Re: One other thing
wilbur
>Mark,
That reminds me of a joke.
A guy's car is making all kinds of noise and is shaking violently. He brings the car to a mechanic, who takes a look at a car. The mechanic lifts the hood with the engine running, listens for a bit, the takes a mallet and whacks the engine. The car immediately stops making noise, no longer shakes, and runs like new.
The guy gets a bill in the mail later for $100. He gets steamed that he has to pay that much. He calls back the mechanic and says, "I want to know what I am paying for with this bill, when all you did was whack my engine with a mallet. I could have done that myself! Send me a bill that explains your charges."
He gets an itemized bill the next day. It reads:
1. Whacking your engine with a mallet: $5
2. Knowing where to whack it: $95
That's what physician charges are for. If managing diabetes was really as easy as just tracking your blood sugar numbers, a reasonably smart high school student could do this job.
And as far as the issue of billing even when the outcome is not good, there's a big difference between physicians and executives. Physicians, and other health care professionals, get paid when the patient doesn't do well, but we don't get paid extra when the patient does well. I'm a pediatric oncologist, and when I cure a kid of leukemia or a brian tumor, I don't get a bonus.
Furthermore, we get paid the same for managing patients with the same disease, even if one patient takes much more thinking about and effort than another. If this standard was applied to CEOs, then a CEO of a Fortune 500 company would get paid the same as the CEO of a corner grocery store.
I am not against the idea of merit based pay per se. I do think that merit pay for CEOs is way out of line compared to other professions, and, as I said before, despite the theory justifying the current status of executive compensation, there is evidence to show that this is actually detrimental to a company.
Wilbur