Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Gutter Guards

Posts

Gutter Guards

#1

Gutter Guards

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I'm getting a new roof and gutters here in the next few weeks, and am contemplating the gutter guards. I have a huge pine tree that towers over my house and drops cones and needles all year long it seems. I also have a flowering dogwood and magnolia that drop buds, seeds, petals etc, and a huge ash tree in back the drops it's leaves too. Are the gutter guards going to eliminate the clogging from the smaller stuff or am I wasting my money. It's a significant price jump from the standard seamless ones. I just had another episode with a huge Spring downpour and climbing up in the rain on a ladder to pull the glob of @#!& out of the downspout to keep the water from flowing over the gutters. As usual, I don't seem to get up there to do it when it's not pouring. My neighbor who just had gutter guards installed last year was standing in her living room gazing out the window at me sipping her coffee with an evil smirk on her face. Why I oughtta!

Thanks for any insight into which way to go.

Jen

Re: Gutter Guards

#2

hey Jen

KurtK in Indy

>Gutter guards are great for keeping junk out of the gutter. The only problem with them is when we have that huge storm, they don't allow for all of the run off to get into the gutter. This may not be a huge problem but it will spill water over the side of the gutter. Something to think about if you have any plantings that may get damaged from volume coming over.

Hope you're doing well!

Kurt

Re: Gutter Guards

#3

Re: Gutter Guards

Virgil Johnson

>I had Leafguard gutters put on the house 12 years or so ago and have never had one stop up or had to clean them.No pines though only water maple and ash. The only negative thing I can say about them is they can't handle the water flow in one area that the downspout from the second story produces. The water from this downspout overshoots the gutter only in this area. The gutter seems to handle everything else. The longest run I have is twenty five feet. I don't think they (Leafgaurd) do as well in long 50' sections as they are not very deep. The design (depth) might have changed since mine and my neighbors were installed.Neighbor across the street has gutter helmet and they seem to be a similar hood design .

Re: Gutter Guards

#4

Im kinda thinking...... *LINK*

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>........that 'ole Tom Skaggs installed these in the last year or two on his place. Maybe he can chime in on how he likes 'em or what he really installed?

FWIW...I dont have them in place, but almost pulled the trigger a coupla yrs back since I have 5 huge maples with helicopters flying every year. I think this company warrants no guter clogs for the life of your house.

I dont know if they warrant for the pine needles....seems to me that is one "leaf" that might make it past this defense.

Good luck and let us know what you do!

Scott


The Gutter Helmet

Re: Gutter Guards

#5

Re: Im kinda thinking......

Mac

>Jen, The most practical thing to do is..............cut those suckers down and turn them into money, on the lathe.

Re: Gutter Guards

#6

Royal Guards

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Jennifer,

I was wondering if the Royal Beefeater Guards at Buckingham Palace might also work...I am sure your castle could use a few of them.

:-)

Take care,

Jim


img

Re: Gutter Guards

#7

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Gutter Guards

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Jen,

Two years ago, I had a product called "GutterLoov" installed on my house, shop, and barn. It was considerably less than the 'helmet" et al. I paid $7.50 a foot, installed, on my existing gutters.

They've worked great. Virtually no 'run-over' and definitely no clogs. BTW, I have oak and maple trees all around the house, so the product really gets heavily tested. Also, being only a couple hundred miles away from you, in NE Ohio, my climate and rainfall amounts are pretty similar to yours.

Jim D.

Re: Gutter Guards

#8

Oh, 'leaf' the poor woman alone!

Joanne in Point Pleasant

>She is 'pining' for some good advice and help. Such 'unguarded' attempts at humour can be truly 'draining.'

Jen, my parents got some kind of gutter guards years ago and never seem to have a problem. I thought about them for my house, but I don't really have tall enough trees near enough to clog up the gutters. I was up cleaning them last Fall and there wasn't much muck in there. Guess I get to save some money. Or rather, put it towards something else. Hmmm. Dust collection ducting, yeah, that's what I need. :-)

Re: Gutter Guards

#9

Re: Gutter Guards

Barry Irby

>Jen, My house is 48' long and a simple A roof. I bought a product called Gutta Guard that is made locally but sold nationally I believe. It works on the same principle as Gutter Helmet. I put it on myself on standard rolled aluminum gutters when I put the new roof on. Worked perfectly so far (about 8 years). A couple or minor problems. My gutters were twenty years old and slightly mangled. They have slipped loose in one or two places and I had to put them back. If you had new roofing and new gutters, I think they would be flawless. I had a pine in the back and an oak and maple in the front.

These types of systems are occasionally overwhelmed by extraordinary rain, but it may do little harm if it is only once or twice a year.

My system cost me about $100 and I installed it myself. (Not including the gutters).

Englert Gutters that have the gutter guard built into them. They guarantee they will not stop up, but they cost several times as much as standard rolled gutters. One of the things they do that you might be able to do on yours is use oversized down spouts. 3 X 4" rather than the standard 2 X 3". Might cost a little more, but couldn't hurt.

I also have earmarked a site that sells foam strips that fit inside your gutters. Sort of coarse open foam that fills the gutter keeping the crud out and allowing the water to flow. HMMMM? No experience with them. Skeptical. Sounds like it would turn into a perfect hunk of potting soil to me.

Re: Gutter Guards

#10

Re: Gutter Guards

mdclor

>Jen,

We had gutter guards installed about 3 years ago and they seem to work fine so far. One note of caution is to be aware of your roof lines. Where two planes come together, you will get "run over". This is especially bad if that happens to be over a door, DAMHIKT. Still preferable to the annual gutter cleaning 'party'.

Merle

Re: Gutter Guards

#11

of course

Joe Piotrowski - Chicago Burb's

>if you have a huge storm and you gutters are clogged with junk they will not handle the volume and you will have some overspill :)

Re: Gutter Guards

#12

Too much Cake Today?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>If it weren't your birthday I'd send a swift cyber smack right at you!

...now excuse me while I go thank Joanne for standing up for me!

Re: Gutter Guards

#13

Re: Gutter Guards

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thanks Jim,

I'm googleing now. These sound interesting.

Jen

Re: Gutter Guards

#14

Thanks Joanne :)

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>

Re: Gutter Guards

#15

Re: Im kinda thinking......

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Mac, I had $600 worth of trimming on the ginormous ash tree in the back. It's not diseased or anything, just huge and hanging over the house. I sleep better at night now. The estimate to have it taken out was $4000. I'd be hard pressed to see a return by way of bowls at that cost. At least, I'm not that confidant :)

Jen

Re: Gutter Guards

#16

strainers *LINK*

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I'm wondering about gutter guards myself. Meanwhile, I've placed strainers in each downspout drain. They keep the drain functional when the gutter contains leaves etc. The gutter still has to be cleaned periodically of course. My lot is heavily wooded with pines and oaks. I clean them twice a year.

Ed


Strainers

Re: Gutter Guards

#17

gutter screens

brad bransky

>About eight years ago I installed very inexpensive plastic screen panels which fit under the edge of the shingles and are grooved on the opposite edge into which the lip of the gutter is inserted. It has worked flawlessly. I have two roof sections which drain into one gutter on each side of the house. Water shoots over the gutter at these two spots anyway. I'd encourage you to invest the few bucks in this system first. Initially, I purchased wire screens which had a convex surface and trapped the leaves, etc. and required regular cleaning. Next I purchased the plastic screen in a dark color to not be very visible. The summer sun (Kansas) distorted them immediately. I switched to white which doesn't show from the street anyway and they've been up there many years. I have a row of tall Austrian pines along one side of the house, four gigantic Sycamores over the other three sides, and two huge oaks close enough to bombard us with acorns and zillions of leaves. Brad in Kansas

Re: Gutter Guards

#18

Thanks Everyone...

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>After reading your comments and understanding a bit more about the cost of having the LeafGaurds installed, I think I may try one of the do it yourself versions. Lowes and HD both have some that slip up under the shingle and snap over the lip of the gutter. Some are grated, and others look to be solid with slots for the water to run into the gutter. With the pine needles I'm thinking the solid ones...I'm just wondering if the holes would then clog? Probably. Hmmm....life is so difficult.

Jim DeLaney, I never found a resource for GutterLoov. I did a Google search to no avail. I'm still interested in that so if you know of a link or some online info I'd love to read it.

Thanks for all the replies everyone!

Jen

Re: Gutter Guards

#19

holes

brad bransky, lawrence, ks.

>The holes in my screens are diamond shaped about 1" x 5/8". Brad

Re: Gutter Guards

#20

Ps, I forgot......

Barry Irby

>Lowes had Gutta Guard in Bare aluminum only (shiney silver). I wnet to a local hardware and bought them in black. They also had brown. It was $88 for a hundred feet.

Re: Gutter Guards

#21

Jen, now you need a

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

>Shop Insulation and Gutter Guard Party! Get some help with that chore, too.

Re: Gutter Guards

#22

Re: Gutter Guards

Al Goldstein

>Last fall I had a fine mesh gutter guard installed on my gutters. Haven't had enough experience with it yet. But, to me it looked better than the gutter guards that let the water drain into the gutter and the leaf fall to the ground. Even on the TV commercials you can see small bits of leaves falling into the gutters with the water.

Here is a web site explaining the product. http://www.leafsolution.com/company.htm

Good Luck.

Al

Re: Gutter Guards

#23

Re: Thanks Everyone... *LINK*

John Tenhundfeld

>I looked for gutter loov and found Jim Delaney on Sawmill Creek site with about an exact quote of what he had on Woodcentral posts. Following that up I found the following site: http://www.waterloov.com/ for a gutter guard-type implement. Hope this helps


http://www.waterloov.com/

Re: Gutter Guards

#24

Re: Thanks Everyone...

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Thanks John!

Much appreciated :)

Re: Gutter Guards

#25

Re: Jen, now you need a

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>No kidding Joanne. I think that is a fabulous idea. I'm writing out the invitations today! You're first on my list!

;)