Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

OT - Exodus?

Posts

OT - Exodus?

#1

OT - Exodus?

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>I just read that Hooker Manufacturing is offshoreing their production, closing their last factory in the US. This was the company that spearheaded the antidumping campaign from China.

The other signatories also closed their respective factories down in the US.

I had to reread it twice to believe it!

It is sad to see so much of our manufacturing base leave chasing better profits, etc. I understand that most of them need to do so for competitive reasons, but what will the landscape look like here in a few years, when we no longer make anything ourselves?

Is anyone ( governments) concerned about this, or is it purely corporate profits that matter anymore.

Something is seriously wrong with this picture, to think that these large core (furniture) industries will be supplanted by new, nonexistant industries is wishful thinking in my opinion.

Other opinions?

Norman

Re: OT - Exodus?

#2

Re: OT - Exodus?

Steve in Fresno, Go Dogs

>I agree Norman, it's a shame, but what is a company supposed to do? Your competition is in Mexico or China. They don't have to pay a "living wage" (WTH is that anyway?) They don't have to offer health care for employees "significant other". They don't have to offer family medical leave.

You do, and that adds to the cost of doing business.

So if you want to stay in business, you've got to go where costs are least, or get into a much smaller niche market.

Steve

Re: OT - Exodus?

#3

Capitalism

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>that is what has always driven this country. No where was there ever a morale concern for the workers. industries relocate all the time. a tax break hear, a tax break there.

to top it off our fine government is out of control with taxing the heck out of them. I recall someone is/was proposing a bill to tax there profits.

the beast has an insatiable appetite and must be feed more and more. didn't we revolt against such a thing over 200 years ago? ....

I am not saying that corporations aren't greedy but they are not 100 pct to blame as well.

there is much more to that puzzle but the driving force is always money. I wonder why it is that the media only reports 1 small fraction of a story and problem. usually the one that is closets to the emotional surface and never seeks to fully educate the masses. who profits from that the most? it's not about the money. it's about THE MONEY.

research is boring but there is always more to a story.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#4

Re: OT - Exodus?

Ted Wong

>It's a race to the bottom. Did you know that Walmart is China's 8th largest trading partner and that over 70% of the non-food items sold there are manufactured in China? Most people do not think about the hidden costs when they shop merely on price alone. But outsourcing is just one of the hidden costs of shopping on price alone. Not only does Walmart encourage it's suppliers to reduce their own costs it hurts competitors that have to compete on the huge clout Walmart has. Local businesses reduce their labor costs accordingly and cut benifits just the same as Walmart does.

IMHO its an unfair advantage. Doing business with countries that have lax environmental standards, poor records on worker rights and safety and poor records on human rights hurts the global economy in the end. Not to mention environmental disaster it has brought to this country like the Emerald Ash Borer, Asian Carp in the Great Lakes, Eurasian Milfoil, etc.

On the otherhand this is capitalism and just as Walmart and others have exploited it to their advantage you can react by voting with your $$.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#5

Re: Capitalism

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>There are bills in the House and Senate that would eliminate all taxes on individuals and corporations including Medicare tax and Social Security and replace them with a national cosumption tax,(Sales Tax).Corporations would not have to pay all the imbedded taxes that are now included in the price of their product so the U.S would become the biggest tax haven in the world. Then watch corporations both domestic and international flock here for that haven. It would eliminate the Internal Revenue Dep't. The main opposition to it is from lobbyists who would no longer have any use to corporations and of course to the politicians who would lose lots of power. If you want to read more on it go to FairTax.Org. There is also a book written by Rep.John Linder of Georgia and Neal Boortz,(Boortz.com) a talk radio host who is syndicated. You can read about the Fair Tax at his site. There is a slow but sure growing support for these bills and if you feel as I do that this is the way our tax system needs to work, contact your Senators, and your Represenitive. I am on a 1st name basis with mine.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#6

OT to the OT-- Lobbyist

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>only to things will ever make a dramatic change in our government. ban lobbyists and special interest groups from giving money to the Government on any level.

two Ban riders on bills. riders were intended for tweaking the rules in order ot pass while in session. now they become the back scratching post for the corrupt deals. why should a gun bill have an abortion rider?

just wiping out the current tax in one fell swoop will never work. it will cripple our government. It must be done in strong individual actions that are decisive and move toward a better goal.

the problem with these tax reforms is that the would cut the head off to save the toe. sort to speak.

a simple act as making riders only pertinent to the content of the bill would have negative impact for at least 3 or 4 congress cycles.

we would survive as a country and all will be well. but it can no longer be business as usually.

I could dive into more details but in the end common sense has no place in politics. I have no clue on how this ever rectify itself. I believe it won't and only when teetering on collapse and the general public has suffered long enough will change ever take place.

remember, these are rich people in charge and very little disturbs there lifestyle.

that enough politics for me. The topic usually sickens me and ruins my day.

I'm off to walmart to save 2 bucks on a box cereal.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#7

Re: OT to the OT-- Lobbyist

Jason Roehl in Mulberry, IN

>I disagree somewhat, Joe. If any radical changes are made to a tax system, I believe they should be gradual--over the course of 10 or 20 years. Indiana did well in that department with the elimination of the business inventory tax over 10 years (it just went away entirely this year), which was a strong incentive for businesses to move to or stay in Indiana. This state was suffering greatly from "brain drain", particularly with our local technical heavy-hitter, Purdue. However, Indiana gets a thumbs down in how they have moved from a "true tax value" property tax system to a "fair market" property tax system. They just about wiped out our local landlords, and I know of one who committed suicide due to the sudden financial burden. Besides, if you think you own property, try not paying your yearly rent...er...property tax!

Personally, I think that moving to a tax system that is almost or entirely a "use tax" system would empower more individuals. Those who are irresponsible or wasteful of our resources would pay much more for the privilege, while those who want to conserve can more easily do so. Drive a heavy vehicle that destroys the roadways? Pay a higher tax. Drive one that guzzles gas? Pay a higher tax. Take long, hot showers? Pay a higher tax. That seems much better to me than taxing someone more the harder they work. I'd also like to see some sort of regulation on the ratio of a company's top level to lowest level. Perhaps then we would see fewer execs raking in hundreds of millions of bucks while they lay off 10,000 or 20,000 people who are scraping to get by.

Time to go do some Yoga, I guess...or maybe just have a beer (which should be taxed higher, too...)

Jason

Re: OT - Exodus?

#8

Great!!!

John in New Mexico

>The CEO's can have another big raise when these pass!!! :):):)

Tempting as it is to blame taxes for everything, the greed is ubiquitous, right down to the janitor wanting a raise too.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#9

Homogenization

Bill Howatt

>Better jobs are being moved off-shore to lower cost venues, there is nothing magic in assembly these days, virutally anybody can be trained to do it and the real fancy stuff is done by machines anyway. To say the Chinese can't build a decent tool is silly since they were obviously able to put a rocket into space and build an A-bomb.

So the better paying jobs are going off-shore to be replaced probably by poorer paying jobs. The off-shore people's standard of living should go up and ours likely will go down.

Taxes too high, maybe, but remember that to provide the various "services" governments need so much money so if they don't get it from A they need to get it from B. Governments don't make money they just shuffle other people's around.

Greed, sure but that's human nature for the most part. It doesn't start and stop with those at the top either. Look at the mess the big 3 automakers are in. After years of rich wages, benefits and retirement benefits the industry can no longer support the cash outlay.

You can try and vote with your wallet by not buying imported goods at WalMart or elsewhere but the sad fact is that you are wasting your time since you are vastly outnumbered by those that will buy them. The more your standard drops the more likely you are going to be looking for the cheapest price so the situation is a downward spiral.

One thing that would perhaps even the playing field a bit is if there was strong international pressure to force the industries located in the off-shore countries to provide decent wages/benefits, adequate safety measures and strict adherence to environmental concerns.

It is a changing world and this time we are on the wrong end of the stick.

Bill

Re: OT - Exodus?

#10

there is enough blame

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>to go around. like I was saying or trying to, it's not just one side or the other. it's the whole system as it has evolved.

all in all, USA is still one nice country to live in. Maybe that is why a blind eye is turned to such shady turn of events.

it's easy to take a little more when people are well fed. when people go hungry is when the !@#% hit the fan.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#11

Re: OT to the OT-- Lobbyist

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>it needs change, that is for sure. but who will be the ones who decide what a "fair use tax" would be?

that is a lot of power to give to someone. buy taxing things in certain ways you can manipulate the market.

no single ideal is the answer. the best minds in the country have made the system un-changable with a simple reform.

it requires a major overall that will not send the economy into a downward spiral.

It's interesting that this thread is turned into a discussion about a specific emotional issue close to everyone wallet. just like the media present this information to us. the big picture and the ramification of such issue have to be considered from every aspect from education, utilities,business culture,environmental concerns to social impacts.

programs, corrupt or fair have been around for a long time this need to evolve. will it take 10 years? 20 years? I doubt we could even make educated guess without several years of unbiased study of the entire system.

as a side note. why is our ecosystem doing well? is it because the toxic emission have been reduced or is it because these companies are located elsewhere now?

Re: OT - Exodus?

#12

Re: OT to the OT-- Lobbyist

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Joe and Jason,

I think that if you will read about the Fair Tax, you would see that it can be done quickly. Neal Boortz and John Linder's book (the newest edition) would convince you. My wife was very sceptical about the whole thing. She read it and was then sending copies to all her friends and relatives, and handing out the Video that you can get at the web site. There is a huge ground swell of support. That is where the individual can make a change.

Mark

Re: OT - Exodus?

#13

Re: OT - Exodus?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>The fact of the matter is, that the number of manufacturing jobs in America, has declined since 1948, while manufacturing out up has gone up. We do more with less. And consumer demands change. Not one person here doesn't want a higher wage and buy things at a lower price. Even if you want superior quality (however is making it), you want to buy it at the lowest price possible. Yeah, you may want a New Cadilac Escolade, but you want to find the dealer that can provide you the lowest price.

"Greed is good". Turned into a bad phrase by Hollywood in the movie "Wall Street", but it was in a movie made by people that demand more and more money for their servies and products. Greed is a basic human condition that move the civilization forward. We work harder so the boss will pay us more, the company does things to increase sales to increase profits. Profits go to the stock holders - You, or someone like you.

It is alway funny to me to hear someone scream about "Companies" making all this "Excessive" profit. COmpanies are for the most part owened by stockholders. And today most stock holders are company and union pention funds, your IRA's, your individual investmonts, your 401K. Them making "Excessive" profits mean that you benifit. Big companies are seldom owned by individuals. There isn't some fat cat sitting up on high getting all the money.

Yes, of big companies make big money. If some company pays a CEO $200 mil as a bonus for bringing in record profits, you can bet that the stock holders like the increased value of the company and the dividends. An even better example is when a company is on the downward slide. They bring in a new CEO. They are projected to lose $500M. Under his management they only lose $100M and is paid $100M (whatever) as a bonus. He saved the company the company $300M net. Pretty good. AND you will hear such things reported on the nightly news as somehow bad, by some pretty face that makes $13M a year for basically reading what someone else wrote.

A company I work with was slated to lose $27M this last year. New CEO, changes made (including some jobs moving to China) and they made $13M. I don't know if he got a bonus for that in particular, but the employess all got nice profit sharing bonuses this year that no one expected. Do you think they would begrudge him a bonus?

Yes, some people lose one job they have had all their life, and take a lower paying job. The carriage makers screamed when Ford started up his plants. Ford workers can now scream as Google is crying out for workers.

It is an never ending cycle.

Mark

Re: OT - Exodus?

#14

Re: Homogenization

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>"One thing that would perhaps even the playing field a bit is if there was strong international pressure to force the industries located in the off-shore countries to provide decent wages/benefits, adequate safety measures and strict adherence to environmental concerns. "

This will eventually occur as it has in the past with countries such as Japan which went from second world or even third world to a first world country and now needs to even outsource their own manufacturing, as it is expensive to manufacture in Japan..Same with Hong Kong, Taiwan, etc.

The problem is that once this manufacturing base is gone it's never coming back. As it stands today it is expensive to set up manufacturing in N. America. Over time, stricted environmental regulations, the loss of our trained workforce,and increasingly expensive health programs will make it even more prohibitive to bring back.

The appeal of manufacturing in China is so great today and the capacity will take years to be absorbed, underlining the complete loss of many industries here.

It just feels to me that we're selling the family jewels and instead of alarm bells going off, there is more and more mnfctring. leaving.

Nobody seems to care, and I wish it was something I misunderstood,

but it feels very wrong.

The environmentalists are rubbing their hands with glee since these industries are classified as "smokestack industries" and not clean,

not thinking of the long-term repurcussions.

We're slowly evolving into a nation of white collar office workers and service industry workers.

Such short term thinking :(

Norman

Re: OT - Exodus?

#15

Taxes, schmaxes

Edward in Vancouver

>So Hooker is leaving the country, Levis did a few years back too. It's a money thing, people want cheap goods, and the cost of goods is dictated either by supply and demand, or by the cost of labour. Even if you offer tax havens you still have to compete with the cost of labour in Asia and availability of trained and untrained labour in Asia.

We are now where Europe was just in the early '60's, they couldn't compete against the Asians with cheap and medium priced goods. What did the Europeans do? Invest heavily in R & D, spend lots of money on design and focused on the best product possible, price be hanged. Quality of life is just as good or better over there than here, and they manage to sell their stuff too.

Politics and tax havens will only complicate things even more. The only radical thing to do is to educate the public on a foreign concept: quality, and to banish the current word, "disposable"....

Re: OT - Exodus?

#16

Re: Homogenization

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>This "Exodous" post has been interesting. My wife and I were talking about it and we came up with, what we think, would be a good doctoral thesis for a business student. "Could the U.S. Wage and Sustain War Against another Superpower?" Can you imagine how unsettling the findings could be?

I recently did a plumbing job where all of the piping came from offshore somewhere. If a major offshore player decided to hold off exports, so as to tool up for a war, a lot of countries would find it difficult to side with the U.S. If I were in Europe, Middle East, etc. and wanted to do some plumbing, I would be out of luck 'cause of no pipe or fittings. My kids would be ticked off 'cause there would be no cool toys, clothes, shoes, electronic stuff, cheaply available. The countries that own our steel mills would say "Hey, U.S. we can't sell you any steel 'cause you want to use it to build elements of war to keep the fight going. And..little Helga and Omar can't get toys, my wife can't get new kitchen ware, and some(many) of our country's population can't get sex aids."

Man, it would take years to fire up the blast furnaces, the few that are left, in Pittsburgh. If an Abrams tank needed parts how many of these are made in some other country somewhere? If the machined parts are fabricated here the CNC machines, that they are fabricated with, are offshore brands.

The whole scenario would suck, big time.

I don't see any universities NOT preaching "go offshore" to any of its aspiring future MBA grads. In fact if an MBA grad approached a potential new employer with the prospects of keeping production in the states he/she would most likely not get hired. The company managing my 401K would be unhappy if they did.

Awh, heck with this, I'm going back to the shop to make some saw dust.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#17

Re: Homogenization

Bill Howatt

>You make a very good point about reliance on external sources in times of crisis. Anybody who has seen more than 1 documentary on WW2 knows that it was the manufacturing capability of the US that was really instrumental in turning the tide - not to belittle the human sacrifice.

We, in Ontario, had a not too disimilar experience with your point about a month ago. A Imperial Oil (Esso) refinery had a fire and that combined with a rail strike caused gasoline shortages such that some gas stations were shut down and the prices were up. Apparently, there have been no new oil refineries built in North America since 1979. Now if I were a terrorist, I certainly know where a small number of bombs would bring our oil-guzzling economy to a grinding halt.

Bill

Re: OT - Exodus?

#18

Re: OT - Exodus?

Ted Wong

>You raise some interesting points Mark. But I question when is greed healthy and when does it turn to corruption? Try telling the employees of Enron or Worldcom who had their pensions in the company robbed by their CEO. I doubt they would agree that their CEO deserved his compensation.

It's true that by our western standards that greed keeps our economy going but has anyone ever taken a pause to think that maybe our economy isn't so good for the people lately? I think the philosophy that greed is mans prime motivator is pretty much exclusive to western cultures and other cultures that have been diluted by western philosophies and is an outdated model that is only helping to drive this country to the bottom.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#19

Well Said Mark

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: OT - Exodus?

#20

Re: OT - Exodus?

Bill Howatt

>Hard to argue with you Enron example and unfortunately you don't have to even go to blatant examples. I wish I could remember where I saw it but I read an article about the number of executives that still got huge bonuses even though the company's performance and stock price had declined.

Another thing that ticks me off is that when most of these guys are given the boot when somebody catches on that they are really a dud, they have a contract clause that gives them millions in severance. The average Joe would just be booted out the door.

As they say there is plenty of blame to go around and the whole issue of job-loss and the economy isn't a simple one. Probably what's happening is beyond anyone's control and is reflected by that great economist Bob Dylan when he pronounced, "The times, they are a changin".

Bill

Re: OT - Exodus?

#21

Re: Homogenization

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I've tried VERY hard to stay away from this thread, but you pushed a button...

The MBA grads are part of the problem, not the solution. What is needed is clear-headed economists (of which are very very few), and politicians more in tune with the country's needs instead of BSing their way into more corporate contributions just to bamboozle citizens into voting for their (soon to be broken) promises again...

DC

Re: OT - Exodus?

#22

Re: Capitalism

Diz

>Thanks for posting this. There has got to be a better way than the system we have.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#23

More pay for CEOs => better performance, but....

wilbur

>Mark, I don't think that anyone here would begrudge anyone else increased compensation for a job well done, whether you are a CEO or a hourly employee. However, it is clear that increases in executive compensation has far outpaced increases in compensation for workers at lower levels. There was a study (Hurrt et al., Mid American Journal of Business, Vol. 15, No.1; http://www.bsu.edu/mcobwin/majb/?p=290) that showed that CEO compensation increased 35 percent over a year, which significantly outpaced the increase for blue-collar and white-collar workers, which averaged only 2.6 percent and 3.8 percent. That's a ten fold difference. The jarring thing is that this study was done back in 1997, and the disparity has gotten worse in the 10 years since.

There are other indicators that executive compensation is excessive, and may actually negatively impact a business' performance:

1. Executive perks are linked to negative stock performance in excess of the resources spent on those perks: http://www.wwz.unibas.ch/forschung/dokumente/Aircraft0305.pdf

2. The probability of accounting fraud rises with stock-based executive compensation: http://leeds-faculty.colorado.edu/Bhagat/ExecCompAcctFraud.pdf

3. If a CEO has more of his compensation tied to stock options, they tend to manipulate earnings more aggressively, which leads to reductions in the total return they deliver to their shareholders: http://wpweb2k.gsia.cmu.edu/wfa/wfapdf/BergstresserPhilippon.pdf

4. Pay disparity may lead to negative effects on a company's performance: http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1075301.1075340

5. Executives are in a good situation: they tend to get compensated for good performance, but not punished for bad performance: http://econpapers.repec.org/paper/clmclmeco/2003-01.htm

The idea that increasing executive compensation leads to better company performance is a good theory, but the theory doesn't seem to hold up once you start looking at numbers. I think that the two key elements is the disparity of compensation between the executive and the employees lower on the company ladder, and the fact that there really is no "punishment" for a CEO not doing what he was brought in to do.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#24

One other thing

wilbur

>One of my favorite pieces of "analysis" on CEO compensation and business performance was this piece on CNN Money:

http://money.cnn.com/magazines/business2/business2_archive/2005/07/01/8265509/index.htm

The writer's basic point was that executives should not be punished for lackluster performance because poor performance is often due to factors out of their control.

Which begs the question: if those performance-related factors are out of the executive's control, why should there be rewards for good performance, since the good times may happen due to factors out of the executive's control?

In medical school, one of our "joke" rules of surviving our clinical rotations was, "Concentrate the glory, diffuse the blame." I didn't realize until now that you could be paid for this behavior.

Re: OT - Exodus?

#25

Re: OT - Exodus?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>You all show good examples of abuse of the system but I will point out a couple of things.

1) Many of the abuses over the last 10 years or a little more, came about because congress made a law that limited executive salaries, but did not limit how they were compensated in stock options. Thus to attract the executive they what, boards of director for companies gave exectives generous stock incentives, and that gave the bad ones the ideas about inflating stock values.

2) The contractual obligations to pay executive with stock, or bonuses regardless of company performance, or golden parachutes, are set my boards of director elected by the shockholders. It is ultimately the company stockholders that allow such things. And frankly, should not matter to any one but them, and only they should change it.

3)Now as far as the "greed is good" being a Western philosophy. I don't culture that does not try to provide something better for themselves and their children. Sometimes it manfests itself differently, in different cultures. I suppose that would be a great discussion.

4)Corruption is a diffent matter, and is actually a legal definition. I am talking about within the law.

Mark