Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Canadians don't need SawStop?

Posts

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#51

Re: I certainly can blame the insurance co.

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Once again I didn't make myself clear. The insurance company is often the interface for the large corporation. The corp. essentially sets the rules, and the insurance company works with the rules. Does this mean they are bad guys, not necessarily. We could debate this all day.

What frosts me is when I see a physician, or hospital, bill an insurance company $1000 for a procedure, and then the insurance company 'gets them honest' by telling them that it is only worth $600, and that is all they will pay, end of discussion. Oh yes, the patient may have to pay a nominal deductible each year. But once that is paid, the amount owed by the patient is not the difference between the original bill and what the insurance co. paid.

What we really need is truth in billing. There is no reason why a physician or a hospital should bill 50% higher than they expect to be paid. There is no reason why any patient should pay more than what an insurance company deems "customary and proper" for that part of the country. It is time for the medical profession to get honest with the public. Then the uninsured person would pay the same as the insurance company is paying. Maybe the medical profession should spend more time teaching financial management than sending the young doctor through the AMA fraternity initiation of working 30 hour days in the ER.

Speaking of uninsured, if you can't prove you are a legal resident of the US or a legal visitor, you don't get care. I would support daily hospital flights back to their country of origin, parachute provided.

As another cost cutting move, let the lawyers pay the entire legal cost of these malpractice suits when they loose a case. While we are at it, put a cap on the amount of the settlement. Pain and suffering, my @#*&%$. Look at the "Willy, Cheatem, and Howe" group from New England. You can hardly go through a day without seeing a TV ad for some exotic disease for which 'you may deserve compensation.' They must throw darts at the PDR to find these diseases.

No, I do not advocate or want socialized medicine. But if it does happen, the medical profession brought it on itself.

I have little sympathy for a physician that drives around in a Mercedes SL500. I wonder if he bought it in his first or second year of practice.

Sorry you asked....

Ken

If this post breaks the rules of WC, please delete it.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#52

Excellent point!

Bill Howatt

>

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#53

Re: I certainly can blame the insurance co.

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>"I have little sympathy for a physician that drives around in a Mercedes SL500. I wonder if he bought it in his first or second year of practice. "

Thank you for saying that.

The doctor who brought me into the world and saw me through all the usual childhood diseases lived pretty much at the same level as most of his patients. He lived in a modest house and drove an average car. He would often forget to bill those who he knew might have a hard time paying the bill. When you were really sick he didn't expect you to sit in a chair in his office for hours waiting to be seen. He came to your house.

These doctors still exist, but they are about as common as an Ivory Billed Woodpecker. 99.999999% of those who aspire to become doctors are in it for the money.

I seldom get sick and have not had a "family doctor" for over fifteen years. I dropped the one I had shortly after losing a job and needing SOME kind of insurance. I found a high deductable policy I could afford and was told I could save $90.00 on the first payment by providing a copy of my medical records. My doctor refused to provide them unless I forked over $150.00. My records did not/do not amount to much. I could have copied everything at the local convienince store for less than two bucks. I figured that if the greedy ^*&^)*& cared that little about my welfare I didn't want him having anything to do with ant health problems I might have.

Yes, there are problems with the cost of malpractice insurance and many have student loans to pay off. But I can't think of a single doctor in this area that isn't living at WAAAAAAY above average means.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#54

Randy, you'll have to retract your statement

wilbur

>"99.999999% of those who aspire to become doctors are in it for the money."

Since I'm a doctor, I find this highly insulting. I'm sorry that you had the experience with your doctor that you had, but unless you can come up with some sort of facts to back up this assertion, you will have to take it back.

I was brought up to believe that discussing other people's salaries was rude. But since you brought it up, here are some real facts.

The average debt that a medical school graduate has coming out of medical school was $109,000 in 2003. The amount of debt for medical school graduates has been on a linear rise since the 1990's, and shows no sign of easing up.

Furthermore, consider the amount of training that becoming a doctor requires. 4 years college, 4 years of medical school. Then comes residency, during which you are paid minimally, and are still expected to make payments on your $109,000 loan. By the time you are making that big doctor salary, you're 30 years old before being able to draw a salary that Ken thinks will allow you to buy a Mercedes SL500 in 1-2 years, after you make the payment on what is essentially a second mortgage, except that you don't have a house to show for it. On top of that, this is the first time that you'll be able to even think of beginning to save for retirement, compared to those who first started working coming out of college. Any financial adviser will tell you that saving early is the best thing that you can do to save for retirement, and med school graduates lose 8 years of time by making the choice to become a doctor.

Anyone who goes into medicine for the money gets what they deserve. There are many ways of making a lot of money that take less time for training and less work besides going into medicine.

Now, I'm not complaining. I live in New Jersey, which is one of the most expensive places to live in the U.S., and make enough to take care of my student loans, have a small house, and still be able to save enough so that my wife doesn't also have to work, which is great because she can take care of the kids.

But I find it appalling that people who want the best health care possible would begrudge physicians what they make. Randy, do you really want someone who makes enough to maintain an average means of living in Connersville, IN, taking care of your family? After all, the glory of capitalism dictates that to get the best health care possible, you're going to have to pay doctors top dollar for that care.

By the way, after being in practice for 7 years, curing kids of cancer, I'm the proud driver of a 1999 Camry.

Sorry for being so angry, but this comment really irked me -- understandably, I hope. Nonetheless, I expect a retraction.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#55

well said Jim.

Ted Wong

>

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#56

You're quite right to be insulted...

John in New Mexico

>I've had the pleasure of knowing three doctors well enough to guess at their motivations, none of them are or were in it for the money. Many doctors make high salaries, some do not. Seems to me it might just come down to demand for their speciality and their abilities, just as it does with bankers, lawyers, engineers, and any other profession that requires a lot of education and experience. I haven't seen many people taking such speculative and un-substantiated cuts at engineers based on how much they make and which car they choose to drive.

John

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#57

Time To Move this Along

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>To All,

We have had great conversation to this point. On this line though we are touching the edge.

I think we are about to enter an oppertunity for this to get personal....and at that risk I will put on my WC Moderator Hat and say I think we need to let this be please and move along.

Thanks,

Jim

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#58

Re: You're quite right to be insulted...

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>You don't see too many engineers driving Mercedes. I worked as an engineer for 40+ years. I certainly had a good income and am not complaining. Those engineers who drive Mercedes are those, in general, who became entrepreneurs and started their own companies and were successful.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#59

Actually depends on what state you live in

Jonathan in Brooklyn

>insurance does not always vary by risk. Some states, and New York is one of them, have enacted "community ratings" so that everyone pays the same premium regardless of risk. The effect of this is often higher premiums as the less at risk get end up with higher premiums than sometimes. But it depends on the scheme. New York enacted community ratings in I think 1993.