastic protractor in addition to Starrett 4", 6", 9", 12", 24" squares
>My Dad ( tool & die maker ) also made his decision on hiring like that ! But he started with the tool chest. If it wasn't a Kennedy ( or Gerstner ) he would'nt look any farther. After that he wanted to see Starret but his preference, to this day, is Lufkin.
>I was fine with Lufkin, Brown & Sharp and of course Starrett and later Mituyoyo. And yes, at least a Kennedy was a must. Cardboard boxes just didn't get it. Hit the road Jack...
I told them to come in for the interview and don't forget your tools.
>Good question. To me it is worth it as I can rely on the Starrett to not only start square (more than square enough for any woodworking task) but it will stay that way. The other issue is that it is a finely made tool. I feel a sense of pride when using one of my good tools like the LN chisels and dovetail saw. I have Porter Cable routers - would a Craftsman or Homier brand do the job? Probably, but I have more confidence in the accuracy and like the better tools. I have one Mitutoyo machinist square I purchased new with the certificate of accuracy included (<.00063" error in 7") that I use to check my other squares so it isn't essential that I use a high quality square but I sure like the feel of Starrett. I could nail two boards together and set them with my "standard" and it would work fine. I could also buy all my tools from big lots or Homier and get by - but I do feel good when I look around my shop and see the quality tools and equipment. I don't woodwork for any income - it is my hobby, so I really want to enjoy everything about it, including the tools and equipment I use. By the way I spent over 39 years in manufacturing as an Engineer, last few were as a Quality Engineer working as the management representative for the ISO/QS 9000 program in our plant. I also was involved in maintaining the calibration laboratory - we used many LS Starrett tools for in process inspection. The lab also, upon request, calibrated the toolmakers equipment. IMHO the Starrett was the top of the line - above the Mitutoya, Brown & Sharp and far above the Lufkin. Many of our "master gages", which were calibrated outside our plant in labs directly traceable to the NIST, were Starrett. These were used to calibrate the equipment used in the lab about every 30 days.