Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Canadians don't need SawStop?

Posts

Canadians don't need SawStop?

#1

Canadians don't need SawStop?

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>I just saw that new movie "Sicko" and they did a comparison of Canadian versus U.S. woodworking accident expenses. The U.S. guy had to chose between paying $12K for one finger or $60K for the other. He saved the one he could afford. The Canadian guy sawed all his fingers off, but his was paid for by his national health care, so it cost him nothing. So, SawStops are much more cost effective in the U.S than in Canada, eh?

I better keep using my guards, splitter, push sticks, safety glasses, ear muffs and dust mask.

Joe

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#2

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Jerry Nicholson

>I think Michael Moore is the Sicko!

Jerry

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#3

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

albertabob

>Pardon my naivety but don't Americans have access to insurance for medical expenses? - We do not.

When you factor in the "huge tax grab" at every level of Government here you will find that free(partially) health care is a bit of red herring.

Mr. Moore is a stranger to the truth.

I quote:

"Canadians start working for themselves on June 28th, one day later than last year. According to The Fraser Institute�s annual Tax Freedom Day calculations, all income earned prior to June 28th was used to pay the total tax bill imposed on them by all levels of government: federal, provincial, and local."

Free medicare ! - Not!

Bob

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#4

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>Do all Americans have access to health insurance? Hmmm... I guess that depends if you have had pimples on your butt. My daughter was rejected by Blue Cross when she was 2 because they thought she had pneumonia twice. We finally got that cleared up since the agent is a friend. Our medical insurance is pretty inexpensive - about $500 a month. It doesn't cover doctor office visits, drugs, dental or vision. It only kicks it if we are hospitalized and we pay the first $5000, and then you better hope they don't reject your claim.

So, you guys in Canada have it worse than this?

Joe

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#5

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Bob,

And Dental care is not free either is it.

;-)

take care,

Elmo

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#6

Having lived in both countries

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>"...Pardon my naivety but don't Americans have access to insurance for medical expenses?...

Naivety pardoned.

I've had the priviledge of living in both countries and have had the "opportunity" to be employed as well as self employed, and I can say that they answer to your question is: "No".

Medical insurance costs a ton of money. You sometimes hear that a large percentage of the population has no insurance and some people think that's crazy and unresponsible. The fact is that it costs alot of money, and alot more than many people can afford. And insurance companies don't HAVE to give it to you, so sometimes no amount of money will be enough to get coverage.

I've said it before and I'll asy it again, health costs including insurance is my biggest expense. Mortgage? Car payments? Retirement savings? Groceries? Education? Ha... They all pale compared to the medical costs. And that's for a HEALTHY family who is rarely sick with anything more than colds, etc.

I know several people who make more money than I do and still can't afford insurance.

The gov't can stop your from driving your car if you don't carry automobile insurance, and the banks make sure you have house insurance, but what could anyone do to force you to have health insurance? Kill you? They don't have to, the insurance companies take care of doing that ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#7

Re: Having lived in both countries

john lucas

>Here in the US If you have money you may or may not have insurance. If you don't have money you can get fixed. I have excellent health care but it takes a good chunk out of my paycheck. My friend who more or less works for himself, when he does work, doesn't seem to have any trouble getting health services. He knows how to play the game. It pisses me off because I pay so much and he doesn't pay anything. Maybe that's not the way in every state but in Tennessee you just have to know how to play the system.

As for Mike Moore, he's full of himself and does biased reporting to fit his slant on things.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#8

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Rusty

>We pay a monthly premium for health coverage.If you are above the poverty line you pay on a scale that goes to nothing if you are below it.They have lobbyists here constantly trying to undermine it but we hold fast. Would hate to see families wiped out financially by an illness or accident.Moore didn't say it was free just universal.

Our health care is like cherry wood it looks better as we age.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#9

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If you think that U.S. medical care is expensive now, just wait till it's free.

Clint

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#10

Re: CNN Checked the facts on the movie *LINK*

Peter Gregory

>If you don't want to read the story in the link, here is the summary -

"Moore covers a lot of ground. Our team investigated some of the claims put forth in his film. We found that his numbers were mostly right, but his arguments could use a little more context. As we dug deep to uncover the numbers, we found surprisingly few inaccuracies in the film. In fact, most pundits or health-care experts we spoke to spent more time on errors of omission rather than disputing the actual claims in the film."

I think the medical system in the US is broken, I'm sure it could be worse, but broken.


http://www.cnn.com/2007/HEALTH/06/28/sicko.fact.check/index.html

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#11

Re: Having lived in both countries

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>John, it isn't just Tennessee and it isn't just on health insurance. There is a segment of the population whose most highly developed skill is knowing their "rights". Couple that with a few Bureaucrats whose compassion for the disadvantaged far outweighs their common sense, and it's easy to see why both factions consider those of us who have always played fair and by the rules as suckers.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#12

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Mark Mcc

>Nothing is free...anywhere. As stated, in Canada healthcare is universal, everyone is entitiled to access equal levels of healthcare(theory).

This is becoming more controversial in Canada as some argue that those who are prepared and can pay for health care services should be allowed to do so through private providers. This would also take some pressure off the public system. Other's fear this could be the death of the public system. Result is nothing happens...the public system is broken, slow and under increasing pressure from an aging polulation.Polticians are afraid to show support for a private hybrid system..polticial suicide

Several years ago there were more MRI units in Buffalo NY, then there were in all of Canada. But the few there were ..were universally accessible..yeah right!

Bottomline is no one here is going to get financially wiped out because they had the audacity to get sick.

Work safe and stay healthy!

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#13

Re: CNN Checked the facts on the movie

Jay Hanks

>"Moore covers a lot of ground. Our team investigated some of the claims put forth in his film."

Key words there SOME of the claims put forth. Doesnt change the fact he likes to bend whatever to fit his view/need for a film. Not worth the change to see the film in my iew.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#14

Re: CNN Checked the facts on the movie

Peter Gregory

>I doubt I will see it, but that doesn't make the thrust of the movie wrong. The fundamental question, is the health care system of the USA broken, he has right IMHO. Hopefully, this will open our eyes to the problem, so we can start to fix it. That is the point of the movie, isn't it?

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#15

Re: Coal miners in Southern Illinios

Peter Gregory

>They just redid the contract with our local coal miners. They didn't have to pay anything for health care, the insurance or company covered everything 100%. The found that the miners were averaging, more than a trip to the doctor, per work day. Now there is a co-pay.

Yes, people will abuse a free system there is no doubt. That doesn't mean that insurance is bad, just free services will be abused.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#16

Re: Coal miners in Southern Illinios

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>If the "miners were averaging, more than a trip to the doctor, per work day", when did they work?. Those numbers just don't make sense.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#17

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Bill Howatt

>Like any documentary that has an axe to grind, you have to take Sicko with an open mind and realize that quite likely not the whole story was presented in a truly balanced fashion.

Does this mean it is all wrong - certainly not.

Is the system here in Canada a medical Utopia, again certainly not.

Do I think that the care is totally free here - no, our taxes are higher and things like the dentist, prescription drugs are not covered normally.

Do I think it is reasonable that the richest, most prosperous country in the world, the US, which has excellent facilities that are not universally available to all citizens - no.

Do I think that administering health care via totally profit-driven insurance companies is a good idea - no.

Do I think the typical US view of "everything gov't is bad" and "private-enterprise is always the way to do everything" clouds objective consideration of competing methods - yes.

Bill

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#18

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Jerry Nicholson

>Part of our problem here in the US is that we have almost all the personal injury lawyers in the world and all of these lawyers view the medical profession as their own "cash cow". That of course leads to a very large malpractice insurance industry and the upper management of every company in that industry believes in a divine right to millions of dollars of unearned compensation every year. And guess who pays for all these Non-Value-Added parasites? And us voters enable the whole thing by continuing to vote for lawyers to represent us in congress - and those lawyers aren't about to do anything that would reduce the income of their fellow travelers. NOTE: This may be a political rant but it is a non-partisan political rant!

Jerry

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#19

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Bill,

Hey just got all the same answers you did as well to those questions.

:-)

I have been a frequent customer of the Canadian system over my life, 19 years ago I had cancer twice....both operations were completed within a week of prognosis, I was also living near a large cancer hospital. In the last 10 years I have had knee surgery and two hernia's. I am in the system again, a heart issue and a pending hip resurfacing. In all my experiences there have been no issues with extensive waits or postponments.

The Canadian system is what it is as others have said, a model of universal care for all. It is not free, it is a universally managed program via our taxes which are high. Geography and a shortage of doctors are a major issue here and the root of complaint. Many of our good doctors leave for placements in the US or where ever money is a draw, some go for research oppertunities as did my onclogist (a South African who went to Harvard to teach and do research).

If you live in Snow Lake Manitoba and need heart surgery, it's a pretty good bet that they would have to fly you to Winnipeg. Facilities in remote regions of our country are about providing the basics, so advanced care may require travel. The government is not perfect here either, it's not black and white, there is a lot of grey and making it right for the whole country is also like trying to hit a moving target, the needs of the population keep changing.

I have not seen this Sicko movie, not sure if I ever will, but that doesn't matter. If health care matters then Moore has achieved his point and brought the topic to discussion, you don't have to agree with him, he is a movie maker. There are no sides on this debate in my mind, it's about human health and in my world we don't have the liberty of choosing teams in this, it's about providing the best care for all humanity in what ever manner works best for all.

I happen to like the Canadian system......it has saved my life and my sanity.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#20

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>Thanks for sharing that information Jim. It's nice to hear information from the source instead of getting the information second hand from either Micheal or Fox News.

Micheal Moore seems to have nothing but good stuff to say about you Canadians, or for that matter the Brits and the French. I saw the movie and it was very powerful. My 11 year old daughter thought it was a bit sad that people in the U.S. have to die because medical insurance corporations don't wish to pay for treatments, but they have no problem giving billions in bonuses to their leaders. Micheal Moore also had nothing but praise for the quality of health care in the U.S. His complaint seems to be that we all cannot access that care.

I must say that the trip to Cuba in the movie was also very touching. Castro may not be a good guy, but the Cuban people are not our enemies. And geeze, if we opened a dialog with Cuba we could be selling them millions of new cars to replace the ones they have been driving since the 50s. Not to mention it would be easier for Fred Thompson to get good cigars - legally! ;^)

Joe

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#21

Just had Gall Bladder removed in Colorado

Brian in Brighton

>First. I'm self employed, very heathly, 39, married, non-smoker, non-drinker, no drugs, overall very good health. We pay $286 a month for Kiaser Permanente insurance. No dental, just medical.

Thursday before last at 6PM I was in great pain in the upper abdomen. I went to the local hospital and they figured out the pain was due to my gall bladder. Not from stones, just rotten. They could not make a firm determination with only a CT-Scan, so off to another one. I was transfered to the K-P hospital that had the ultrasound to determine the gall bladder and whether it was coming out. 9:30 AM in the operating room, 2:30 back home. I had the best surgeon ever. Almost no pain, so I got a lot of pain meds left over.

I have not gotten a bill yet. Admin at the 2nd hospital said I did just as I was supposed to do in an emergency by going to the nearest hospital. All in all a grand experience with the nicest bunch of people. They treated my wife with more dignity than any other place we have ever been. She knew exactly what was happening with me in real time with a cool monitoring system.

Would this have happened in the great white north? I can't say. What I can tell you is that my friend cut his fingers apart on my TS about 14 years ago and the doctor sent him to another hospital because he had no insurance and did not have $15K in the bank. The 2nd place did a good enough job and he did pay everyone. Damages: $78,000 to fix 3 fingers. Had he not sued me for not having guards on my saw (which I did not) he would have had to be another bankruptcy filing at 25. Great way to start a life. Gimpy hand and bankrupt.

My wife worked as a paralegal at a bankruptcy attny in the early 90's and she says that 50+% of the people had huge medical bills. MOST of them thought they had enough coverage. Hospitals and insurance try everything to make the patient pay first.

I'll drop a note when I get the bills for the gall bladder removal.

Our system is great in some ways, but if you don't have access, you get to die.

Brian in Brighton, feeling about a pound lighter.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#22

Some things to consider

Derek

>I agree that the "system" is broken. The question is "why?". I am aware of several specific issues.

Here is California, many hospitals have closed (gone out of business). One big reason is the large number of "poor" who can not afford insurance but use the services. The fact is that the hospitals MUST treat them. No one pays them for it. The hospital emergency rooms are full of "poor" (mostly illegal immigrants, oh, I'm sorry I mean "undocumented immigrants") who use them as their medical practitioners for everything.

The hospitals try to make up the difference by over-chargng people who "can" pay. My son had an out-patient operation a couple of years ago. The hospital billed us around $18,000 for the few hours he was in there. Because I have insurance (which I pay 100% of the cost), I ended up paying around $3000 and the insurance company paid around $1000. THey wrote off the difference. If I did not have insurance, I would have had to pay the WHOLE AMOUNT personally, UNLESS I did not have naything of value that they could seize to pay cover the costs.

If I was "poor" (never mind that I was out of work for most of 3 years) I would not have had to pay.

My son had some permanent damage because they were busy handling the non-emergency cases for something like 5 hours rather than him (it was an OBVIOUS emergency). Oh, the non-emergency cases were the afore-mentioned "undocumented immigrants".

Another problem is that doctors must play the game of legally-safe medicine. This increases costs astronomically. In europe, they had 5% Cesarean births. When my son was born, our doctor (who was in charge of a panel monitoring them) told us that some doctors have rates as high as 40% and the average is 25%. Why is this? They can not be sued for doign a Cesarean when it was not required but they CAN if anything goes wrong with the birth and they did not do one. The Cesareans cost at least twice what a vaginal birth costs and then the hospital stay is greatly extended - gee, my wife was only in the hospital for less than 12 hours with a vaginal birth.

Another question I have - how many Canadians buy US health insurance? I read that quite a few do.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#23

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

albertabob

>Nope Jim, Dental care is only free for the armed forces and most cival servants.

We, as citizens, pick up that tab and then we get to choose from several third party insurers for the type of coverage we think we will need.

It's "a la carte" as it should be.

Senior citizens get a subsidy for little more than full dentures or extractions and it is limited to a few dollars per year.

Medicine on the other hand is state controlled and now offers a much lower standard of service than it European counterparts at and ever increasing cost to the taxpayer.

Bob

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#24

Re: Having lived in both countries

albertabob

>Hi Mark:

I dont know that you are addressing the question.

There are differing rates of taxation in each country that dramaticlly affect how much money there is to toss at subdised health care.

The the U.S. tax free day is:

" In the United States, Tax Freedom Day for 2007 was April 30, for a total average effective tax rate of 32.69 percent of the nation's income."

If you read my first message you will see that Canadians work a lot longer for the Government and that translates, fortunately for us, into more "state" benefits.

We work until the end of June for the Govt and you Yanks work until April 30.

That's 2 whole months! If your wife works it's 4 months per year.

If you folks are willing to make that type of sacrifice then perhaps you can get free helath care.

Or,you could use all that extra income we have to part with to buy yourself some decent insurance.

Regards

Bob

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#25

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>My company covers the balance of my medical costs as you noted, and if I retire with the current one they will do so into my retirement as well.

Take care,

Jim