Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Canadians don't need SawStop?

Posts

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#26

Get well soon!

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>I hope you heal quickly and have no complications.

I agree on the illegal alien (er, undocumented immigrant) problem with the emergency rooms. The typical wait in the emergency rooms here seems to be around 5 hours. The best bet is to arrive via an ambulance. That seems to bump you up the list and that will also really cost you.

Earlier this year we waited about 4 hours with my 7 year old daughter in the emergency room to see a doctor. She fell on her head and was crying severely and vomiting. Fortunately she is okay. I wonder how many hours they have to wait in Canada's emergency rooms?

Joe

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#27

Re: Get well soon!

Brian in Brighton

>Thanks. Been two weeks now and no problems. I was seen within 10 minutes of hobbling in. I think the obvious and unknown pain was the key to getting in early. There was one family in the ER, so it was not busy. Unlike the Denver hospital which is mobbed with people with all kinds of minor and major problems when my buddy cut his fingers.

As we were told at the first Hospital with his fingers. The only thing they MUST do is to stabalize you from any life threatening problems. They made it very clear that there only legal resposibility was to get him out of any life threatening problems. this means that they could stitch over the would and send him on his way. How does this benefit society? Making a guy lose the use of his primary hand because of $78,000? He now makes about $300,000 in his own business, so he has more than paid his fair share of taxes in the last 14 years to cover the expense if it was covered by the government.

I think we need a hybrid system. Government should pay for injuries to keep people productive. People should pay their way when they smoke or overeat of have some other problem that is long term stupidity. Glad that it is not my call.

Brian in Brighton.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#28

Re: CNN Checked the facts on the movie *LINK*

John Meikrantz

>A better analysis can be found here:

Raises some interesting questions, anyway.

JohnM


Cato Institute Analysis

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#29

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

albertabob

>Isn't your company,for all intents, actually an American Co?

bo

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#30

Re: Get well soon!

Bill Howatt

>"I wonder how many hours they have to wait in Canada's emergency rooms?"

Well, it depends. Somedays they are busy as heck and you will wait hours depending on the nature of your problem. If you happened to go when there was a flu expidemic last winter then you certainly would have been waiting hours plus a few more.

My wife got ill (gastrointestinal issue) when we were vacationing in New Brunswick last fall. I would say she was being examined within 1 hour and the waiting room was fairly full and complicated with a traffic accident as well. My step-son has waited over 4 hours in emergency in Ontario before seeing a doctor for a non-critical skateboarding ankle injury. Really too many variables to do any sort of an apples to apples comparison.

Bill

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#31

Re: CNN Checked the facts on the movie

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>I guess "better analysis" of the movie facts depends on your perspective. CATO is also a big defender of the tobacco industry. Not my idea of an organization I would put my trust in, but to each his own.

Joe

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#32

Don't be too quick to blame insurance co.

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>In large companies, the insurance company is just a filter and accountant for the company. The company carries the lions share of the medical cost and premium.

While I was working, I paid around $150/mo for health insurance for my wife and myself. When I took early retirement, the cost jumped to over $600/mo. Now that we are both on "the dole", I still pay over $200/mo for supplemental insurance through my previous employer.

Short story:

Three weeks ago today my wife feel while gardening and broke her ankle in 3 places. We called 911 and within 15 minutes had the EMS truck in our driveway. In less than 30 minutes she was on her way to the local hospital. She was immediately taken into a room in the ER and within an hour she had her ankle "reduced"(put back in place, it was twisted at 90 degrees to her leg.) and was ready for a room. At 8 am Sunday morning, she was operated on and several metal parts installed to support the break. Sunday afternoon she came home.

I am now playing housekeeper, gardener, cook, and shopper until around Labor Day. She had very fragile thin bones that will take a long time to heal. But, I signed up for this duty some 33 years ago....

As far as Michael More goes, he is a secular progressive that would like to see the US turn into a socialist country. IF I ran into him drowning on the beach, my biggest problem would be deciding whether to pour more water on him with a 5 or 10 gallon bucket.

If you want my real opinion, just ask,

Ken

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#33

Geez, Ken...

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>You mean you wouldn't call for help for Mr. Moore? You know, so more of you could be pouring water on him? Should this ever happen, look me up in the Lafayette phone book... ;^)

Jason

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#34

I certainly can blame the insurance co.

wilbur

>As someone who works within the system, I have a pretty dim view of insurance companies. I'm a pediatric hematologist/oncologist. One of the more common reasons that a kid is referred to see me by their pediatrician is that the kid is found to have abnormal blood counts. Over half of the insurance companies that we deal with will not allow me to look at a blood slide directly when the kid comes to see me. This is a vital part of doing the workup for the kid. They would rather that the kid be sent to one of the commercial labs to have their labs done because that's who they have their contract with, which leaves me only with a sheet of numbers to deal with. To those of you who wonder why I can't just use the numbers, for me to do so in evaluating a kid who has abnormal labs is like asking someone to make a dovetail joint without the use of a chisel.

We can badger the insurance companies to make an exception, but in order to do this, I have to have my office staff get on the phone, negotiate the insurance companies' phone tree, which is as bad if not worse than the phone tree that the patient has to deal with, and speak to a representative to get the waiver. This takes about 15 minutes for each patient that comes in, which is not a great use of my office staff's time.

I know why this system is set up this way. The insurance companies hope that our office will get tired of this and skip this step, which saves them money. Remember, the purpose of the insurance company is not to provide health care coverage for their insurees. The purpose of the insurance company is to make a profit.

Even worse, I know the quality control at the commercial labs is poor. We've been complaining to the medical director of one of the labs, and the response was that we should be happy, because abnormal results means more business for us. Again, the purpose of the commercial labs is not to provide accurate testing for diagnostic purposes. The purpose of the commercial labs is to make money for their stockholders.

Now, I know that a third party payer system is inevitable*. The costs for health care in case of a catastrophic event is more than the vast majority of people could afford, so some sort of collective payment system is needed. With private insurers, I get what I get, and if the terms of my coverage are changed, there is little recourse. On the other hand, if such a system was put in the hands of the government, at least I would have some sort of say both as a patient and as a practitioner because I can vote. It may not be much, but it's a better deal than I get with my insurance company. Besides, if third party payment was run by the government, the system can get away from the profit issue and really start to cover health care costs.

As a doctor, I'm looking forward to seeing "Sicko". Michael Moore may not be completely objective or accurate in this film or his others, but in his previous work he's been more much more right than not.

* For those who may think that people can do this on their own, consider this. Suppose we assume that the 14-15% of GDP that is spent on health care in the U.S. actually does result in the greatest health care system in the world (which I have doubts about as well). That would mean that everyone would have to save 15% for the day that they need health care coverage. The personal savings rate in the U.S. has not been above 10% since the mid-80's, and has never been close to 15%, and has been less than 3% since 2000.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#35

Re: I certainly can blame the insurance co.

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Wow Wilbur,

That is very eye opening....

Thanks for your post.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#36

My Experiences

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Joe,

I will tell you that in 14 years living in Oakville the wait times in the Oakville Trafalgar hospital have varied. Years ago I walked in with a cut and waited 2 hours and left and went to a walk in clinic, stitched up in less than 20 minutes.

The times I have gone in with Real problems I was assessed very quickly and treated quickly. A few years ago I had an abdominal blockage, I was a walk into the emergency department, I was taken right away and in a bed and medicated in 15 minutes. The staff there does a great job in understanding your need when you walk in.

What also works well is the walk in clinic we have, so the last time I cut my hand needing stitches I went straight to the clinic, I was home in less than an hour from the time I cut my hand.

Times can vary dramatically though from hospital to hospital, these are just my experiences.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#37

Like I said....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Unless I misunderstood, the question you asked was: "but don't Americans have access to insurance for medical expenses?"

And my answer was/is: no, access to insurance is onyl granted to those who can afford it.

I've paid income tax in Quebec and in Ontario, and in Georgia. And I know that the amount you don't spend in taxes won't always provide enough money to pay for medical insurance. Sorry, that double negative sentence sound strange. The amount you "save" in taxes, may not be enough to cover medical insurance.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#38

What does that have to with truth?

Don henthorn

>The Cato Institute is simply standing up for private enterprise and not having the government act as big daddy for supposed adults.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#39

As with everythign else there is no real solution.

Don henthorn

>Unfortunately in this country the level of education in the field of economics is so non-existent that all kinds of absolutely faulty proposals come from people who are in a position to know better. Ignorance is the LACK OF KNOWLEDGE in someone who could and should know. No one would call for government control of any field if they were not ignorant of economics. The only thing that keeps prices low on anything is competition and the first thing government will do is stifle or control competition thus guaranteeing the prices will drastically increase. There would be no health care crisis if government were kept out of the loop. This does not mean that local and state governments could not set up programs to help those who truly need help. But providing help to those who can provide it for themselves, as we are doing now, on a national level is simply giving more power and control to the government and taking away the dignity and respect which men should earn for themselves. I am an old fart who is dirt poor and forced to have medicare. I do pay another 6 hundred a month out of my pitiful income for supplimental insurance so that my health care providers receive a little more for treating me. I was scared into signing up for the drug program thinking they would not provide for me if I got to the place where I couldn't pay for my own drugs. I wish I hadn't done that now. I would rather pay for my own drugs than have others pay for them. It seems we now have a series of generations who no longer have any respect for themselves or any pride in themselves.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#40

Re: Like I said....

albertabob

>Mark:

Maybe what you dont understand is that Canada's health care regulations prohibit us from seeking medical services outside the system.

When there are long line ups and that is becoming more frequent some of us die waiting.

All we need is a pandemic to completely wipe out our resources here because there is no contingency plan at any level in our medical. system.

For many folks medical care has become a crap shoot here insurance or not.

Cheers Bob

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#41

Re: Like I said....

Rusty

>I have never heard of anyone dying in Canada waiting.All major problems get moved to the front of the line.Also in Canada only 1.5% gets used in administrative costs ,I think it is more like 35% in States.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#42

I think I understand

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I believe I understand. I lived in Canada for 30 years (okay first 10 don't really count because I was too young), and worked in a Canadian hospital (administrative role, not as a doctor) for the last 5 of them. And we still discuss and compare the situations frequently with the rest of our family that is still there.

Regulations or not, I think both Canadians and Americans who can afford it get care anywhere they want to.

I will hazard a guess (that's all it is) is that any Canadian who is dying waiting, or any American that is dying broke, is in that situation because of lack of money.

You might not be able to buy love or happiness, and all the money in the world is useless to you when you're dead, but money can delay it.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#43

Front of the line

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I was in Toronto on a Friday afternoon in a taxi on the way to an airport to fly back to Montreal when I had my second collapsed lung (a year after the first).

The taxi dropped me off at the closest hospital (can't recall which but it must have been between Markham and the airport). I walked in and felt a little panicked when I saw a rather long line in the emergency room. I waited for less than a minute before deciding to walk to the front of the line. I explained the situation and within 10 seconds I was on a cart (or a chair?) being wheeled somewhere. And that's all I really recall for that weekend.

I too have have very long waits on some occasions and very quick attention at other times, both in Canada and the US.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#44

One of the big differences betw'n the US & Canada

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Having lived in both countries, I think one of the biggest difference is in the costs people are requried to pay. In Canada, the amount you pay for healthcare is a percentage based on your earnings, in the form of income tax. In the US it's based on your risk.

In Canada everyone pays a percentage of their income, in the US you could have to pay $1500/month regardless of how much money you make. I've had to pay that much and more. I know people who've had to pay much more than that each month.

Someone in the US earning $40K/year, could be required to spend $18K for medical insurance. Someone in Canada makign that salary would never be required to spend that much.

What do you think someone making $50K/year will do when faced with a $3000/month insurance premium? Go without.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#45

Canadians need SawStop as much as everyone else

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>There's no way you should measure the value of ANY safety device by the amount of money it could save in medical / insurance costs.

By the crazy reckoning underlying the start of this thread I don't need to use ear-muffs, visor, dust mask, dust collector, blade guards, splitters or even wear boots in my shop because my country has comprehensive health and accident coverage funded by taxpayers and accessible by anyone regardles of fault (i.e. no matter how stupid you were to hurt yourself, you'll still get the injury fixed at taxpayers' expense).

The whole point of a safety device is to protect the person, not the wallet.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#46

Re: CATO's take

Peter Gregory

>I like this quote from the link "America needs to have a serious debate about how to fix our health-care system." I suspect that both Moore and CATO are right in a way. Of course, the CATO analysis doesn't point out that we are spending about twice as much, per person, for health care as everyone else. When you have systems with remarkable similar results, but one has twice the costs, shouldn't that bother you?

The horror stories about health care from foreign countries, sound just like the stories from the US.

At least, everyone can agree that change is needed. I think the film is doing an excellent job pointing this out.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#47

Re: I think I understand

albertabob

>I think the point I wanted to make in the first place is that Canadian health care is not free and that Canadians pay a healthy price for the service.

Second point became that the U.S. prides itself on the strengths of a free enterprise system but has become and oligarchy with large corportions dominating the tax payers with the backing of big government.

It is painfully evident that many areas of the American system are in need of an overhaul, not the least of which, appears to be the health care system.

..and to agree with those of you who insist that money has it privledge. - I agree.

Bob

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#48

Re: Like I said.... *LINK*

albertabob

>Let me bring you up to speed with the state of our system.

Natually, the system goes out of its way to minimise any negative events suchs as the untimely demise of it citizens that slip through the cracks.

Bob


Bed shortages across Canada

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#49

Re: I appreciate your knowledgeable input

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Wilbur, and 100% agree with your assessment of the insurance companies. I worked for a company who, after being bought and sold several times became a small division of a very large corporation. This corporation was "self insured". The medical insurance control was subcontracted to Atena for administration. IMHO, the "administration" was intended to discourage all claims - and make all claims as small as possible. I was in middle management (Engineer & Management representative for QS-9000) so had some information not available to the hourly workforce. I had one claim that was denied, so I called from my desk at work using the company's penny and time. I went through the inevitable phone tag and -we will get back to you stalls, but refused to hang up. (There is a reason the claims personnel won't give you their full name.) As they finally figured out after about the first hour that I wouldn't get off the phone - I ended up with a first line supervisor. Same scenario - after about 2 hours the director of engineering asked me who I was on the phone with, I explained my situation - he said stay with them - he had had similar problems. In a nutshell, it took me over three hours to resolve an issue that ended up costing the "insurance" about $200. My salary and the phone line probably cost more than the charge. But, when I called the next time I found I received prompt service that resolved my problems. Guess they have a "list" of people that they service to get them out of their hair. I have some friends that are physicians - according to them the largest costs they incur is the liability insurance. One told me almost half the patient fees are used to cover insurance costs. Seems to me if the US did one thing that is done in all other countries except third world we could eliminate much of the medical problem. That is to allow one who is sued and wins, the right to recover costs from the person that sued. This system seems to work well in Britain, Japan, Sweden, Germany, Switzerland and all the other countries. Of course this would eliminate the "ambulance chaser attorneys". Probably not much of a chance of getting this type of law implemented as, IMHO, most of our legislators fall into this category.

Re: Canadians don't need SawStop?

#50

Re: Canadians need SawStop as much as everyone els

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>I was actually just being sarcastic. I am personally a very safety conscious person. I ALWAYS use my guard, splitter, extra-long push sticks, ear-muffs and, when needed, a full-blown $1000 3M respirator. The SawStop looks like a terrific machine, but I am happy with the safety features provided by my European made slider. By the way, the American woodworker staring in the Micheal Moore movie who trimmed off his fingers had no guard or splitter and was pulling a piece of wood off from behind the blade when it kicked back and pulled his hand into the blade. Ouch...

The Micheal Moore movie just started playing in the U.S. and I really wanted to know what people thought of the health care systems not only in the U.S., but in other places, like Canada and New Zealand.

I know the conversation drifted from woodworking accidents, but I personally found it to be very informative, especially getting the first person information from woodworkers who tend to be honest, shoot-from-the-hip people. The beauty of this forum discussion is that although we may disagree we remained civil and I think had a pretty good discussion about an important topic.

Actually, Micheal Moore looks like he could be a woodworker himself. Hmmm... I wonder if he's lurking on this forum? If you are Micheal, buy a SawStop - and buy a few for those guys who want to drown you on the beach you nasty old liberal do-gooder! ... ;^)

Joe