Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT: Garden fencing

Posts

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#26

Trip-wire electric fence

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>This method came from a local animal control person. String a single strand electric fence about 6" off the ground. Deer barely lift their feet when they are walking, so they hit it with their feet. The jolt scares them away. I was skeptical, but it really works.

One year I didn't have the fence up when I planted the garden. Deer tracks all over the place the following morning. Installed the fence that day and no more deer tracks.

It is especially interesting to watch one of the young ones sniff the wire - only happens once.

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#27

I just ran a few hundred BF

Dustmaker Mike

>of hard wood though the planer at odd times of the night or early morning after they partyed to late at night. Oh yea I did it out side across the street from their house on a quit Sunday Morning around 4:30AM never heard a peep out of them after 10PM again. If you take different depth cuts it changes the sound really nice.

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#28

Re: I just ran a few hundred BF

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Good one Mike. I've actually thought about doing that....

Joe

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#29

Re: OT: Garden fencing *LINK*

Tom Carson

>Hi, Ellis,

Check out Benners low visibilty deer fence there in PA. Others (i.e. DeerBusters) have similar products available. We have friends that installed this on a very wooded lot here in Oregon and have been very pleased with results.

Tom


Benners Deer Fencing

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#30

Ellis Walentine

Wow. There's a good solution.

Ellis Walentine

>I love it, Stephen. Thanks. Saplings are not in short supply here.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#31

Possible Solution Ellis......

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>....Deer can jump high and deer can jump far.....but they cant do both at the same time.

My solution is a double fence.

Install a 4' tall fence 3-4'out from each edge of the garden.

Right along the garden edge install a 8' tall fence.

The deer can easily jump the 4' tall fence right?.... but once in between the two fences they have no way to jump the taller fence, since they have no momentum or running space to jump the taller fence again..... so they must jump back out.

I highly doubt a deer is crazy enough to try and jump a 4' and a 8' tall fence in one leap.

Now....you have just won the deer war.

Good luck Ellis

Scott

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#32

Ellis Walentine

You get the award, Bart

Ellis Walentine

>That is the Guantanamo of gardens. I'm trying to calculate what it would cost to surround 600 s.f. with something that elegant. Nice work.

Thanks,

Ellis

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#33

Ellis Walentine

Re: OT: Garden fencing

Ellis Walentine

>Thanks, Tom. I will look into local dealers.

Ellis

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#34

Motion Sesitive Water Sprinkler

Dave Morris

>Ellis, these things really work. You know the type of sprinkler I'm talking about... the Chh--chh--chh--chh ones that can be set to rotate for a specific amount of degrees, then go reverse direction and rotate back at a faster rate.

The water doesn't hurt anything, but the sudden noise and water motion scares the deer away. Works pretty good on Trick-or-Treaters as well... or so I've heard, I'm not admitting to nothing! ;-)

Dave--- who was introduced to these things by a customer who had the same problem as Ellis, but was trying to protect the flowers on his front porch... you do the math

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#35

Re: OT: Garden fencing

Brint in Atlanta

>Ellis --

My advice comes not from gardening, but from working the summers of '95 and '96 in a whole bunch of different yards for a landscaper in New Jersey (where there are more deer roadkill than there are skunk roadkill in Virginia -- or at least, seems that way...)

All the folks we worked for had had trouble with deer. We heard most of the solutions mentioned above (with the notable exception of the electric tripwire 6" off the ground -- that sounds intriguing), and the general consensus, from about 20-30 homeowners who had tried lots of different solutions over the years, was:

- Deer can jump anything under 8 feet

- Deer don't like electricity

Sooner or later, it seemed, most everyone bit the bullet (or recognized the need to) and installed one or the other, or both.

As I said, this isn't my own experience -- just my recollections of a very unscientific poll, and worth every cent you paid for it....

;-)

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#36

Ellis Walentine

Impeccable logic

Ellis Walentine

>I'd love to go to that length, Scott, but one fence is expensive enough. And how do you get into your garden? I've gotta think about human access, too.

It gets curiouser....

Ellis

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#37

Let me simplify.......

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.......just depends how good a scrounger you are I guess to limit the expenses 8^)

How about this one....using the netting angle, which I forgot to add btw:

Sink 10' tall posts 24" into the ground every so often, maybe 8' apart. Connect these posts at the very top with horizontal 2x material along the entire perimeter. In between these horizontal members on the garden side of the 2x, attach screws about 12" apart that will each hold a strand of heavy gauge copper wire (so it wont rust out). Make a grid of this wire inside the perimeter that will hold up the netting. Cover the sides of this with netting as well.

Now the expense of this whole idea may indeed be the netting. Google some landscaping or golf suppliers and look for the heavy gauge netting made of nylon. Its less than 1/8" thick. Dont cheap out if you go this route on netting or you'll be replacing it every year like I did previously. (ie the thin black nylon netting you get at most garden centers). Birds and sticks get entangled in it easily.

I have this system in place protecting my rasberries garden that is roughly 12' x 12'. I sunk my posts in 5 gallon buckets of concrete and the cross members were made of 2x wood. It works very well.

Scott

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#38

fence recommendation from Premier 1

Bill Tindal, E.TN

>The easy solution would be for me to come up and shoot some. I like to eat them. They vanish from my farm the day the season opens (I don't know how they know) and some years I don' t get one to eat.

But next best is to call Premier 1 fence company 800 282 6631. They are experts in deer fencing (and sheep fencing which is how I know them) They will recommend an arrangement of electric fencing effective for deer.

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#39

Go to the zoo

Johanna

>and get some poop from the big cats.

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#40

Lets get this back to woodworking

Gary Camp, Bend, Oregon

>I'm thinkin a bent Yew wood stave, 'bout 6' long, a draw knife, spokeshave and maybe a scraper or two. Some linen string a few inches shorter than the Fine Oregon Yew stave. I think you know where this is going. I do have a few Port Orford Cedar dowels about 5/16" dia 32-34" long, some even are footed with Purpleheart. Ya get to do some traditional wood working and obtain the raw material for sausage and jerky both of which require more wood, for smoke.

good luck Let me know if you need any of those Port Orford shafts

glc

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#41

Re: OT: Garden fencing

Charles Self

>Ellis, We've got a similar problem, but this place is more than I want to fence. Actually, here the rabbits are the worst, but deer can drive you nuts. We have lost innumerable fruit trees to them.

The only solution I've ever heard is a high fence wire, at least 8', wired to a solar electric fencing transformer.

According to one hotshot fence builder some years ago, that keeps them out. Personally, I can't afford to fence two acres that way, and wouldn't if I could. A garden area, though, might be practical, though I'm not sure 8' is really enough for adult whitetail deer.

Probably the best set up is the one commercial orchards get to use around here: a .30-30.

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#42

Ellis Walentine

I like the idea, but...

Ellis Walentine

>...I refuse to butcher 60 deer. :-) Maybe I'll let Bill come up and pop a few of them. Anyhow, I'd like to see your homemade bow and arrows sometime. And, if you have good sources for Port Orford cedar, let me know.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#43

make sure your blades are dull too...

John in New Mexico

>

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#44

Re: OT: Garden fencing

Pat Barber

>An electric fence will be the most effective way to stop the

deer. All the local "truck farmers" are now using a new

"slanted" fence post that slants outward. It apparently is

a major confusion point for the deer. The "slant" is fairly

steep and creates a rather strange optical appearance. The

deer "will not" attempt to jump that.

A decent electric fence for that size garden should be

well under $200 for the deluxe version.

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#46

Re: OT: Garden fencing

Ernie Miller

>I haven't read all the posts but I was watching the Victory Garden a couple weeks ago and they were at a park back east and they use a simple fence. a hight one 5-6' and about 5-6 ' beyond that one another 3-4' fence. they say deer have a depth perception problem and can't figure out how to jump them. I wonder if you could just put up somthing that gave the illusion of a tall fence. Like a cheap low fence that is just hung high in the air. or a wire with weighted streamers hanging from it. My problem is rabbits. they are eating the lettuce as fast as it grows.

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#47

Re: Could I use option #3 for ...

Dan Donaldson

>I have a better one;-) I have a set of professional PA speakers and a 1kw amp. I would set them up and then find some of the oldest, scratchiest bluegrass I could find and play it a high volume. ;-) No home stereo would even come close to competing. (The speakers are about 10db more efficient plus will take the full amp output ;-))

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#48

You'll Get Busted, OTOH

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>If you were to hook those big coils up to a subsonic generater and giv'em an extended case of the "creepy crawlies" with no identifiable sound source . . .

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#49

Ellis Walentine

Maybe banjo or accordion music...

Ellis Walentine

>

Re: OT: Garden fencing

#50

Re: OT: Garden fencing

Charles Self

>Small chicken wire fencing works for rabbits. It only needs to be 2' high, no gate, as you can step over it. If you don't fence, plant about 11 times what you need and you might get half what you need.