I certainly can blame the insurance co.
wilbur
>As someone who works within the system, I have a pretty dim view of insurance companies. I'm a pediatric hematologist/oncologist. One of the more common reasons that a kid is referred to see me by their pediatrician is that the kid is found to have abnormal blood counts. Over half of the insurance companies that we deal with will not allow me to look at a blood slide directly when the kid comes to see me. This is a vital part of doing the workup for the kid. They would rather that the kid be sent to one of the commercial labs to have their labs done because that's who they have their contract with, which leaves me only with a sheet of numbers to deal with. To those of you who wonder why I can't just use the numbers, for me to do so in evaluating a kid who has abnormal labs is like asking someone to make a dovetail joint without the use of a chisel.
We can badger the insurance companies to make an exception, but in order to do this, I have to have my office staff get on the phone, negotiate the insurance companies' phone tree, which is as bad if not worse than the phone tree that the patient has to deal with, and speak to a representative to get the waiver. This takes about 15 minutes for each patient that comes in, which is not a great use of my office staff's time.
I know why this system is set up this way. The insurance companies hope that our office will get tired of this and skip this step, which saves them money. Remember, the purpose of the insurance company is not to provide health care coverage for their insurees. The purpose of the insurance company is to make a profit.
Even worse, I know the quality control at the commercial labs is poor. We've been complaining to the medical director of one of the labs, and the response was that we should be happy, because abnormal results means more business for us. Again, the purpose of the commercial labs is not to provide accurate testing for diagnostic purposes. The purpose of the commercial labs is to make money for their stockholders.
Now, I know that a third party payer system is inevitable*. The costs for health care in case of a catastrophic event is more than the vast majority of people could afford, so some sort of collective payment system is needed. With private insurers, I get what I get, and if the terms of my coverage are changed, there is little recourse. On the other hand, if such a system was put in the hands of the government, at least I would have some sort of say both as a patient and as a practitioner because I can vote. It may not be much, but it's a better deal than I get with my insurance company. Besides, if third party payment was run by the government, the system can get away from the profit issue and really start to cover health care costs.
As a doctor, I'm looking forward to seeing "Sicko". Michael Moore may not be completely objective or accurate in this film or his others, but in his previous work he's been more much more right than not.
* For those who may think that people can do this on their own, consider this. Suppose we assume that the 14-15% of GDP that is spent on health care in the U.S. actually does result in the greatest health care system in the world (which I have doubts about as well). That would mean that everyone would have to save 15% for the day that they need health care coverage. The personal savings rate in the U.S. has not been above 10% since the mid-80's, and has never been close to 15%, and has been less than 3% since 2000.