Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Ian Kirby....drafting??

Posts

Ian Kirby....drafting??

#1

Ian Kirby....drafting??

Brian in Brighton

>Tell me I am not being too harsh with this letter I sent to WWJ about the article Ian Kirby wrote on drafting and this month's letter from Frank Kutney where Ian will basically not admit that he is wrong. This is what I wrote.

"Dear Editor,

Having created over 20,000 drawings in the 20 plus years I have been drafting and engineering I must write to dispel the falsehoods being told by Mr. Kirby. While I admire his woodworking skills, he should stay out of drafting. There are only two methods of projection in use, First and Third. The U.S. uses primarily third angle projection, not fourth. While Europe and Asia use first. The difference is in the pivot point to create the views adjacent to the primary view. If the model is pivoted about a point between the object and the drafter it is third angle. Thus the left hand side of a part is on the left hand view. First angle projection has the pivot point behind the object. The left hand side of the part is now on the right hand view. It is not as Mr. Kirby states where the position of the views dictate the angle of projection. It is also not optional or left up to the drafter. I have been with too many major corporations and seen too many drawings to count to back this up. Any company doing international trade will show a blunt cone in the border, like a broken pencil point. The view beside it will show the end of the cone with two circles to indicate the blunt point. These two circles will indicate first or third angle projection depending on location, usually backed up with a note. It is this simple. There is no fourth angle projection in use. If by stating this Mr.Kirby means an auxiliary view, than he should state it as such. I am amazed that the editors of such a fine magazine could not recall all the plans they have published and questioned Mr. Kirby on his references for this article."

Am I being too harsh or do the editors think he walks on water?

Brian in Brighton

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#2

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

Martin from Granbury

>"I am amazed that the editors of such a fine magazine..."

I don't know much about drafting, but I disagree with the above statement. WWJ is not a fine magazine. Certainly not on par with PPW or FWW. It is second rate, at best, slightly better than AWW, which is a joke. I have some older issues of WWJ which are much better than the current editions.

Now, am I being too harsh? Maybe, but I don't think so.

For the record, I like Ian Kirby, but based on your experience, I think your knowledge about drafting trumps his.

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#3

Have to agree with you Brian

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Brain,

I have to agree with you. I don't know where Mr Kirby is getting his information from. While I admire his work and have enjoyed reading his books, I would recommend that he stick to what he was classically trained in; wood working. I feel your letter's content is correct. It's well written and too the point. BTW, I canceled my WWJ subscription several years ago due to (what I felt) was poor content. (If I saw one more article in there for a router table I thought I was going to explode!) IMHO both PWW and FWW are much better written magazines.

I've been in drafting and engineering now for just about 20 years. In that time I learned to "hand draft" on a board, ran a CADD department, and later a Design Department. I can't count the number of drawings I must have created!

In all the jobs I've had I found that many companies were taking it as gospel that all countries around the world were using the same angle projection as the US. That is a recipe for disaster! You can't assume that and send a drawing from the US to China and not expect them to misinterpret the design! In order to add some form of consistency to the drawings, in each place I worked I (or someone on my team) convinced them to add the "Third Angle Projection" symbol to ALL drawing formats.

See ya,

Dominic

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#4

Moses Yoder

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

moses yoder

>If I read your letter before I started drafting, I probably would never have attempted doing drawings for projects in my shop. I don't think that any part at you say would mean anything to people who are making shop drawings for a woodworking hobby.

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#5

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I totally agree with you Brian. I worked as an Engineer for over 39 years before retiring. I am not aware of any "forth angle projection" in use. I have worked with thousands of drawings from all the major US, and several foreign automakers, many electronic houses, many of the larger automation equipment manufactures, dozens of die and stamping tooling houses. I have worked with drawings from the US, Mexico, Canada, Europe and Asia. It would behoove anyone that wants to do any drawing that may be used by anyone but themselves, to learn the raw basics. The projections are just that - basics. Any drawing not done in a standard format are certain to mislead anyone that is at all familiar with correct procedures.

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#6

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>Making a drawing for your own use is akin to writing a grocery list for yourself. it dosent matter what you use for spelling or format. But for a message on this list we all assume it is in english and that it will read from left to right and top to bottom. This thread is addressing that issue for those that exchange drawings for a living and relly on the acurate interpretation of those drawings by others.

Robin Corell

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#7

KIRBY IS A BIG BAG OF WIND IN MY HUMBLE OPINION

CHICAGO Bob

>

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#8

Gee, Bob, tell us how you really feel! ;-)

Martin from Granbury

>

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#9

Kindly disagree Robin

Brian in Brighton

>Drafting is akin to writing. It is a way to communicate with one another. There are standards for a reason. You can make isometric drawings and put dimensions on them if you wish, or you can make lots of views that are labeled to show what they are. If people go about saying that the right view means a fourth angle projection you will get a lot of funny stares. Drawing is so simple that there is really no reason not to do it properly, or at least put the proper views in the proper place. There might not be a time when your drawing will end up in someone elses hands, but then again someone here at WC might ask for a set of prints for something you made. If they can't read it because it is drawn wrong they lose.

There is a time and place in drafting for expression, usually in the lettering style Architects do it one way, engineers another. There was a time when I could draw letters that someone would guess was done with a template. With CAD, those days are gone. But the basics of how to place views and dimension are really set in stone and a look at most plans will show how it's done.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#10

Re: I couldn't bring myself to say that.

Brian in Brighton

>

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#11

Re: WWJ not that great, just like some projects.

Brian in Brighton

>Maybe I should drop my subscription and just pick up copies at the store when I see a project I like in it. It does seem that WWJ and AW went downhill a few years back. Did they start getting sold at Borgs around that time and have to dumb down the projects? FW is sold at Lowes and it is still, IMHO, the best out there. I would still like to see more variety of classical projects that span several issues. I enjoyed the highboy from Sandor N. a few years back. I for one am getting sick of the small boxes that seem to crop up every month in one mag or another. That sounds like a good start to another thread!!

Brian in Brighton

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#12

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

Rob Johnstone

>Hello Woodcentral gang,

I am adding my voice to this discussion to make a couple of points. First, anytime I see our magazine being discussed I feel pretty good about it. Even if we are getting kicked in the chops � at least we are �in the game.�

Second, regarding the specifics of the question of whether Ian Kirby knows how to draw or not � I�ll let you guys come to your own conclusions. Let me say that I have worked with Ian�s drawings for nearly eight years now � they work just fine. (They are in truth, things of beauty.)

But do let me put this article (which it is clear that many of you have not read) in context. And this might reflect on the expressed opinions regarding the Journal�s quality. Ian and I, over the last several years, have addressed woodworking from many perspectives. We addressed basic joinery, preparing stock and advanced joinery and more. We have also addressed project design � in a more in-depth fashion than any other woodworking magazine to my knowledge � from concept, to mock-ups, to methods of work � ending with two articles on drawing. Now, you may choose to take exception to the content of any of those pieces, but our readers have been treated to a depth of coverage that few authors could provide. In fact, what other woodworking author still writing has the chops to even attempt the scope of what we have been covering? I don�t know of one.

And finally, let me say a word or two about Ian Kirby. Ellis Walentine introduced me to Ian several years ago. He is a fine man who knows more about woodworking and its related disciplines that anyone I know personally. He is passionate about woodworking and teaching woodworking.

I got a bit preachy in there � but, hey � now I�m in the game!

Rob Johnstone, editor, Woodworker�s Journal

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#13

I agree with Rob

Joe Dusel (Vista, CA)

>I have never met anyone who knows more about woodworking or design than Ian Kirby. Ian is a man of many talents in woodworking and beyond. He is also one of the most open people in the world about sharing the things that he has learned with others. I was fortunate enough to have studied for about 3 years under Ian and it was the most valuable educational experience of my life.

Joe

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#14

Ellis Walentine

Thanks for weighing in, Rob

Ellis Walentine

>As you know, Ian and I go way back, too. I have a lot of respect for his understanding of woodworking process, as taught by the main protagonists of his particular discipline, the English Arts & Crafts movement. Few people I've known in my forty or so years in woodworking are certifiable scions of culture-specific woodworking movements, but Ian is one of them. His understanding may not be the only one you might encounter or subscribe to, but it is unassailable in its logic and continuity.

This doesn't mean that he is always right, and some of the technical drafting evidence offered here seems to raise valid questions about some of Ian's terminology, but I think we need to use this occasion to get some agreement on these issues. I will contact Ian personally and let you know what he has to say.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#15

It's a matter of technique

Ray Thompson - Middletown,IN

>Everyone seems to be a stickler for proper technique when using or teaching hand and power tools. Why would we teach bad technique for anything else. While we may not get hurt using bad drafting techniques, although I did get a nasty pencil stab once, proper views and layouts can help a novice understand the drawings better as long as everyone subscribes to the same standards.

Ray

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#16

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

Vijay Kumar

>I agree with you Brian. I have 30 years of experience as an engineer.

There are only 2 projections in the engineering.architectural drawing world, first and third angle.

It does not matter what Ian Kirby says. His expertise is woodworking, not drafting. As a woodworker he is great, as a drafter he makes pretty drawings, but these drawings cannot be sent to 3rd parties for building--because mistakes can be made.

This is probably not an issue for Ian, because his items are not mass production, and he is personally involved in building the pieces. So much damage will never be done--certainly not by him.

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#17

Re: but Vijay...

Brian in Brighton

>By Ian making the article he is passing himself off as an expert. His reply in the latest issue is an even more glaring example of the problem. He is an excellent woodworker and I only wish I were that good at woodworking. He is however, not a draftsman. Rob has some good points. But this is a subject that is dear to me, as you can tell. I have hired, and fired, too many engineers fresh out of college being taught the wrong way to draw or not taught at all to let this slide. When someone is printing an article that is blatently wrong and misleading I must speak up. I do not agree that it is not a big deal, as other seem to think. I think this is such a fundamental issue that it MUST be taught properly. There are only two ways to draw, period. I have too many drawings under my pencil to keep this garbage going. Too many people in today's society think it is not a big deal to change standards to suit themselves. Look at how kids spell today, text messaging has done wonders to them. I have worked with guys who do not see any need for standards that they do not agree with. They want something simpler today. Forget about it being more difficult later. What makes my life easier today is all people are concerned with. I had an hour long meeting with a bunch of idiots I worked with several years ago on why lineweight was important, even with CAD. They did not see the problem, yet the shop was openly on my side. Lineweight is important and makes things easier to read.

Drafting properly is as important as spelling is. If you write all the letters worng but the sepllnig is clsoe enough people think it's OK. No sir, not on my watch.

I do agree with some of the other posters, maybe it is time to let some of these less talented mags (rags?) go. This is just my pet peave and I can't tolerate it anymore.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#18

THAT'S A BULLSEYE ROB!

Art Silva

>

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#19

"It's all in the wrist" NM

Jim Moore

>

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#20

Re: but Vijay...

Charles Self

>Kirby is not teaching engineering or architectural drawing in school. He's presenting examples for woodworkers to use in their own shops, as he uses his drawings in his.

AFAIK, he doesn't intend them to be passed along. He also doesn't pretend to be teaching an engineering class.

The techniques taught engineers do not necessarily apply to hobby woodworkers, and vice versa. Claiming that they do is silly.

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#21

weight or thickness?

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>are you sure you are using line weight in the correct context?

as taught in the college I went to, Line weight is all the same. the thickness of the lines is different. now I have never studied the history of drafting techniques but I have seen some old blueprints an an exhibit and you are right and wrong.

I was taught one way, but was instructed differently by my first employer that the subject matter should be darker. as in electrical drawings should have outlets darker than the walls. using line weight to contrast the subject at hand.

I believe the ANSI standards only suggest the thickness of the line not the weight.

if you know of a source for this information like a ISO stansrds website, that would be fun to go visit.

later,

Joe P.

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#22

Re: weight or thickness?

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>There are very specific standards which govern interpreting mechanical drawings. In the US, the standard for drafting and interpreting drawings is ASME/ANSI Y14.5 Dimensioning and Tolerancing. Every view, every symbol, and every box has a very specific meaning so that there can be no misinterpretation betwween the various parties involved indesinging and making a part.

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#23

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

Rob Johnstone

>As is often the case, a small thing can get blown out of proportion. At the urging of my publisher, I went back to Ian�s article and looked at what he said about projections. You will find it below. Therein you will find that Ian was exactly right about which projections were in preference on both sides of the Atlantic. We did print a typo in his response letter where Ian incorrectly said first and �fourth� � which of course was not really the point of his letter. (His letter simply said that he was attempting to educate the average woodworker how projections are determined.)

So, now a long thread of Internet ink has been spilled, which included such helpful and insightful comments as calling Ian a windbag, over a typo. I hope this will help Brian in Brighton to settle down � as his cause of properly teaching drawing was indeed carried out by Ian in the first place. Which if he read the article, he would have known.

Road Maps of Woodworking: The Importance of Drawings, Part 1

By Ian Kirby Page 61

�Of the four layouts available in the system, the First Angle and Third Angle are the two commonly used, the difference being the location of the plan above or below the elevations. Once again we see an effect of the �pond� between the U.S. and the U.K. Here in the U.S., the Third Angle prevails; there, it�s the First Angle. That being said, drawings are occasionally positioned out of sequence, usually in the cause of showing an awkward detail. This underlines the importance of naming every element to avoid confusion.�

Rob Johnstone, editor, Woodworker�s Journal

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#24

�Me thinks you protest too much!�

Chicago Bob

>Discussions like this are healthy, again in my humble opinion. Trying to shut them down with a clever journalistic response of discounting this feedback is very counter productive and quite frankly, insulting to woodworking amateurs such as myself.

Kirby has a long and admirable history as a professional & innovative woodworker. I probably own everything he has published in the last 10 to 15 years. My problem is a continuing sense of arrogance on Mr. Kirby�s part based upon, again my personal impression, that his fundamental approach to a woodworking technique or method (i.e. including drafting) is that his way is only really �right� and acceptable way to do it.

The readership of Wood Central spans everyone from professionals who make their living skilled in practicing the art to hobbyists, and to woodworking hacks like me who�s dream is to become �good enough� someday to escape the corporate world to work the wood (which reality says will never quite happen). This board is one of the finest if not the best educational and discussion forum for woodworkers of all skill levels that I personally know. At the heart of this is the ability to state opinions and share information globally.

Mr. Johnstone, I believe that you have received some excellent feedback here concerning your publication. To discount it because it somehow �offends� you is probably a disservice to your publication and your acknowledged efforts to bring it into the realm of a top tier woodworking publication. Improvements have been made but you have much work remaining.

Sir, it is regrettable if I have offended you and certainly wish you much success in the future. And yes, I still think Mr. Kirby is very arrogant and a self proclaimed expert in every area of the art, but I will still probably read everything he writes because it has value.

Regards,

Robert Haines

Corporate Manufacturing Executive & Woodworking Hack

Chicago, IL

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#25

Re: �Me thinks you protest too much!�

Rob Johnstone

>Dear Chicago Bob,

I have no intention or desire to shut down discussion. I did have a desire to set the record straight -- which I assumed was the goal of the discussion. As I stated in my earlier post, I have no problem with folks making their own determinations as to the quality or value of our magazine's content. I like it when our magazine is discussed ... because that means people are reading it and reacting. And I listen to all feedback carefully. But I have to say that some slices of this thread strike me a bit like the Rosann Rossana Danna bit on SNL. And as a person who has on more than one occation had to say "never mind!", I find no fault in pointing that out.

Rob