>Okay, gardeners, here is one of my rare OT posts for you...
Our property is overrun with deer. They have eaten every scrap of undergrowth in our woods and our yard and gardens. They've even eaten our yew bushes and have stripped the ivy off our house to a height of 6 ft. Last summer, they decimated Candy's garden, eating everything of value or interest. We're not going to even till the garden this year unless I can somehow fence the area to keep the deer out.
My question is, what is the best and/or most cost-effective way to fence in a 20' x 30' garden to keep deer out? Should I hire the job out to somebody who does this professionally? What kind of budget should I have for this project?
>Gemplers.com carries a couple of deer fencing/netting products that might work. There are plants that are claimed to ward off deer but a physical barrier is probably the only sure way.
>If you were out west I'd suggest buying used seine boat netting (or trawl netting) and draping it over a trellis style framework that's at least 8' high and rings the garden (don't use used gillnet as birds can't see it and will fly into it - 'specially gillnet used in the US where monofillament mesh is stil legal and even more invisible).
what we use is 6' or 8' wire fenceing attached to t posts, if you can only get 6' fencing run a couple of strands of wire between the top of the fencing and the top of the t post. Deer can jump pretty high. A freind of mine who grows organicly used to think that there were ways to repel deer, he now invites his neighbors to hunt his property and shoots deer that are in his garden.
New Zealand style electric fence is supposed to work well, I think it is some times called high tension fencing.
>a friendly junk yard dog does wonders about keeping deer out. When my pines were small, I'd lose way less than 1% to deer rubs. I'd always get on to my drop-off dogs for chasing deer way. After the dogs died, me get more deer rubs, now. Gotta get me another pooch!
Dan's suggestion of elect. fence should work also. Dale
2. While deer are willing and able to jump a 6' fence (electrified or not) to munch your plants, they will not do so if the "landing zone" is not clear and flat. Thus a gardener who put up a 4 foot fence and then raised the planting beds 12" within 3 feet of the fence (with low walk rows between the beds) has not been bothered by deer that had previously gorged themselves on her snow peas and lettuce.
3. Heat/motion sensing controlled chainguns work quite well, provide a ready source of protein, and won't bother the neighbors so long the correct silencers are used which also gives them a distinct advantage over Claymores.
>When I lived in Texas, I had friends who hit upon a similar solution: let hunters have access to their land during deer-hunting season. The hunters were actually willing to pay them for the privilege of hunting and they ended up with some nice venison steaks and sausage as an added bonus. They still had an occasional deer that would wander into the yard and go after the garden or flowers, but not the large-scale devastation they'd been experiencing previously...
If you stick to just a fence then it needs to be at least 6' tall. You should also tie nylon flags at various places. The fence doesn't have to be overly robust (poultry netting, welded wire, or several strands of barbed wire will suffice) but it has to be visible and tall enough that the deer can't easily jump it.
If it's not too cold then the "scarecrow" works well. It's a motion activated water sprinkler that runs on a 9v battery. Obviously it doesn't work below freezing (or when you forget to turn it on). I'm thinking that a few outdoor motion sensors, some pvc and a few impulse sprinkler heads could be added to a spare slot on your sprinkler system and might give protection to a larger area. FYI - the scarecrow runs $50 - $70 depending on where you buy it. Outdoor motion activated floodlights might also be of some use but anything that makes noise or moves will startle the deer and encourage them to move to quieter pastures.
There are also some electric deer deterring devices that emit a deer attracting odorant. The deer touches the device and gets a shock. I don't know of anybody that uses them though.
Some people swear that they've had success with shaved Irish Spring soap (and yes, it has to be Irish Sprng). I don't about deer but it deters me. It's similar in concept to "Deer Off" but it's much, much cheaper. You just shave a bar of soap and spread the shavings around the area you want protected. You can also just hang the bars from trees. I've tried this method but can't confirm if it works or not.
I've got a garden that's a bit bigger. I currently have a scarecrow attached to the top of a 3' fence and seem to have solved my deer problems.
>4' high wire fencing, plus two strands of heavy nylon string trimmer cord set 2' and 4', respectively, above the wire fencing has kept my garden deer-free. It was a lot cheaper, and more attractive, than an 8' fence.
>I have dogs and the deer don't seem to like that. So far my yard is deer-damage free while me neighbors can't grow stuff the deer like to eat. Hopefully this will continue.
The warden service in our area recommends fencing 8 feet high. Several suggestions posed such as seine net, 6 foot fence with single strands above, etc sound good. This isn't prison fence. You just need to give them a visual barrier and they'll stop. That said, they might try to lean in and nip off some of the closer stuff so the openings have to be small enough so they can't snake in a head. There are all sorts of claims of soap, peppers, hair and other stuff that will keep off deer due their odor. Others advocate noisemakers like tin plates, foil or old recoding tape. The county extension service tested all of these as well as a special tape that was light colored on one side and dark on the other. When you put it up you would give it a couple of twists and when the wind blew, it looked like lightning bolts going back and forth. It looked really cool! Bottom line was that they ALL worked UNTIL the deer got used to it. The recommendation was to change strategies from time to time. One family sicced a bunch of paintballers on a herd that was plaguing a neighborhood. It worked and the deer sported pretty patches of color. The warden service was not amused and put an end to everyones fun. Those people have NO sense of humor.
>This might work and if it doesn't, just think of all the fun you can have with it. http://www.northerntool.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product_6970_1050064_1050064
>Ellis, My understanding is that all the repellants and noise makers and such only work for a very short time, until the dear figure out they are not being injured.
What does work is fencing. There is a spatiality deer fence made of very light netting and posts that are eight feet tall. I think you run a strand att he top that supports it and also supports some flags like pennants that warn the birds. There are electric options too. I don't think the netting fence is outrageously expensive and it tends to blend into the background pretty well.
The fence has to be eight feet tall and/or have a strand of electric fence at the top. Actually, the electric strand needs to be about "nose" high and the strands above that don't have to electrified at all. Once they touch one of them, they won't touch the rest.
The electric system can be solar powered or battery powered, or hard wired through a transformer.
Do a Google search and I bet you come up with a bunch of stuff.
Dogs work well too. Since they tend to be carnivores, they don't eat many of your veggies.
I have friends who are truly tormented by deer. Some of them raise their flowers in heavy wire cages. The dear stick their tongues through the wire and pull the flowers over to the side and eat what they can. I have a cousin raising nursery stock on a commercial scale. She hires hunters and has a harvest permit to kill as many as they can. The venison goes to "Food for the Hungry" or some such program.
When the circus comes to town people go collect the lion and tiger poop and use it to fertilize there gardens. Supposedly keeps the deer out.
>Many moons ago my son raised wild ducks. I built him an aviary that was 20 by 40 and 14' tall. I have some of the netting left. Don't know how big the piece is, but its big, big enough to do what you want to do. Its black netting woven of some weather resistant stuff. Strong. If you are interested, I'll go look at it and see if it is labeled for size. If you want it, it's yours for the shipping.
As for posts, you are on your own. Get some wood worker farmer guy to help you.
>Deer can jump/reach over most any fencing that you can navigate easily.
We tried "scary" stuff like hanging noise makers, material that had shiny sides and flashed, etc. We tried chemical repellants. They worked but you couldn't use them while the plants were budding and they rinsed off quickly when we or Ma Nature sprinkled the garden.
What keeps the deer out of our garden and their favorite munching spot, our raspberry patch, is motion-detection lighting set to go on and off quickly. If the lighting comes on and stays on for multiple minutes, the deer get used to it. But if the lights come on and go off in just a few seconds (you can get lights that will stay on only 5-10 seconds), the deer freeze when they first activate the light, move just a bit when the light goes off, causing it to come back on, and that seems to scare them off. It's worked the last two summers after our losing most of the new berry bush growth and a lot of tender veggie tops several previous seasons.
Put a short fence around your garden to keep out the rabbits. Then every 2 feet put up a tall stick or sapling 10 to 12 feet in height. The deer think the fence is that tall and will not jump it.
>Here's a unique and paretty cheap way of keeping deer out: Human hair and pantyhose...
Seriously. As deer forage, they are constantly sniffing, deer smell human hair and trott off away, they don't like it. Get the hair for free at any barbership and stuff it into pantyhose "sausages" and lay the "sausages" around your property line.
I built this fence around my raised, square foot garden. Note the cantilever design that discourages deer from jumping over it and critters from climbing it (they can't climb in an inverted position).
It has worked for me. The netting is some type of plastic that I acquired from Agway, and the posts are 4x4 PT lumber set in cement. I attached the cantilevers using gorilla glue - and PT lumber screws from HD.
I also edged the ground perimeter with 2x10s to discourage any critters from digging under the fence to gain access - and it gives you a nailing surface for the fence along the bottom.
Lastly - I added a drip irrigation system to the garden that is fed by an underground tube connected to a hose bib and is set on a timer - This is a very little work required garden.