Ian Kirby....drafting??
Brian in Brighton
>Tell me I am not being too harsh with this letter I sent to WWJ about the article Ian Kirby wrote on drafting and this month's letter from Frank Kutney where Ian will basically not admit that he is wrong. This is what I wrote.
"Dear Editor,
Having created over 20,000 drawings in the 20 plus years I have been drafting and engineering I must write to dispel the falsehoods being told by Mr. Kirby. While I admire his woodworking skills, he should stay out of drafting. There are only two methods of projection in use, First and Third. The U.S. uses primarily third angle projection, not fourth. While Europe and Asia use first. The difference is in the pivot point to create the views adjacent to the primary view. If the model is pivoted about a point between the object and the drafter it is third angle. Thus the left hand side of a part is on the left hand view. First angle projection has the pivot point behind the object. The left hand side of the part is now on the right hand view. It is not as Mr. Kirby states where the position of the views dictate the angle of projection. It is also not optional or left up to the drafter. I have been with too many major corporations and seen too many drawings to count to back this up. Any company doing international trade will show a blunt cone in the border, like a broken pencil point. The view beside it will show the end of the cone with two circles to indicate the blunt point. These two circles will indicate first or third angle projection depending on location, usually backed up with a note. It is this simple. There is no fourth angle projection in use. If by stating this Mr.Kirby means an auxiliary view, than he should state it as such. I am amazed that the editors of such a fine magazine could not recall all the plans they have published and questioned Mr. Kirby on his references for this article."
Am I being too harsh or do the editors think he walks on water?
Brian in Brighton



