Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Ian Kirby....drafting??

Posts

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#26

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>Hmmm:

To qualify - I'm a draftsman, and I've been reading this thread with interest.

First off - drafting is a language. As with all languages there are dialects and nuances, but it's a language that's been developed over time and by all who participate - worldwide. It's truly common to the world and other than music, is one of the few languages to achieve this status.

As a language it's purpose is to define and convey information between parties. In this case, from a designer to a builder. It's an exercise in mapping out details, thoughts and concepts such that every one of these that's important to the final product has been identified and put on paper in such a way that there can be no (NO) misinterpretation.

If the product that's created using the drawings as a guideline do not meet the designers vision or intent, the message has not been properly conveyed and this rests solely on the shoulder of the person who created the drawings in the first place.

Secondly - the language of drafting has been around long enough that it does an excellent job of providing a toolset and methods for defining detail and putting it on paper. But it also recognizes that while this definition of this language is very thorough, it's by no means complete. So there are guidelines established that allow a draftsperson to step outside the lines (sorry - bad pun) if he/she feels it's necessary to define the message that may not fit within traditional methods..

To negate the importance of detail in drafting is to admit ignorance of the the importance as to why the language exists in the first place. To have knowledge of the language and choose to circumvent it while trying to transfer knowledge and information via drafting to another party is to show both arrogance and ignorance. As has been proven in this conversation, neither is acceptable by those that are a true study of the language of drafting.

That said - I read the snippet of Ian Kirby's article that Mr. Johnston's published here and I have to say that it's an excellent description of the fact that there are two "legal" methods of projecting. And also that there are times when neither will tell the story effectively, so the ingenuity must sometimes be called for to convey a message - is allowed, provided it's been properly labeled.

As a draftsman - I have no problem with that.

Rob

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#27

Re: weight IS thickness

Brian in Brighton

>Joe, In drafting lineweight is the thickness. When I used a board. The object was in 0.7mm lead, dims and text in 0.5 and hatch, hidden and centerlines in 0.3mm lead.

It makes it much easier to read.

Brian in Brighton, thanks for the input.

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#28

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

Brian in Brighton

>Mr. Johnstone. I indeed did read both the original article and the latest editorial. The difference in not simple where the plan view goes. The difference is where the pivot is taken for the part in question. You show a correction in the editorial that shows the missing side tab. This is correct for a first angle projection, but the plan view should be on the bottom for first angle. There is no such projection as second and fourth. They simply do not exist. Ian is incorrect in his letter stating "If you want the side elevation to the right and the plan above then you are in the third angle." This is so incorrect it is remarkable. The side elevation can be right or left side. The proper statement is to discuss the viewers pivot point, not just the position of the views. The direction of the views and to which side they are will dictate the first or third angle projection. NOT just the placement. In third angle the right side of the part will be on the right with the front of the part facing the front view. The left side of the part will be on the left with the front of the part facing the front view. Same concept for the top and bottom views. The easiest way to "see" it is that the front of the part will always face the front view and the side of the part will always appear on that side. For first angle the front of the part will always face away from the front view and the right side will be on the left view, left side on the right view, bottom side on the top view and top side on the bottom view. Any view can be detailed or brought away from the rest with a simple note saying which view it is. It is usually done with a set of arrows on either side and letters dictating a view callout.

I am insulted that you would make a statement saying that I would have understood this if I would have read the article. How dare you make a statement like that. As an editor I would expect more. OBVIOUSLY I read the article, otherwise how would I know about it?

My subscription runs out in July/August 2009. I will not be renewing.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Ian Kirby....drafting??

#29

That was Emily Latella.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Same actress (the late great Gilda Radner), but a different character. Rosanne Rosannahdana's trademark line was, “it just goes to show you, it's always something…if it's not one thing, it's another…”

Rod

With nothing whatever to add to the titled thread.